Menu
‹ Chapter 194 of 223 ›

"The Wickedest Man in New York."

7 min read · Chapter 194 of 223

OUR friends, the Americans, are far ahead of us in many things; and it is not always that we desire to be abreast of them. Our old-world prejudices are so fatal to our rapid conversion to novelty, that we must content ourselves with moving quietly round our accustomed circle of duties, without attempting to startle the nations by any erratic departure from conventional usages. It was reserved for a Yankee to doubt the expediency of the world moving on its own axis every twenty-four hours, unless it was "subject to the American constitution;" and for other, and equally important revolutionary ideas, we are indebted to the same race. Perhaps, however, there are few contrivances of ingenuity that have startled us more than the last new move in the religious

world of New York. We have heard of various methods of leading men to religious convictions, and to the abandonment of an evil life; some of them have astonished us greatly, and offended our conservative ideas; but we had never conceived the possibility of converting a sinner from the error of his ways by writing to the Times. Yet that has been, practically, the last new effort of Yankee ingenuity, and as almost every religious newspaper in New York has been filled with articles and correspondence on the subject, and as no English magazine has referred to this extraordinary case, we purpose to give briefly the leading particulars.

New York, like London, has its dens of iniquity. They may be worse than here—they are certainly no better. A Mr. Oliver Dyer, who seems to be a Protestant writer, being anxious to secure the conversion of a keeper of one of the most prominent of these dens, entered one of them, and boldly told him that “the fatal hour had come for serving him up in a magazine article.” The threat strikes our ears as a ludicrous one; and we venture to say that had anyone offered a like prominence to a London lodging-house keeper, he would have been expelled the premises, minus all the clothing which added to his personal appearance. Not so in New York. “The wickedest man in New York” was “jolly and defiant”—told his literary visitor to go ahead, to do his worst, and, quoting Shakespeare, begged as a favour that he would

“Nothing extenuate, nor set down aught in malice.”

The visitor was naturally taken aback, but he persevered, and took the exceptional method of proclaiming in the public prints the keeper of the dance-house, by name, John Allen, “the wickedest man in New York,” and wrote lively sketches of his character and of the vile den which he conducted, to prove his wickedness. Newspaper placards, sensational pictures, and universal talk, made the man a nine-days’ wonder. Not unnaturally, after reading the sketch, he ran off to the house of the missionary who introduced the writer to the dance-hall, with the intention of avenging himself. He appears, however, to have broken down. Tears rolled down his cheeks, as he complained of the name by which he had been designated. “My children” he said, “will see the article when they’ve grown up, and know that their father was called the wickedest man in New York.” It is very evident that the poor fellow was not so wholly given over to the devil as the writer had affirmed; and the painting à la brimstone was by no means so truthfully coloured as it might have been. It is evident enough that he was a vulgar and common-place transgressor—and, as a Baptist newspaper in the city points out, his wickedness could be matched fifty times over in New York. From Mr. Dyer’s own account it is clear that he was not “the wickedest man” in the city; and the writer had no right to confer brevet rank in the kingdom of Satan.

The result of the article was to bring out some of the finer feelings of Allen’s nature. He was run down with visitors; parsons begging the favour of praying with him; numbers meeting together to supplicate on his behalf. The clerical visitors were always liked. He was always glad to see them; would get into theological discussions, and frequently confound them in argument, and all with the utmost good

497

nature. He revelled in orthodox papers, especially those in which editors scent out heretics and shake them as a dog shakes a rat. He liked "a lively gospel and a muscular religion." Bad as were his ways, he taught his children to sing, "Shall we meet in heaven above?" utterly thoughtless as to the meaning of the words, but concerned that the young ones should only sing such ditties as were pious, and should sing these perfectly. He was always fond of sacred music; for it brought to his mind scenes of youth and of parents' loving instruction. In the winter of 1864, when a policeman, with a comrade, was walking his beat, they stopped about three o'clock in the morning, to kick their heels on Allen's stoop. It was bitterly cold, and, to keep their hearts warm, they began to hum some heart-stirring old hymns. After awhile they struck into old Coronation—

"All hail the power of Jesus' name!

Let angels prostrate fall;

Bring forth the royal diadem

And crown him Lord of all."

As they concluded the hymn a noise was heard inside of Allen's bar-room, and one of the policemen exclaimed: "Hush, Gilbert! there's some one in there!"

"Its only me, Towns," responded Allen, opening the door and stepping to the threshold in his night-clothes, bitterly cold as it was. "I heard you humming old Coronation, and had to get up and come down. I could not stand it with that old tune buzzing in my ears. Old Coronation will always fetch me at any season of the year, and at any time of the day or night."

He was observed one day to sing with his child the well-known hymn—"Nearer, my God, to thee;" on another day, he vanquished an infidel, who went to the dancing saloon, with the hope of spreading his views. Yet his ideas of vice remained the same as ever. He would swear vigorously before his children; the impure women who haunted his house could conduct themselves infamously, and yet he feared not that. But he dreaded that his favourite boy should imbibe sceptical notions. As he once said, "To have Chester get the notion that the Bible isn't true, or to have him hear any man deny the existence of God, or to make God anything less than God—why, gentlemen, I wouldn't have such notions put into Chester's head for all the world!"

He was once sworn in as a special constable, and became a "terror to evil-doers" by his rigour and passion for law and order. He takes a peculiar delight in defending out-door preachers, reproaching their assailants thus: "When a gentleman takes the trouble to bring you a message from heaven for nothing, aren't you man enough to listen to him respectfully? If I catch you making any more disturbance here, I'll boot you into the dock!" Yet Allen is tender-hearted towards poor children. He gathers them, we are told, into his house by dozens and scores during the inclement weather, and often not only feeds but clothes them; he also sends them to Sabbath-school. Sometimes he goes into the streets on a Sabbath and gathers up the vagrant children in squads, and marches them off to the Mission Sabbath-school. And he looks to their behaviour, too, after he gets them into Sabbath-school, and takes a fatherly interest in their welfare. He is equally kind to

33

costermongers, or as they are termed in America, "licensed venders." Indeed, there is much that is excellent in his temper and feeling. He has extraordinary talents, but they have all been perverted to wicked ends. He is fond of truthfulness, and his word can be depended on. This assures the hearts of those who have taken so much interest in his case, for he has promised to leave his premises, and to give up his wicked courses, for the sake of his children, that they may have a fair start in the world which he has done so much to pollute. Meanwhile, it would seem that hundreds of Christian people are praying for him; and ministers and missionaries unite in believing that if truly converted to God he would be a most successful preacher of the gospel to the outdoor poor of New York, and to the vagabonds of the streets and docks.

We utterly disapprove of this new way of doing good—by advertising a man's iniquity. For one case of conversion as the result of this mode of procedure, nine hundred and ninety-nine cases would be found in which the effort failed. The wonder is that Allen was not terribly hardened in his course by the "showing-up" business, and that it did not crush every fine feeling left in him. If he had been approached in a simple, quiet way, by a good man more in love for souls than for sensational pictures, and the story of the cross had been faithfully told him, we should not have been surprised if his heart had given way to reproof. Hundreds of villains have been saved through personal instrumentality. In our pages descriptions have been given of dens probably as bad as that in New York; and the writer has seen the most wicked of men and women subdued by the teaching of the cross. We should be sorry to see the day of sensational conversions ushered in among us. God does not send missionaries to do work which shall be chronicled in newspapers; sufficient is it that the good done is chronicled in heaven. We know we have many evangelists among our readers, and we have given the narrative mainly for their benefit. We may learn from it the danger of unwarranted methods of doing good; and the necessity for believing that no man is required by God to play a trick to catch a soul.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate