Menu
‹ Chapter 122 of 234 ›

The Experience of a Conbert to Romanism — By David Gracey

16 min read · Chapter 122 of 234

IT was a pious and becoming custom of ancient times that led the sailor who had been saved from shipwreck to dedicate a tablet, and hang up his drenched garments in the temple of the god of the sea. On the tablet was inscribed the scene of the wreck, and the garments showed in their rents the signs of the violence of the storm, while both together told of the power of the supposed deliverer, and of the gratitude of the delivered. After the same manner, but in the exercise of a purer gratitude, and under the guidance of a divine religion, Miss

* Personal Experience of Roman Catholicism. By Eliza Richardson. Morgan and Chase. Mrs. Richardson's maiden name (Eliza Smith) is used throughout this paper, which is written with the view of drawing attention to the book itself.

Eliza Smith was constrained to tell to the public the narrative of those perils which threatened shipwreck to her faith. The narrative itself has been for years before the nation, and its publication has not only made a suitable return to her merciful Saviour, but has exposed the seductive power and degrading nature of that superstition, founded upon a lie and maintained by imposture, which daily spreads its influence in the community. For five long years she lived in the communion, and rigorously observed the discipline, of Roman Catholicism; and if that period be admitted as a sufficient test, her experience possesses a peculiar significance, as well for those who strive to hinder, as for those who seek, the restoration of the Confessional to England.

During an interval of feeble health, the affection of her family advised a visit to an adjoining county. The change was as desirable as it was necessary. The friend's house where she was to stay presented strong attractions in the variety of scenery and change of air which it afforded, but stronger still in the society of one who dwelt under its roof. Of the same age, with a similar distrust in the creed she professed, with a like tendency towards Romanism, the daughter of her friend was in that very state of mind and heart which would qualify and dispose her to sympathise with the wasting inward struggles of her guest. At home, the manifestation of the slightest departure from the faith of her fathers was met with a severity of word and manner which compelled Miss Smith to conceal as much as possible the symptoms of the great revolution taking place in her thoughts. Here, she anticipated, in the companionship of this kindred spirit, the long-wished-for opportunity of freely telling her difficulties, stating her scruples, discussing her own suspected convictions, and hearing the varied experience of one passing through the same spiritual ordeal as herself. With intense eagerness, therefore, she looked forward to a journey which promised so many sources of delight, little thinking that it was to issue in darkness and distraction of soul for years to come. Yet so it was; but she was not surprised into that lamentable decision for ever, though her friends were astonished and afflicted with the sense of a sudden calamity when it became known. For months she had been fast advancing towards it; and all the arguments on which it rested had already won complete control over her judgment, and taken their place among the things which she most certainly believed.

Nor is it difficult to discover how the false teaching of Romanism should have so entirely subverted in her mind the doctrines of Evangelical religion, in which she had been strictly trained from her youth. These doctrines had never found a firm lodgment in her heart. While her mind was yet undisciplined, her judgment immature, her fancy in unlimited empire, and her will unsubdued, she was accustomed to place the most implicit confidence in her own ability to think, and decide, and act for herself. Her faculties were vigorous, but their vigour was misled by the pernicious quibbles which a wrong course of reading had supplied. The loss by death of a beloved brother and sister awakened a more solemn consideration of the value of the soul, and a keener enquiry concerning the unseen world and the eternal punishment of sin, but led her no nearer the truth. Fresh enquiries brought new misgivings, and the mind that had learned to suspect,

299

soon dared to set aside, the sure words of the gospel; and pondered in misery amid the confused creations of its own imagination. Relief from the oppression of these thoughts was sought in poetry, in the grave pages of the historian, and the light fictions of the novelist; yet, the unrest and disquiet of soul still remained unallayed, untouched.

At length, in this unhappy state, Miss Smith accidentally fell in with some works treating of Roman Catholicism. A new current of ideas began to flow through her mind, finally engrossing and absorbing all others. It may seem strange, that one whom the majestic simplicity of the gospel could not satisfy, should find satisfaction, even for a brief space, in the cumbrous and complicated worship of an apostate church. But the explanation is at hand, first, in the natural repugnance of the human heart to the cross; secondly, in the fascinating influence of a new idea, of which it is said, that "it bestows charms on a monster, and makes even the imperfections of nature please us." Those very features of the Romish church, its gaudy formalism, its rigid asceticism, its offering heaven to human merits, which are least in harmony with the gospel plan of salvation, impressed most easily her fancy, and gained her most ardent devotion. Far removed herself from that disposition of soul inspired by the New Testament, and yet not willing altogether to abandon the form of Christianity, she discovered in Roman Catholicism a refuge for her alienation from God, while she might still retain the name of a disciple of Christ. Had she at first perceived that the system was, as she afterwards discovered, of man's invention, it would probably have received nothing more than contempt at her hands; but as it came with pretensions of a heavenly origin and authority, her eyes were blinded by the imposture. The secret of its victory over her conscience lay in its being, as Isaac Taylor describes it, "nothing but man's own religion, embellished with the spoils of Christianity."

Such, then, were the leanings of Miss Smith's mind when she set out on the journey mentioned. A formal profession was all that was needed to give completeness to her conversion; and to that she was hastening on. It is by no means necessary to pause over the minute details of this event; the general results bind our narrative together. In the company of the daughter of her friend, Miss Smith attended a service in the Roman Catholic Chapel; and as she reckons among the most powerful persuasives, the style of the building, the white habits and flowing veils of the sisters, the black monkish costume of the brothers, the intonation of the deep, rich voice of the priest, and the performance of the well-arranged choir, it does not require the penetration of a seer to discover how far Rome depends upon the spirituality of her teachings to win converts. A few interviews with the "palo intellectual looking priest" ripened her resolve to undergo the initiatory rites of Romanism. The day was fixed, but her father hearing of her purpose, recalled her so suddenly home that she was compelled to delay her public profession. In the meantime her sincerity was assailed by the solicitations of friends and the arguments of Protestant clergymen; and having resisted the one and upset the other to her own satisfaction, she appointed a second day, with the assurance that now no one would seek to hinder the fulfilment of her desires. She passed the mystic entrance, stumbling portentously on the very threshold. Many parts of

the baptismal service, in spite of her wish to swallow everything brought forward, appeared to her mind utterly meaningless. Nor is this surprising when one considers that strange ceremony through which persons are introduced into what Milton calls "Rome's idolatries and all the furniture thereof:" it seems like a curiously-patched garment, in which can be detected in one place a venerable relic of the Jewish ritual, in another an ancient remnant of the cast-off mysteries of Grecian worship, and in a third the fag end of a military or civil custom of the Roman Republic; in a word, one may find anything but the original texture, the simple ordinance of the New Testament.

When an individual is presented for baptism, the priest formally enquires of him, or if an infant, of his sponsors, what he demands of the church; and telling him the conditions on which baptism will be granted, he proceeds to prepare him for it as follows:—He first breathes upon him, and says, "Depart from him, thou unclean spirit, and give place to the Holy Ghost, the Comforter." He then makes the sign of the cross upon the forehead, to show that we should never be ashamed of the Cross of Christ; and on the breast, to intimate the love we should bear to Jesus. He next puts a little blessed salt in the mouth, saying, "Receive the salt of wisdom; may it be unto thee a propitiation to life everlasting." After this, he proceeds to the exorcisms, by which, and making the sign of the cross frequently on the person of the individual, he commands the devil to depart from the soul, and orders him to give place to the Holy Ghost, who now comes to take possession of the baptised. He then introduces him to the baptismal font, saying, "Enter into the church of God, that thou mayest have part with Christ unto life everlasting." Then he recites the Apostle's Creed, and our Lord's Prayer. He repeats another exorcism, and at the end of it, touches the ear and nostrils of the person to be baptised with his spittle, saying, "Ephphatha," that is, "Be thou opened, into an odour of sweetness; but be thou put to flight, O devil, for the judgment of God will be at hand." Then commences the action of baptism, for these are but the preparatory ceremonies, and now the priest anoints the recipient with holy oil, on the breast and between the shoulders, making upon each the sign of the cross, and saying, "I anoint thee with the oil of salvation in Christ Jesus our Lord, that thou mayest have life everlasting." After this, he questions him or his sponsors, as to his faith, willingness to be baptised, &c.; and then administers the sacrament, by pouring a mixture of consecrated water, oil, and chrism, upon his head, saying, at the same time, "I baptize thee in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost." Immediately after this, the head is anointed with holy chrism, and a white garment or cloth, placed upon the person, and the whole concludes by a lighted torch being put into his hand, as an emblem of the light of good example; while the priest, exhorting him to keep his baptism without reproof, and obey the commandments of God, gives him leave to depart in peace.

Close upon the footsteps of this fantastic formula came its dark and deadly follower, the confessional. Notwithstanding the soothing influence over previous scruples of the sophistical question, "Is there more shame in the commission or the confession of guilt?" the first

301

time Miss Smith entered the confessional, its atmosphere and its language seemed to smite with decay the finer feelings of the heart. The priest was equally guarded and kind; but the questioning, and the ideas supplied by it, outraged her feelings to such an extent, that, forgetting all respect for her confessor, and careless at the moment whether she received absolution or not, she hastily exclaimed, "I cannot say a word more!" while the thought rushed into her mind, "All is true that their enemies say of them. Here, however," continues Miss Smith, "prudence dictated to my questioner to push the matter no farther, and the kind, and almost respectful tone he immediately assumed, went far towards effacing an impression so injurious. On rising from my knees, when I should have gladly fled to any distance rather than have encountered his gaze, he addressed me in the most familiar manner on indifferent subjects, and detained me some time in talking. What share I took in the conversation I never knew. All that I remember was, my burning cheek, and inability to raise my eyes from the ground; but the conclusion was my acceptance of an invitation to breakfast with him the next morning, which I was too much embarrassed to refuse. I went, and to my annoyance found him alone; and the reader may judge of my feelings: the tendency is apparent—the familiarisation of the mind, under the most invidious disguise, with shame and impurity... The memory of that time will ever be painful and abhorrent to me, though subsequent experience has thrown even that far into the background. It was my initiatory lesson upon subjects which ought never to enter the imagination of girlhood—my introduction into a region which should never be approached by the guileless and pure."

Notwithstanding all this moral degradation, could the devotee be certain of carrying off complete absolution by the mere act of confession, the confessional would be robbed of half its terrors to the truly conscientious; but the spiritual jugglers of the confessional have discovered, by their infernal ascuistry, that there may be such a thing as an invalid confession—a confession which, if it omit a single sin that the penitent only suspects to be mortal, not only gains no pardon itself, though absolution be pronounced by the priest, but deprives every subsequent confession, no matter how many, of the merit that purchases remission. Sins of thought, too, must be spread before the confessor, that he may judge of their venial or mortal nature; and while his decisions are authoritative, their only claim to infallibility springs from the fluctuations of individual character; accordingly, it follows, that at Rome an individual may receive the lenient sentence of a temporary purgation in the pains of purgatory for a thought, which, were it conceived in London by the same individual, might bring upon him the penalty of eternal torments. Under this system of distributing pardons and penalties, Miss Smith was kept in continual perplexity and fear. Finding on reflection that all her former confessions were defective, she resolved to make a general confession to a religieux noted for strictness and sanctity. This exercise was spread over the space of three weeks, by the frequent repetitions of those things most calculated to bow the soul of an upright person in the dust. While this was proceeding, Miss Smith thus describes the effect it had upon her on one occasion: "A feeling, almost akin to suffocation for the moment, overwhelmed me, and I felt as if the

words would choke me; I leaned against the confessional for support; but, by promptings and suggestions, he, the priest, at length gained his point. On rising from my knees I was, for a short period, unable to stand; a kind of fallen and crushed feeling seemed to paralyse me, both physically and mentally. He smilingly attributed this to the length of time I had been kneeling, and commenced talking on the most indifferent subjects, with as great coolness and freedom as though I had no cause for an unpleasant thought."

Suffering in spirit from those wounds which the confessional had inflicted upon her womanly dignity, she called to her aid the ardour of her enthusiasm, and hoped to find spiritual perfection by following out those austerities, the first experience of which had molested her purity of heart. The convent seemed the only sphere where self-denial could exert its sovereign power over her being; but as she could lay no golden fleece upon the altar, and as the Romish church considers it a heinous offence to vow and not pay, some research was necessary in order to discover a shrine so disinterested as to smile with favour upon a penniless vow. At length a foreign convent, of the third order of St. Francis, was found, where a knowledge of English would compensate for the lack of the glittering accomplishment which could have opened the doors of the religious houses in England. But how is Miss Smith to reach the Continent? Her father sees no beauty in the "veil," and would not subscribe a farthing to enable his daughter to obtain it: but the ingenuous confessor takes charge of the whole matter. She is not to ask her father for money; all expenses are to be defrayed by the society; her friends are not even to be told of her intention till just before her departure, when opposition and remonstrance will be in vain; but the superior sagacity of an older ecclesiastic is dissatisfied with this arrangement: Miss Smith must at once inform her father of her purpose, and especially draw from him, by fervent entreaties, the sum that her journey shall cost. Her father yields, and in a few days she is on her way across the Channel, having rent a thousand tender ties, that she might secure, as she believed, the eternal salvation of her soul.

The convent where she was to spend her novitiate was situated at some distance from the port where she landed; and the journey thither through the country permitted her to observe the variable aspect of Roman Catholicism. In England she had seen it away from its home, wearing its most attractive garb and manners; on the Continent she viewed it as it sat beside its native hearth, without an eye to watch, or a tongue to criticise, its conduct; and how strangely contradictory were the feelings inspired! In whatever church she entered, Mary seemed the reigning deity. In the most conspicuous and the most secluded places of the building, on the side of the altar and in the niches of the walls, her image was set up. In one place it shone in costly array, decked with gold and precious stones, as the goddess of the rich; in another it drooped in tawdry ornaments, as the idol of the poor. In the eyes of all Mary was the chief object of adoration; and to her alone prayer and praise were continually offered. In the convent the same idolatry prevailed. Upon one little statue of the Virgin the novices were wont particularly to lavish the tender tokens of their devotion. They repeatedly kissed it, toyed with it, dressed and undressed it; and on

303

dressing days their elevated piety found a congenial exercise in examining and expatiating upon the rich garments of its extensive wardrobe.

With these palpable infringements of the divine prerogatives Miss Smith could never bring her spirit to sympathise. All her previous knowledge of God, and his sole and incommunicable right to the worship of his creatures, rose within her conscience and condemned the guilty practices. Yet she was afraid to look her doubts fairly in the face, or even to acknowledge to herself their existence; but the continual grief and repeated struggles of mind, on account of her inability to reduce her thoughts to that entire conformity to the teachings of Romanism required of a true Catholic, compelled her at last to bestow some attention on these rebellious thoughts. This was the signal for the tide of feeling and conviction to turn and set in steadily towards evangelical sentiments. She practised the voluntary and involuntary humiliations, and cheerfully submitted to the severe discipline of her novitiate; but the result was more intense vexation of spirit, and a deeper conviction that bodily exercise yields no profit to the soul. The dreary monotony of her daily duties was calculated of itself either to disgust the taste, or break the energies of an active mind. Summer and winter the sisters met in the chapel at five in the morning, and separated in the evening at nine. Of this day of sixteen hours nearly six were spent at intervals in religious services in the chapel, in attending mass, in meditation, and in repeating psalms and hymns, Paternosters and Ave Marias. About an hour and three quarters were allotted to the four meals, which were of the simplest character, and always partaken of in silence, except dinner, at which one poor damsel was called upon, all unforewarned, just as she had begun her own, to read for the spiritual benefit of the rest. A long half hour was set apart for recreation; and during the remainder of the time the sisters went to their various employments—some to visit the sick, others to teach in the school; and others make it their care to wash, iron, and sew, and discharge the ordinary duties of the household. The principal end in every duty is to render the novice so passive that she may be altogether like a corpse in the hands of her superior. Every time a sister asks permission to go anywhere, or do anything, she is obliged to kiss the ground, and kneel with clasped hands in the attitude of a suppliant. And when zeal flags, such startling tales as the following are rehearsed to inflame it: "A religieux of a certain monastery was so celebrated for his absence of any will at all, that it had become a problem whether any test, however ingenious, could discover traces of one. After some rumination on the subject by one of his superiors, the novel idea was elicited of applying the ordeal of fire. Accordingly, the next time the large bread oven of the house was heated for baking purposes, the poor will-lacking hero was commanded to enter it, in order to see whether the prospect of being baked to gratify his superior's caprice could bring to light the evidences of the missing will. Without a moment's hesitation or thought of consequences he obeyed. And the result! Like Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego, when cast into the fiery furnace, a miracle was wrought in his favour, and in reward of his obedience, he came out without a hair of his head being scathed."

At length Miss Smith's health gave way under the double pressure of an intolerable formalism, and inward distress. Her unhappy state of

mind became apparent to her superiors, and was by no means improved by their asking invariably at each visit to her couch, "Well, are you now contented? Are you now satisfied with your state?" The confessor was brought; but confession only afforded fresh causes for grief and fear. A Novena, or "nine days' prayer," for her recovery was advised by the novice-mistress; but when Miss Smith chose the "Litany of Jesus," and the "Lord's Prayer," the zealous lady burst forth into a glowing eulogium on the merits of the "Litany of Mary." Assent was given with a slight indifference of manner, whereupon she immediately added, "Yes, but you must invoke her with great confidence, or your prayers will be unavailing." "I cannot promise that," was Miss Smith's reply, "I never did feel as much confidence as some do." From that hour there was a withdrawal of trust, the effects of which were sensitively felt. The end of her delusion was not far distant. Her own inability worthily to attend the communion, rightly to confess or pray, gradually became so clear to her mind, as to plunge her in the deepest humiliation of soul, and force her to exclaim out of a bitter sense of her own sinfulness, "I cannot pray—I can do nothing!" Her bands were broken, and she began to rejoice in the freedom wherewith Christ maketh his people free. Not having taken the veil, she could leave the convent; and in a few days she was on her way back to her native land and to her father's home—like one alive from the dead.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate