The Sword and the Trowel Two Hundred Years ago — By Edward Leach
THE Church's most important work has been accomplished in seasons of the greatest trial. When the trowel was being skilfully used in building up the walls of Jerusalem, it was found necessary to also employ the sword against the enemy. Our Lord, in accomplishing the great work of our redemption, emphatically announced that he had come not to bring peace, but a sword that would divide heterogeneous elements. The foundation upon which the glorious superstructure of Christianity was to arise was laid amid turmoil and strife. In proportion to its conflict, the church has flourished. Put on its defence, it has exerted its giant, God-inherited power; and the closer the combat with the enemy, the more triumphant has been the issue. While it has been fighting heresy, it has vigorously prosecuted its missionary enterprises; and when its foes have slackened their fury, or offered their treacherous friendship, its sluggishness has increased, and its power for mighty purposes declined. "Combat with sin," in its multitudinous developments, has proved to be "labour for the Lord." Warfare with heresy has been the means of developing the spiritual vigour of the church, which might have slumbered in less agitated times. The world, even now, does not fully understand, if it ever understood, the strength of the
* "Ecclesiastical History of England. From the opening of the Long Parliament to the death of Oliver Cromwell." By John Stoughton. In 2 vols. London: Jackson, Walford, and Hodder.
church. Possessing within her reach, infinite strength—for faith can heave adamantean mountains—she may well smile at the ridicule of the world. Her enemies may recognise her as weak, infirm, and puny, but she is able to confound the mighty. Strong in faith, men have done great exploits; and the most humiliating cowardice, by its influence, has been magically transformed into the utmost courage and heroism. We do not fear for the issue of the religious conflicts of the present day. If simple evangelical truth be of God, as we so strongly believe it to be, all latitudinarian and Popish error will be overcome, and must ultimately retire, crestfallen and defeated, from the field of battle. The God of truth, who is the light of the world, must chase away the darkness of the night of error.
Heresy has a tendency to repeat itself throughout history. It exists to-day, for instance, in much the same form as it did two hundred years ago. The points of resemblance between the religious conflicts of the present age and those of the Puritan era are to be observed on a surface glance. The same arguments that were used by our forefathers in combating priestly assumptions, are now being employed in fighting that tangible foe known, politely, as Ritualism. The Anglicanism of the Laudites has been accepted by the Ritualists of to-day, who, weak in everything but in ingenuity, have adopted superstitious beliefs which none but those possessing wondrous gullability would refuse to ridicule. That in these enlightened days, when our superior common sense is boasted of, and our practical methods of viewing most things lauded, error should seek so sickly, effeminate, and lackadaisical a form as that of the glorification of ecclesiastical millinery, noisome perfume, and childish vanities, is an evidence either of the prevalence of a chronic cerebral affection in the minds of some persons, or of a love for refined buffoonery. We are not inclined at the present day to meet Ritualistic nonsense with precisely the same weapon that our forefathers used. Physical iconoclasts we do not choose to be, and prefer the Ritualists undoing (as they must ultimately) the work to which they have put their hands. Our weapons of warfare are not carnal, and hence they are all-powerful. But the spiritual forces which the Puritans so boldly marshalled against the adversaries of truth must be called out and put in array by us, in order that Antichrist may be dethroned. It was by the simple, earnest, determined preaching of the cross, and the vigorous and valiant wielding of the sword against error, that our Puritan forefathers overcame in the day of conflict. This Magazine plies the Trowel and wields the Sword with the same view. When error has been rooted out, we will lay down our weapon of defence; for when the foe is gone, we can turn our swords in ploughshares. Till that happy day arrive, our sword must not be allowed to rust by remaining idle. For “we believe, and therefore speak. We speak in love, but not in soft words and trimming sentences.”*
Mr. Stoughton, in the two handsome volumes before us, gives us a clear insight into the “ways and means” by which the Puritans overcame Anglican heresies two hundred years ago. The object of the publication is to present us with pictures of the Struggles and Growth of
* Our Editor's declaration of war. See The Sword and the Trowel, Vol. I., p. 2.
255
the Church of the Civil Wars and of the Commonwealth, and a most interesting record it is, as we can testify. Mr. Stoughton has done good service to truth by the issue of his history—a history compiled with great care, from the best authorities, and from the State Papers which have of late years been arranged in the Record Office. The author has most of the gifts of an historian. He is careful, candid, generous, large-hearted, thoughtful, and industrious; although he lacks the capacity of vigorous denunciation of deeds too irresistibly bad to create any sympathy in honest hearts. Still, there are violent denouncers many, and furious critics many, but discerning, discriminating judges few; and numbers may be disposed to listen to Mr. Stoughton's recital of facts, which carry with them their own condemnation, who would not patiently bear, if brook, the withering scorn which a less tender historian might indulge in. No student of the period of which Mr. Stoughton treats should rest content without acquiring these volumes; and the general reader who wishes to understand the relation of ecclesiastical parties prior to and during the Cromwellian wars and government, cannot do better than read this history.
We will, purposely, select one portion of that history for a few observations, since it has considerable significance at the present time. The Sword and the Trowel, two hundred years ago—though our forefathers were not blest with a magazine of that name, which we in more favoured times possess—were used so successfully, that error was defeated, and truth exalted. The Anglicans against whom that sword was used, of course, do not fully resemble the Anglicans of the present day; for the latter have been taught better manners. Nor do the gospel-warriors of this century fulfil all the conditions which would make them the types of their sturdy old forefathers. The circumstances under which we live so widely differ from those under which the Puritans were, at first, scarcely allowed to breathe, that the characters of the two classes materially differ. We question whether we are as passionately in earnest for the conservation of truth as the Puritans were; but our heart's desire should be that we may imbibe a measure of the spirit, enthusiasm, and devotion, which animated them in their labours for the Lord.
It should not be forgotten that Anglicanism and Puritanism existed at the time of the Reformation; and that the former power, being more in conformity with the worldly policy which formed the State church, was vastly preferred to the less fascinating but far more spiritual element to be found in Puritanism. Ecclesiastical principles were put into contrast with the rugged simplicities of church worship, and a compromise had to be effected. The spirit of Puritanism was felt long before the Reformation; as a distinctive party, however, it did not appear until the Reformation had been accomplished. It was forced into prominence by the settlement which had been made—a settlement which, like most things in this earthly stage, without a prospect of finality. Separation and scruples were soon advocated by conscientious men who could not accept the Anglican system. Prior to the civil wars, the churchmen were mostly, if not wholly, Arminians, as we learn from that characteristic reply of Bishop Morley to the question, "What Arminians held?" Why, "the best bishoprics and deaneries in England."
It was soon evident that England had changed the Roman Pope for a sort of mild Canterbury Pope. The aim of Protestantism was the exaltation of private judgment, not of kingly authority. If the king succeeded to the Pope in the Anglican system, it was under different conditions, and to trifle with the position which he had usurped, and to use his power for the dishonour of God's simple truth, were evils which began to be sorely felt by those whose spirituality of mind and life exceeded that of the mere Anglo-Catholic. The clergy submitted to, but did not enjoy the whippings of the pedagogic Queen Elizabeth; but they soon got accustomed to the yoke of bondage, and began to think, if not to boast, of their fancied freedom. Favoured with kingly smiles, they fawned at the feet of royalty, and soon bartered away their souls. You acknowledge our divine right to the episcopacy, and we will advocate the divine right of kings, was the crawling policy of priestism. The elevation of the episcopal office, the exaltation of church power and authority, the Romanising of the State church, were sought instead of the purer atmosphere of religious, social, and political freedom. Mr. Stoughton points out, quoting from Strype, that "out of 9,400 ecclesiastics, at the accession of Elizabeth, less than 200 left their livings"—so that the genuine Protestant element must have been microscopically small. Sacramentarianism therefore increased. Medieval fascinations began to be openly invoked. "The external, the visible, and the symbolic, more exalted their souls than anything abstract, argumentative, and doctrinal;" and simple faith in a crucified Saviour was placed at a discount. Abstinence and fasting were rigorously enforced. The monastic system began to be advocated. The Reformers were held in mean repute, and Catholic unity was craved for—a feverish craving similar to that which is felt at the present day by those who long for union with Catholic Rome, but not with Protestant Nonconformity. "Anglicanism," says Mr. Stoughton, "allowed no exercise of private judgment, but required everybody to submit to the same standard of doctrine, worship, and discipline. Moderate Puritans were to be broken in, and Nonconformists 'harried out of the land.'" The canon law was a very effective instrument of Anglican intolerance. It has been the fashion to magnify the so-called fanaticism of the Puritans; but such fanaticism was mild compared with the wild outburst of intolerance of which the Anglicans were guilty. Fining for not attending parish churches, imprisonment, and exile for Nonconformity, "struck most Englishmen as a stretch of injustice perfectly intolerable." Some of the charges under this canon were very curious—such as "hanging up linen in a church to dry;" that is, we suppose, unconsecrated linen, for priestly linen is still allowed to be hanged up in church; "a girl sitting in the same pew with her mother, and not at the pew-door, to the great offence of many reverent women, and matrons being churched without wearing veils." "Two foolish boys," we are informed by a calendar, "taken amongst others, at Francis Donwell's house, the alcholder at Stepney," for "sitting at the table with Bibles before them," for which they suffered many days' imprisonment. Puritanism cannot show anything like so preposterous a case of injustice and fanaticism as that. Some poor rustic civilians asserted that "a ploughman was as good as a priest," and though some thought he was far better, he who dared to hint at
257
such a belief was summarily dealt with. Some asked, "What good do bishops in Ireland?" and were answered by imprisonment. Others prayed that Prince Charles might not be brought up in Popery, and a Protestant church fined those who offered up the prayer. Our forefathers must have been made of poor stuff, if they had not felt aroused at such grossly unjust and irritating jurisdiction. The Star Chamber and the High Commission Court perpetrated such great atrocities, that no wonder public indignation should have led to vigorous action. Then, too, the secular teaching of the church exasperated the people. To be told that kings are the fountains of all power; that they reign by "right divine;" that the soil is their property, and the people their slaves: that those who resist the king's will are in "peril of eternal damnation,"* was enough to alienate the hearts of the people from Anglicanism, and to put the most invincible weapons into the hands of the Puritans. For its favour of oppression, the Anglican church far exceeded the Romish church. "The church of the middle ages had commonly thrown its shield over subjects against the oppression of rulers; but in contrast with this, the Anglo-Catholic church of the Stuart times stood in closest league with government for purposes the most despotic." The scandalous immorality of the clergy was notorious. But nothing stirred up the enmity of the people so much as the ritualistic stage-acting which passed itself off as worship. Mr. Stoughton gives a very carefully-drawn picture of Laudian ritualism. He says:—
"The person who carried Anglo-Catholicism to its greatest success, and who, by other unpopular proceedings, did more than anybody else to alienate from the State religion a large proportion of his fellow-countrymen, was William Laud. Ritualism ran riot under the rule of this famous prelate. Alienated from the theology of Augustine, but relishing the sacerdotalism of Chrysostom, he delighted in a gorgeous worship such as accorded with the Byzantine liturgy, and was penetrated with that reverence for the priesthood and the Eucharist which the last of the Greek orators, in the flights of rhetoric, did so much to foster. Whatever might be the extravagances in Byzantium, they were nearly, if not quite, paralleled when Archbishop Laud held unchecked sway. A church was consecrated by throwing dust or ashes into the air. The napkin covering the Eucharistic elements was carefully lifted up, reverently peeped under, and then solemnly let fall again: all which performances were accompanied by repeated, lowly obeisances before the altar. This ceremony was quite as childish, and far less picturesque than the dramatic doings in the Greek Church, when choristers aped angels, by fastening to their shoulders wings of gauze. Into cathedrals, churches, and chapels, were also introduced pictures, images, crucifixes, and candles; which, with the aid of surplices and copes, bowing, crossing, and genuflections, produced a spectacle which might be taken for a meagre imitation of the mass."
This description reads something like those accounts which have been recently published of certain Anglican follies in the State church—that "bulwark of [anti-] Protestantism"—only, the imitation is still more childish. The "little Archbishop," as Laud was called—and the power of mischievousness is not always in direct ratio with a person's size (even little foxes will quickly burrow where larger ones will with difficulty pierce and tunnel)—the "little Archbishop," wherever he went, entered with the most provoking scrutiny, into almost every conceivable ecclesiastical and moral detail. Churchwardens were asked, "Doth your
* Dr. Manwaring, p. 29.
18
minister preach standing and with his hat off? Do the people cover their heads in the church during the time of divine service, unless it be in case of necessity, in which case they may wear a night cap or coif?" These are among the numerous tid-bits of Anglican ritualism. "All men," we are told, "are overawed" by Laud's cunning vigilance, "so that they dare not say their soul is their own." Mr. Stoughton states, on Laud's own confession, that "he kept a ledger, in which he preserved a strict account of the theological and ecclesiastical bias of clergymen, for the guidance of his royal master in the distribution of patronage. O and P were the letters at the heads of two lists. On the Orthodox, all favours were showered. From those favours all Puritans were excluded."
The Anglican doctrines were—when Anglicans held any—mostly of the Arminian and non-Evangelical type. "They contented themselves, too, generally with a hard, dry, Nicene orthodoxy, coupled with strong ritualistic predilections." Some earnest churchmen protested against these tenets, and consequently there arose the distinction between doctrinal and ecclesiastical Puritans. "Puritans disliked ceremonies. Earnest as to the spirit of worship, they cared little, often not enough, about forms." They refused to wear a surplice, to read the whole of the liturgy, to kneel when others thought it worship to kneel; and they everywhere declared that Popery was overspreading the land, and prayers were offered that God would mercifully visit England, and rid her of the great curse which afflicted her. Rather than bow down to the spirit of the times, the Puritans emigrated to other lands. Yet, the day of retribution was approaching. The people grew dissatisfied. "The intense horror of Popery felt by the Puritans was deepened by the Papistic practices of the Anglicans." The lax feeling respecting the observance of the Lord's-day, the encouragement given to the "Book of Sports," the looseness of doctrine of some, the no-doctrine of others, all helped to bring about the reaction. The Puritans zealously preached the good old doctrines of the cross. The more the simplicities of gospel truth were impugned by their adversaries, the more they exhibited them as the marrow of true religion. Men began to increasingly feel that forms, ceremonies, bowings, and pleasant fancies, could not promise them one tithe of the blessings which flowed from attachment to the cross. The simple unadorned gospel, as the manifestation of God's love to fallen men—their rescue from eternal wrath by faith in the Christ of God, was acknowledged to be the most delightsome of messages. When men saw what mighty transformations had been effected by the gospel in the lives of the most ignorant and selfish—when they saw that men who, previous to conversion, had been like pigs which bury their noses into their troughs, oblivious of all the outside world, became manifestly unselfish and earnestly desirous of other people's good, then they affirmed that this was the religion which met their wants, and satisfied their aspirations. Nothing but the cross can do this. The prettinesses of Ritualistic theology may allure for a time, but can never satisfy the soul's cravings. A reaction must again come; and the dear old gospel will shine all the more glorious in the hearts of the people, because of the darkness by which they have been for a time surrounded.
All England seemed to be thoroughly in earnest. The dread of the
259
restoration of Popery was very prevalent, and operated as a warning to all idlers. Roman Catholicism, by which was meant more than it can possibly mean now, was increasing in favour. The queen was a firm Papist, and Papists were received and favoured at court. The emissaries of Rome were more than usually active. People saw the wisdom of Pym's dread of Anglican innovation as the bridge which led to Popery: They began to protest against communion-tables placed altar-wise. They saw that organs and anthems were stepping-stones to something worse—the chanting of Latin verses, which no one could understand but the learned. They condemned wax candles. They despised ecclesiastical millinery. They protested against copes of white satin. When they saw innocent little boys in innocent white surplices, parading the church with lighted torches in their hands, and so gracefully bowing down before the altar, and looking so Popishly-pious, they smiled, and refused to bow before the golden calf which had been set up. "Flat Popery" was a familiar and apt designation of certain sermons which taught confession, absolution, and transubstantiation. All these complaints were made known to the Long Parliament. It was stated in one petition, that a certain High Churchman had declared that "the High Commissaries were the suburbs of heaven, and the High Commission the archangels, and that to preach twice a day, or to say any prayers but the common prayers, was a damnable sin." Things had grown to so high a pitch that the Puritans reasonably concluded that their existence was threatened, and that they must bestir themselves. Then came the fight as to the future of Episcopacy—a contest in which, as we all know, the bishops were ultimately defeated, and had to bear the loss of their lucrative posts.
The debates on the ceremonialism prevalent in Episcopal churches are interesting, as showing the public feeling of the time. "In villages and towns with high church clergymen, and low church congregations, where semi-popish arrangements had been made in the chancel, while rigid and ultra-Protestant Puritans sat in the nave, or absented themselves altogether—such feuds arose, that, to preserve the peace, as well as to check 'innovations,' the Lower House deemed it necessary to interfere. The opposition to Sunday afternoon lecturing, and the refusal of incumbents to admit lecturers into their pulpits, increased the strife; and in reference to this, the Commons interfered by declaring it lawful for the people to set up a lecturer at their own charge. Bishops inhibited such proceedings; but the Commons declared the inhibition void." The prohibition of certain ceremonies by the House of Commons was not acceded to by the Upper House. The result was, that the Anglicans adhered to the order published by the Lords, and the Puritans to that issued by the Commons. This led to disturbances and breaches of the peace.
We have no space to further detail the struggles which succeeded these events. While the civil war was raging, the tide in favour of Puritanism set in so strongly, that it was found necessary to overthrow the State church system. Episcopacy doomed, ritualistic follies were doomed likewise: and in the place of high church ceremonialism, was enthroned a simple, and more befitting, and God-honouring form of worship. When Cromwell told a church parson to "Leave off your fooling, sir, and come down from the pulpit," he merely gave expression
to the nation's desire in the matter, for the honest heart of England was heartily sickened of the scenes it had so long witnessed.
Mr. Stoughton's picture of the assembly of Presbyterian divines, met for their first time in Westminster Abbey, is so well drawn that we cannot do better than to conclude our notice of his volumes by quoting it:—
"The vaulted roof springing from the clustered pillars in the walls, like branches of lofty trees interlaced together, forming a rich canopy of leaves, while the bossed pendants resemble stalactites, though appearing to most persons now, even those who feel strong Puritan sympathies, a monument of exquisite taste and consummate skill, would be regarded by those who, on this occasion assembled beneath its shadow, as mainly, if not exclusively, a symbol of that 'petrification of Christianity' which, to their great grief, had over-arched mediæval Christendom. Dressed in black cloaks, and wearing bands and skull-caps, as they walked over pavements hitherto trodden by prelates and priests in mitres and copes, they would be reminded of what they deemed superstitious and idolatrous worship; and as they now met in assembly where convocations had before been wont to gather, they would think of obnoxious canons and of Archbishop Laud with feelings of pain, if not of bitterness, such as the charms of Gothic architecture had no power to subdue. Their principles, and the principles of the church before the Reformation, were in mutual opposition. And as we watch the divines entering within those gates, well described by one who himself came from the land of the Pilgrim Fathers (Washington Irving), as 'richly and delicately wrought, and turning heavily upon their hinges, as if proudly reluctant to admit the feet of common mortals into this most gorgeous of sepulchres,' we may fancy that the gates, if they had sympathy with those who caused them to be hung there, would open that morning more reluctantly than they had ever done before. Altogether, the scene and the purpose for which the assembly met, marked a new era, not only in the history of the Abbey, but in the annals of the church and the nation."
