THE GROWTH OF PUSEYISM — Chapter Iii
LEAVING the troubled times of the Stuarts, and coming nearer to our own era, we notice one prominent characteristic of the Romish Church bidding fair to become almost equally prominent in the sister Church of England. We refer to that refined and most fascinating form of idolatry sometimes called image-worship; which term so used, implies the worship or undue exaltation of the outward emblems, images, or symbols of the Christian religion. In the Catholic Church it is seen in the adoration of saints, in the superstitious regard paid to relics, shrines, and crucifixes, and in the saving efficacy attached to sacraments. In the English Church it has been perpetuated under various forms. But whether in the Romish or English Church, and with whatever outward modification, the pervading spirit is one and the same, and it is the spirit of Popery.
Thoughtful observers have been long familiar with the fact of the growing power of this form of error under the disguise or designation of Puseyism. For in truth, Puseyism, fully developed, is the nearest approach to undisguised Popery that the English Church has conceived or brought forth. Nor is it indeed absolutely of modern origin. It is the ancient legacy of the Papacy, bequeathed to the Reformation, and the nursling of one after another of the English hierarchy. Chief upon the roll of this apostate succession is inscribed the name of Laud. This prelate is well nigh forgotten by the multitude; but Puseyism, of which he was once the embodiment, survives—not to decay, but as the fashionable, if not the prevailing religion of the age. You who love to talk of Protestant England will do well to consider that. Such power of vitality argues a congenial soil. For never before was a community of professed Protestants deluded by a fraud so transparent, and yet a fraud that seduces alike the simple and the scholarly, the so-called High Church and Low Church. Witness such indiscriminately abasing themselves before those same slavish superstitions that degraded the so-called Christianity of the dark ages. Accepting with softest credulity assumptions resting only upon the shallowest sophistry; prostrating themselves in all sorts of attitudes before priestly orders; tamely yielding up the supremacy of reason and revelation—grovelling there in
295
delighted fascination, false alike to Protestantism and true patriotism—and all this fostered in the bosom of the Church of England—that Church for ever boasting herself the foremost defender of the faith, and conservator of pure Christianity in England,—a spectacle of shame and confusion, enough to make every true Protestant blush for the dishonour done to the good old name.
That Puseyism does exercise a spell thus potent is a sufficiently obvious fact, and one demanding the intelligent consideration of every earnest mind. We regard it as a cleverly devised embodiment of that which is most plausible and insidious, and therefore most deadly in the Catholic system. The main intent, and indeed the whole tendency of Romanism in the Church of England is to transfer the realm of Christianity from the moral and spiritual to the material;—from faith, set forth by outward symbol, to a belief that saving virtue is really in the symbol;—from a reliance on the efficacy of the sacrifice of Christ, to a reliance on the efficacy of the sacrament which is the visible emblem of that sacrifice. And this not, possibly, from any designed perversion of the truth, but from an intense desire for salvation, while yet failing to perceive its spiritual character. Like Jeroboam, who set up the calves, not because he was irreligious, but because he could better appreciate the visible than the spiritual. But although the ultimate result desired by the teachers of this specious heresy—call them Puseyites or Romanists, as you please—may probably be the salvation of souls, yet the ultimate result of their teaching unquestionably is to substitute the worship of the external, that is, idolatry, for the religion of the New Testament. This grand error has, from the earliest times, exercised an influence so mighty over the human mind as to justify the belief that in Puseyism we have a foe too strong and too subtle to be lightly despised.
The wide and engrossing tyranny which Rome has exercised over mankind is without a parallel in religious history. Her avowed ecclesiastical supremacy is scarcely less now than it was two centuries ago. Perhaps a solution in part of this strange problem may be found in the consideration of one circumstance, namely, that the Catholic system addresses itself chiefly to those parts of our nature which are capable of being the most powerfully acted upon by means of external or sensuous excitements. With profound and subtle ingenuity the Church of Rome has flattered and drawn to her aid the noblest powers and passions of the soul—those which are in their motions changeless and indestructible. It is scarcely possible to over-estimate what she owes to her influence over the imagination. Her outward professions have changed times "without number, numberless." But her one secret and unchanging purpose has been, whilst enslaving the mind by means of that regal faculty, to obtain universal supremacy over the bodies and souls of men. This indeed, is the very spirit and essence of Popery; and it is equally the spirit and essence of Puseyism. The difference at most is only in degree of development; and we may reasonably conceive of Puseyism that it is a modification artfully adapted to suit the spirit of the English Church; more persuasive, and therefore not less, but, in its place, more pernicious than might have been the grosser idolatry. All this is bad enough, but we must add to it the consideration that Puseyism has,
in England, engrafted itself upon a Church which, by its primary constitution, too nearly accords with, and has indeed at all times been far too complacently disposed towards, this special form of heresy. The alliance is therefore mutually satisfactory; and it seems quite possible that under favouring circumstances, Puseyism might spread until it should leaven the whole and become universal in the Church of England.
Now, one cannot fail to see that by this unholy alliance the Established Church has in this age also, as in times past, constituted herself in effect, the defence—the stronghold—of Popery in England, making its expulsion a work beset with difficulties that appear well nigh insurmountable. Because the reformer is now by dire necessity driven to wage war, not against openly-armed Puseyism only, but also against whatsoever has, by long and perverse dalliance with the evil, become allied with and virtually a part of that evil, and in this country the very root of it. Thus, to strike effectually at Popery in the Church of England involves the invasion of many sentiments which at first sight would seem not to be connected with the evil, but which may nevertheless lie at the very foundation of it; and among them we must number those strong ties of affection which prejudices, arising from birth or education, or old association, have thrown around the imagination. The not unnatural nor unlooked-for result of all this is—and we ask you specially to observe it,—that the community thus implicated in the crime of fostering Romanism becomes greatly incensed when awakened to find itself confronted by an accusation so wide and sweeping, and that spares not its most sacredly-cherished institutions; and instead of directing its attention to a fair and truthful examination of its position, takes to kicking against the pricks, or, in other words, turns upon the reformer with sufficiently zealous but not very serviceable execration,—a proceeding not to be accounted for on any other conceivable supposition than a confused belief on the part of such community that the reformer has stood sponsor for its adherence to the faith, and is now to be visited with judicial vengeance, because the community itself has wickedly refused to "renounce the devil and all his works."
We, however, revere him who vindicates absolute, persistent, inflexible adhesion to pure morality—to principle—to the law of conscience—to the Word of God;—and who does this not simply by asserting their inviolable supremacy—their all-sufficiency for all occasions—but who, above all, shows forth this supreme all-sufficiency in the conduct of his own life;—
"Who never sold the truth to serve the hour,
Nor paltered with Eternal God for power;
Who let the turbid streams of rumour flow
Through either babbling world of high and low;"—
"WHOSE LIFE IS WORK." And after all, such a life—so ordered—and that the work be effectually done, is all that a truly great man will much concern himself about. Such a man, too, must needs look down with contempt, and with something still better, with vehement indignation, on "all great self-seekers, trampling on the right." He invents no smooth apologies for the sin of the age. He rather, since nothing else will avail, shrinks not in plain terms to denounce all unhallowed confederacy, and to "impeach before the bar of God," the men who,
297
under the shadow of a venerated superstition, misnamed an apostolic institution, or under the plea, vainer still and yet more impious, of a Divine sanction, have leagued themselves with the deadliest enemies of the truth.
We have stated our convictions. Let us now freely admit that some of those sentiments and feelings just now referred to, and which constitute so many bands of strong affection, attaching multitudes to the communion of the Church of England, are, without doubt, natural and not unamiable feelings; and certainly they are not easily weakened or effaced. For they lie deepest and linger latest in the human heart; and, though in action sadly perverted, they not unseldom spring from the sincerest depths of man's being. They are interwoven with the dearest and holiest recollections of life from its earliest dawn. They have gathered strength from traditions hallowed by the confirming testimony of many generations; and poetry has shed over them a lustre that allures, the while it wilders and beguiles the soul as with the power of sweetest sorcery. The inheritor of such sentiments regards with peculiar veneration the sanctuary before whose altar his sires have knelt in supplication, and beneath whose shadow they have been laid to rest. Then everything connected with the established order of worship is to his heart fraught with indescribable, but most affecting charm. That beautiful Litany—and none can deny the surpassing beauty which breathes through every line, and mingles with the perfect pathos of that simple, sublime petition,—the devotional and ritual services;—even the very formalities incident to the worship,—all have been endeared to the worshipper, in that they are the observances—the self-same supplications—which his ancestors had been wont to use in their lifetime, and which their lips have uttered when dying. Nor are we insensible to the power of those earlier memories that ever and anon revisit the soul, even after long years of conflict with the world, and of conflict harder and deadlier far with something in our own heart, may have dulled the finer sensibilities,—tender remembrances that stir us with emotions, haply sweet, or it may be—and oh! who is there that has not felt it?—sometimes sorrowful exceedingly. Lo! from out of the mist-enshrouded past there flashes the recollection—the vision—of a sweet secluded spot—the home of our childhood, illumined transiently in that old-world sunlight,—brighter—so it seems to us—than any that now visits this dim earth. Still and sublime solitudes! Dear old familiar places and pathways! lightly trodden by the free foot and gladdened by the hopeful heart
"In life's morning march when our spirit was young!"
With feelings of unchanged affection, with deep and passionate heart-yearning, we bail once more your silent shades! Here we walked to the house of God "with a goodly company,"—the aged survivors of a generation now passed away. Yonder rises the grey spire of the village church! Ah! yes; that church is, to us, consecrated for evermore,—a link between our souls and the unforgotten dead. Many a Sabbath morn have we paced those aisles. There we sat, hidden by that high pew, and gazed—we remember it as if it were but yesterday—upon the "quaintly carved oak, and oriel stained with saintly legend," our young heart hushed by all that still solemnity,—for a deep, devotional calm seemed in those times to pervade all the earth and sky; and that humble
church was, to our imagination, haloed and haunted by a sense of what seemed to be indeed a religious inspiration, affecting us with strange emotions of awe and reverence;—emotions which can never again be revived in our soul, any more than we can restore to our now dim eyes the unshadowed brightness of our dreaming boyhood.
What then? "A change has come over the spirit of the dream." And was it a dream? Ay, the dream of a child. More properly a religion of the imagination, which grows dim and dies in the light of revealed truth, as the many-coloured, changeful glories of early dawn vanish before the beams of the full-orbed sun. True religion is not a fantasy; and that dream of ours was, we know, born of the soul's ignorance of itself and of its God. Real, spiritual discernment is wanting there, or at best is but half awakened; and meantime, that which is manifestly superstition is mistaken for the work of the Holy Spirit. Yet there are multitudes who really seem not to know that all this is nothing more than devout dreaming,—a purely fictitious piety,—and who live through all their days with no better assurance of their eternal safety; nay, even trusting that such a religion will take them to heaven; whereas they might as well deem that for them Nature's sunlight will "brighten the great mystery of the grave," and that they shall pass unchallenged and secure through its black portals, nor need the illuminating rays of the Sun of Righteousness. H.
(To be continued.)
Sheep-washing—a Fragment.
SITTING the other day at a window which overlooked the lake of Windermere, I saw a sight which greatly amused me while it lasted, and set me thinking when it was over. A wooden pier ran out a little way into the lake, and upon this, with barking of dogs and shouting of men, and somewhat rough use of sticks, a number of sheep were driven much against their own tastes and desires. When the whole company were fairly at the end of the jetty, they were seized one by one and most unceremoniously pitched head foremost into deep water. When they rose they swam to the nearest shore of course,
299
making a bashing of a very gulpy kind as if the water had spoiled the music of their voices, and looking altogether amazed and bewildered. Meanwhile, men in boats, with their oars, submerged again and again such of the swimmers as they could reach, and others drove back into the depths those poor creatures which had landed on the side of the jetty and avoided the longer route to the shore. The water bore sure evidence in its colour of the need there was that the flock should feel the cleansing flood. Great congratulations were offered by the little family groups when the lambs and their mothers had all passed the watery ordeal and were shaking their dripping fleeces; but those congratulations were premature, for the flock was a second time driven to the place of affliction, and each of the sheep had again to be immersed in the troubled waters. It was a day of sore perplexity and multiplied trial such as the lambs had never expected, and the oldest sheep could scarcely remember; they came up all of them out of the flood like those whose tribulation is greater than they can bear, who are driven to their wit's end. The shepherd took the whole affair quietly enough, seeming to treat the matter rather joyously than otherwise, and yet I have no reason to doubt his tenderness, but on the contrary thought I saw much of it in his way of handling his charge, and especially in his sparing the lambs the second plunge which they needed less than those whose longer fleeces showed a greater familiarity with dirt and dust. Certainly he was not just then making his flock to lie down in green pastures, and the waters to which he led them were far from still, yet was he a true shepherd, and as much playing the shepherd's part as when he carried the lambs in his bosom, or folded the flock for the night. It was a sheep-washing which I saw, and it typified the sanctified afflictions of believers. The same strife and turmoil, and hurrying and tugging have we felt, and the barking of far fiercer dogs has been in our ears. We, too, are hurled headlong into a sea of sorrows, and find it hard to keep our head above water. Harder still is it when we are pushed under and thrust down by new adversities, which cause the waves to go over us, while we sink into the depths. It is stern toil to swim to land with the heavy fleeces of our cares about us, and the waters of grief in our throats. When with much labour we pass from the present sorrow and begin to rejoice in our escape, we often find to our dismay that the process is to be repeated, and that once again we must stem the flood. Our hearts might fail us if we did not know that the good Shepherd would not subject us to unnecessary trials, but sees a needs-be for them all. We are not like sheep, ignorant of the design of trouble, let us not therefore struggle against the afflicting hand; we can see the natural perverseness of our nature, and how much of chastisement is required to bring it out of us; let us therefore rejoice in tribulation, and pray that it may be divinely sanctified to us. Swimming to shore, may we leave our pride, our worldliness, our sloth, our evil habits all behind, and by the grace of God the Holy Spirit may we be as a flock of sheep which come up from the washing. Child of God, struggling in the depth of affliction, look not to the present grievousness of thine adversity but to the future benefit thereof, when tribulation shall have wrought "patience; and patience, experience; and experience, hope; and hope maketh not ashamed; because the love of God is shed abroad in our hearts by the Holy Ghost which is given unto us."—C. H. S.
