Theatre Preaching — By Edward Leach
A WALK on Sunday evening through some of the purlious of Bethnal Green would give a far more accurate idea of the moral and spiritual condition of the masses of London than it is possible to convey by the most graphic pen. It seems incredible that in this Christian country, while a few hundreds are worshipping God in places assigned for that purpose, thousands (and those not a few) are outside—men, women and children, whose ignorance of religion and religious observances is so dense, that he must be a persevering man who attempts to enlighten them. And yet, ever and anon we are hearing the old question anxiously and solemnly put, "What shall be done for the masses?" We are sick of the question. It is growing an impertinent one, and a cloak for inaction. What to do, is not difficult, if men had the will to fairly grapple with the evil and the want. How to do it, is not hard to determine, were Christians full of zeal to enter upon the work. But truth to tell—and it is time we did not shrink from the avowal of this truth—there is an unaccountable apathy felt by the church towards movements that are in existence for the evangelisation of the masses. The church of Christ has efforts enough and perhaps to spare, but most of these efforts, instead of being vigorous and enterprising, are weak and infirm, as if suffering already from premature decay. We do not think that all these efforts are wise ones, or that they are necessarily controlled by wise men, or that all the agents are fitted for their work. They have made mistakes in the past, and probably are making them now. Some have been over sanguine and reckless; others timid and useless. Some have sought to proselytise instead of to convert; others have made sensational representations of what they have done, and have done but little; indeed, we have long
401
found that where the trumpet has been well sounded, and names have been everywhere ostentatiously paraded, there the real work has been insignificant and worthless, while there are a few men, calling themselves preachers and teachers, who actually live upon the money they obtain for charitable purposes, instead of devoting the whole to the object for which they professed to gain it. But yet taking the various agencies on the whole, they are exceedingly creditable to the hearts and heads of those who carry them on; and if they are not more successful, it is from causes that are not far to seek. We find little fault with the machinery: in most instances it works well, and if those who regulate it are not always wise, they are invariably earnest. But those who should keep the machinery going, have failed adequately to do so, and have manifested an indifference that might almost be described as appalling. We are not taking a melancholy view of the case when we assert that were it not for the personal subscriptions of a certain number of godly men and women, most of whom subscribe to more than one object, the efforts of most societies for the evangelisation of the masses would have to be considerably curtailed. All who are engaged in appealing to the Christian public, know well the names of these generous benefactors, who so nobly set their fellow Christians an example which it is a pity they do not copy. What the Christian church needs at the present time is a more equally diffused spirit of charity, and a throwing overboard of the fashion, now so lamentably prevalent, of allowing the few to do the work of the many. It is a shame that a select few of the wealthy should be drained, while the vast majority of Christians scarcely exert themselves at all for the evangelisation of the people outside their own churches. If our churches were capable of doing the work independently of societies which are supported by united churches of various denominations, we should prefer all such efforts to be left to them; such is not as yet the case; and it is therefore imperative that societies should do what the church, in its individual capacity, cannot.
That the remarks we have made are justifiable is not difficult to prove. A statement was made at a conference of ministers held the other day to promote theatre services by the Earl of Shaftesbury, which has pained us deeply, since it reveals in dark lines, the apathy of which we have written. "So limited," the noble earl said, "were the means at the disposal of the committee, that they had not been able to preach the gospel to more than 100,000 of the population of London." We find from a reference to a previous report, that this number is 80,000 less than that of three or four years since. Either this failure is due to want of interest in theatre services, or to an increase of other efforts of a like nature. That such efforts have increased we do not dispute; but to nothing like the extent that would justify such a lamentable decrease. The theatres in which services have been conducted are invariably filled by the working classes. These people are still indisposed to enter chapels, where they believe they are not wanted. A sight of the congregation that assembles on a Sunday evening in any of the poorer theatres is sufficient evidence of the popularity of the services. Working men who never had a Sunday suit of clothes, labouring women dressed in rags in which they seemed to have slept, boys and girls ragged and unkempt, will quietly though half-suspiciously walk into these buildings
26
and listen attentively to the preaching, but would emphatically and stoutly refuse to enter a building set apart for public worship. Are these people to be thrown into the streets again uncared for? According to Earl Shaftesbury's statement, it seems so. For Christians who sit comfortably on soft cushions and listen to favourite ministers, are growing comparatively careless of the neglected thousands outside.
At the conference referred to, two important topics occupied the serious attention of the brethren present. The Rev. Newman Hall suggested that the audiences at the theatres might advantageously be invited to contribute to the expenses. We think so too. Working people are about the last persons in the world who desire to have their religious wants supplied for nothing. As a rule, it is the miserly rich and grasping and rising tradesman class who err most in this direction: the men whose increasing ambition it is not to be good but to be rich. Let boxes be placed at the door—not plates taken from sent to seat—and a gentle hint be tendered, not in too many words, as if it were a collection at a Methodist chapel—and we believe the result would be satisfactory, at least, in some of the theatres. A more important question still is that of the use of lay agency. On this subject great division of opinion is felt. The society consists of both Evangelical clergymen and Nonconformist ministers, from whom the preachers are chosen. The committee find it difficult to obtain "clerical ministerial supplies" for all the services in the eight theatres now engaged. It has therefore been suggested that laymen should be invited to assist. Such a proposal seems most reasonable. Surely laymen are most likely to gain the ears of the working classes! The poor naturally respect the preacher who "labours, working with his own hands," and they soon learn to place confidence in him. Such men, too, have been greatly honoured of God, have done a work which others have left undone, or felt themselves incapable of doing. We have looked upon their exclusion by the committee as a great blot upon their plans, and a source of weakness which they should endeavour to get rid of. At the conference, two objections were stated to the employment of lay agency. It was objected that if the services were not confined to the regular ministry there would be no guarantee against the introduction of wild heterodox and mischievous teaching. To this Mr. R. C. L. Bevan aptly replied that "as to clerical profession being any guarantee for orthodoxy—why the notion would be perfectly ludicrous, if indeed it were not so sad. The clergy of the Church of England were notoriously unsound, and there was plenty of heresy in the Nonconformist ministry too. Almost all the heresies that had ever existed had been originated by ecclesiastical personages." This testimony is alas! too true. At the same time, would it be so very difficult for a committee to act with ordinary prudence in the choice of lay preachers? Is the orthodoxy of a layman any more difficult to ascertain than that of a parson? We think not, for the divine can becloud his views by the use of theological language to which laymen are unaccustomed. Another objection, if it was not part of the first, was that Plymouth Brethrenism might get possession of the platform. Now, experience has taught us that the intrusion of this element anywhere is so great an evil as to become a scourge and a miasma, and therefore we would rather exclude lay agency
403
altogether than countenance an influence so deleterious. It is impossible to associate with these effeminate Ishmaelites; they are neither to be argued with, nor countenanced by any who have respect for manly piety. But, again, we ask, if the committee be not infected with this evil, can they not exclude Plymouthism without excluding laymen who are accredited members of Evangelical churches? If not, we should think they are the only committee in the world so utterly helpless.
We feel strongly that a determined effort must be made to carry on and to extend religious services in theatres and similar buildings. Every "penny gaff" should be opened; and if lay preachers are excluded from the larger buildings, the churches should secure for them the smaller ones. The need of such services is as great as when first they were organised. Their popularity is not diminished. The last report of the committee states that "wherever a building has been opened under their direction, thousands of the people who had 'broken clean away' from the ordinary action of the Christian church, have literally flocked to hear the word." One case alone will show this. The Amphitheatre at Holborn was secured for a series of services. One of the missionaries of the City Mission was appointed to superintend the work and to adopt means, by visiting workshops and lodging houses, to get the building filled at least on the first night. "To my knowledge," he says, "there were thousands of men in the neighbourhood, and hundreds of families who never entered a place of worship to attend divine service, and whom no persuasion or entreaties could induce to attend. I could name many that for years past I had tried in vain to induce to attend the means of grace, and whom I could not even persuade to attend my own meeting, whom I felt persuaded could be got into a theatre." And the result has shown that where all other means had failed, this one has succeeded. It is not always easy for persons unaccustomed to mix up with the labouring classes, to understand why such disinclination to enter a church or chapel should be felt. But courageous as artisans generally are, they lack in moral courage in reference to this matter. They cannot endure the "chaffing" of their shopmates. A very remarkable case of this sort is described by a city missionary. "On my district," he writes, "there is an intelligent artisan, who works in a firm where several hundred hands are employed, and out of the whole number only three men have the moral courage to attend divine service in the house of God on the Lord's-day, and these are subject to the derision of their mates, 'Bible-back,' 'Parson' and 'Methodist' being the names given to them. Some of the men employed in this firm will dare to work on the very verge of sudden death who dare not meet the laughter, scorn, and derision of their shopmates." One man sometimes "works in such a dangerous position that the slightest false movement on his part, or a moment's negligence on the part of another, would result in either instantaneous death or mutilation for life. Yet the man who has the courage to work in such a very perilous position for a few shillings a day, dares not go to the house of God on a Sunday for fear of the 'chaff' and derision on Monday, although he is imperilling his soul's salvation thereby."
Without doubt, these special services are appreciated by the class for whom they are intended. They comport more with that free-and-easy
style which is so dear to the average working man. He can smoke his pipe while going to the service; he can talk freely to his "missus" while waiting for the preacher; he can discuss secular subjects there without offence to the occupant of the next seat. He does not feel restrained, or bound down by customs which he dislikes, and by observances to which he is unaccustomed. Not that he is guilty of rowdyism. A better-behaved and more seriously-disposed audience it would not be easy to obtain; but still there is an abandon and a feeling of ease which is not always attained by the non-worshipping class when in an ordinary conventicle. Unused to consecutive thinking, our working man indulges in frequent utterances; and he considers it to be no disrespect paid to a speaker if he should whisper to his companion when anything strikes his mind. We have heard some racy yet not rude criticisms from these listeners; and should the speaker give the parsons a wigging for not caring for the working man's interests (a very cheap mode of gaining popularity at some theatre services by lay democrats, who love to have a fling at "the one-man system"), the operation is richly enjoyed. For the working man is tempted to believe that ministers are an exclusive class, which is true indeed of the Church Evangelicals, whose Toryism is rank, and partly true also of the old Wesleyan type of parsons, but is far from being so with the majority of Dissenting ministers. This opinion, however, is considerably less general than it was, for we all move with the times, and the political and ecclesiastical events of the last few years have made it increasingly necessary for ministers of the gospel to take their part in public advocacy of justice. Fourteen years ago, we remember hearing artisans employing revolutionary language against preachers which in times of civil commotion might have led to serious disturbances; but this feeling of bitter antagonism is decreasing. And if it should please God early to free the English Episcopal church from her state bonds, as has just been the case with her Irish sister, we shall not only have introduced social equality among the ministers of Christ, but have removed one of the most potent causes of distaste of religious teachers which keep artisans from their instruction.
The rough and ready mode of criticism in which the attendants at theatre services indulge is not merely amusing, it is just and appreciating. "That fellow gave us some good stuff to-night, Tom." "A stunning sermon, Bill," remarks a knowing-looking customer, who, with his hands in his trowsers pocket, and his wide-awake carelessly thrown on his head, looks as if he had been startled out of, or into, his senses. A common-sense working man, who was evidently a student of the newspapers, once remarked, after a church minister had concluded, "I say, that fellow needn't fear disendowment, he's worth his money anywhere;" a remark which we commend to those good Evangelicals who dread voluntaryism as though it were the "first-born of hell." Another man, after hearing a Nonconformist minister, observed to his companion, "If all the clergymen and ministers would unite together to preach as this man has preached to-night, we'd soon have a different state of things in London." This, indeed, is indicative of a widespread feeling among the non-worshipping classes, that ministers should settle their own theological and ecclesiastical differences among themselves, just as
405
families settle their domestic squabbles, and not obtrude them to the gaze of such as they. For lack of charity on the part of God's servants has produced more scepticism among the working classes—whose opinion of the ethics of Christianity is much higher sometimes than obtains among our church members—than all the efforts of brazen-faced infidelity.
It is not alone among the respectable artisans that theatre services are popular. The lower classes—street bread-winners—have been prevailed upon to attend them. We have seen many such persons at some of the services held in the Victoria Theatre, which is the costermonger's home on the week-night. Last winter, over one thousand persons crowded Sabbath after Sabbath into the Pavilion Theatre to hear the gospel preached. There were professional beggars, harlots, thieves, swell-mobsmen, street-hawkers, street musicians, costermongers, and habitual drunkards—"the most sinful and vile that the east of London can produce." It was found necessary for policemen to be present in plain clothes. And yet, the demeanour of the "roughs" was excellent. We just imagine the horror with which the presence of such characters would inspire our present congregations. Imagine Miss Prim sitting next to a man in fustian who had brought with him the odour of fried onions! Imagine—oh! as once we more than imagined—the closest propinquity to clothes that smelt strongly of fresh, or rather stale, herrings! It is all very well to invite the people to come "just as they are"—but when they come in dirty, with bristling beards, frousy caps, shiny trousers, buttonless vests, the worse for drink, it is a relief to know that a platform divides you, your clean clothes and white linen, from them. Let not our respectable old deacons, whose dread of innovation is so great, fear the intrusion of such elements into our cushionless seats. They won't come. They know they are not wanted. But—thanks be to God and to the Christ that sought the ill-clad and the vile e'en in the highways and hedges and compelled them to come in—they can be persuaded to enter a theatre, where their presence is not considered an intrusion.
If you ask, why do these people like such services, we reply, because they suit them. "I like the style of preaching at the theatre" said a shoemaker once to a city missionary. Some like the sensational style, of course; but it is a fact, that this style is not generally popular. It looks too like acting, and mere acting it often is. "We have not had a sensational sermon," says the missionary at Holborn, "nor fine singing in the whole course. Our preachers have taken their style from the New Testament—earnest, loving, descriptive, pathetic."
The usefulness of such preaching is placed beyond a doubt. The cases of conversion best illustrate the kind of preaching that is most winsome. One preacher, a churchman, preached in Victoria Theatre, a "direct" sermon—i. e., one full of direct appeals to the heart. Four thieves were among the listeners. In a short time three of them left the place, "'cos we can't stand this any longer." The fourth remained, as if spell-bound. So impressed was he with the truths that were preached, that at night when he got home he cried to God for mercy. Somehow, he managed on the following day to find out the preacher's address, and he determined to open his mind to him. The preacher
read to him the words, "Know ye not that the unrighteous shall not enter the kingdom of God? Be not deceived; neither fornicators . . . nor thieves . . . such were some of you, but ye are washed," etc. "Washed," thought the poor man, "ay, that is what I need." With the first few peucie he earned he purchased for twopence a pocket Testament. Reading the words "He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life," he felt he could believe and that he could realise the forgiveness he had prayed for. He subsequently became a street dealer of almanacks, and in rejoicing over his abandonment of his old evil habits, he once observed, "We used after a good day, as we called it, to go home and have hot beefsteaks and beer for supper, I don't get that now; but with the little I have, I've got Christ, and oh! that sweetens everything."
Faithful, solemn, preaching—ay, preaching the terrors of the law—the wrath of God—the doom of the impenitent, is owned of God. The prevalent dislike of this awful truth is growing to be a serious matter. Mr. Edward White has recently suceingly called it "Missionary Theology"—but if missionary efforts are to be successful, this as one of the solemn facts of revealed writ, preached intelligently and wisely (as the Saviour preached it), must have its place in sermons. Neither "enlightened criticism" nor carnal distaste of the truth will extinguish it. And though,
"Law and terrors do but harden,
All the while they work alone,"
yet the exhibition of the love of God and the cross of Christ, with the terrors of refusal, do "convert the heart of stone." And this has been peculiarly verified in theatre preaching. "The wrath of God" has led many to escape for their lives. Could some whose conviction of the heinousness of sin bear the terribly graphic descriptions of the soul-agony of some of the converts of theatre and similar services, they would scarcely, as reasonable men, treat lightly that which God in this world punishes so heavily. And if the righteous be scarcely saved—saved through the fire of fierce remorse and maddening despair—what will be the condemnation of the wicked? At a social meeting, a new convert related the following story:—"I have to thank the Christian public for these services. I was in London some two years before the theatre services were commenced; at that time I went to hear Mr. Spurgeon at the Surrey Gardens. I then was in the habit of reviling him, and calling him everything bad I could think of. I called him a hypocrite, and only went to hear him out of daring. I heard him twice at the Gardens, and although I still reviled him, I felt that what he had said had had a great effect on me. I followed his ministry to this hall (Exeter), and attended here regularly for some months every Sunday morning. I was in agony for months through listening to him. I was then led to Sadler's Wells Theatre, and there I first saw the Lord Jesus Christ as the Saviour of my soul. As the poet says, 'It was a joy when first I knew the Lord.' I went home, and I shall never forget that night; I knew then what a blessing it was to have a wife. I knelt before her, and I cried like a child. We were not in the habit of attending any place of worship, but after this I attended the theatre services regularly, and I felt the greatest joy when the missionary said,
407
'We want helpers here in the theatre, and if any will come forward, we shall only be too glad of their services.' I naturally ran to the work, and I have been happy ever since. Myself, my wife, and my mother, have now joined a church in the neighbourhood of the theatre. I went to the preaching on Clerkenwell-green, and the very man I had reviled at three months before, for holding services on that Green, I now joined and assisted." Many other cases of good done through these services are to be found in the various reports of the Society and of the city missionaries, who are mostly brought into connection with the men after conversion. Enough however has been written for our purpose: these services cannot be dispensed with. They are absolutely essential when we consider what is the spiritual destitution of the metropolis. The object of the committee, as stated in the following paragraph of their last report, has our hearty support:—
"Were the principle of success justifying a measure to be applied to this effort, the committee can with confidence appeal not only to the repeatedly crowded houses, the order and fixed attention of the audiences they have assembled together, but also to the now numerous decided cases of usefulness and real conversion which, under God, have been accomplished at these services. But they decline to have this work so judged. They rest its claim for the sympathy and support of the Christian public on the paramount duty of the church of Christ to do something more than put up a mere signal of invitation to the great gospel feast. Poor, fallen human nature needs something more than this. It must be pressed in to the supper chamber. To bring the great principles of gospel truth into contact with the masses of the people, to lift up in their midst the standard of the cross of Christ, and under this sign bid them fight the battle of their class with society, to scatter broad and deep that 'salt of the earth,' found only in the divine message of Christianity to fallen man, was the original, and is the present purpose of the committee in the institution of these services."
