Menu
‹ Chapter 109 of 203 ›

England's Break with Antichrist — By G. Holden Pike — (Second Paper.)

20 min read · Chapter 109 of 203

THE pain and disgust engendered by studying the pages of mediæval history find some compensation in the discovery, that while apparently supreme, evil was usually too blind to be unbrokenly successful. The false-hearted never have memories sufficiently powerful for their necessities; and the cause of error has never yet attracted to its standard enough sagacity to ensure its escape from disaster. During the ascendancy of the popes in the dark ages, kings and subjects were the common if not the uncomplaining slaves of the church. When times changed, instead of adopting a liberal policy in keeping with the progress of knowledge, an insolent bearing and lofty airs were retained, which, being obsolete, helped to open people's eyes to the absurd pretensions of the ecclesiastics.

Most of us have been interested as children, while our indignation has been awakened by those pictures of death and torture, or illustrations of old Foxe's text, drawn to show the nature of the rough discipline that tried our fathers' faith in distant days. If the martyrologist's pages with their prints still present

[THE SWORD AND THE TROWEL. JULY 1, 1870.

to English readers unanswerable evidence of the iniquity of popery, let us proportionately estimate the worth of that irresistible force of conviction, which emanating from the real fire, the torture, and the dying testimony of the martyrs, biased the multitude against the papacy till it prepared England for the Reformation. False and earthly indeed must a system be when it can supply excuses to a powerful mind like Wolsey's for his extravagance and libertinism; and wherein the otherwise learned and pious More supposed he found divine license for oppression and cruelty. But so false and so earthly is popery. Had Wolsey manifested the fiendishness of a hundred Bonners, and had More sank to the moral level of a Nero, each would have been stimulated in the work of a deadly repression of religion somewhat after the manner that slave-hunters urge on their hounds.

The flames of Smithfield, it is true, shot forth their testimony, while prisons witnessed against the cruelty and intolerance of Rome. These, however, were not the only agencies at work to open the yet dim eyes of the populace. The attendant circumstances of an execution would occasionally tell on public opinion with a power such as persecutors would seem to be incapable of realising. That the heroism of a Bainham or of a Bilucy aided the cause their death was supposed to cheek will easily be believed; but when evil overwhelmed those who had hunted down the Protestants, feasted their eyes on dying agonies, and mocked the heretics in their last hours, people stood aghast, as though the visitation of punishment on the offender had filled them with wonder and terror. "May God forgive thee, and show more mercy than thou angry raviler showest to me," cried Bainham from the fire, when derided by the town clerk of London. A few days, subsequently, the ghastly news sped through the City that the ruler had hanged himself. The martyr's words had haunted him to the death, if they had not hunted him into the grave. Nevertheless, the cause of error had its confessors; for in common fairness we cannot deny that the papacy had some very noble martyrs—such is the frailty of human judgment when perverted by a wrong education. Sir Thomas More, and Fisher, bishop of Rochester, saw in the church, notwithstanding her corruptions, enough of good to be worth testifying for unto death. Besides these illustrious victims of religious delusion there were the less conspicuous, but not less devoted Charterhouse monks, men whose life and cloisters combined as it were to form an oasis of purity in a wide desert of moral corruption and spiritual deadness. All these were unmistakable examples of conscientious devotion to the old order of things; and they all, no less than did the fourteen Baptists who were burnt about the same time, discovered an unwavering faith not common to quieter times.

It is one glory of the Reformation that though it produced its agitators, it was not in itself the work of agitation. Looking back from our standpoint on the first half of the sixteenth century, and regarding the area of its great movement, it seems as though some good angel must have gone abroad, now to visit a monk's cell, or a students' hall, or anon to call at a warehouse, or step into a royal palace to drop into favoured hearts seeds destined to germinate to the troubling of rulers and the shaking of the hierarchy. Thus stealthily proceeded the work of the Christian brethren. These people were poor and obscure; but that fact necessitates our forming a high opinion of their labours; for their energies were of a nature which nothing short of strong faith could have prompted or sustained. It may also be remembered that in those days, earth contained no asylum for heretics within the confines of civilisation. Whatever were their political differences, a common sympathy against heresy bound together the European rulers; and consequently, we should judge leniently of those in the vanguard of progress who are found to have quailed and recanted in the prospect of fire and death. Smithfield had too often been provided with its hideous paraphernalia of the discipline of mother church: it was reserved for old St. Paul's to present the less happy spectacle of a public retractation of Protestant doctrine. How mockingly unreal do the surroundings appear.

ENGLAND'S BREAK WITH ANTICHRIST.

321

There is a burning pile of Bibles and Testaments. There are pale victims carrying fagots around the flames. Sitting in state there is the magnificent Wolsey with his brilliant suite. Six Christian brethren recant; but alas, their shrinking from present pain is no escape from the punishment of a convicting conscience.

In times of popular revolution comparatively small actions may become so linked with great results, and be attended with such noble danger as to compel our chasing them among deeds of heroism. To this order belongs an occurrence of 1532—a work that a few years later would have elicited popular applause instead of earning the death awarded to the majority who were engaged in its completion. The Dovercourt of those days contained a wondrous rood. The nods, winks, frowns, or glances of approval of this image attracted an anxious and interested stream of pilgrims, who were not averse from paying liberally for any supposed blessing they carried away. Night and day the sanctuary remained open and unguarded; for, so the monks mysteriously intimated, whoever sought to close the door of the church was preternaturally opposed. Now it happened that four stouthearted and comely youths, with souls irradiated by the light from Germany, not only doubted but resolved on testing the popular theories by putting them to a strain sufficiently severe to convince the populace of their truth or falsehood. The time chosen for the adventure was a frosty, moonlight night in February. After walking ten long miles they came to the open door, the same having been open, as tradition averred, from time immemorial. In ghostly solitude, with silvery light shining aslant through the windows, stood the dreaded object, now destined to be dreadful no longer. Entering the church, and deliberately taking down the image, these nocturnal reformers carried their burden into the open air, set it on fire, and while it blazed and cracked in the crisp atmosphere, returned to their homes and beds. We rightly give all honour to the leading spirits of any beneficent movement. There are lesser men—men who could do such a deed as that of burning the Dovercourt rood—"Their consciences being burdened to see the honour of Almighty God so blasphemed," and their names are inscribed in noble prominence on the roll-list of British reformers.

While regarding the Reformation as a whole, we must not mistake Henry the Eighth for its originator, nor even as its abettor, though undoubtedly he materially smoothed the path for its progress in England. While not so illiberal as many of his contemporaries, the King still showed himself to be a stickler for papal doctrines, although his natural sagacity prevented his associating infallibility with the tiara. He seems to have supposed, that for ecclesiastical purposes a local pope in England would answer as well as a universal pontiff in Italy. There is no disputing that the quarrel with Rome on the question of the divorce hastened reform; but to make the divorce the pivot on which the movement wholly turned is to misunderstand or misrepresent. During the weary period of Henry's negociating, or of Wolsey's dream of purifying and amending the church, an under-current of public opinion against priestcraft daily increased in volume. The ecclesiastical fabric had grown notoriously corrupt, and only a slight shaking threatened to lay its apparently fair exterior in ruins. Here and there a household had received the "new" doctrine of salvation by faith; and the inmates in stealthy meetings and nocturnal studies represented the leaven destined to permeate the nation. In students of the New Testament the corrupt church found the truest opponents to her pretensions.

As already shown, the church lost ground in Parliament though dealt with by professed adherents. A desire for something better than hypocrisy was abroad in the nation; and the prolonged controversy on the divorce almost involuntarily drew the King to the right side. Persons are commonly sensitive observers of passing events when their interests are affected; and therefore the priests saw with rage and alarm that their power was waning. Because so sensibly losing ground in the senate and in public esteem, they desperately attempted to restore by violence, coercion, or superstition, the prestige forfeited by a

21

[THE SWORD AND THE

TROWEL. JULY 1, 1870.

profligate procedure. A persecuting spirit was revived in all its intensity. Because a gentleman of Buckinghamshire died without honouring the church in his will, his body was contemptuously burned to inculcate a spirit of liberality; while, in the department of superstition, the services of Elizabeth Barton, the maid of Kent, were enlisted.

The tragical story of the Maid of Kent, an epileptic girl, whose misfortune the opponents of reform sought to turn into capital, is too long to be given at length. Elizabeth Barton was just such an instrument as the corrupt clergy gloried in possessing, and had she lived a century earlier, she might have become the means of diverting considerable spoil into the ecclesiastical exchequer. In 1534, the village of Aldington witnessed an unwonted excitement, consequent on the strange doings of one, who, the peasants believed, exhibited involuntary symptoms of speaking and acting under preternatural influence. The country people had scarcely begun accounting for her distorted features, uncantly writhings, and half-intelligible utterances, ere one Masters, a priest, and one Bocking, a friar, discovered in the epileptic a source of profit. The priest rejoiced in commanding a means of money-making, and the friar in possessing an agent of approved potency for obstructing the Reformation, and of hindering the divorce which especially threatened to trouble the hierarchy. The girl's wonderful doings were industriously noised abroad: and what were called miracles were plentifully exhibited, until the attention of high and low was attracted. Being well tutored, Elizabeth made her peculiar misfortune serve the Church, as desired by the ultramontane party. In her rustic simplicity, she may have imagined that she was the favoured medium between shortsighted humanity and invisible powers. For a time all progressed smoothly. Crafty and worldly, the churchmen cautiously felt their way. In order to prevent any flagging of the excitement, it was arranged that a forsaken and desolate chapel in the vicinity should become the scene of the maiden's miraculous cure by the Virgin Mary. This farce having passed off satisfactorily, the party adopted stronger measures. The king was threatened in church and cloister, should he dare to marry Anne Boleyn. Yet one more step, and the pinnacle of triumph would be reached. Elizabeth must appear before Henry himself, and break his Tudor obstinacy with the terrors of heaven, if commonplace entreaty failed. These manoeuvres were partially successful. On being carried before his Majesty, the girl, in homely village phraseology, assured him he would "die the death of a villain," unless he changed his determination. Growing yet bolder with success and desperation, the party, of which this girl was the nucleus, as they saw high and low—even Fisher and More—came over to believing in the inspiration of their protégé, contrived a conspiracy for restoring the Pope's supremacy. All this ended, as it could not but end in such troublous days, in ruin and death. Elizabeth admitted her fraud, and her confession, a few minutes before her death, was a protest against the iniquity of popery: "I was a poor wretch without learning," she cried to the Tyburn crowd, "but the praises of the priests turned my brain."

Defeated and exposed in the affair of the Maid of Kent, the priests looked for assistance in other quarters. They could have borne with Pope Henry the Eighth, had his subjects been in a temper to tolerate abuses. Happily, it was otherwise. With the Pontiff's decision in the matter of the divorce came the voice of warning and alarm to monkery. One centre of hope, however, remained. Catherine of Arragon was intensely bigoted to the papacy. She came of a powerful family, while her obstinate temper and fanatical mien rendered her the pliable agent of the extreme party. The harsh treatment, or supposed harsh treatment, experienced by the queen, was awakening indignation on the Continent, and arousing the vindictiveness of her nephew, Charles the Fifth. Fearful rows of vengeance were taken. France was offered substantial rewards to ally herself with Germany against rebellious England; and Europe suddenly resounded with preparations for war. In the midst of this alarm and commotion, Catherine died, and in her grave were covered the

TROWEL. JULY 1, 1870.

ENGLAND'S BREAK WITH ANTICHRIST.

323

budding hopes of the enemies of the Reformation. In the range of English history, the hand of providence nowhere more visibly appears than in the timely removal of this misguided woman. Dangers were gathering around our island like a threatening tempest; and had she lived, the queen would probably have become the soul of a powerful coalition against purity of faith. At her decease the voices of alarm were hushed; the political atmosphere quickly cleared, and the Reformed doctrines so lately threatened with destruction, had their growth encouraged.

In the meantime, the great business of inspecting the monasteries was progressing. The notion has been too commonly entertained that Henry the Eighth first looked with greedy eyes on the religious houses, and next, in a covetous spirit, planned their destruction for the sake of the spoil. The truth is, that the need for these institutions was superseded; and not only had they grown unpopular, they were a moral eyesore and a shame. While, therefore, he dealt with them as his wisdom dictated, the King in the main yielded to the pressure of public opinion. The worst about these refuges of sin is not known, for Bonner, instructed by Queen Mary, destroyed every copy of the "Black Book" laid before Parliament by the Commission of Inspection. Much more is known about the abounding iniquity, however, than can be told with decency by modern historians. Despised in common by squire and peasant, those ignorant and indolent monks, who wasted their lives in feasting and sensuality, inherited sufficient wit to perceive that the pope was their stoutest defender, and that Rome was the only capital whither they could safely appeal against English affronts—an important consideration, since certain yeomen were now beginning to feel aggrieved at handing over the fat of the land to incompetent pastors and useless monks, while they, the thrifty producers, were constrained to live on common fare. The days had been when the religious houses in a certain manner had served the nation. Learning had been encouraged, travellers hospitably entertained, and the needy sick carefully succoured. But mediæval night had departed, and institutions which, with all their errors, were once a partial blessing, were now an insupportable burden. Thus, because the fabric was rotten, and invitingly attracted the hand of the spoiler, the agitation and threatened quarrel with Rome on the question of the divorce bred alarm and apprehension. To complete the breach with the papacy, it was seen, would seal the doom of the convents. When the dreaded rupture was actually occasioned by the pope's declaring against the divorce, the Government had no alternative, while preserving its honour and safety, but to defend itself by collecting information respecting the interior of houses crowded with transgressors, who, to the list of crimes contained in the first of Romans, occasionally added the art of false coining. The exposure of the fraudulent sins and low sensuality of the monks contributed much towards preparing the way for the swift demolition of their sanctuaries, besides hastening the complete separation of the national heart from Rome, by revealing the true nature of monasticism.

The idea of visiting the monasteries was not altogether novel. Towards the end of the preceding century reports were murmured among the populace of the amazing wickedness to be found in the places consecrated to holy purposes, and some abortive attempts at reform were made by the reigning pope. But now everything was ripe for immediate action. England was under an interdict. Her monarch was excommunicated, and political as well as moral and religious considerations made it necessary for due surveillance to be exercised over houses which, under the hitherto impregnable shield of a holy profession, promised to become temples of treason as well as moral lazarettos. The well-timed inspection of these places greatly aided the Reformation; and the principle then acted on still remains as just and as reasonable as it did of yore. It is no encroachment on the liberty of the subject, nor does it savour of intolerance to bring within the jurisdiction of the magistrate institutions whose nature is subversive of liberty. If the commissioners in their progress were not scattering light they were at least exposing darkness. Nor were the written reports the only evidence

[THE SWORD AND THE TROWEL. JULY 1, 1870.

given to the country of monastic abominations. Wherever the visitors halted, nuns under age, and monks not older than twenty-four, were allowed their freedom; and the numbers who accepted the boon dispersed themselves over the country, to become witnesses against an unnatural system. Many of the circumstances attendant on the visitation were sufficiently ludicrous, though painfully illustrative of a phase of the papacy which cannot with propriety be exhibited in all its enormous wickedness. A company of Waltham Abbey monks were literally caught in a strong game net on their return from a midnight debauch. At one place a phial, said to contain some of the blood of Christ, was found. This fluid, now discovered to be the blood of a duck, renewed weekly, became visible to penitents only; and, as sorrow for sin and handsome donations were commonly blended, the bottle was conveniently constructed with a thin and thick side, the former being turned towards the sinner on the forthcoming of something substantial. At another place a crucifix with a nodding and winking figure, was brought to light, and when the people realised how they had been befooled by mechanical contrivances, the bitterness manifested towards their detractors helped to widen the great breach.

We may believe that Henry sought the national welfare when he confiscated the abused property of the ecclesiastics. The King was certainly a reformer, and a host of good things followed in the train of the Reformation. The people awakened to a desire for knowledge, and in proportion as knowledge increased trade expanded. Then the growing expenses of the executive became more pressing as the traffic grew between England and foreign nations. Funds were needed for improving the home ports, and for other public works; so that it was not strange if partially to meet the outlay, the squandered revenues of the monks temptingly offered themselves.

But while the breach with Rome daily widened, and though reformers gained ground and rejoiced in the promise of better days, it was still a time of martyrs. Thomas Hardinge, an old man of Buckinghamshire, and John Frith, a Cambridge scholar, were burnt in 1533. Clerical fanaticism was urging churchmen to extreme action when their blindness to the signs of the times became the indirect occasion of their discomfiture. They discovered that one Thomas Phillips possessed a New Testament, and also impiously ate butter and cheese during Lent. An imprisonment in the Tower, and other indignities inflicted on him, provoked the opportune interference of Parliament. An immense advance in the cause of freedom was made when the secular power refused to sanction ecclesiastical cruelty, or even prevented its perpetration; and the preachers of the reformed doctrine breathed freely when the legislature invested the king with power to correct abuses and order observances. Better than all, was the grand declaration which now rang throughout England.—SCRIPTURE IS THE STANDARD OF THE CATHOLIC FAITH. The Bible was released, and before a free Bible, with a populace competent to read it, Antichrist cannot maintain its empire.

Hundreds of small religious houses were abolished in 1536, and during subsequent years the larger convents followed. About the same time a controversy sprang up concerning printing the Bible in the vulgar tongue. The king, the queen, before her fall, Cranmer and others, were for placing a copy in every parish church. Partially stayed in their persecutions, the papal party hailed this timely innovation with demonstrations of rage and alarm. A free Bible! What strange infatuation! The doctrines and practices of Rome could not be reconciled with the popular interpretation of inspiration! As all knew, or might know, the heresies of Luther sprang from the New Testament.

On the demolition of the large convents, swarms of famishing monks traversed the country, each with only forty shillings in his pocket; but with a heart filled with vindictive passions. The government used a sharp cure for a sore evil, and the sudden breaking up of so many houses was necessarily attended by temporary inconvenience or actual misery. This apparently harsh procedure was strictly in keeping with an age in which changes often came with sudden

ENGLAND'S BREAK WITH ANTICHRIST.

325

violence, rather than in the gradual manner common to our own quieter days. With no other possessions to lose but their heads, and having no choice between penury and a life of industry, the monks, encouraged by the priests, stirred up rebellion, their success being shown in the Lincolnshire rising, and in the formidable northern outbreak under Aske—the Pilgrimage of Grace. Defeat and the usual executions of rebels followed. The sword in religious controversies is sure to produce the results predicted by Christ, and, therefore, the humiliating spectacle was now witnessed of two great parties pushing their quarrel to blood and death. In Anne Boleyn and others, churchmen hunted down their prey. The death of sundry popish lords for treason was regarded as fair retaliation.

On the pope's publishing his Bull of Deposition, in 1538, the breach with Rome may be said to have been completed. It was a bold or even desperate course to adopt. The Vatican gave an example of its own impotence. Its curses were discovered to be no withering blight, but rather the ravings of an imbecile blasphemy. The requirements of the Bull, for candles in churches to be extinguished; for religious ordinances to be suspended; for trade to be stopped; for the King's goods to be seized, and for his orders to be disobeyed, served as a seasonable intimation that the power of the pope had set in England. His anathemas were replied to in an edition of the Bible now published. From the Vatican issued the voice of cursing and condemnation; but, said Cromwell, referring to England, "The light of God's Word does shine over it without any cloud."

There are a few interesting facts illustrative of the times associated with the above-mentioned edition of the Bible. The art of printing being then imperfectly understood in England, a Parisian printer was engaged. The afterwards notorious Bonner was then French ambassador, and receiving instructions from home, he obtained the sanction of the authorities before proceeding with the work in hand. The clergy, however, were intensely anti-Protestant, and discovering what was being done, they began an agitation, which resulted in the seizure and destruction of most of the printed copies. Fortunately the type and a few sets of sheets were preserved, and these, with the workmen, being removed to London, the printing there satisfactorily proceeded. Yet, amid all this happy promise of a revival of life and liberty, John Lambert was burned for denying the Real Presence.

In 1539, the Reformation received a check in the Act for Abolishing Diversities of Opinion—a measure showing how the Legislature groped in darkness while light was breaking over the country. With the exception of the pope's supremacy, and the permission to read the Bible, the cardinal papal doctrines were defended. Anon, the Government authorised the sale of the Scriptures; for hitherto it had been illegal to uphold such a traffic in England. Then the Reformation found a compensation for the fall and death of Cromwell in the publication of the Formularies of Religion, which, encumbered as they were with error, retained enough of truth to cause the opponents of Rome to "Rejoice to see the doctrine of the gospel opened more and more." This book, moreover, prefaced by the King, awakened a spirit of enquiry. Truth advanced; but the van of progress was troubled by two evil spirits—two names destined to become linked with lasting infamy. Gardiner and Bonner instigated most of the persecutions and burnings which yet occasionally disgraced the administration.

In the meantime an unrestricted study of the Bible created a public interest unparalleled in kind and degree. People began spending their leisure hours in parish churches, where good readers with clear voices were sure of attentive and appreciative congregations. From Bible reading sprang desires for education. Aged persons, whose dim eyes had never read, wished that their children at least should be endowed with the coveted art. Six Bibles were chained to as many desks in old St. Paul's, and thither the citizens flocked in crowds, the children frequently being the readers. Nevertheless, during those closing years

THE SWORD AND THE

TROWEL. JULY 1, 1870.

of the reign of King Henry, much alloy mixed itself with the sterling metal. The populace, for the first time, understood what was meant by preaching the gospel. Hitherto the practice had been rare, and when undertaken on holy-days or saints' festivals, the sermon was too commonly a farrago of fable and mummory, unprofitable because unintelligible; but as light increased, a race of genuine preachers appeared, and drew around them delighted multitudes. On the other hand, many injudicious reformers encouraged the interludes—those absurd stage-plays acted in churches or in the open air, ostensibly for the purpose of exposing the excesses of monks and priests.

Space will not allow of our extending this sketch. The reign of Henry the Eighth was pre-eminently a time of awakening; and it is especially dear in an Englishman's remembrance, as the era of his country's severance from the papal see. What occurred subsequently, not excepting the shocking persecutions of Mary's dismal ascendancy, served to show how complete was the rupture, and how impossible it was for an array of terrors, springing from an alliance of the ecclesiastical and secular powers for the suppression of truth, to undo what the Bible in the hands of bold preachers had effected

A few of the party-leaders of the time merit a parting word. Henry the Eighth rises before us as the chief enigma in English history. We may not believe him to have been the master of iniquity delineated by most writers; neither may we accept as altogether unchallengeable the portrayal of his character as drawn by Froude. It is impossible to harmonise Henry's solicitude for the spread of piety with his every-day actions; but charity will remember, that through long centuries, the abettors of Rome have striven to blacken the king's character. It is the same with Anne Boleyn. Vilified or extolled by rival parties, her true character cannot be recovered. The severe exposure of her failings by Froude, and the equally able picture of her pattern life, cruel usage and tragic end to be found in the pages of D'Aubigné, if taken together, will form an historical maze not easily escaped from with any clear notions of the real truth. Near the king and his consort moves Cranmer, whose character also is variously written. Suffice it to say, that his conversion from Rome to Protestantism was really his experience of the new birth. What is more affecting, the change was aided by the writings of Frith, whom the bishop had helped to condemn in darker days. Then Wolsey deserves more pity than contempt. Though a great minister he had the infirmities of a weak man; but his beneficence and encouragement of learning may be allowed to outshine, though they cannot atone for his frailties. In Cromwell, moreover, we discover the enviable trait of never forgetting a kindness; while so little is known of Tyndale's busy life, that one refers to him as "a man whose history is lost in his work, and whose epitaph is the Reformation."

The mention of the names of those who began the great work in England begets hope of final victory, though the day may be deferred till a future generation. If popery occasionally shows signs of life amidst our Protestant population, it is in its dotage elsewhere. In France it is held in contempt. In Spain its chief upholder has been driven from her throne. Even in Rome itself, the symptoms of impending anarchy and ruin are more plentiful than any signs of a so-called Catholic revival.

MARROW OF A SERMON. Jesus said, "They need not depart." Matt. xiv. 16. If these strangers need not, much less need his own people. Saints need not break their communion with Jesus. No present necessity exists either in their circumstances or his own; and no future want, trial, or sin, need drive them from fellowship with him. Certainly no force can compel them to leave him, nor is it in itself impossible for their fellowship to remain unbroken. No reason can be imagined which will render it needful for them to leave him, and therefore all their departings from their Lord are as inexcusable as they are injurious.

TROWEL. JULY 1, 1870.

327

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate