Jerusalem which is Above
A STRANGE notion has been very extensively circulated during the past few years—that Old Testament saints have no part in the promise to reign with Christ in glory. The question has been just propounded to us in a letter from a person, who, though now removed to a distance, gratefully owns some obligations to our ministry for instruction in the doctrines of the covenant of grace, as well as for our frequent exposition of dispensational truth. And we have felt that in meeting the scruples of one we may be anticipating the exercises of many minds. We therefore propose to transfer from the pulpit to the press some reference to the substantial promises on which we rest, and the hope that animates us in travelling forward to that "reward of the inheritance" which stimulated patriarchs and prophets as well as apostles and martyrs.
It is not difficult to trace the schismatic doctrine we repudiate to certain so-called "Brethren," whose empty conceit of their own superiority has led them to displace Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, together with all the saints of whom Moses said, in the name of the Lord, "All his saints are in thy hand," in order to make room for their own ambition to occupy the highest seats in the synagogue of heaven.
Whether the dogma be a novelty hatched on the western coast of England, or whether it be a revival of the Popish theory that gives the title of "saints" only to those who have lived under the Christian dispensation, we are not careful to determine. For our part we would as freely speak of St. Abraham as of St. Peter, and recognise the bond of brotherhood that unites us to Isaiah as fully as to Paul. But the less we have to say to such as pervert the gospel the better. In the jealous regard we entertain for our own flocks, we must warn them against such seducers. They tell us with the utmost persistency that they are not a sect. What they are then is left to our conjectures; and we have thought that it must be interpreted in one of three ways. If they are not a sect, they may pretend to be the Church of Christ on earth;—holy, catholic, and undivided. This, we think, is really too absurd to need refutation. Or perhaps they are not a sect because, attached to no particular fellowship, they hold communion with all who love the Lord Jesus Christ, in whatever denomination they may be folded together. That such however is not the case we have palpable evidence; for their adherents are the most captious, quarrelsome, cynical and exclusive professors of religion to be found among Protestants. What other solution of the riddle can we fly to, unless it be that they are not a sect, or section of the church of Christ at all? This view has been recently taken in the adjudication of one of our law-courts, and so far as we can discern in simple justice without any breach of charity. What palpable element of a
church can you discover in a divided fraternity which acknowledges no creed, no ministry, no church order, substitutes private meetings for public worship, owns no rule as to one ordinance, and gives a social rather than a sacred character to the other ordinance?
We sincerely hold that their identity is not positive enough to be determined, and their profession too saponaceous for us to take hold of. Reader, we appeal to yourself. Suppose some benevolent individual like Mr. Peabody were to leave a quarter of a million of money to be divided among the poor members of all the churches in Lambeth, without respect to creed or denomination. I fancy among the communities that apply for a share in this bounty there is one from the church at 24½ Wentworth Place—first floor. Why what church is that? A very blessed church, it is replied, just such an one as Mr. Spurgeon described in a recent sermon (see "Baptist Messenger" for February). It consists of a father, a mother, a son, a daughter, and a servant, who have family worship every day. Would it be a gross injustice if the claim were disallowed? And yet its ecclesiastical character would be as palpable or more so than full many a Brethren's meeting. We can imagine for this family that the members stand in full alliance with the evangelical churches of Christendom. And we can suppose for those Brethren that they deny the imputed righteousness of Christ, forbid adoration to the Holy Ghost, and busy themselves with secret efforts to seduce believers from their stedfastness rather than to draw unbelievers to Christ, practically doing much to foster division, but certainly never endeavouring to keep the unity of the spirit in the bond of peace.
Justice demands one of two things, either that we acknowledge the Brethren as a sect, or that we discountenance them altogether as being no sect. They are not the whole church, whether they are a section of it or not.
Confining ourselves now to one point, we shall speak of "the new Jerusalem," and in order to limit our review of that one point, we shall at once profess our attachment to the pre-millennial school of interpretation, and the literal reading of those Scriptures that predict the return of the Jews to their own land. To those who hold opposite views, the insidious question at issue, though equally repulsive, would have other bearings.
There are, then, two economies of God revealed in Scripture; of these we ordinarily speak as the Jewish and the Gentile dispensations. There are two peoples declared to be the objects of Jehovah's choice; the nation of Israel, and the church of Christ. There are two territories comprised in the scheme of prophecy; the earthly and the heavenly. We, according to God's promise, look for new heavens and a new earth wherein dwelleth righteousness.
As to the former of these economies we possess two sources of information, the one relating to its past history, the other relating to its future destiny. In that history we find the providence of God related in multiplying the seed of Jacob, in bringing them, after much severe discipline and many trials, into the land of Canaan, placing them under a provisional law, establishing among them a holy temple and a royal throne, and afterwards punishing the people for their iniquities with banishment and dispersion. Yet it is the unanimous voice of all their inspired prophets that God would not make a full end of the nation. Of this he gave two distinct signs; first, that their land should lay desolate; and, secondly, that their posterity instead of losing their identity by mixing with other races, should remain distinct and easily recognisable. Both these facts are open to our current observation, and evident to us at the present day. Then we are taught that there is a destiny both to the land and to the people which shall obliterate the shame of their youth. The former and latter rain, long withheld, shall come down in plenteous showers to fructify her soil, and beautify her desert plains; her city shall be rebuilt; her temple restored; her sons and daughters gathered together from all countries, and her ascendancy among the nations established.
As to the latter of these two economies, we have the account of a people belonging to no particular tribe or family of mankind, but an elect of all nations.
373
Their present history is detached and fragmentary. It is a record of trials and struggles that betoken a fight for existence rather than a struggle for supremacy. Ever victorious, the results of their oft-repeated triumph of faith are of little account in this world. Followers of the Crucified, the sphere of their full development is the world to come. That this was and is the object of their desire, the annals of every godly life, the theme of every faithful ministry, and the hymns of every devout congregation, bear abundant evidence. They have a hope, and that hope not merely personal. They look forward to the joyful era when all who have witnessed the good confession shall be gathered together in one, and dwell together in happiness and harmony. They turn their thoughts toward the consummation of that prospect in a definite locality. To one particular city of habitation they aspire. Now what is that city called? When we answer this question we touch the casus belli. It is called "Jerusalem."
Then the city of terrestrial and the city of celestial hope, each bears the name of Jerusalem. The latter, however, hath a superior designation—"Jerusalem which is above." "The New Jerusalem."
Is there any difficulty now in resolving the problem—for which of these cities did Abraham look? It is, we allege, so easy, simple, and obvious that it never involved a problem until a demur was wilfully introduced a few years ago by a certain party that is not itself a sect, never agrees with any sect, while it is banded together for the express purpose of dividing the church in theory and fact, carrying out the plan of the serpent in Eden; asking questions that may impugn the veracity of God, and sowing doubts that may occasion discord in the elect family.
In the eleventh chapter of the Epistle to the Hebrews we have some very important testimony. "By faith Abraham, when he was called to go out into a place which he should after receive for an inheritance, obeyed; and he went out, not knowing whither he went. By faith he sojourned in the land of promise, as in a strange country, dwelling in tabernacles with Isaac and Jacob, the heirs with him of the same promise: For he looked for a city which hath foundations, whose builder and maker is God." What now does the city that hath foundations refer to? Does it not point to that city spoken of in Revelation xxi. 14, where we read, "The wall of the city had twelve foundations, and in them the names of the twelve apostles of the Lamb." This obvious reference might be assigned among many reasons for doubting the correctness of the date commonly appended to the Apocalypse. Or would any one say it might possibly refer to Isaiah liv., where especially in the eleventh verse mention of the foundations is made, we should produce the absolute testimony of the Holy Ghost that this chapter relates to the New Jerusalem (see Gal. iv. 26, 27).
At the sixteenth verse of the same eleventh chapter of the Epistle to the Hebrews, the testimony concerns not Abraham only, but all the patriarchs. "Now they desire a better country, that is, a heavenly; wherefore God is not ashamed to be called their God; for he hath prepared for them a city." How would the argument hang together which should pretend that because they sought a heavenly country, therefore God prepared for them an earthly city? There are two other passages in the Epistle to the Hebrews respecting the city: "But we are come unto Mount Zion, and unto the city of the living God, the heavenly Jerusalem, and to an innumerable company of angels." Chap. xii. 22. "Here we have no continuing city, but we seek one to come." Chap. xiii. 14.
We venture to affirm that not one of these four allusions to "the city" in the Epistle to the Hebrews can justly be said to have any pertinence to the earthly city of Jerusalem, or to the Millennium. It is the distortion of Scriptures like these which brings into disrepute among Christians the transparent prophecy contained in other parts of the blessed Volume that does relate to a terrestrial condition. Whatever city the Apostle refers to, the patriarchs looked forward to it; and whatever faith of expectancy animated them in their dying hours, it was the self-same with that of the Christian church. They died in faith, seeing afar off
promises which they could not then enter into possession of, because "they without us cannot be made perfect." Comp. Heb. xi. 13 with Heb. xi. 39, 40.
In observing the ready ear that is given to the strange vagaries of seducers,* we are often at a loss to discover any charm in their new theories. To ourselves and to the noble host of evangelical witnesses whose sermons and treatises have come down to us, there has always been a sweet attraction in the unity of faith and hope. We liked to hear the Jewish prophets utter the invitation, "Rejoice, ye Gentiles, with his people." And then in the days of Israel's degradation, we admire the vigour of the apostle of the Gentiles, when he protested, "God hath not cast away his people which he foreknew." The heavenly city has the prospect of congenial associations when we read of sitting down with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob there.
And is all this to be changed? Must the pleasing spell be broken by the cold repulsive thought that the city which is built by God himself is prepared, not for all the saints, but for the church that was founded at Pentecost or at Plymouth(?) May we no longer sing with Bernard—
"The Lamb is all thy splendour,
The Crucified thy praise;
His land and benediction
Thy ransomed people raise.
Thine ageless walls are bounded
With anethyst unpriced;
The saints build up its fabric,
The corner-stone is Christ."
Must we rather tell how this novelty is built on "SPIRITUAL GIFTS." and the names of the gifted leaders among the Plymouth Brethren must surely be graven in its foundations?
Let us now turn to the Epistle to the Galatians, from which we shall draw some further evidence to confirm our own hearts in the ancient faith.
First, we are taught that the gospel of our salvation is that which Abraham received and held in trust. Can words be more explicit? Could an answer have been framed more exactly to meet the unscrupulous allegations of these modern troublers? "Know ye therefore that they which are of faith, the same are the children of Abraham. And the scripture, foreseeing that God would justify the heathen through faith, preached before the gospel unto Abraham, saying, In thee shall all nations be blessed. So then they which be of faith are blessed with faithful Abraham." Gal. iii. 7—9.
Is it objected that Abraham's lineal descendants, the saintly ones, such as Moses, Samuel, David, Josiah, Daniel, &c., were under the law, and therefore not partakers of the spiritual promises contained in the gospel? We refer to this emphatic passage—"Now I say that the heir as long as he is a child differs nothing from a servant, though he be Lord of all; but is under tutors and governors until the time appointed of the Father. Even so we, when we were children, were in bondage under the elements of the world." Gal. iv. 1. Surely there is only one interpretation of this assertion, and it lies upon the surface. The bondage of the law was temporary; the heirship by which all things were theirs was antecedent to the period of their discipline, and was of inalienable right.
Once more—for it is difficult to shut the mouths of "those who zealously
* "I have been wanting to ask you," said a lady on whom we recently called to make a pastoral visit, "the meaning of that passage in Matthew, 'For as the lightning cometh out of the east and shuneth even unto the west, so shall also the coming of the Son of man be.' Chap. xxiv. 27. Does it not imply two comings?" "There are two different words," I replied, "in the original for 'coming,' one neuter of a thing that comes or happens; the other personal of an individual who makes an appearance." "Ah! but that is not what I mean. I am told that it sets forth two adrenals of Christ, one before and the other after the Millennium!!"
375
affect you, but not well"—they will ask a plain question which might embarrass the weak disciples if they had not a Cyclopædia of all wisdom to resort to. "Was not the posterity of Abraham a fleshly race, with temporal promises and threatenings placed under a conditional covenant?" We will borrow our answer. The mind of the Holy Spirit is expounded by the Apostle Paul on this subject. Gal. iv. 20—31. We recommend a perusal of the whole passage; we shall merely quote the words we want to emphasize:—"Abraham had two sons."
"He who was of the bondwoman was born after the flesh; but he who was of the freewoman was by promise. Which things are an allegory; for these are the two covenants." "Jerusalem which now is, and is in bondage with all her children." "Jerusalem which is above is free, which is the mother of us all." "Now we, brethren, as Isaac was, are the children of promise."
It is our turn to ask a few questions. Who is the father of the faithful? Abraham. Who is the mother of the faithful? The heavenly Jerusalem. How do you distinguish the heirs of the earthly and the heavenly city? By their birth. Who are the heirs of Jerusalem that is above? Those who are born from above. Of which city was Isaac an heir? The same city that all believers now are. And once again, whether was Hagar or Sarah the proper wife of Abraham? Sarah. And what, according to the Holy Ghost's interpretation of this allegory, does Sarah answer to in the order of dispensation? To the new covenant which hath promise of the new Jerusalem. Will those who waver learn this catechism and study the proofs.
Let our enquiries take another turn, while we venture to ask if there is any evidence that the church, as constituted at Pentecost, laid a positive, unequivocal claim to relationship and identity with the Jewish church? Before, however, we quote another text, we beg our readers to observe that we have sought to avoid puzzling them by heaping text upon text. We have asked them to open the Epistle to the Hebrews; then having examined that we have lingered a little while on the Epistle to the Galatians; and now, without distraction, let us turn to the Epistle to the Ephesians. We will pass by the testimony of Paul to the Romans in the ninth chapter, where he represents the graffing of the branches of the wild olive-tree into the good olive tree, merely because the figure employed, however apt in itself, is not consonant with "the city" which we have dwelt upon as the basis of our argument. In Ephesians ii. 11, we read of the past disability of the Gentiles; then as we proceed to the 19th verse we are told of their present immunities in parallel lines.
Remember, that ye being in time past Gentiles in the flesh, who are called Uncircumcision by that which is called the Circumcision in the flesh made by hands.
That at that time ye were without Christ, being aliens from the commonwealth of Israel, and strangers from the covenants of promise, having no hope, and without God in the world.
Now therefore ye are no more strangers and foreigners, but fellow-citizens with the saints, and of the household of God.
With what saints are we fellow-citizens if not with those of the commonwealth of Israel?
And are built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner-stone; in whom all the building fitly framed together groweth unto an holy temple in the Lord: In whom ye also are builded together for an habitation of God through the Spirit.
We might hope that these references to the Word of God would suffice to disabuse the tender lambs of the flock of that delusion so speciously carried
about in the present day. We must not forget, however, the tactics of the foe. Some one will innocently ask who has been preaching on the subject—any one of note? What book has been written? Oh! no, we answer, nothing of that kind. "Of this sort are they which creep into houses, and lead captive silly women laden with sins, led away with divers lusts, ever learning, and never able to come to the knowledge of the truth." They are a wandering tribe, religious gipsies; they are not a sect, they have no country of their own; they profess to have kings and queens who exercise lordship among them, but their laws are not compiled into any code. They are chiefly known as fortune-tellers, practising the art of necromancy upon the Book of the Revelation; and this would be comparatively harmless if they did not decoy members of respectable families of Christian profession away from the homes in which they were born again, with the flattering bait of that fruit which grew of old on the tree of knowledge. And you must never expect books of any magnitude from them. Little tracts they very habitually leave about; but these may be easily recognised by the air of mystery they contain. They do not on the cover draw the attention of the poor to some chapel or edifice where the gospel is preached. Inside they do not avow any great cardinal truth. You, dear reader, are addressed as a believer, and the drift of the address is just to cast discredit upon all the truth you believe and wherein you have been rooted and grounded.
Perhaps now we have scarcely satisfied some wavering minds upon one point. They will ask if, after all, it was not the earthly Jerusalem for which Old Testament saints really did look, even though God in his bounty intended to exceed their hopes with something better? We answer, No, emphatically no;—we will not be decoyed into giving subjection in this matter for a single hour.
The patriarchs did not anticipate that they should inherit an earthly city; for they "confessed that they were strangers and pilgrims on the earth." They desired a better country, that is, a heavenly. "Well, but their case was probably exceptional. They had never seen the hill of Zion, or known anything practically of the temple built there; otherwise they would have changed their opinions." Then we deny that in toto. There was not a single exception among all the godly; under any circumstances they were unanimous in looking for the heavenly city. Even David, with the crown of royalty on his head and the imperial purple on his shoulders, "rejoicing with great joy" in the dedication of offerings for the temple, made profession of the patriarchal disavowment of earth as their home. "For we are strangers before thee and sojourners, as were all our fathers; our days on earth are as a shadow, and there is none abiding." 2 Chron. xxix. 15. Such, too, have been all believers under the New Testament—pilgrims and strangers. Any effort to found a colony of saints or gather a congregation of spiritual men and women into which no alien can enter has proved abortive. The Christendom of this day has no more pretension to purity than the Israel of David's day. That economy ended in defection; so will this. The remnant is saved in both. In fact we see little difference between the children of God who lived before and those who have lived subsequently to the incarnation. We sometimes marvel at the evangelical strain of their ancient hymnology; and we very commonly lament the legal tone of our preaching and prayer in these last days.
It will not be necessary for us to follow out in this article a description of that celestial city, as it is painted in the two last chapters of the Apocalypse; nor yet to mark the essential difference between it and the terrestrial city delineated in the closing chapters of Isaiah and Ezekiel. The measurement differs. Ezekiel's city was 4,500 reeds square; that spoken of by John, 12,000 furlongs square. In the one there is a temple, in the other there is no temple. The prophet tells of waters issuing out of the temple and emptying themselves into the sea; the divine tells us that there was no more sea. And is not the city of which prophets spake rebuilt by man? Not so the heavenly city; its maker and builder is God. The new Jerusalem is prepared in heaven, and descends
377
from thence, coming down to earth. In this resplendent metropolis of the universe God shall dwell with men. His tabernacle shall be pitched with us, lighting the city with his glory. Once he visited the earth on a temporary sojourn, again he comes to take up his permanent abode. This is the consummation of desire, the sum of all delight. The locality of the city is above the earth, or at least in its highest parts, and appears as a sun giving light to the lower parts of the new earth. "The nations* shall walk in the light of it."—Rev. xxi. 10. Its streets are of transparent gold. Its walls clear as glass, so that the splendour within is visible without. The foundations of precious stones are not buried beneath the soil but exposed to view. The gates are each a single pearl. "There shall be no more death, neither sorrow, nor crying, neither shall there be any more pain: for the former things are passed away." "There shall in nowise enter into it anything that defileth, neither whatsoever worketh abomination, or maketh a lie: but they which are written in the Lamb's book of life."
"Beyond the dark and stormy bound
That girds our dull horizon round,
A lovelier landscape swells,
Resplendent seat of light and peace,
In thee the sounds of conflict cease,
And glory over dwells.
For thee the early patriarch sigh'd,
Thy distant beauty faint descried,
And hail'd the bleat abode:
A stranger here, he sought a home,
Fix'd in a city yet to come,
The city of his God.
Oft by Siloa's sacred stream
In heavenly trance and raptured dream
To faithful Israel shown;
Triumphant over all her foes,
The true celestial Salem rose,
Jebovah's promised throne.
We, too, O Lord, would seek that land,
Follow the tribes that crowd its strand,
From every peril saved;
And march, as when in olden time
Were marshall'd all thy hosts sublime,
And high thy banner waved."
