Rahab: her Faith and her Falsehood


A REVIEW OF MR. JAMES WELLS' SERMON ON "THE FAITH OF RAHAB THE HARLOT."
[We had not intended to take any public notice of the fearful error lately uttered by Mr. Wells, for we do not think it wise to give unnecessary publicity to any man's false doctrine; but when the protest of the Strict Baptist ministers was sent to us, with a request that it might appear in the Sword and Troxel, we could not refuse it insertion, and an explanatory article seemed needed to make it intelligible to our readers, who, for the most part, know nothing either of Mr. Wells or his utterances. We are glad that our Strict brethren have so distinctly cleared themselves of all complicity in the error. The article which we have placed before the Protest is written by our friend Mr. GRACEY, Classical Tutor in our College.]—ED.
RAHAB, by her lonely and daring faith, has gained the praise of the faithful through all time. Jews, by their learned Rabbins, and Christians, by their inspired Apostles, have joined in concert to bind the wreath of glory around her brow. And lest the honour of her life of faith should in any way be tainted with the shame of her life of sin—or, rather, lest one numbered among the ancestry of the Messiah should be branded with such a title of guilt, some have strained every nerve to rescue her from the appellation of "harlot." Whiston, Calmet, and Clarke, deriving the Hebrew word from a root with which it has no connection, translate it "innkeeper." Gesenius*, however, who traces it to its proper root, proves incontestably, in harmony with the Vulgate, the Septuagint, and the New Testament, that Rahab must still be called ἡ πόρνη, the harlot. In mistaking the meaning of the word, these critics have also mistaken the praise of grace and faith; and since she has been proved to have been once an abandoned woman, that faith loses nothing of its glories, but shines forth the more conspicuously, like a solitary star in a night of gloom. Why should not divine grace visit the den of vice as well as the abode of morality?
But lo! in our days, a Christian preacher, popular among his own sect, discovers new excellencies in the character of Rahab. Virtues which slept in silence for centuries, and escaped the notice of the apostles and fathers of the Church, are brought forth to be admired and applauded by all lovers of truth. The infamy of the former part of her life is by no means extenuated. Nothing is detracted from the triumph of free grace, but the laurels of faith are not so secure. Hitherto her faith has carried off the palm, and her falsehood has been passed by in perplexity, or covered with the mantle of charity. But now we are regaled with a new reading of the victory of the heroine of Jericho. A formidable rival, in the person of falsehood, now challenges the honour of her faith; for the lies which she told are asserted to be "the best part of her conduct," and consequently worthy of the greater share of praise. Give place, then, O faith of Rahab, to Rahab's more excellent falsehood!
To come to a more minute examination of this subject as handled in the sermon under consideration. After a needful exhortation to pious hypocrites to get their piety ready, Mr. Wells asks, "Was Rahab justified in these falsehoods?" and replies, "Certainly she was." Now, this "justification in falsehoods," if it have any meaning whatever, has exactly the same meaning as "justification by falsehoods," since it is repeatedly asserted that "this part of her conduct was the best part of her conduct." Hence the works which the apostle commends are interpreted to be the falsehoods which she told. For the explanation of the manner in which the spies were preserved, is thus given—"How did she do that? Why, by saying they were not there, and by saying they were gone. The apostle makes that the best part of her conduct." But if this be the mind of the Spirit in the passage, and if the untruths which she told were of such transcendent merit, they must necessarily be specially mentioned
* See his proofs, Gen. xxxviii. 15, Deut. xxiii. 19, Lev. xxi. 7, in which cases, the same Hebrew word, zohah, cannot possibly be ambiguous.
501
in the eulogies pronounced upon her. Joshua must highly extol them. Let us hearken: "Joshua saved Rahab the harlot alive, and her father's household, and all that she had, and she dwelled in Israel unto this day, because she hid the messengers which Joshua sent to spy out Jericho." Why have the falsehoods slipped from his memory, seeing they are so worthy to be commemorated? Paul, who declared the whole counsel of God in other matters, in speaking of this, cannot keep anything back. What does he say? "By faith the harlot Rahab perished not with them that believed not, when she had received the spies with peace." Why is he so silent about the falsehoods? But surely James, the patron of all good works, and upon whom the author of this sermon principally relies, cannot pass by this without an honourable mention. He says, "Likewise also was not Rahab the harlot justified by works, when she had received the messengers and sent them out another way." Why does he omit the colloquy with the officer of the king of Jericho? Why is this "best part of her conduct" forgotten? Why are not the falsehoods mentioned? Simply because they were failings, yea, more, sins; and the New Testament, according to its invariable custom while praising the virtues of Old Testament saints, and holding them up as examples to us, points not the finger to one of their shortcomings. Besides, the inspired writers are very particular in mentioning the exact acts which were meritorious, are ever careful to separate the clay from the fine gold. Hence the reception and dispatch of the spies are mentioned and praised, while not a word is said in commendation of the lies told for their preservation, plainly intimating that in them no faith existed.
It may be asked, how could the faith of Rahab be praised consistently, without at the same time praising her falsehood? Now it is in looking at the matter from this point of view that even the pious Matthew Henry flounders in such uncertainties; and the author of the present sermon propounds such "horrible divinity." It must be admitted that the faith and the falsehood stand very closely together; indeed, so closely, that they are very liable to be confounded, unless the first principles of the doctrine of Christ be kept clearly before the mind. Mr. Wells soars so high above these first principles, as to disregard the wide difference between the nature of "faith towards God," and the nature of falsehood towards man; and to confound these two opposites together, or, what is as grave an error, to regard the latter as the offspring of the former. This is a parentage of falsehood disowned and discredited by the whole of Revelation. What sacred penman has ever numbered this among the fruits of the Spirit? Where is there the most slender authority, in all the doctrines of the gospel, for metamorphosing the ugly distortions of this "dreadful vice" into the comely features of a Christian virtue? If Rahab's faith were true, and we know it was, falsehood could never have sprung from it, for "no lie is of the truth." We, therefore, fearlessly affirm that these falsehoods had no more connection with the faith of Rahab, than had the equivocations of Abraham in Egypt and Gerar, with the faith of Abraham on Mount Moriah. The faith of Rahab and Abraham had a common origin—the distinguishing grace of God: the falsehood of both had a common source—the weakness and depravity of their old nature. And we know that "quac et a falsis initiis profecta, vera esse non possunt"—things which are false in their beginning cannot be true in their end. They both failed in that for which they were distinguished, and the reason of their failure is given by Isaiah—"Of whom hast thou been afraid, or feared, that thou hast lied, and hast not remembered me?" Rahab lied because of her fear, not because of her faith. Her falsehood, therefore, had no connection with her faith, and merits as little commendation as the failings of other saints. Nor is it any objection to this conclusion, that her fear was manifested in denying that she sheltered them, immediately after the exercise of her faith, in the reception of the spies—because the same sudden alternation of strong faith and cowardly fear was displayed by Peter on the night of the Lord's betrayal.
Again, it is said, "She must either have uttered these falsehoods, or else betray 2 I.
the spies, and their lives would have been lost." At the sight of this assertion, we are inclined to ask, how can this come from the lips of one who believes that all things shall work together for good to the people of God's choice? How can a disciple of the high doctrines of grace, consistently become a "prophet of ills" to the redeemed of the Lord? But are we bound to believe, as here taught, that truthfulness would have sacrificed the lives of the messengers, and that falsehood alone could preserve them? From the circumstances in which they were placed, we must grant that they would have been endangered by truth on Rahab's part; but from a consideration of the seasonable deliverances accomplished by God for his people from the most extreme peril, we are compelled to believe that these men could not have been destroyed. They had come, by God's command, to perform a work of vast importance to Israel, and can we therefore accept the doctrine which tells us they were left to be shielded or sacrificed by the word of a woman? Their own folly might have brought them into this jeopardy, but the work of God never. Let us suppose, for a moment, that Rahab had told the truth, and that the spies had been dragged before the tribunal of their enemies, would their danger have been greater than that of Moses, exposed on the Nile to the cruel Egyptians?—of Jonathan and his armour-bearer discovered to the whole garrison of the Philistines?—of the Hebrew youths in the fiery furnace, or of Peter in the condemned cell, the night before his appointed execution? Nay, for the danger in each of these cases had gone beyond the limit of all human aid, but not beyond the realm of divine deliverance. Would it not have been presumption to have expected miraculous interposition? No: first, because faith's natural sphere is the supernatural. Secondly, because these men had a right to expect it above all others. They were on a duty imposed by God. In their success were bound up vast interests of a people whom God had by miracles called into national existence, by miracles sustained, and still the same wonder-working Jehovah was theirs by covenant. We cannot, therefore, agree with Mr. Wells, that the lives of these two "godly men" would have been destroyed by Rahab's telling the truth, but are forced to conclude that though the truth had been told a thousand times, their safety would still have been divinely secure.
Moreover, we cannot see how very far beyond the reach of harm their lives would have been, as Mr. Wells supposes, protected only by Rahab's "refuge of lies." If the king and officers of the city had exercised the penetration natural to men in their situation, would they have been so credulous as to believe the word, or even oath, of a barlot, relative to persons in her house? And if the house had been searched, of what avail would the falsehoods have been? This very want of discernment and mental activity showed that the men of Jericho were doomed men, and under a strong delusion, that they should believe a lie. If it be said that the spies were actually preserved by the untruths, we reply, God permitted it to be so, and the permission and overruling of evil is a very different thing from sanctioning it, or changing its character. If the truth had been told, all that was necessary for the preservation of the spies, was the divine aid, which, when the falsehoods were told, was still needed.
Let us now review the conclusions to which we have come. We have seen that Rahab's falsehood sprung not from Rahab's faith; that it had no connection with it; that it was not praiseworthy, but deplorable; that if truth had been told the spies would not necessarily have been destroyed, and that the falsehood did not necessarily secure their safety.
What bearing have these conclusions upon Mr. Wells' teaching? Mr. Wells states that though Rahab "told two falsehoods, there was no sin in them, no crime in them." It has been proved that Rahab's falsehood sprung not from Rahab's faith, and that it had no connection with that faith, consequently it must have been sinful, for "Whatsoever is not of faith, is sin." Mr. Wells declares that necessity demanded the suspension of "the usual law of truth," and the permission of "the law of falsehood." It has been shown that truth could not necessarily have ruined, and that falsehood did not necessarily protect,
503
the spies. There was therefore no necessity for the suspension of the law of truth in favour of the law of falsehood. And if no necessity for it, there is no reason to believe it ever did take place, while there is abundant evidence to the contrary. For no necessity could exist that would require the setting aside the moral law—which means acting contrary to God's nature—since for all the wants of his people and the universe, God has made ample provision; but for this he has made none, for he is "God that cannot lie."
Thus, then, the two main pillars of Mr. Wells' argument—viz., the necessity of Rahab's falsehood, and its sinlessness—have been demolished, and the whole fabric of his thesis falls in a common ruin.
Having thus shown how utterly groundless Mr. Wells' theories are, I cannot close without expressing my intense horror at the wildness of these theories. That the physical and ceremonial laws may be suspended, affects nothing absolutely vital; but the mere suspicion that the principles of eternal truth could for a moment be stayed, drives one to the very brink of blasphemy. If the doctrine of Mr. Wells, that God grants a plenary indulgence to lie, could be true in any circumstance, I do not hesitate to say that my inmost soul should recoil from his allegiance and worship, since I could only adore unsullied purity and immutable truth. I could not obey the Church of Rome, I could not reverence the Hermes of Greece; but it is my joy to believe that the fountain of that Deity whom my whole spiritual being willingly worships, can never flow forth to man or angel, otherwise than in the crystal streams of truth.
