Menu
‹ Chapter 78 of 217 ›

Right of Churches to choose their own Pastors — By G. Rogers

19 min read · Chapter 78 of 217

IT has hitherto been an admitted principle of Nonconformist churches that each Church, whether great or small, has its own entire government within itself. It is a voluntary compact for the purpose of observing amongst themselves all the duties and privileges of a Christian Church. This right for a number of individuals to form themselves into such a society is implied in the freedom of their belief, and the ordinary laws of social life. If they are free to embrace and maintain their own Christian principles, they are free to act upon them. If they are free to use them in private and in the family, they are free to exercise them in a more enlarged social community. A man may have a Church in his own house, where no extraneous authority is allowed, and it may be a Church as real and entire as that which numbers its thousands. All agreements among men to form themselves into distinct societies are lawful, provided there be no interference with the rights of others in the objects they have in view, or in the methods by which they are attained. In the case of a number of individuals entering into professed Christian fellowship with each other, no injury is inflicted upon others; no rights of others, social or religious, are infringed; and, consequently, there is no violation of the natural or moral laws of our being. Each voluntary community has its own laws, and each individual who has voluntarily joined that community binds himself to the observance of those laws. The authority to which he is pledged to submit is one, in a measure, of his own choice and his own creating. Such communities may spring up in any numbers and in any place. A Christian Church may rise of itself among any people from the use of the New Testament only. A solitary Christian, without having been an officer or member of any Christian Church, might be instrumental in gaining converts from the heathen, and gathering them into a Church fellowship as genuine and scriptural as any that existed in the times of the apostles. This is the necessary consequence of a religion which gives freedom of belief, and freedom of action according to that belief. It is essential, too, to its unfettered dissemination in the earth.

Such a community, it must be admitted, is a Church so far only as it is conformable to the Church rules and practice of the New Testament, but who is to judge in this case what are the laws of a New Testament Church? Is it competent to take that judgment upon itself? We reply yes! just as competent to think for itself upon this as upon all other doctrines and requirements of Christianity. Let those who deny this inform us why men who are free to believe the Gospel for their own salvation, and free to unite together in Church fellowship, are not equally free to choose their own form of Church government. Why should any foreign aid be required here more than in the previous stages of their faith and practice? Why any pressure from without upon that which is the outgrowth of their own personal and united convictions? If men may be controlled by other men in the exercises of their faith, why not in their faith itself? A Papist who claims the rule of our faith is much more consistent than a Nonconformist who claims dominion over its exercise only.

207

It is presumed, therefore, from the very spirit and genius of Christianity, and from its whole character and design, that each Church or voluntary society of Christians should have its own government entirely within itself, free from Church control derived from any other man or body of men. This is so accordant with the natural and social laws of our being, that a clear and special revelation must have been made, and special reasons assigned had it been otherwise.

Self-government implies, of course, the selection of its own officers either as deacons or to the pastorate. This is the necessary result of its own voluntary constitution. Others might attempt to impose a Church officer upon them, but he cannot become such until he has been voluntarily received by them. No other law than the will of a considerable majority is recognised by them, and if worthy of the name of a Church, brotherly love will ensure submission to that law. As the authority of each Church is entire within itself, so it has no jurisdiction beyond it. One Church has no more power than another. Each is bound by the same laws. The relation of Churches to each other is moral and spiritual only. As families differ in size and influence, so may Churches; but as no family is less under its own self-discipline on that account, neither are the Churches. What is thus true of Churches is true of their pastors. The head of one family has no authority over the children of another, neither has the pastor of one Church over the members of another. Neither has a convocation of pastors any rule over the Churches. Individually they may form fraternities for their own spiritual and ministerial improvement, and synods as the appointed representatives of Churches; but the Churches are not bound by any laws, however strongly recommended and enforced, that have not been voluntarily adopted by themselves. Pastors, as pastors, cannot take action, except in the names of the Churches over which they preside. Their office is not distinct from their charge. Individually, their power is intellectual, or moral, or spiritual, not official. As Church officers are appointed by Churches, so they may be dismissed by them; and no one who is influenced by right motives would wish to retain office among those who, justly or unjustly, had lost confidence in him. When the office has been conferred upon moral or spiritual grounds, and those grounds are entirely changed, the office has virtually ceased. Any persistence in the outward duties of an office when the only authority upon which it was founded is withdrawn, is subversive of all laws human and divine. The same love and mutual confidence bind the pastor to the people that bind the members of the Church to each other. No voluntary society can be coerced within itself or from without, since any part or the whole may retire at pleasure. The constitution of the Church allows no rule but that of love.

Let us see, now, how far these views coincide with New Testament teaching. If they are in harmony with its spirit, and are the natural fruits of its own principles, they needed not to have been formally stated and logically defended, but simply exhibited in the history of the first formation of Churches. It was not absolutely needful that we should have a declaration to the effect that Churches had the right to elect their own pastors and officers. We should rather have required some positive prohibition of such a natural procedure. Supposing the

apostles to have held the principles we have laid down, would they have acted as they did, and written as they have written? We presume that they were agreed upon Church discipline as well as in doctrine; and that one certain form of Church government was unanimously adopted by them. This is implied when Paul says to the Corinthians, "Let all things be done decently and in order;" again, "The rest will I set in order when I come;" and again, "If any man seem to be contentious, we have no such custom, neither the Churches of God." It is implied when he says to the Colossians, "Though I be absent in the flesh, yet am I with you in the spirit, joying and beholding your order, and the steadfastness of your faith." The same word that Paul here uses for order, Luke applies to Zecharias, executing the priest's office before God in the order of his course; showing an order to have been ordained in the Christian as well as in the Jewish Church. It is implied when he says to Titus, "For this cause left I thee in haste, that thou shouldst set in order the things that are wanting." It is implied in the Epistles to the seven Churches in Asia, in which they are censured or commended upon the subject of Church discipline. Had there been no agreement upon this subject amongst the first teachers of Christianity, it could not have been said, "God is not the author of confusion, but of peace, as in all Churches of the saints."

Admitting them now to have had a uniformity of belief and of action in the constitution of Churches, at all times and in all places, did their theory correspond with that which we have ventured to propose as most reasonable and just? Upon this supposition how would they have acted? They would not have censured any Church for presuming to choose its own pastors and officers; neither do we meet with any prohibition of the kind. The Church of Corinth is not blamed for allowing its members to exercise their gifts of teaching, but only for the want of order in their ministrations. The Churches of Galatia are not condemned by Paul for admitting teachers among them without his authority, but for the character of the teachers they had chosen. One of the seven Churches hated the deeds of the Nicolaitanes, another encouraged those who taught their doctrines. Had they both been under one rule this could not have happened, and the Churches themselves would not have been chiefly responsible for this difference between them. If it be said, therefore, that we have no instance in the New Testament of a Church choosing its own officers, it may be fairly replied, Neither have we any instance of one being forced upon them against their own will. Much less have we any injunction to one Church to submit to another, or to the pastor of another; but, on the contrary, each Church is addressed as responsible for its own teachers. "Thou hast them that hold the doctrine of the Nicolaitanes" was the fault of the Church of Pergamos, of which it is required to repent. "Thou sufferest that woman Jezebel, which calleth herself a prophetess, to teach," is the crime with which the Church at Thyatira is charged. If it did not choose its own teachers, the fault would not have been its own. If it should be said the fault lay with the angel or minister of the Church, it is still apart from foreign agency, and the whole responsibility lies within the Church itself.

Had the apostles admitted the right of Churches to choose their own

209

pastors, they would not have forced themselves nor other teachers upon them; neither did they act upon this principle. The apostles had an authority peculiar to themselves. They were the standards of Church doctrine and discipline in the first age of the Church in their oral instructions, as they have since become in their writings; and yet even they desired no other than a voluntary hold upon the Churches that had been planted by their own instrumentality. Paul speaks of himself as the servant of all, rather than of all being in servitude to him. He commends the Galations for the manner in which they first received him, and instead of demanding their submission, appeals to the principles and considerations by which he ought to be reinstated in their affections. When he proposes to visit Churches it is not in the spirit of episcopal authority, but of brotherly love. He could, as an apostle, he says, to the Corinthians, have come to them with a rod, but he would rather come to them in love and in the spirit of meekness. He feared lest he had used too much severity, and assumed too much authority in the matter of Church discipline in his first letter to that people, and rejoiced afterwards when he found his admonitions had been favourably received. Nor was he himself above receiving a commission from the Church at Antioch to accompany Barnabas to convey its contributions for the relief of the brethren which dwelt in Judea, and afterwards to go upon a mission to the heathen. This last was by express direction of the Spirit of God. "The Holy Ghost said, Separate me Barnabas and Saul for the work whereunto I have called them; and when they had fasted and prayed, and laid their hands on them, they sent them away." The chief movers in this were certain prophets and teachers in the Church at Antioch, but it not less showed the deference of Paul to the will of others, rather than an absolute authority over them. When he has occasion to send a minister to any particular Church as his representative, he does not command, but solicits for them a friendly reception. "With Titus," he says to the Corinthians, "we have sent,"—we, not I,—"we have sent with him the brother whose praise is in the gospel throughout all the Churches; and not that only, but who was also chosen of the Churches to travel with us." Here the choice of several Churches uniting in one person as a suitable companion in his travels was greatly valued by Paul. When he sends back Epaphroditus, their own office-bearer, to the Church at Philippi, he entreats them to receive him in the Lord, with all gladness. It was at their option, therefore, though sent by an apostle, either to receive or reject him.

As the apostles did not thrust themselves, neither did they thrust their own sentiments and decrees upon the Churches. Their language is, "I speak as to wise men; judge ye what I say; "Let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind;" "Think of these things;" "Let us, therefore, as many as are perfect be thus minded: and if in anything ye be otherwise minded, God shall reveal even this unto you." Of the council at Jerusalem much has been made in opposition to our views. We humbly conceive it tends to confirm them. The proposal for this council came from the Church at Antioch, which desired some uniformity of belief upon a subject on which their teachers were not agreed. They deputed Paul and Barnabas and certain others to go up

P

to Jerusalem to consult the apostles and elders upon this matter. They were brought on their way by the Church. The council, therefore, did not originate with the apostles themselves. When they came to Jerusalem, "they were received of the Church and of the apostles and elders;" of the Church first. The discussion of the question—as far as can be gathered from the narrative—was confined to the apostles, but was in the presence of the disciples; as it is said, "Then all the multitude kept silence, and gave audience to Barnabas and Paul." James, as the minister of that Church, and ex officio president of its assembly, sums up the evidence and pronounces the final decision. He puts it to the whole assembly, and it is adopted by them. So says the narrative. "Then pleased it the apostles and elders, with the whole Church, to send chosen men of their own company to Antioch, . . . and they wrote by them after this manner." Look at that letter, observe its strain! Is it dictatorial? Is it in the form of an imperious decree? Is it anything more, in fact, than friendly advice, or the expression of an opinion upon a subject according to request? It was a Gentile Church, seeking advice from a Jewish Church in relation to Jewish ceremonials, not upon either Christian doctrine or Church government. "It seemed good unto us," "It seemed good to the Holy Ghost and to us," is the only authority assumed. This letter was read to the Church at Antioch, and gave great satisfaction. It was expressive of the terms upon which Jewish converts were willing to unite with Gentiles in Christian ordinances; a question peculiar to those times, and forming really no precedent for the after guidance of the Church. It settled no doctrine. It interfered with no form of religious worship. It pretended to no dominion over the faith and conduct of others. There was nothing in the whole proceedings contrary to the Saviour's golden rule, "One is your Master, even Christ; and all ye are brethren." How upon this, the only assembly of the kind, the whole fabric of episcopal synods for the regulation of articles of belief and forms of worship could be reared, is known to those only who have other purposes to serve than to bow implicitly to divine truth. A synod so great, even of the apostles themselves to have effected so little, clearly shows that this was not designed to be a governing power in the Church of Christ.

When Peter went to the house of Cornelius, he had, in his own opinion and that of the Jewish converts, acted contrary to Church order, or would have done so if he had not been overruled in the matter by the Spirit of God. He knew that he should be called to account for it by the Church at Jerusalem, and therefore took the six Jewish brethren who had been with him at Cesarea, in order to meet the charges that might be brought against him. "When Peter was come up to Jerusalem, they that were of the circumcision contended with him, saying, Thou wentest in to men uncircumcised, and didst eat with them." They of the circumcision were the Church at Jerusalem, which consisted entirely, it would seem, at that time, of Jewish converts. The same title is given just before to the six brethren who accompanied Peter to the house of Cornelius. Did Peter disavow their authority, and refuse to be accountable to them? Did he appeal to James, the bishop of that Church, or to other elders? No! He "rehearsed the matter from the beginning, and expounded it by order unto them." "When they heard

211

these things they held their peace, and glorified God, saying, Then hath God also to the Gentiles granted repentance unto life." Instead of passing any censure upon Peter, they applauded him for what he had done. Supposing now the highest Church rule to have been in the Church itself, would the narrative have been differently worded? We confidently affirm, it would not. If a synod or archbishop bore rule, the whole scene would have been changed. At Antioch, where the Christians had been part Jews and part Gentiles, Peter, after practising open communion, went back to close communion, "fearing them which were of the circumcision." Had he then more authority over the brethren, or the brethren over him? To cite one more instance. When Paul, after great success amongst the Gentiles, went up to Jerusalem, he gave an account of it first to James, and all the elders of the Church. Was this sufficient to secure the approbation and compliance of the Church itself? They at least did not think so. "When they heard it they glorified the Lord," showing that they were perfectly satisfied with his proceedings; but they added, "Thou seest, brother, how many thousands of Jews there are which believe, and they are all zealous of the law; and they are informed of thee," &c. What is it, therefore? the multitude must needs come together; for they will hear that thou art come." They then propose to him a plan by which they hoped he might propitiate them. Does this look as if the chief rule lay with the pastors of Churches, or with the Churches themselves?

Our argument, we conceive, would derive force from an examination of the titles given to Church officers in the New Testament; and especially from those titles being sometimes interchangeably used. Paul styles himself a deacon in the Epistles to the Ephesians and Colossians, and yet at the commencement of both those epistles he styles himself an apostle. He speaks of Titus and certain brethren as the apostles of the Churches, and the term elder is applied both to bishops and deacons. This might be supposed to prove too much, as though there had been no separate offices in the Church. It goes, in fact, just to the extent we require, that distinct officers were recognized by the Church, but they were lovingly blended together. There was no contention about a name as expressive of an authority, which it would have been sacrilege for others to invade.

The theory of their independence would have led the apostles to give directions to Churches for the selection of pastors and other Church officers. Well! How readest thou? Did not the apostle say to the Church at Jerusalem, "Look ye out among you seven men of honest report, full of the Holy Ghost and wisdom, whom we may appoint over this business"? Did not the Church then choose its officers? and did not the apostles give their sanction to the choice? Timothy is exhorted "to lay hands suddenly on no man," "to commit the things he had heard to faithful men, who shall be able to teach others also," and Titus "to ordain elders in every city;" but all this affirms no more than teaching and ordaining those who have been chosen to the work by others. Why should John say, "Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God; because many false prophets are gone out into the world," if the choice of their prophets was with others and not with themselves? Why, too, again we ask, should any

be blamed for admitting false prophets amongst them? When to Timothy Paul says, "The time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine; but after their own lusts shall they heap to themselves teachers having itching ears," is not the power of the Church to choose teachers of sound or of unsound doctrine implied? This power, too, is most assuredly implied when the Corinthians are said by the apostle to have "set them to judge who are least esteemed in the Church." They are not censured for selecting judges of all matters of Church order, or even of secular disagreement, from among themselves, but for the unwise and partial manner in which that right was exercised. No direction is given to look to other Churches, or other Church authorities of any kind, even when they had abused their own privileges. They are not required to call in foreign aid, but to settle their differences amongst themselves. Had any higher court of appeal existed in Ecclesiastical matters, this would have been an occasion for its aid. Many such tribunals have since been erected, but they were unknown to the apostles. They themselves assumed no such prerogative, and much less conferred it upon others. They could not have said more or less had it been a settled maxim with them, that the Churches had the right of choosing their own pastors. They have written just as persons wishing to have a great moral influence over them, with the most tender regard to their personal and social freedom, would have written. It is surprising that men conscious of so great a superiority over new converts should have touched and trained with so gentle a hand the free-born gifts and graces which, as with a live coal upon their lips, had not long before been kindled into being.

Suppose, now, the apostles to have considered that the Churches had no such power within themselves, but were amenable to some other constituted authority for its pastors and teachers, what course of action and tone of writing would they have adopted? Would they not have clearly stated where that authority resided, and what provision should be made for its continuance? If challenged to produce any passage in the Christian Volume in which the right of the people to choose their own pastors is affirmed, we may safely ask for the production of one in which that power is said to reside elsewhere. Where should we look for this prerogative? If in any one man, his claim must be founded upon apostolic succession, or upon other rules and regulations laid down by the apostles for that purpose. Paul must have nominated a successor, or have instructed the Churches to do it for him. If the power were invested in a synod, the constitution of that synod must have been clearly laid down. If any one Church, on account of its superiority in numbers and qualifications, might exercise a lordly authority over another, we should have required to know the limit beyond which that authority would be generated. The fact is, that the instant you set up a power over Churches, you introduce a higher Church state than that which belongs to a Church properly so called; you erect an intermediate tribunal between each Church and its Lord, and you open an avenue to Ecclesiasticism which has no termination short of the most dominant usurpations of Papal Rome. According to the religion of the New Testament, every man is responsible to God alone for his own belief and practice.

213

No one has any right to coerce another to the profession of any one truth, or the observance of any one religious ordinance. "To his own Master be standeth or falleth." Superiority of rank, talent, or reputation gives to its possessor nothing more than moral influence over others in the Church of Christ. The poorest and most illiterate has the same liberty of judgment and of action as the most wealthy and most wise. On this principle Churches are formed, and by no other method than having the whole voluntary power within themselves could that principle be preserved. It is not violated by submitting to the decision of a whole, of which each one is a part, and to which he has before been voluntarily pledged. It would be violated if that decision were overruled by the introduction of any other power. Once, as we have said, admit a Church power beyond that of the accountability of each member to the Church, and of the Church to its Lord, and the rights of conscience and of private judgment are assailed, and a door is opened for all the abominations of Rome. There may be dissensions and separations upon the principles we have laid down, and such there were in apostolic times, but there may be, and there have been, far greater upon any other. If a Paul could say, "Not for that we have dominion over your faith, but are helpers of your joy," and a Peter, "Neither being lords over God's heritage, but being ensamples to the flock," what right have their successors to talk in any other strain? We are amazed and grieved to observe how, while one party that had half emerged from Romanism, is sinking deeper and deeper in its waters, those who had fled from it with horror draw nearer and view it with less dismay. How is it we hear now of the power of pastors in distinction from Churches and even in opposition to them, of the claim for Church rule of fifteen hundred or two thousand accredited pastors, and of the authority of some Churches over others? For moral influence over Churches that exist, and for the formation of others let pastors combine, but let them beware of spying out their liberty which they have in Christ Jesus that they might bring them into bondage. To all our Churches we would say, "Stand fast, therefore, in the liberty wherewith Christ hath made you free."

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate