Some Characteristics of the Puritans as Commentators — By Pastor W. Humphries, Of Wellington
THE whole human family owes a debt of gratitude to the Puritans as instruments in the hands of God, which is even now but very partially acknowledged, and where most fully recognised is but very scantily paid. The Puritans by toil, suffering, and death, carried forward the glorious work of the Reformers. The Puritans preached the gospel to the poor, and diffused religious knowledge when the state-paid clergy were utterly indifferent or averse to the spiritual well-being of the masses of our fellow countrymen. The Puritans were the means of infusing high principle and earnestness into the treatment of political and social questions which frivolous and unprincipled men had been accustomed to degrade. Those of the Puritans who remained in England saved this country and its political constitution from ruin. And that part of the Puritan body which sought a more peaceful home in the solitudes of America, founded the states which were the nucleus, and have ever been the source of principle and power in the mighty confederation across the Atlantic. And more than all these noble achievements, the Puritans have left a store of theological writings astonishingly vast in extent, and invaluable in character. This is perhaps the greatest, the most precious of the many legacies which have come down to us from the age of the Puritans. It is only now that the majority of even ministers of the gospel, are beginning to form an idea of the number and nature of the writings of the Puritans. These works have for the most part been unknown to the generality of those who are devoted to the study of theology. Only the productions of a few, such as Bates, Baxter, Charnock, Flavel, Howe, and Owen, were accessible even to those possessed of ample means. But now the writings of most of these "giants" have been cheapened, and the almost lost works of Adams, Brooks, Cawdray, Clarkson, Goodwin, Sibbes, Henry Smith, and Swinnock (may we hope that Manton will be added?) as well as the commentaries of Bayne, Burroughs, Reynolds, George Greenhill, King, Torshell, Trapp, and many more are put within the reach of all. It was a noble enterprise on the part of Mr. Nichol to undertake to recover for us the hidden, almost lost, treasures of Puritan theology, to clothe them in modern handsome form and dress, and issue them at the very lowest of modern prices. And nobly has the enterprise been carried out. We have remarked an ability, an amplitude of knowledge, a conscientious carefulness in editing as well as a generosity on the part of the publisher, which are beyond all praise. Nor has Mr. Dickinson in his less extensive, but in their proportion, not less valuable labours, come behind Mr. Nichol. The latter has given us a series of the most valuable works and commentaries, and the former has issued the inimitable volumes of Old Trapp, and the "Things New and Old," of Spencer, with the "Treasury of Similes," by Cawdray. We believe that the wide extent to which these works have been subscribed for, is an indication of the growing love for theological studies and orthodox doctrine. In hundreds of ministers' libraries where the writings of the Puritan divines formerly could have no place, they now figure as a most prominent part of the material which supplies food for thought to those who preach the gospel in Nonconformist pulpits; and the schemes of these publishers would be far more widely supported were the salaries of ministers more adequate to the just claims which pastors have upon their people. No more profitable expenditure could be made than that devoted to enable those who preach the gospel to read and study the writings of the great Puritans. The careful perusal of these books would mightily tend to preserve sound doctrine in our midst, and to foster the work of grace in the soul. With the view of making the excellencies of the Puritan commentators more widely known this paper is written; and if what is said shall increase
22
the circulation, and induce the more diligent study of the volumes which are being published, there will be much cause for gratitude. We would say with reference to the title of the paper, that though nearly all the leading Puritans were commentators, and possessed the following high qualifications in common, there was among them the greatest possible variety of mental power, of intellectual culture, of habit of thought, and mode of presenting their views. Nor did they all agree upon every point in theology. The great verities of the gospel were held by these good men one and all with a firmness of grasp which proves their mighty power, and the deep sense which they entertained of the essential nature of the doctrines of ruin in the fall, redemption by Christ, and regeneration by the Holy Spirit; but then in the Puritan writings we see as manifestly as anywhere individualities of character, the variety which God has given to the intellectual powers in man, as well as to every portion of his created works. We sometimes hear the Puritans described as if they were all men of one mould; they are spoken of as all ponderous, diffuse, obscure, and wearisome in their writings; all are included and condemned in one charge. Nothing can be more unjust than such sweeping depreciation of a large body of good men who have evinced, in the literary bequests which they have made to posterity, as great a diversity of talents and acquirements as can be found among the leaders either dead or living in the walks of law, literature, or politics. Who that has read Howe and Adams would say that these two writers were alike in mental endowments, in the way in which they looked at or presented the subjects that occupied their attention? Will any one dare say that Brooks and Goodwin, or Charnock and Henry Smith, or Sibbes and Clarkson, so nearly resemble one another as to deserve the oracularly pronounced opinions which it delights some people to utter? We venture to assert that in the majority of cases those who express a low estimate of the Puritan writings, have no more knowledge of what those writings are than is acquired from the most superficial glance at the well filled pages of the volumes Mr. Nichol is publishing. In order to appreciate the works of the Puritans, we must bring to the study of them something of the devoutness of spirit, of the patience of enquiry, of the exactness in statement which characterise the writings we have before us. But this is an age in which these qualities are not by any means common—there is hurry, rapidity, and consequent shallowness; there is very little of the depth, fulness, and grandeur of thought which impart to the works of the Puritans their great worth. It will be a happy result of the re-publications of this old theology, if it shall contribute to banish the mere surface work, the gilding, and give us again the solid and true. We do not wish for a repetition of the form in which the Puritans wrote and preached—that is obsolete—but what we desire is the scriptural teaching, the clearness of doctrinal statement, the massiveness of thought and the earnestness of spirit which distinguish all the volumes which have come out in Mr. Nichol's Puritan Divines. What, we may now ask, are the characteristics of the Puritans as commentators? In reply, we say—
1. They were men of deep and fervent piety. They were men most evidently who enjoyed "the happiness of high and intimate communion with God;" they possessed "deep insight into the grace of God, and the covenant of grace." Thankful Owen and James Barrow, the editor of Dr. Thomas Goodwin's works, say that he was "a man mighty with God in prayer, to whom he had frequent recourse in difficult points and cases; and such men wade further into the deep things of God who have such a leader." "No man's heart was more taken with the eternal designs of God's grace than his." Sibbes in a Preface to the Exposition of Ephesians, by Paul Bayne, says of him, that "He was a man fit for this task, a man of much communion with God, and acquaintance with his own heart, observing the daily passages of his life, and exercised much with spiritual conflicts. As St. Paul in this epistle never seemeth to satisfy himself in advancing the glory of grace and the vileness of man in himself, so this our Paul had large conceits of these things, a deep insight into the mystery of God's grace and man's corruption." That the Puritans were
323
eminent for piety, even their enemies and caricaturists acknowledge. According to Macaulay, "To know God, to serve him, to enjoy him, was with them the great end of existence. They rejected with contempt the ceremonious homage which other sects substituted for the pure worship of the soul. Instead of catching occasional glimpses of the Deity through an obscuring veil, they aspired to gaze full on the intolerable brightness, and to commune with him face to face. They recognised no title to superiority but his favour, and confident of that favour, they despised all the accomplishments and all the dignities of the world." Of all qualifications for understanding the deep things of redemption, this spirituality of mind, this fervour of piety, and close communion with God, form the principal part. There is nothing which imparts greater clearness and power of penetration to the eye of the soul, and nothing that so effectually gives susceptibility to impression, capacity to appreciate and power to apply the word of God, as this depth and intensity of piety. No mental ability, however great, no fund of knowledge or acquirement of any kind, will in any sense avail to open up the meaning of Scripture apart from this piety which was so distinguishing a feature in the case of the Puritans. In reading their expositions, we feel constantly that we are brought in contact with men who lived very near to God—whose affections were set on things above. The writers seem to have wrestled in prayer for every thought, and to have realised constantly the presence, light, and power of the Comforter. The Puritans wrote as men having authority, and with an unction from the Holy One. They knew nothing of timidity or coldness. They wrote and preached because the fire burned within and could not be suppressed. From this one element their expositions have a value which they can never lose. Whatever other characteristics they may possess, possessing this, the expository works of the Puritans will be cherished as among the most precious inheritance of the church of the living God; and the deeper the piety of the reader, the higher the value which will be set upon such volumes as those of Old Trapp, of the fragment of Goodwin on Ephesians, of Hardy on John's First Epistle, Bayne on Ephesians, and the many other works which, thanks to Mr. Nichol, now stand a goodly array on our bookshelves. Next to a prayerful reading of THE BOOK, or intimate communion with God in private, we know of no exercise more eminently fitted to intensify love, faith, humility, zeal, and heavenly-mindedness in the intelligent believer's soul than to be closeted in careful meditation in company with the Puritans.
2. The Puritan commentators were sound and most able theologians. No one has ever questioned their orthodoxy—at least no one now for a moment doubts their being "sound." Some of them might have entertained suspicions as to one another on a few minor points; but we, who have the advantage of judging their opinions from a distance, which enables us to exercise judicial impartiality, can thankfully bear testimony to their doctrinal correctness. We believe that those who are the most lynx-eyed in the detection of error, are not able to discover in the Puritans even the slightest deviation from the straight line. Indeed, we have before now noticed a tendency in high quarters to set up the Puritan writings as the test of orthodoxy. This is doing with our fallible human guides pretty much what we decry in the Papist and Anglican, when they take the opinions of uninspired men rather than the revealed will of God as the standard of faith. Whilst we pay all respect to the teachings of the Puritans, we are not quite prepared to assign to them an authority which only inspiration can claim.
After the word of God itself, the authority of the Puritans must ever hold a very high place in questions of doctrine. We may apply to most of these writers what Bates said of Manton, "They were endowed with extraordinary knowledge in the Scriptures, those holy oracles from whence all spiritual light is derived; and, in their preaching, gave such a perspicuous account of the order and dependence of divine truths, and with that felicity applied the Scriptures to confirm them, that every subject by their management was cultivated and improved. Their discourses were so clear and convincing, that none,
without offering voluntary violence to conscience, could resist their evidence. Their doctrine was uncorrupt and pure; the truth according to goodness." There are many witnesses of widely different views and tastes who may be brought forward to testify to the unsurpassed power of the Puritans as theologians. There is the indisputable fact, that the works of Howe, Owen, Charnock, Goodwin, T. Adams, Sibbes, and Brooks, have supplied more instruction, been productive of more thought, and have suggested more sermons to our leading Nonconformist preachers than any other uninspired writings. Or, taking the more purely expository works, we might select a vast number of the most emphatic approving statements from Churchmen as well as Dissenters, who have been fortunate enough to possess rare copies of the volumes which are now supplied to us on such easy terms. Or, if any one competent, will carefully read through almost either of the expositions given us by Mr. Nichol, he will be constrained to acknowledge that there is an amplitude, a depth, a scripturalness of teaching which cannot be matched in any commentary of similar pretensions in modern times. There may be many modern expositions, which in some one or two points will surpass a Puritan commentary on the same part of Scripture; but having regard to the fulness of theological knowledge, we venture to say that the older work will prove the most valuable. Without a profound acquaintance with theology as a science, for such it really is, no one should undertake to publish expository works. The Puritans whose expositions we are reviewing, had attained this mastery, and so the theological student cannot fail to be profited in placing himself under their guidance in the study of the word of God. If we are to defend ourselves and the people to whom we minister from the wiles and arguments of those who are seeking to lead us back to the bondage of superstition and Popery—if we are to be fortified against the deadly influences of that semi-septicism which is abroad and has taken possession of so many of the clergy in connection with the church of England, there can be no safer or more able human instructors than these old Puritans, who lived sufficiently near to the age when Rome held the English people in thraldom to discern the abominations of the teachings and practices of the Papacy; and yet they were just so far removed from the period during which the fanaticism and tyranny of Romanism prevailed in this country as to enjoy all the advantages which could result from a diligent study of the writings of the Reformers. In many respects the Puritans were in a better position for conducting the controversy with Rome than the Reformers; and their full biblical knowledge, their intelligent and strong faith, with their profound humility and reverence, are the best defence against the pride which prompts short-sighted human beings to set up their "intuitions" and reason in opposition to the teachings of God's word. Let our pulpits be occupied by men of intense piety and sound biblical knowledge, then, with the divine blessing on this instrumentality, we need not fear that England will become enslaved by Popery or be given over to cold Rationalism.
3. The Puritan commentators were men of well-disciplined and richly-furnished minds. They have been represented as ignorant men, who had not received the advantage of a thorough collegiate training, and who consequently were deficient in culture and breadth of reading. This representation is based upon ignorance of what the Puritans really were, or it arises from a malicious purpose to traduce the whole body by putting forward the obscure as samples from which the rest are to be judged. This is neither generous nor just. We ought not to form our opinion of any religious party from the weak and insignificant, but rather from those whose talents, learning, and earnestness are means of blessing, not only to the immediate community, but to society at large. We are not writing about any of the Puritans except the commentators; and of them it can be asserted without any possibility of contradiction, that they were very able, very learned, as well as eminently devout men. Some of them filled the highest positions at the universities, and under the training of these Puritans many of the greatest statesmen and writers of the seventeenth century were brought up;
325
and if we take any one of the commentaries now being re-issued, we find on every page proofs that the writer was a profound scholar, a skilful dialectician, and a man of the most varied reading. In this feature of the Puritans we find one very effectual answer to those good Christians who cry out against a learned ministry. They say, "We don't need learning or great ability, but only piety and earnestness in our ministry"—as if there were any opposition between piety and learning, or any incompatibility between great talent and earnestness. The Puritans were intensely pious, and yet they were among the most learned men England has ever seen. They were possessed of surpassing talent, and yet so earnest that their words were as "living things with hands and feet." These Christian people who decry learning in the ministry often set up the Puritan divines as models! The simple truth is that such persons know next to nothing about the Puritans, and they know less as to what is the proper place of learning as a qualification for the expounding of Scripture. Provided there is depth of piety and aptitude to teach in the minister, the more knowledge he possesses the better, as is abundantly evidenced by the case of such men as Howe, Charnock, Owen, Adams, and Henry Smith, and even the apostle Paul.
4. The Puritan commentators had a deep experimental acquaintance with the teaching and preciousness of Scripture. This is acquired only by much prayerful meditation and through the discipline of trial. No one can possess it early in his Christian course. Years are needed for its attainment even in the case of the most highly gifted and favoured of Christians. There are many unreasonable expectations cherished by older Christians with regard to this feature in those who are just commencing their ministry. The comparative lack on the part of the young minister of experimental acquaintance with Scripture, and the workings of grace in the soul, is often treated with cruel impatience and proud contempt by those who have unhappily forgotten the poverty of their early knowledge of divine things; and thus an irreparable injury is done to a young minister who is full of love and zeal, but who has not had time to ripen into the mellow richness which will come with the working out of the process which God has ordained. If we enjoy and are profited by the deep rich experimental teaching of the works of the Puritans, we must bear in mind that most of these writings came from men in the mature autumn of life, and from men who had passed through a discipline which was eminently fitted to develop the excellence now under consideration. We can fully endorse Dr. Miller's opinion on this point. Not only were the Puritans pre-eminently men of God, and deep students of God's word—"living and walking Bibles"—and this in combination with great secular erudition; but their lot was cast in troublous times, times in which great principles were at stake, to which they were called to witness, and for which they were called to suffer. As with the individual Christian, the time not of his wealth and ease, but of his trial and suffering, is that which braces his power and stimulates his health and growth, so is it with the aggregate church, stirring times produce stirring men. Christ's heroes are drawn out by conflicts. When we handle the doctrines of the gospel merely as subject matter of sermons, and treatises, and controversies, we are in danger of handling them drily and abstrusely; but when we are called to confess Christ by the actual bearing of his cross, and to suffer for his truth's sake, our theology must be experimental. We then want not Christianity but Christ. The gospel is then a reality, not a creed, nor a system only nor mainly, but an inner life, an indwelling, inworking power. "Christ, the Scripture, your own hearts, and Satan's devices," writes Thomas Brooks, "are the four things which should be first and most studied and searched; if any cast off the study of these, they can be neither safe here nor happy hereafter; his words are the key-note of Puritan theology." And this which is the "key-note," is one of the strong points and highest recommendations of the Puritan commentaries. In them we have the heart searched—its secret places and mysterious workings laid bare—we find the joys and sorrows, the hopes and
fears, the hallowed mood, and the worldly backsliding tendencies of the Christian soul opened up. These works enter most deeply into the varied emotions and sympathies of the Christian life, and apply the word of God with a marvellous power for conviction, instruction, and consolation.
3. In these Puritan commentators we recognise a distinct practical tendency. They appear to have kept in view that "all Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness." The profound learning in these expositions, the able discussion and their rich experience, are never allowed to push aside the practical lessons and applications. We have been reminded many times in reading these works of the structure of Paul's epistle, in which the doctrinal argumentative and experimental lead on to, and end in this, which bears immediately on the ordinary relations and duties of the Christian. Thankful Owen and James Barrow in their preface to Dr. Goodwin's exposition of Ephesians, say, "His discourses all along are very evangelical, carrying the soul to a higher holiness, and from a higher spring and arguments than what are to be found in philosophers, from the great pulleys and motives of the gospel, which are higher and nobler springs than what Adam himself had in innocency." As the commentaries were for the most part delivered in the form of "lectures" or sermons to mixed audiences, and not written for the student, they everywhere contain practical reflections and applications; and in this feature they agree with the intent of the Holy Spirit in guiding the writers of Scripture to aim at the development of the holiness and benevolence of the Christian life. It is really very wonderful how all the Puritan commentaries are so distinctly in accord in this point with the mind of the Spirit in the structure of the Scriptures. For one thing this could only have arisen from the most intimate, broad, and experimental knowledge of the word of God; and it indicates, too, most manifest divine help given to these good men, no doubt in answer to humble waiting on God, in view of the difficult and responsible nature of the work of expounding his revealed will. We cannot do better, in closing, than quote the very sensible and weighty words of an able reviewer in the Edinburgh, who, in an article on "The British Pulpit," remarking on the selection of inappropriate topics as inexcusable on account of the large provision of subjects of enduring and universal interest in the Book which the preacher professes to interpret, says, "He may freely expatiate over the ample circle of its doctrines and precepts, in all their applications to the endless diversities of life, and the endless peculiarities of individual character; he may find an equally legitimate province in the interpretation of difficult passages, or the reconciliation of apparent discrepancies; in the illustration of manners, customs, and antiquities; and in the elucidation of those ever varied and deeply interesting narratives in which, for the profoundest reasons, the doctrines of Scripture are everywhere embedded; as if for the very purpose both of securing the requisite variety in pulpit discourses, and preventing the truths of religion from assuming the form of naked abstractions. Well would it be it, in this respect as well as in others, the preacher would make the Bible the object of his sedulous imitation. It is everywhere a practical book; it contains no over curious speculations, no superfluous subtleties: on the contrary, it has often been remarked that there is a singular silence maintained in that volume on all that tends merely to gratify curiosity. The very mysteries it discloses, it discloses only so far as is necessary for some practical purpose; whilst it everywhere views man just as in common life man views himself and his fellows—recognising at once, without discussion, all those facts connected with our intellectual and moral constitution, the true theory of which has occasioned such endless differences and enquiries in the schools." If the reviewer had penned this admirable passage as a description of the aim of the Puritan commentators in their discourses, and not as a piece of advice to the preacher, it would have been true to its every letter. We need not say that we earnestly urge the most careful study of the Puritan commentators.
