Menu
‹ Chapter 211 of 241 ›

On Forms of Prayer — By G. Rogers

7 min read · Chapter 211 of 241
On Forms of Prayer — By G. Rogers

A WAG once wrote upon the wall of St. Paul's Cathedral, "I publish the banns of marriage between St. Paul's, at London, and St. Peter's, at Rome;" another of equal wit wrote beneath it, "I forbid the bands because they are too near akin." Of this near relationship many unmistakable evidences remain. There is the Book of Common Prayer, "Whose image and superscription is this!" It is an acknowledged subjection to the Church of Rome. Let the services of St. Paul's, at London, be compared with the services of St. Peter's, at Rome, and it will be apparent to all, that, although they are not the same, they are near akin. The Prayer Book of the one is merely a revised edition of the Prayer Book of the other. Many boldly and strenuously confess the relationship, and are doing their utmost to exhibit it in its strongest features; and as Churchmen they are consistent in so doing. Others are pleading for the removal from their Church of the most obvious indications of its origin, by an entire remodelling of its requirements. Nonconformity implies the rejection of all the established formularies of the Church of England, and an entirely independent course of action. Some there are who have dissented from its government and retained its ritual. These cannot claim to be Nonconformists. Any conformity with the peculiar formularies of the Episcopal Church is destructive to such an appellation. Could it be shown that fixed forms of prayer had descended from the Apostolic to the Romish, and from thence to the English Church, or even the existence of any such formularies, we might have retained the practice consistently with our Nonconformist principles; but until this can be shown, and so long as ritual and liturgical services are known to be one of the fruits of an awful apostacy from primitive Christianity, we cease to be Nonconformists in proportion as we adhere to those forms. Dissenters, therefore, are not always Nonconformists, neither are Independents, and it would seem, not even Baptists. In some Wesleyan and Independent places of worship, the prayers and liturgy of the Church of England are adopted. In some instances, amongst the Independents, either the Prayer Book, or an imitation liturgy is used. We have recently had a "Biblical Liturgy" sent us by a Baptist minister, composed for the use of his own congregation. There is a growing tendency, in fact, in Dissenting Churches to mimic the Church of England, as there is in that Church to go back towards Rome.

We eschew all written forms in the worship of the sanctuary. We see in them the mark of the beast. We may be told that some have derived great profit from them. We do not deny it, but they might have profited more without them. On the whole, they have been a hindrance rather than a help to devotion. There is a necessary and irresistible tendency in them to generate mere formalism, and to supercede the naturalness and fervour of free prayer. Many of the best Christians and of Christian martyrs, it may be said, have been brought up in the use of a liturgy. "What!" it has been asked, "could public services of free prayer have done more for these confessors and martyrs, than make them ready either for prison or for death?" This argument has no force, unless

it can be shown that the Christian excellence of these martyrs may be traced to their use of liturgical forms; and shown too, that they would not have been so ready for death if they had been accustomed to the use of free prayer only; and shown also that none without liturgical forms have been equally prepared for imprisonment or death. If the value of a particular mode of worship may be argued from its good effect upon a few, its insufficiency may be argued on the same principle from its bad effect upon the many. How many religious usages of their times have been sanctioned by the examples of the best of men, which subsequent inquiry has proved to be detrimental to faith and devotion! Were our Ridleys and Latimers indebted to their Church formularies for what they were? They were good and holy men in spite of the errors of their day, and the disadvantages under which they laboured. We doubt not but a comparison of the worshippers by free prayer with the worshippers by responsive forms, in reference to the experimental and practical effects of devotion, will be greatly in favour of the former. The great advantage of free prayer over liturgies, lies not merely in the method of address, but in the adaptation to the wants and condition of the worshippers. It is impossible that the same written forms should express the ever varying experiences of those who worship in spirit and in truth. Prayers need to be as diversified as sermons; and there is no more reason why the same prayer should be used every Sabbath than the same sermon. Adaptation to the occasion is as needful in one case as the other. Granting that many excellent prayers are offered from a book every Sabbath, how many still more excellent have been prevented? The defects of free prayer, on the other hand, are often pleaded in behalf of set forms. By some, the superiority of free prayer on private and social occasions is admitted, but its availableness for public use is supposed to be less certain than formularies, and even where both are accessible, the best exercises of extemporaneous devotion are considered to be necessarily accompanied by certain defects which may be remedied by a regular form. Others, while admitting that occasional faults in free prayer are "far more than compensated by the life, warmth, variety, and adaptedness for the time being which characterizes the free method," aver that such faults "conduce to make it desirable that free prayer should be accompanied or supplemented by some brief and varying liturgical forms." These objections apply solely to the frequent incapacity of those who undertake to lead the devotions of others. What then? Are we to require them to read the prayers of others, or are we to supply their places by those who can offer suitable prayers of their own? He that is unfit to pray in public is unfit to teach. Is not the ability to pray with propriety, with unction, and with power in public, a needful test of an ability to preach? To its formularies the Church of England owes a clergy who, if extemporaneous prayer had been required of them, would have never dreamt of "holy orders." The spiritual qualifications in those who minister in holy things require that they should ever be equal to the utterances of free prayer. We confess, therefore, that we look with jealousy upon any change that might even imply a disqualification in our ministry for all the purposes of ready and appropriate prayer. Perish the day in which a mere ability to read with propriety can suffice to conduct the devotional services of Nonconformist Churches! If our pastors, be they ever so eminent as preachers, cannot

481

meet all the purposes of devotion without supplementing them by intoned liturgies and psalms, let them give place to those who can. Forms are of use to those only who cannot engage in free prayer with propriety; but such ought not to become public teachers of others, and, therefore, forms should never come into public use. Whatever might be said in behalf of forms of prayer for children or for family worship under certain circumstances, does not apply here. Our observations refer to the worship of the sanctuary. While some advocate the use of forms for their own intrinsic value, it cannot be concealed that others have adopted them to disarm prejudices and to diminish the apparent distance between the cathedrals of episcopacy and dissent. Taking the New Testament for our guide, not a word can be discovered in their defence. The Master says even of doves in his temple, "Take these things hence." Innocent and dove-like as the innovations may seem to be, take them hence. No instance of the use of such formalities occur in the times of the apostles, not even of the model prayer which at their request was given them by their Lord; nor is any trace of them found in Church history until the general corruption of Christianity commenced. The "Amen" is the only response of which any intimation is given in the New Testament, and it is so introduced as if it were the only one in use. Supposing, then, the public exercises of the sanctuary to be conducted by persons duly qualified by their office, extemporaneous prayer answers all the purposes of devotion, and leaves nothing to be supplied in fulness, fervour, or adaptation by a liturgical form. What better preparation can there be for sympathy between the minister and people in preaching, than communion of spirit in the utterances of free prayer? Instead, therefore, of going back to dull ceremonials when a deficiency of interest in this part of divine worship is felt, which can only make the matter worse, let a larger measure of the spirit of grace and supplication be sought from above; and let ministers by stirring up the gift that is within them, in prayer as well as in preaching, seek that they may excel to the edifying of the Church. O for more simplicity and godly sincerity! If the devotional exercises of the sanctuary become mechanical and artistic, farewell to all spiritual power in other parts of its services! The real power of Nonconformity is in proportion to its close adherence to its distinctive principles, and all who are re-adopting the symbols of any kind of that from which they profess to dissent, are of those who, having begun in the spirit are seeking to be made perfect by the flesh.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate