Menu
‹ Chapter 118 of 217 ›

"Ecce Homo."

24 min read · Chapter 118 of 217

A VOLUME under this title is creating a considerable sensation in the world of religious literature, and reading men are constantly asking one another, "Have you read 'Ecce Homo,' and what do you think of it?" The answers to this question are about as wide as the poles asunder, and are not always equally well considered. The good Earl of Shaftesbury was astonished to find a clergyman, otherwise orthodox, thinking well of this work, concerning which he himself declares that it is the vilest book ever vomited from the mouth of hell; rather strong language to say the least, and implying quite a sufficient degree of warmth in the speaker, if not more. We have heard of two equally safe and sound divines, whose opinions were almost as wide apart as those of the earl and the clergyman, though tempered by saving clauses on either side. The new craft sails under no ostensible colours, and being suspected, from this circumstance, to be a pirate, is fired into by the ships of the line on the orthodox side even before they have overhauled her; while the buccaneers on the side of the Broad-church hail the new vessel before they are altogether sure that it is one of themselves, although of this latter we may add few "ancient mariners" have any sort of doubt. With all due deference to those who have given their judgment, and with the view of sparing our readers the trouble of reading so doubtful a book for themselves, we shall give them our opinion, together with such extracts as may give the better parts of the treatise, and present as fair a view of it as we know how to present.

Addison has somewhere said, that many readers do not enjoy a book unless it has the portrait of its author as its frontispiece, and are not quite easy until they know whether the writer had or had not red hair

309

and a Grecian nose. In the present case, some information as to the author would be of the utmost importance to the reviewer; for, upon the way in which the man's face is turned must our verdict greatly depend; if towards Jerusalem we tolerate, if towards Tophet we detest. A skeleton-key may or may not be a dishonest instrument; very much must depend upon the character of its bearer, and the intentions which led him to carry it upon his person; and, to use a better illustration, an ill-told tale may be the honest endeavour of a true but blundering messenger to convey as much of truth as he had been able to grasp, or it may be the deep designing attempt of a villain to force us to receive a lie by coating it with so much of truth as may overcome our suspicions. It is not, therefore, unreasonable that we should hesitate when we are dealing with anonymous writers who may have other reasons for withholding their names beyond those which modesty would supply. In itself and by itself there is so much good lacking in the book, and so much evil present, that the portion of good which exists is neutralised, and the whole is unhealthy and unsafe. Yet much must depend upon the writer's personal state and position. If this treatise be the production of a minister of any denomination of evangelical Christians, he ought, if he has even half as much honesty as an ordinary thief, to resign his position at once; we place his honesty at that low mark, because if he had possessed a larger share he could not, being a minister, have written the book at all. If, on the other hand, the man who produced these pages be a thoughtful sceptic feeling his way out of the dark regions of unbelief into some degree of holy light; if, as a cautious discoverer, taking nothing for granted, he is content to make his way slowly by painful gropings for the right path, we rejoice in much that he has learned, but regret that he had not gone further before he gave his thoughts to the world. What is medicine to one man may be poison to another, and men inured to the deadly drugs of doubt may receive not only harmlessly but possibly even with benefit doses of speculation which it were injudicious to offer to others. This last theory we can scarcely espouse. There are evidences of an acquaintance with Scripture, religious life, and spiritual truth rarely possessed by any but those who have sojourned among the tribes of our Israel. We incline to a third supposition, namely, that one of our Broad-churchmen has been muddling his brains with the works of Renau and other blasphemers, and has in addition drank deep of German rationalism, and on the whole has been descending upon a sliding scale to the very depths of atheism, until, growing uneasy at the lengths to which he feels himself going, he desires to halt, and by a most laborious process pulls himself up by hanging upon a thorn-bush and pitching his foot against a crag; that process of pulling up he here describes. The point at which he stops is illogical and dangerous, and that he will remain long in the same place is uncertain, but still he is so pleased to attain a resting place of any sort that he cannot resist telling us how he got there, and what he stands upon. If this be so, we so deeply pity the author for his previous career in the melancholy regions of doubt, and are so happy to see a fellow creature getting a little light that we cannot condemn him for its haziness, but are rather anxious to watch the way by which the morning cometh to the man

who has long dwelt in darkness, although we much question whether this darkness which is still around him is not far greater than the light. The writer, be he who he may, is no blasphemer of the Lord Jesus, but a warm admirer of the self-denying love of the Man of Sorrows; he sees in him a marvellous revelation of moral truth and power, and believes the great principles of Christianity to be eternal truth. He is a Christian from the point of morals; but, theologically, he will not commit himself; he subscribes to the ethics of the prophet of Nazareth, but counts it to be a part of those ethics to hold his mind free to believe whatever enthusiasm may suggest to it. He believes that Christ has made men free, free even from himself; so that he declares that even the New Testament, the precepts of the Apostles, and the special commands of Christ are not the Christian law. He bows before the majesty of the life of Christ, and says of him—

"This unique man was elected to a unique sorrow, and holds as undisputed a sovereignty in suffering as in self-devotion, all lesser examples and lives will for ever hold a subordinate place, and serve chiefly to reflect light on the central and original Example. In his wounds all human sorrows will hide themselves, and all human self-denials support themselves against his cross."

And yet he talks of Christianity as "one of many revelations, and very insufficient by itself for man's happiness;" libellously asserting that some of the men in whom the Christian spirit has been strongest have been among the most miserable of the race. Coming from a heathen we should hopefully accept the admiring testimony which is rendered to Jesus, and reckon it to be a serviceable answer to the outrageous slanders of vulgar infidels; but coming from one who would probably reckon himself to be a Christian, the kiss of Judas and the fair speeches of the serpent are forcibly called to our remembrance. To a very small class of intellectual seekers our author may render some service, especially if they are able to drive his statements to their proper conclusions, but we fear that to the generation of little men who are fond of every new thing which looks like intellectuality, it will have all the dazzle and danger of a penny candle in the midst of a company of silly moths. The preface gives a statement of the author's professed end and aim, and is needful to our enquiry.

"Those who feel dissatisfied with the current conceptions of Christ, if they cannot rest content without a definite opinion, may find it necessary to do what to persons not so dissatisfied it seems audacious and perilous to do. They may be obliged to reconsider the whole subject from the beginning, and placing themselves in imagination at the time when he whom we call Christ bore no such name, but was simply, as St. Luke describes him, a young man of promise, popular with those who knew him and appearing to enjoy the Divine favour, to trace his biography from point to point, and accept those conclusions about him, not which church doctors or even apostles have sealed with their authority, but which the facts themselves, critically weighed, appear to warrant.

"This is what the present writer undertook to do for the satisfaction of his own mind, and because, after reading a good many books on Christ, he felt still constrained to confess that there was no historical character whose motives, objects, and feelings remained so incomprehensible to him. The enquiry which proved serviceable to himself may chance to be useful to others.

"What is now published is a fragment. No theological questions whatever are here discussed. Christ, as the creator of modern theology and religion, will make the subject of another volume, which, however, the author does not

311

hope to publish for some time to come. In the meanwhile he has endeavoured to furnish an answer to the question, What was Christ's object in founding the Society which is called by his name, and how is it adapted to attain that object?"

We believe that the character of our Lord Jesus is still far above the writer's comprehension, but it is something that he should have avowed his full belief in the existence of such a person as he does in the following passage:—

"Now the present treatise aims to show that the Christ of the Gospels is not mythical, by showing that the character those biographies portray is in all its large features strikingly consistent, and at the same time so peculiar as to be altogether beyond the reach of invention both by individual genius and still more by what is called the 'consciousness of an age.'"

It is more satisfactory still to find him assigning to the Saviour motives and virtues which render it far more easy for us to believe him to be divine than to conceive of him as mere man. As we have said before, our author has a sincere admiration for Christ, as he always calls him, and makes his example the flame at which holiness is kindled, but he has nothing to say for his deity, his atonement, or any of those verities which are the soul and marrow of the revelation of Jesus. According to him, the great Teacher resolved to re-establish in its sublimest form a Theocracy, a spiritual kingdom in which he should from sheer superiority of loveliness represent Jehovah and be the spiritual King; this kingdom was to be founded upon the great principles of unselfishness and holiness of which he himself was the great model. Men were no longer to be coldly virtuous, but to glow with holy enthusiasm because of their attachment to his supremely excellent person; these men associated into societies called churches were to uplift others, and by united zeal to rouse the nations to admire the good and the true. Religious enthusiasm, which is the author's rational term for the Holy Spirit, elevates the soul to so consecrated a pitch, that it becomes a law unto itself and renders not mere obedience, but self-denying devotion to the great Leader and the spirit which he exhibited. The grand scheme of establishing by force of love an abiding spiritual empire the man Jesus commenced by his life and established by his death. This is a very brief and incomplete sketch of our author's story.

Miracles are not denied, nor is even the Deity of Christ impugned, but there is an evident shirking of the supernatural, and an attempt to explain the whole of "the wonders of the cross," upon a theory as little as possible objectionable to the sceptic. Still the author so clearly sees that Christ's kingdom is spiritual, that its forces are also purely spiritual, and that its principles are in the highest degree promotive of freedom, philanthropy, brotherhood, and progress, and he is withal so free from the views which priestcraft always takes of the church of Christ, that it is difficult to read long without finding much valuable thought. There is, moreover, a great deal that is fresh and suggestive, which may be plucked out of the fire and turned to good account; it is for the sake of these portions that we have occupied any of our slender space with a book so out of our ordinary track. We heard the lion roar, we turned aside; we found honey in its carcase, and we would not eat it alone. The writer's version of our Lord's temptation in the

wilderness, although thoroughly rationalistic, has much in it which sets out the threefold conflict in a novel light; and if it be understood as referring only to our Lord's manhood, we are glad of the new view which it opens up.

"He finds himself in a barren region without food. The tumult of his mind has hitherto kept him unconscious of his bodily wants, but the overwhelming reaction of lassitude now comes on. And with the hunger comes the temptation, 'Son of God, into whose service all natural forces have been given, command that these stones become bread.' The possession of special power, and nothing else, constitutes the temptation here; it is the greatest with which virtue can be assailed. By it the virtuous man is removed from ordinary rules, from the safe course which has been marked by the footsteps of countless good men before him, and has to make, as it were, a new morality for himself. In difficult circumstances few men can wield extraordinary power long without positively committing crime. But here we see the good man placed in a position utterly strange, deprived of the stay of all precedent or example, gifted with power not only extraordinary but supernatural and unlimited, and thrown for his morality entirely upon the instinct of virtue within him. Philosophers had imagined some such situation, and had presented it under the fable of the ring of Gyges, but with them the only question was whether distinctions of right and wrong would not vanish altogether in such circumstances. The question by which Christ's mind was perplexed was far different; it was what newer and stricter obligations are involved in the possession of new powers.

"A strange, and yet, given the exceptional circumstances, a most natural and necessary temptation. Still more unique, and yet at the same time natural, is Christ's resistance to it. Unique by its elevation, and natural by its appropriateness to his character. He is awe-struck rather than elated by his new gifts; he declines to use for his own convenience what he regards as a sacred deposit committed to him for the good of others. In his extreme need he prefers to suffer rather than to help himself from resources which he conceives placed in his hands in trust for the kingdom of God. Did ever inventor or poet dare to picture to himself a self-denial like this? But, on the other hand, what course could so exactly suit the character of Christ as the Baptist painted it? What answer could more exquisitely become the Lamb of God than that quotation—'Man doth not live by bread only, but by every word that proceeds out of the mouth of God'? Is it not substantially the same as that which the Psalmist uses in the very psalm in which he pictures himself as one of God's lambs, 'He prepareth for me a table in the wilderness'?

"Then follows a temptation, which again is extremely appropriate, because it is founded upon this very confidence of Divine protection. A new temptation arises by reaction out of the triumph of faith: 'Throw thyself down, for it is written, He shall give His angels charge over thee, and in their hands they shall bear thee up.' To no other person but Christ could such a temptation occur; to him, we may boldly say, such a temptation must, at some time, have occurred. And if in the Son of God there was filial reverence as well as filial confidence, it must have been resisted, as it is recorded to have been resisted, 'Thou shalt not tempt the Lord thy God.'

"The third temptation is somewhat less easy to understand, but its appropriateness to the character and condition of Christ, and its utter inappropriateness to every other character and condition, are quite as clear. A vision of universal monarchy rose before him. What suggested such thoughts to the son of a carpenter? What but the same new sense of supernatural power which tempted him to turn stones into bread, and to throw himself into the arms of ministering angels? This, together with the Baptist's predictions, and those Messianic predictions of the ancient prophets, on which we can imagine that he had been intensely brooding, might naturally suggest such an imagination. He pictured himself enthroned in Jerusalem as Messiah, and the gold of

313

Arabia offered in tribute to him. But, says the narrative, the devil said to Him, If thou wilt fall down and worship me, all shall be thine. This, at least, it may be thought, was not a temptation likely to overcome the Lamb of God. One remarkable for simplicity of character, one who was struggling with the fresh conviction that he was himself that Messiah, that beloved Son of God, whose glorious reign wise men had been permitted to foresee from a distance of centuries; was he, in the moment of his first enthusiasm, and fresh in the possession of sacred prerogatives of power, which he feared to use in self-defence even against famine, likely to do homage to a spirit of evil for that which he must have believed to be surely his by gift of God? We should remember that the report of these temptations, if trustworthy, must have come to us through Christ himself, and that it may probably contain the facts mixed with his comments upon them. We are perhaps to understand that he was tempted to do something which on reflection appeared to him equivalent to an act of homage to the evil spirit. What then could this be? It will explain much that follows in Christ's life, and render the whole story very complete and consistent, if we suppose that what he was tempted to do was to employ force in the establishment of his Messianic kingdom. On this hypothesis, the third temptation arises from the same source as the others; the mental struggle is still caused by the question how to use the supernatural power. Nothing more natural than that it should occur to Christ that this power was expressly given to him for the purpose of establishing, in defiance of all resistance, his everlasting kingdom. He must have heard from his instructors that the Messiah was to put all enemies under his feet, and to crush all opposition by irresistible God-given might. This certainly was the general expectation; this appeared legibly written in the prophetic books. And, in the sequel, it was because Christ refused to use his supernatural power in this way that his countrymen rejected him. It was not that they expected a king, and that he appeared only as a teacher; on the contrary, he systematically described himself as a king. The stumbling-block was this, that, professing to be a king, he declined to use the weapons of force and compulsion that belong to kings. And as this caused so much surprise to his countrymen, it is natural that he should himself have undergone a struggle before he determined thus to run counter to the traditional theory of the Messiah and to all the prejudices of the nation. The tempter, we may suppose, approached him with the whisper, 'Gird thee with thy sword upon thy thigh; ride on, and thy right hand shall teach thee terrible things.'

"If this was the temptation, then again how characteristic of the Lamb of God was the resistance to it, and at the same time how incomparably great the self-restraint involved in that resistance! One who believes himself born for universal monarchy, and capable by his rule of giving happiness to the world, is entrusted with powers which seem to afford the ready means of attaining that supremacy. By the overwhelming force of visible miracle it is possible for him to establish an absolute dominion, and to give to the race the laws which may make it happy. But he deliberately determines to adopt another course, to found his empire upon the consent and not the fears of mankind, to trust himself with his royal claims and his terrible purity and superiority defenceless among mankind, and, however bitterly their envy may persecute him, to use his supernatural powers only in doing them good."

The following portrait of Jesus with the woman taken in adultery is equally vivid and original, and possibly we may add accurate:—

"Some of the leading religious men of Jerusalem had detected a woman in adultery. It occurred to them that the case afforded a good opportunity of making an experiment upon Christ. They might use it to discover how he regarded the Mosaic law. That he was heterodox on the subject of that law they had reason to believe, for he had openly quoted some Mosaic maxims and declared them at least incomplete, substituting for them new rules of his own,

which at least in some cases appeared to abrogate the old. It might be possible, they thought, by means of this woman to satisfy at once themselves and the people of his heterodoxy. They brought the woman before him, quoted the law of Moses on the subject of adultery, and asked Christ directly whether he agreed with the lawgiver. They asked for his judgment.

"A judgment he gave them, but quite different, both in matter and manner, from what they had expected. In thinking of the 'case' they had forgotten the woman, they had forgotten even the deed. What became of the criminal appeared to them wholly unimportant; towards her crime or her character they had no feeling whatever, not even hatred, still less pity or sympathetic shame. If they had been asked about her, they might probably have answered, with Mephistopheles, 'She is not the first;' nor would they have thought their answer fiendish, only practical and business-like. Perhaps they might on reflection have admitted that their frame of mind was not strictly moral, not quite what it should be, that it would have been better if, besides considering the legal and religious questions involved, they could have found leisure for some shame at the scandal and some hatred for the sinner. But they would have argued that such strict propriety is not possible in this world, that we have too much on our hands to think of these niceties, that the man who makes leisure for such refinements will find his work in arrears at the end of the day, and probably also that he is doing injustice to his family and those dependent on him.

"This they might fluently and plausibly have urged. But the judgment of Christ was upon them, making all things seem new, and shining like the lightning from the one end of heaven to the other. He was standing, it would seem, in the centre of a circle, when the crime was narrated, how the adultery had been detected in the very act. The shame of the deed itself, and the brazen hardness of the prosecutors, the legality that had no justice and did not even pretend to have mercy, the religious malice that could make its advantage out of the fall and ruin and ignominious death of a fellow-creature—all this was eagerly and rudely thrust before his mind at once. The effect upon him was such as might have been produced upon many since, but perhaps upon scarcely any man that ever lived before. He was seized with an intolerable sense of shame. He could not meet the eye of the crowd, or of the accusers, and perhaps at that moment least of all of the woman. Standing as he did in the midst of an eager multitude that did not in the least appreciate his feelings, he could not escape. In his burning embarrassment and confusion he stooped down so as to hide his face, and began writing with his finger on the ground. His tormentors continued their clamour, until he raised his head for a moment and said, 'He that is without sin among you let him first cast a stone at her,' and then instantly returned to his former attitude. They had a glimpse perhaps of the glowing blush upon his face, and awoke suddenly with astonishment to a new sense of their condition and their conduct. The older men naturally felt it first and slunk away; the younger followed their example. The crowd dissolved and left Christ alone with the woman. Not till then could he bear to stand upright; and when he had lifted himself up, consistently with his principle, he dismissed the woman, as having no commission to interfere with the office of the civil judge.

"But the mighty power of living purity had done its work. He had refused to judge a woman, but he had judged a whole crowd. He had awakened the slumbering conscience in many hardened hearts, giving them a new delicacy, a new ideal, a new view and reading of the Mosaic law."

When dealing with "the Society," by which the author means the church, he gives us the following passage, which has in it a weighty truth. He has been speaking of the need of finding outlets for the activities of the higher life of enthusiasm, and he says:—

"Societies do this, but for the most part at present in a very insufficient

315

way. They do require from their members an effort of will, a deed, and one involving self-denial; they require a subscription of money. The money goes to furnish that comparatively small proportion of the members of the society who are personally grappling with the evil to remove which the society was formed. But from the majority nothing further is required; all personal service in the cause of humanity is commuted for a money-payment. So customary has this become that the word charity has acquired a new meaning; a man's charity, that is, his love for his fellow-creatures, is commonly estimated in pounds, shillings, and pence. But it is a question whether this commutation, however customary, is altogether legal in the Christian Republic. It would appear that St. Paul recognised a broad distinction between charity and money-donations. He seems to have thought that a man might give away all his property and yet have no charity. Perhaps we are rather to compare the Christian Republic with those famous states of antiquity which in their best days required the personal service of every citizen in the field, and only accepted a money-equivalent from those who were incapacitated from such service. It is characteristic of the Christian State that it depends for its very existence on the public spirit of its citizens. The states of the world are distinguished from each other visibly by geographical boundaries and language. But the Christian Republic scarcely exists apart from the Enthusiasm which animates it; if that dies it vanishes like a fairy city, and leaves no trace of its existence but empty churches and luxurious sinecurists. And assuredly he who remembers his citizenship in it only by the taxes he pays is but one step removed from forgetting it altogether.

"If then the Christian Humanity is to be maintained at the point of enthusiasm in a man upon whom the cares of middle life have come, he must not content himself with paying others to do Christian work. He must contribute of his gifts, not merely of his money. He must be a soldier in the campaign against evil, and not merely pay the war-tax. But then it is too much to expect that he should find work for himself. Spenser allegorizes ill when he represents his Red Cross Knight as pricking forth alone in quest of adventures. At least this sort of soldiering is long out of date. In civilized war men are marshalled in companies, and put under the orders of a superior officer. To drop the figure, a flourishing Church requires a vast and complicated organization, which should afford a place for every one who is ready to work in the service of humanity. The enthusiasm should not be suffered to die out in any one for want of the occupation best calculated to keep it alive. Those who meet within the church walls on Sunday should not meet as strangers who find themselves together in the same lecture-hall, but as co-operators in a public work the object of which all understand and to his own department of which each man habitually applies his mind and contriving power. Thus meeting, with the esprit de corps strong among them, and with a clear perception of the purpose of their union and their meeting, they would not desire that the exhortation of the preacher should be, what in the nature of things it seldom can be, eloquent. It might cease then to be either a despairing and over-wrought appeal to feelings which grow more callous the oftener they are thus excited to no definite purpose, or a childish discussion of some deep point in morality or divinity better left to philosophers. It might then become weighty with business, and impressive as an officer's address to his troops before a battle. For it would be addressed by a soldier to soldiers in the presence of an enemy whose character they understood and in the war with whom they had given and received telling blows."

The subjoined sentences we marked in reading, and on looking at them again they seem to us worthy of the most earnest heed:—

"Christianity, then, would sacrifice its divinity if it abandoned its missionary character and became a mere educational institution. Surely this Article of Conversion is the true articulus stantis aut cadentis ecclesiae. When the power

of reclaiming the lost dies out of the Church, it ceases to be the Church. It may remain a useful institution, though it is most likely to become an immoral and mischievous one. Where the power remains, there, whatever is wanting, it may still be said that 'the tabernacle of God is with men.'

Many such flowers there are in this basket, but amid them the asp is hidden as we have already shown, and therefore the flowers themselves wither in our sight. We hear that the question of the writer's honesty has been raised; as we read we felt indignant at what seemed to us a gratuitous imputation, till we came to sundry infamously cold-blooded remarks upon war, capital punishment, and the infernal auto da fé of the Spanish Inquisition, which when contrasted with the author's account of our Lord's rejection of all physical force, and his eulogies of our Lord's humanity of character, led us to think that the imputation may not have been ill founded after all. We are loath to think more harshly than is necessary of those from whom we differ, but we cannot do less than express our suspicion. He who is so flagrantly false to his own avowed admirations, may not be so sincere in them as he pretends. Genuine Christianity would condemn cruelty and murder when practised upon heresiarchs and sophists quite as much as when saintly martyrs are the victims, but not so the liberalism of the writer under review. It seems that these admirers of theoretical freedom make good advocates for persecution, and we doubt not if the lovers of "a narrow-minded orthodoxy" were subjected to their tender mercies, they would find them none too gentle. The following sentences might have been written by Mephistopheles himself, and suffice to show the cloven foot peeping from beneath a flowing robe of admirable texture.

"Our good sense may be shocked still more when we think of the auto da fé. We may well exclaim upon the folly of those who could dream of curing intellectual error by intellectual bondage. Our humanity itself may be shocked by the greater number of these deeds of faith. We may say of the perpetrators of them, These are they that kill the prophets; their zeal for truth is feigned; they are the slaves of spiritual pride. But if you could be sure that it was not the prophet but the pernicious sophist that burned in the fire, and if by reducing his too busy brain to safe and orthodox ashes you could destroy his sophistries and create in other minds a wholesome fear of sophistry, without creating at the same time an unwholesome dread of intellectual activity and freedom, then Christian humanity might look with some satisfaction even on an auto da fé. At any rate, the ostensible object of such horrors was Christian, and the indignation which professedly prompts them is also Christian, and the assumption they involve, that agonies of pain and blood shed in rivers are less evils than the soul spotted and bewildered with sin, is most Christian."

We are sorry for the sake of human nature that such sentences could have been penned by one who knows so well that Jesus would have loathed persecution in its very mildest form, and that to burn and torture men by wholesale process as in an auto da fé could never under any pretences or circumstances be the result of Christian feeling, or be justified by Christian impulses. That Jesus is intolerant of error is true, and no one more fully proclaims this than ourselves, but to say that he is intolerant of errorists, so as to teach us to touch their persons or estates, is as the author knows most wicked and libellous. How he could so diverge from his path as to pen the above passage we cannot tell, but its effect upon our own mind is to make us suspect that the

317

calm reasoning of the author's page is but a veil for a cool calculating hatred of the real teaching of the Saviour, and that beneath the semblance of reverent admiration for the teacher of Galilee, there lurks a bitter contempt for the claims of the Incarnate God. Whether it be so or no his next volume may help us to determine. Meanwhile let the man who has any call to deal with such ware and is skilled in discerning the real and the counterfeit read if he wills, for he may possibly read to profit; but as for those who have no vocation in the realm of speculation, let them abide at home in the old faith for the land is not rich enough to repay them for the toil of traversing it.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate