Menu
‹ Chapter 6 of 217 ›

On Duty-Faith — By G. Rogers

12 min read · Chapter 6 of 217

DUTY-FAITH is a modern phrase of frequent use by a certain class of Theologians in our day. It is employed by them as descriptive of the Theological system to which they are opposed, and with the view of holding it up to contempt. They intend it, moreover, to be an avowal on their part, that it is not the duty of man to believe the gospel, that faith is in no sense a duty to saint or sinner, and that no man is responsible for its possession or its exercise. Theirs may be fairly designated, therefore, a No-Duty-Faith. If Duty-Faith be what they repudiate, No-Duty-Faith must be what they approve. It is not intended here to recount the several arguments that might be adduced to prove that it is the duty of all who hear the gospel to believe it, but to show the consequences that inevitably follow from the opposite belief. The truth of a proposition may often be best established by proving its contrary to be absurd. The consequences of No-Duty-Faith are:—

1. That faith is not an act of man, but of God. Either man must believe, or God for him. If man believes, the act of believing is his, and in so doing he either does right or wrong. If right, he has done what it was his duty to do. The principle of saving faith, we admit, is from God; but the exercise or use of that principle is by man. Granting that in the act of believing he is helped by God; help implies that the act is man's, and not God's. So far as man is concerned in believing, duty is implied. In No-Duty-Faith the agency of man is excluded altogether. If faith be a privilege only, it is an act of God only, and not of man.

2. That faith in its own nature is not a duty. Faith, we hold, in everything made known to us, that is accompanied with sufficient evidence, is our duty. It is the right use of the reason which God has given us, and for the right use of which we are responsible. In proportion to the evidence is the duty of believing; and still more in proportion as our own welfare is involved in the belief. It is our duty to believe man when we have no reason to suppose he intends to deceive us. How much more to believe God! The only case in which faith is not a duty, is when the object of faith is unknown, or not sufficiently confirmed. If it be not our duty to have faith in God, much less are we bound to believe those who say faith is no duty at all.

3. That it is not the duty of man to do what God commands him to do. The commands of God are the rule and measure of man's duty. Is faith commanded by God? We reply, Yes! for when the Jews asked him, "What shall we do that we might work the works of God?" Jesus replied, "This is the work of God, that ye believe on him whom he hath sent." He did not mean this is the work of God in you, but this is the work that God requires of you; for that was the subject of their inquiry, and in that sense they understood the reply, as they immediately rejoined, "What sign showest thou then, that we may see and believe thee?" Yes! faith is commanded by God, for in 1 John iii. 23 it is expressly said, "This is his commandment, that we should believe on the name of his Son, Jesus Christ." The next words are, "and love one another." If, therefore, it be our duty to love one another, it is our duty to believe on the name of Jesus Christ,

9

It may be said this refers to the elect only, but if it be the duty of any to believe, Duty-Faith is admitted. In Acts we read that "a company of the priests were obedient to the faith," in the Epistle to the Romans that Paul "received an apostleship for obedience to the faith among all nations," and at the close of that Epistle that the gospel, "according to the commandment of the everlasting God, was made known to all nations for the obedience of faith." Peter too, asks, "What shall be the end of them that obey not the gospel of God?" Three things are evident from these quotations; that the gospel is a new commandment or law to man, that it is the duty of man to obey it, and that faith is the obedience it requires. Numerous other passages, implying the duty of believing the gospel, might be adduced; we have aimed simply to show that it is a positive command, and what God commands, it is man's duty to obey. If it be the duty of the elect to believe, it is equally the duty of the non-elect, since they are, prior to belief, under the same laws, and in the same moral condition; and in one of the instances adduced, the command of Christ to believe in him was given to those of whom it is said, that "many went back, and walked no more with him." The command to believe properly applies to those only who, in the sense of the commandment, have not believed.

It has been said that the non-elect are under the moral law only, and that no requirement of the new dispensation is addressed to them. This, however plausible in theory, is contrary to fact. Men who have the revelation of the gospel are in a more responsible situation than those who have it not, of which the Jews were often reminded by our Lord; and obedience, even to the moral law, required belief in whatever might afterwards be addressed to us by God. No provision, it is said, has been made in the gospel for the salvation of the non-elect, and, therefore, its commands and invitations are not addressed to them. Provision, we admit, must be made to render it the duty of all who hear the gospel to believe it, or the commands and invitations of the gospel would not have been sincere; but the invitations prove ample provision to have been made. Again, it has been said, that it is not the duty of man to do what God has not decreed to be done; consequently, it is not the duty of those who are not decreed to be saved by the gospel to believe it. To act contrary to God's revealed will is one thing, to act contrary to his decreed will is another. We are responsible for the former, but not the latter. What is not revealed, is no rule of duty to us. There may be sin in doing what God has decreed to be done; as in Joseph's brethren, when they sold him into bondage; and in Pharaoh, who was raised up to display the power of God in his people's deliverance; and in the sin of the Jews in crucifying Christ; in which cases their duty was to have acted contrary to the divine decrees; and why not, if it should be so, in believing the gospel? The commands of God are the rule of our duty, not his decrees. Again, we are told, if faith be a duty, it is the duty of man to do what of himself he cannot do. So it is, if he has disqualified himself from doing it, and much more, even then, if God's command implies a promise of help for its fulfilment. There is the command, "Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and thou shalt be saved;" to which, No-Duty-Faith is diametrically opposed, and for which it must give account of itself to God. Another consequence of No-Duty-Faith is:—

4. That man will be punished for not doing what it was not his duty to do.

Condemnation comes upon all men, on account of their violation of the moral law. Here the gospel finds them, and here it leaves them, if it be rejected by them. It does not leave them, however, in the same degree of guilt and condemnation. If their guilt be not removed by receiving the gospel, it is increased by its rejection, and additional condemnation is incurred. "If I had not come and spoken unto them," said Jesus, of the Jews, "they had not had sin," that is the sin of unbelief in him; "but now they have no cloke for their sin." Had not faith in him been a duty, a cloke might easily have been found. "He that believeth not," said the same Divine Teacher, "is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God;" not left in his former condemnation because he hath not believed, but condemned by the light he has already had, because he hath not believed; according to the explanation in the following words, "And this is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil." Again, Jesus said of the Holy Spirit, "When he is come, he will reprove the world of sin, and of righteousness, and of judgment." Of what sin? it may be asked. The reply of Jesus is, "Of sin because they believe not on me." Is not unbelief then a sin? If a sin, is it not liable to punishment? And if unbelief is a sin and condemnatory, is not belief a duty? Why does the apostle point the Jews to their fathers, who incurred the wrath of God, and could not enter into Canaan because of unbelief, and exhort them to take heed lest there should be in them the same evil heart of unbelief, if it were not their duty to believe? And why tell them of sorer punishment than that which befel those who despised Moses' law, that was reserved for those who trod under foot the Son of God, if there were no condemnation for rejecting the gospel, distinct from the law? Why that fearful destruction of the Jewish nation, and their city, and their dispersion to this day? "Because," says Paul, "of unbelief." If, then, it was not their duty to believe in Christ that they might be saved, they are punished for not doing what it was not their duty to do.

5. That the Spirit of God helps men to do what it is not their duty to do. If it be not the duty of men to believe the gospel, and if the Spirit of God helps any to believe, he inclines and enables them to do what it is not their duty to do. If it be our duty to believe with the help of the Spirit of God, it is a duty still; and if with his help, it is our duty before, and without his help; as the very idea of help implies. Whatever the Spirit does for us, is what our interest and our duty to God requires. Faith is the gift of God; but it is not the gift of faith, but the act of faith that saves. The gift is by God, its exercise is by us; and admitting that the gift is both in the principle and its exercise, the Spirit becomes in both respects a party to our believing,—to do what? To do what it was not our duty to do. Faith, it has been said, is a privilege, not a duty; but if it be a privilege, it is the duty of man to seek it on that very account. There is something to be done by man in believing with a view to great privileges; and, certainly, if the Spirit of God helps him in this, and faith be not a duty, he is encouraged, directed, and impelled by the Spirit, to that which he was under no obligation to himself, to his fellow beings, to God, or to his Christ, to perform.

6. That it is not the duty of man to do anything towards his own salvation. If it be not his duty to believe, neither is it to do anything towards it,

11

It is not his duty to read the Scriptures, to go to the house of God, or to pray. How can it be my duty to read the Scriptures, if it be not my duty to believe them? How my duty to hear the preached Word, if it be not my duty to believe it? If it be not my duty to seek an end, it is not my duty to use any means for the attainment of that end. If Duty-Faith be ridiculed, why not duty-repentance, duty-reading, duty-hearing, duty-Sabbath-keeping, and religious duty of every kind? All religion is now given with a view to faith in Christ, and if that be not a duty, all that leads to it ceases to be a duty.

7. That there are no Christian duties. If faith be not a duty, we are exempted from all duty. If the first act of faith be not a duty, neither can any other be, according to No-Duty-Faith. Consequently, faith is not to be reckoned amongst the duties of the Christian. But his whole life is a life of faith; he walks by faith; the life which he lives in the flesh, is by faith in the Son of God; and if faith be not a duty, that which results from faith is not a duty; and, therefore, the Christian has none. All other Christian graces spring from faith, as love, humility, obedience, patience, zeal, hope, joy. If these are duties, so must that be which gives life to them all. "Giving all diligence," says Peter, "add to your faith virtue, and to virtue knowledge, and to knowledge temperance, and to temperance patience, and to patience godliness, and to godliness brotherly kindness, and to brotherly kindness charity." As these graces are to be added to one another, so they are to begin with faith, and to be founded upon it. Faith is the root from which they spring, but the root is of the same nature as the branches. If there be duty in the branches, there is duty in the root also. It is the duty of the root to do its part towards the tree, as well as the branches. If faith is not a duty, neither is prayer, for it must be the prayer of faith; neither is conflict, for it must be the good fight of faith; neither is inward purification, for it must be faith that purifies the heart; neither are outward works, for they are the work of faith. "Take the shield of faith," says an apostle, "and take the sword of the Spirit." If one be a duty, so is the other. In the Epistle to the Hebrews, we are reminded of some of the exploits of faith, what by faith Abel did, and Noah did, and Abraham did, and Moses did, and others did; but, according to No-Duty-Faith, they did what it was not their duty to do. If, in proportion to the faith in good works, they cease to be duties, they would then be duties in proportion as they are destitute of it. An apostle says, "Whatsoever is not of faith is sin." If, therefore, whatsoever is of faith is not duty, no place for active duty remains, except it be a duty to sin. As love fulfils the law, so faith fulfils the gospel. As the duties of the law are included in love, so the duties of the gospel are included in faith.

8. That it is the duty of men to disbelieve the gospel, or to treat it with indifference. The gospel is addressed to them as men; if designed for some more than to others, it is proclaimed alike in the hearing of all. It comes to them, not they to it. It is impossible in most instances where it is proclaimed, to avoid its being made known to them. In this case, three courses of action respecting it, and three only, are open before them. These are to believe it, to disbelieve it, or to disregard it altogether. The third very nearly resolves itself into the second. To be indifferent to it is the result of will, and an act of unbelief. Man, therefore, must believe or disbelieve the gospel; and if it be not his duty to believe it, then it is his

duty to disbelieve it. Some duty must be incurred by the very fact of hearing a revelation from God, to whomsoever it is addressed. Duty is incurred by everything we hear, to believe it, or reject it, or ignore it altogether; but when it comes from God, to reject or to ignore it, must be highly criminal in his creatures; and yet, as some duty must result from it, if that duty be not faith, it must be unbelief or indifference, which amounts to the same thing. We hold, therefore, that if it be not the duty of man to believe the gospel, it is his duty to disbelieve it.

These are some of the consequences necessarily resulting from the sentiment, that it is not the duty of all who hear the gospel to believe it; which cannot, we think, have been sufficiently considered by those who maintain that opinion; and which, it is hoped, may serve in some degree to correct or modify their views upon the subject. Let them consider whether their jealousy for the sovereignty of God on the one hand, does not militate against his equity on the other. Our aim, we hope, is one, and that, whether we strive together or in opposition to each other, it is for the faith of the gospel. May the Spirit of truth lead us into all truth!

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate