Menu
‹ Chapter 50 of 223 ›

Theo-Literary Recreation;

20 min read · Chapter 50 of 223

OR,

REMARKS ON "THE BOOK OF JOB," BY J. A. FROUDE.

B. W. CARR.

THE need of recreation felt and acknowledged by all mankind might furnish an attractive chapter in the digressions of mental philosophy. Amusements, which at first sight appear eccentric, would, on closer inspection, be recognised as the most rational. If a monarch become enthusiastic in watchmaking, or a statesman take refuge from the numberless cares of public office in the manual skill of a mechanic, we have no reason to sneer. It is quite as sensible as the zeal of the village blacksmith in discussing politics—a little exercise by the way, which sharpens his wits, while it is not likely to cover the sphere of his brain with a snowy fleece in the summer of life, as if the responsibilities of the Home Secretary devolved upon him. While the laws of our physical existence forbid incessant application to our special calling, we may all of us obtain a plentiful variety of diversion without killing time, or consuming it upon vicious trifles. Work is recreative, and changes, complete and thorough, rung upon our occupations, are tranquilising as music to our nerves, and profitable as sleep to our natural vigour. All this and much more we are prepared to allow before expressing our jealousy, when theological subjects are handled by literary men as an agreeable pastime without a reverent acknowledgment of that inspiration which should shield the Scriptures from an acrid criticism, befitting enough, it may be, in the revision of secular history.

So diligent a student, so elastic a thinker, as Mr. James Anthony Froude, cannot fail to gain an audience in an age of popular enquiry distinguished by its unrest. And when he so much adapts his style to the taste of the busy public as to furnish "short studies on great subjects," we confess the obligation. Amongst these great subjects he could find few greater than "The Book of Job." It is therefore with the deepest regret we discover in this clever essay such an unhealthy tone, exhibiting far more the virulent antipathies of a religious (?) partisan, than the ingenuous analysis of an upright expositor. The charm we looked for is wholly wanting. Instead of the broad, many-sided man of letters, who could admire Shakspeare because "his stories are not put together, and his characters are not conceived to illustrate any particular law or principle," because "they teach many lessons, but not any one prominent above another," because with "supreme truth" he "represents real life"—we ascertain to our disappointment that our author has imported into his treatise upon the ancient Book of Job scholastic questions and subtleties, as well as religious customs and ordinances, foreign to the time, place, and circumstances of the poem, as inconsistent as the introduction of tropical plants into a picture of the Arctic regions, or as a description of Punch and Judy in the narrative of ascending Mont Blanc.

Without fixing the date or authorship of the book, the learned essayist attributes to it a decisive answer to the Judaising propensities of one age, and the doctrinal Protestantism of another age. Amongst the churches at Galatia it might have supplied a better homily than Paul's epistle; and if it had only been read over with Mr. Froude's glossary at the synod of Dort (an anachronism pardonable in one who has just risen from its perusal) the fierce debates between the disciples of Beza and Van Harmin might have been suddenly quelled.

Had the reviewer contented himself by saying that the language of the book, "impregnated with strange idioms and strange allusions is un-Jewish in form," we could bow assent to his remark; but we recoil when he loses his temper, as if in hot anger, and fulminates his declamations, telling us that it is "in fiercest hostility with Judaism: that it hovers like a meteor over the old Hebrew literature; in it, but not of it; compelling the acknowledgment of itself by its own

internal majesty, yet exerting no influence over the minds of the people; never alluded to, and scarcely ever quoted, till at last the light which it had heralded rose up full over the world in Christianity." We cannot sympathise with the animus of one who thus shuts the book that he proposed to open, and grasping it in his hand, stamps with his foot, and deals out his invectives right and left with merciless severity. The supposition that it was produced at the time of Jeremiah is favoured in so far as it belonged to the great prophetic period, and discountenanced only inasmuch as the era of that prophet witnessed the decrepitude of the nation. But why its composition should point to any Jewish epoch, when there is no internal evidence, either of harmony or estrangement with that people, of respect or contempt for their laws, we are at a loss to understand. It is of little consequence that we refute one by one observations that have no pretext. There are two random shots however that we may parry with one answer. We should not entertain any doubt ourselves that David quoted his description of the sick man's chastening in the one hundred and seventh Psalm from the thirty-third chapter of Job. Our essayist might demur on one contingency; he supposes the speeches of Elihu to be interpolated, that they form no part of the original poem. This may seem to some devout readers a rather formidable exception; to Mr. Froude it appears utterly insignificant; he has disposed of Elihu in a foot note. Is there any just pretence for alleging that the author of Job borrowed from the psalmist? We have evidence to the contrary at hand. In the closing verses of the sixty-second Psalm, David makes an allusive quotation from the speech or speeches of Elihu, as if by a slight reference he would call to mind a well known oracle. For the sake of conspicuousness we will place the respective sentences in juxtaposition. The extended passage of Elihu proclaims its own originality.

"God hath spoken once; twice have I heard this; that power belongeth unto God.

"Also unto thee, O Lord, belongeth mercy: for thou renderest to every man according to his work."—Psalm lxii. 11, 12.

"For God speaketh once, yea twice, yet man perceiveth it not."

"For the work of a man shall be render unto him, and cause every man to find according to his ways." Job xxxiii. 14; xxxiv. 11.

The startling theory of the poem itself, which we have now to glance at, requires us to believe that the intention of its author was to combat the falsehood of orthodoxy in the Judaism of ancient, and the Calvinism of modern times. To effect his purpose, that mysterious writer must have isolated himself from the company and the customs of thought as well as of deed, prevalent among his own people, and to preserve a complete anonym, he stifled in profound secrecy all the knowledge he possessed of facts relating to sacred history, and cast the scene of his exquisite drama away from the charmed centre of divine manifestation. Let Mr. Froude speak for himself.

"The more it is studied, the more the conclusion forces itself upon us, that, let the writer have lived when he would, in his struggle with the central falsehood of his own people's creed, he must have divorced himself from them outwardly as well as inwardly; that he travelled away into the world and lived long, perhaps all his matured life, in exile. Everything about the book speaks of a person who had broken free from the narrow likeness of 'the peculiar people.'"

What this study aims at we must not overlook. The public can form some apprehension of the labour and judgment requisite to construct a volume of history out of fragmentary documents. They must be patiently collected together, attentively studied, sorted with scrupulous care, adjusted, re-adjusted, missing links noted, conjectures hazarded and tested, some discarded, others followed out. Remoter inferences may be drawn from circumstances that transpired only in the imagination of the painstaking author, which at length,

129

by frequent consideration, become as true to him as if he had been an eye-witness of what never occurred. But take away all the materials; what idea can be formed of the undertaking then? Why, Egyptian task-masters who demanded of enslaved Israelites that they should make bricks without giving them straw, bidding them to get straw where they could find it, were mild in their exactions as compared with the German scholars whom Mr. Froude eulogises and emulates. They engage to manufacture history out of their brains. They impose upon themselves the obligation of making statements without evidence; and then, by way of remunerating themselves for their pains, they draw bills on our credit, which they civilly request us to endorse.

The favourite theory that theology "grows up," as experience accumulates, and creeds are a construction of the human intellect, impels them to industrious reverie. Trade becomes dull when there is no speculation; and by parity of reasoning, evangelical enterprise is supposed to dwindle when research is not inventive, or when new commentaries are awaiting to give fresh eagerness to read the old volume. May it be so. If all who peruse the article in question reconnoitre the inspired record itself, they have a profitable exercise before them.

We must not forget Job. The sketch with which this latest edition introduces him, reminds us of a picture of the banquet at Apsley house, where Waterloo heroes were wont to gather annually, at the invitation of their veteran chief. The publisher contrived to have his own profile (so, be it true or not true, it was commonly said) distinctly impressed on the work of art, where he might be seen entering as an attendant at the door. Some marked delineation of the impartial reviewer's spiritual physiognomy may in like manner be traced in the following passage.

"As it is described in the first chapter, we have a picture of the best man who could then be conceived; not a hard ascetic, living in haughty or cowardly isolation, but a warm picture of flesh and blood, a man full of all human loveliness, and to whom, that no room might be left for any possible Calvinistic falsehood, God himself bears the emphatic testimony that there was none like him upon the earth, a perfect and upright man, who feared God and eschewed evil."

We must confess ourselves embarrassed by the strange incongruities that mark Mr. Froude's conjectures. He presumes that the history of Job was a tradition in the East, his name the symbol of fallen greatness, and his misfortunes the problem of philosophers. Yet, strange to tell, while oral tradition could make that name familiar as a household word, the written story consigned him to oblivion. The dazzling brightness of the unknown historian bewildered the generation in which it was first published; they could not appreciate it; they never referred to it; "persecutions come, and martyrdoms, and religious wars;" withal there were revolutions of thought as well as of circumstance; and it was left for a future distant age to estimate the value of a noble poem that fell flat on its own generation, and had long sunk into dissuetude. Lift up your eyes, O ye people, just now it rises, phœnix-like, (the stale figure is dictated to us) out of the ashes of that altar on which it expired. What the work of that veiled author might have been, or in what category he should be classed, we are at liberty to imagine. It is a conundrum to tax our brains in play hours. Was he an antiquarian gathering up the fragments of legendry, and weaving them together with artistic skill, exhibiting a genius akin to the author of Waverley? Or did he, out of the slenderest records, construct a vivid romance, as Henry Taylor, the historic drama of Philip Van Artevelde from Froissart's chronicles? Guess again. Perhaps, whispers our friend, Goethe's Faust is nearer the mark. Is that right? Who can tell? Here is our recreation. We are left to wander in the airy fields of conjecture, a salutary exercise for the mind. At any rate our fanciful guide-book tells us that he showed a studied respect for orthodoxy, while he arraigned it for judgment. He was so charitable that he does not represent the three friends

10

"as foolish, obstinate bigots, but as wise, humane, and almost great men, who, at the outset, at least, are animated only by the kindest feelings, and speak what they have to say with the earnest conviction that it is true." Getting into the heat of the argument, we must let the Westminster reviewer speak for himself. He has so pointedly addressed himself to us, and in such impassioned tones, that we must listen, for politeness demands it, and we must take down his words, for prudence suggests it; whether it is worth while replying is quite another matter.

"The friends repeat one another with but little difference: the sameness being of course intentional, as showing that they were not speaking for themselves, but as representatives of a prevailing opinion. Eliphaz again gives the note which the others follow. Hear this Calvinist of the old world: thy own mouth condemneth thee, and thine own lips testify against thee. 'What is man, that he should be clean? and he which is born of a woman, that he should be righteous? Behold, he putteth no trust in his saints; yea, the heavens are not clean in his sight. How much more abominable and filthy is man which drinketh iniquity like water?' Strange, that after all these thousands of years, we should still persist in this degrading confession, as a thing which it is impious to deny, and impious to attempt to render otherwise, when Scripture itself, in language so emphatic, declares that it is a lie."

We hope that we shall not be suspected of losing our temper, if we suggest that this view of the matter borrows its raciness from "the optics seeing, rather than the objects seen." Some enterprising publisher might give us an illustrated edition of this redoubtable essay, embellished with portraits of the individuals who, at this modern time, represent Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar. Evidently the very essence of Christian unity is taken as a strong proof of the imposition that Christianity has practised upon us. If Herbert, Cowper, and Watts all bear witness to the depravity of man, it is only Temanite, Shubite, and Naamathite over again, singing with more or less power in the same nasal key.

"Let us observe (and the Calvinists should consider this), Job will hear as little of the charges against mankind as of charges against himself. He will not listen to the 'corruption of humanity,' because in the consciousness of his own innocency, he knows that it is not corrupt; he knows that he himself is just and good, and we know it; the divine sentence upon him having been already passed. He will not acknowledge his sin, for he knows not of what to repent."

The profound self-satisfaction of this charming paragraph enchants us. What a sweet tranquil sense of innocence must have reigned supreme in the breast of the essayist who penned it! He had not Job's excuse of being stung to the quick. His sentiment was conceived in sang froid. Doubtless he rose from the desk, laid down his grey goose-quill, looked out of window, and saw with glazed eye, among the passers-by, young and old, rich and poor, aristocrat and beggar, a corresponding pureness, and he mildly cursed the malignant spirit that preferred a charge of corruption against mankind. No room is left us to marvel at this language so like to that in which he describes Job as speaking "vehement, desperate, reckless." Elihu is the proper person to reply, but our reviewer has burked Elihu. Burked, do we say? Thereby hangs a tale. The name of an atrocious murderer who expiated his crime on the scaffold at Edinburgh, nearly forty years ago, has been perpetuated in our language. How astonished Dr. Johnson would be to see that word "burke" a verb active in an English dictionary. With the wretched infectiousness of crime, of which the calendar furnishes too many examples, some two years after the discovery of that mode of procuring a corpse by suffocating a victim, Bishop and Williams were convicted of taking the life of an Italian lad, who sold white mice in London, by placing a plaster over his mouth, after which they dropped him into a pit till the breathless body was cold. The recollection of that ghastly crime occurred to us instinctively as we saw the treatment Elihu had received in the essay. There he is, at the bottom of the page in a deep note, with his testimony

131

stifled, and a dreary blank he leaves behind. "Confusion now hath made his master-piece!"

The conclusion of this criticism on the poem of Job is abrupt. It is necessarily so, because the one character that shines so softly with mellow light in our version is eclipsed. He that said, "Behold I am according to thy wish in God's stead; I also am formed out of the clay," is taken by wicked hands and crucified. He that interpreted God's way of justifying the sinner when he is gracious unto him, and saith, "Deliver him from going into the pit, for I have found a ransom," is dead and buried in Mr. Froude's account. Nothing remains, therefore, but the answer out of the whirlwind. The God on whom Job had called and prayed that he might appear and plead his cause with him, "comes not as the healing spirit in the heart of man; but as Job had at first demanded, the outward God, the almighty Creator of the universe, and clad in the terrors and glory of it."

How this artifice ministers to scepticism our next quotation will prove.

"The secret which has been revealed to the reader is not, after all, revealed to Job or to his friends, and for this plain reason: the burden of the drama is not that we do, but that we do not, and cannot know the mystery of the government of the world; that it is not for man to seek it, nor for God to reveal it."

There is far less novelty than speciousness in the application of broad expository principles (we use the word "broad" in a technical sense), to this isolated part of Scripture. We see in it a feature of the times, and as such we notice it. To epitomise Mr. Froude's view, he has attempted to show that the book of Job contains the poetical narrative of a state trial, in which "orthodoxy" is arraigned, condemned, and executed. Ritualism and Rationalism occupy the same relative positions in opposition to the gospel now, as the Talmud on one side, and Greek philosophy on the other side did at the planting of the church. No marvel surely is it that the analogy should hold good in individual types. The amiable defenders of civil and religious liberty stand proudly aloof from any proclivities of their own, accounting such matters a vain superstition. Like Porcius Festus, who evidently did not sympathise with the bitter animosity of the Jews against Paul, for to his idea the question in dispute was whimsically quaint. We can imagine the curl of his lip when he told Agrippa that the top and bottom of Paul's offending was an issue raised about "a certain dead Jesus whom Paul affirmed to be alive." So the thinkers and writers of our day, persist in speaking of our Lord as "the Christ of history," less the founder of a faith than the emancipator of the human mind from all systems. They do not, will not believe in the living Jesus who was crucified, but is risen from the dead to show light to the people, to loose those whom Satan has bound, to heal diseases of the mind, to speak pardon and peace to the conscience, to sanctify those that believe, and to seal them to the day of redemption by the anointing of his Spirit. This lively faith that draws its animating power from the assured presence of Jesus, rouses the echo of Festus' voice when he loudly exclaimed that Paul was mad.

Leaving Mr. Froude's peroration, which covers nearly a third of his tractate, to those whom a practical homily based on such premises may concern, we revert to the sacred story, with a modest confidence (if we may be pardoned for saying so), that apart from any peculiar theories about the date or authorship, accepting it as a veritable narrative, and taking its inspiration for granted, on proofs that we need not recapitulate, the lessons of wisdom it contains are adapted to make us trustful of God, when our way is dark; patient under afflictions when the cause of our adversity is obscure, and hopeful of our latter end when the blight withers all the present cheer of our hearts. The book has been like an angel in the house to convert and comfort the afflicted for many generations. And we can assure our testy antagonists, that we shall not be likely to deny the doctrine of universal depravity so long as we have the doctrine forced upon us of universal suffering and universal death. Neither shall we be likely to part lightly with our cheering belief in particular redemption

while we have so much particular experience of our own exposed to all the evils flesh inherits, and all the terrors that a future judgment awakens. Far be it from us to cultivate bigotry. We have need occasionally to remonstrate with men of liberal ideas for their illiberal strain of reflection. Granting that it is quite possible for critical analysis to throw a fresh light upon any part of Scripture, it would not disparage that sacred spell the perusal of the same Scripture exerted upon the hearts of men in days gone by, when there was not the slightest clue to such exposition. The fact that coal is adapted to generate a steam, serviceable for locomotion, does not prejudice the real benefit that our immediate progenitors derived from simply employing it for domestic uses. Admit the doctrine that cotton and castor-oil can by a judicious admixture be manufactured into a substance akin to and as useful as ivory, it need involve no slur upon the uses to which either of those valuable commodities has been previously put. Let the volumes of Ewald or Olshausen be never so worth our purchasing, and their suggestions be as valuable as they may, we need not therefore dispose of the portly folios of Joseph Caryl for waste paper.

Considering that the poem proper of Job begins at chapter iii. 3, and terminates with chapter xlii. 6, and that all the incidents which lay beyond these boundaries, before and after, furnish us with the tale in simple prose, it might not be deemed unreasonable to suppose that by consulting these rather than that, we shall be likely to get the view of the writer. The contrast between the beginning and the end is remarkable, because the introduction is so good that we can hardly imagine how the termination can improve upon it. And yet we have an indisputable authority upon this point—"So the Lord blessed the latter end of Job more than the beginning." In respect to his character, his circumstances, and his moral influence, this advantage is forcibly traced out.

The first sentence of the narrative reads well. "There was a man in the land of Uz, whose name was Job; and that man was perfect and upright, and one that feared God and eschewed evil." With this we compare the last sentence of the poem, wherein the patriarch confronting himself says, "Wherefore I abhor myself, and repent in dust and ashes." And yet there is nothing to warrant us in supposing that his character had deteriorated. Quite the reverse. He had passed in the meanwhile through a terrible ordeal, and he had come forth from the furnace "accepted of the Lord." The inference is patent. Do any of our readers start back from facing it? There is a righteousness more to be esteemed than innocence. It hath promise of a greater reward. "Blessed is the man that endureth temptation: for when he is tried, he will receive the crown of life which the Lord hath promised to them that love him." We do not disparage Job's integrity on the outset. Far enough from the mere tinsel of the profession, or the mosaic gilding of a counterfeit, it was like sterling gold of exquisite purity. Still that genuine goodness, unimpeachable among men, was not equal to the standard by which justification is procured in the sight of the Almighty. The righteousness of the Scribes and Pharisees was a fiction. Worse than that, it was a superficial veil that covered a deep subsoil of impurities. But the virtue of Job was not without merit that could make Satan jealous. Such the graces of childhood when the temper is sweet, the language chaste, the sense of duty delicate, the feelings tender, and the manners trained to a high degree of refinement. But ah! we think beautiful as is the picture of such a child, the scrupulous propriety is of too fine a texture to be exposed to the corrupt influences of this wicked world. We should have no confidence ourselves in its capacity to resist evil. Hardly should we write a biography of the little nurseling. Certainly, from the strict human point of view, we should prefer the biography of a man who had seen the rougher side of life, and come out, notwithstanding faults and infirmities, like pure gold, astonished himself only at the quantity of dross he left behind. Such, too, the nobleman, on whose birth fortune smiles; and as his years advance, good principles combine with his good fortune. His path in life is prosperous, and his disposition genial. When he has seen afflictions that he never felt, he has been quick to pity and

133

relieve them. Looking down from a princely station on the sorrows of his fellow creatures, he has shown a generous readiness to give succour to the needy and to support every kind of charity. We lend him our tribute of admiration, but we cannot forget that "to be eyes to the blind, and feet to the lame, and to play the part of a father to the poor," is another and a very different thing from enduring blindness, and lameness, and penurious want. We esteem the righteousness as far as it extends, but we cannot be oblivious of the narrow limits within which it has been found. Job was a perfect man to start with—as perfect as a boy may be in the science of navigation who has passed every examination at the naval school with credit and honour, receiving medal after medal above his competitors, though he has never yet been a voyage on the ocean; such merit would not procure him a cenotaph in Westminster Abbey. And we have a strong impression that Job was canonised in the inspired volume for the renown he gained in the struggles of life rather than for the highly creditable reputation with which he started it.

The prosperity of Job's circumstances in his latter days likewise exceeded that of his early career. Nor does it satisfy us to attribute this dénouement to the poet's art, who to accommodate our sense of fitness, has restored him in the book, and indemnified him for his losses, though in life it need not have been so. We think such a sentiment shows how little the moral is understood. The estimate we set on verbal inspiration assists us here. Not only were his possessions doubled, but the tenure by which he held his earthly goods was far safer than it had been before. Then "the Lord blessed the work of his hands, and his substance increased in the land." Now, "the Lord gave Job twice as much as he had before." While he saw no more than the success of his own works, he avows his timid apprehensions: "I was not in safety, neither had I rest, neither was I quiet; yet trouble came." But afterwards in the gifts of God's grace to him, he could find undisturbed satisfaction. He had his family restored to him the same in number as at the first. The record of this is touching. His children were a source of anxiety to him in the opening of his history. Their revellings were not to his taste. In the end, however, his sons and daughters are his comfort and his joy, and he gives them all an equal inheritance.

The influence he exerted after the Lord turned his captivity is very noteworthy. Job appears in the office of an intercessor both before and after his calamities. His well-intentioned efforts at the former period seem to have been unavailing, while his gracious supplications at the latter period availed to procure the pardon of his friends, as well as a token of his own acceptance. This is one of the minute points that well deserves the attention of those who exercise themselves in the study, with a higher motive than mere historical speculation, the coup d'essai of a secular writer. In making the comparison we must not forget that's Job's burnt offerings, according to the number of his children were not sustained by any acts of devotion on their part, albeit the three friends offered up for themselves a burnt offering, and Job prayed for them.

Enough; we are not oblivious of "the signs of the times," or the fresh calls to faith and energy of which passing events apprise us. But so far as the diffusion of knowledge, the progress of science, or the extension of the franchise are concerned, they are of the earth, earthy, and scarcely to be regarded as signs from heaven at all. The impetus given to civilisation affects the present condition of the inhabitants of the world without casting a ray of light on individual destiny. To-day, as ever, salvation is of the Lord.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate