Menu
‹ Chapter 12 of 203 ›

On Ecclesiastical Councils — By G. Rogers

9 min read · Chapter 12 of 203

BEFORE this number will be in the hands of our readers, the eyes of all Europe will be turned towards a council being held at Rome by all the leading representatives of the Romish Church, which, on account of the influence it cannot fail to have for good or for evil upon the interests of vital godliness, ought not to pass unnoticed by us. Such a council in the present state of Romanism must constitute one of the most critical periods in its history, and must be regarded as an experiment the results of which can be foreseen by none. It is easy to perceive that its object is by concentration and external parade to display the remaining strength of the church of Rome, and to re-assert its imperious claims; but it is by no means improbable that its foundations will be found to be so undermined that the renewal of its lofty pretensions may serve only to accelerate its fall. Already an opposition council at Naples, within its own ecclesiastical jurisdiction, has been determined, and the effect of a kingdom divided against itself is foreshadowed. We shall not, however, endeavour to predict what the results will be, or whether they will be immediate or more remote. We shall rather avail ourselves of the opportunity of looking at the subject of ecclesiastical councils in general.

Our first thought respecting them, as of everything relating to the Church of Christ, is—What saith the Scriptures? Councils may occupy a prominent place in church history, but what is their place in the New Testament? Have they any place here? We candidly confess we have found none. Instead of being prominent here as a part of church government, or foremost in the plan of its organization, there is no intimation respecting them. In vain shall we look for any authority for their convocation, or any instructions respecting them. This is the more remarkable, as we have the record of all that pertains to life and godliness; an apostle tells us what he ordained in all the churches, and the Head of the church has declared he will put upon it no other burden. In

TROWEL. JAN. 1870.

ECCLESIASTICAL COUNCILS.

39

none of the directions given to Timothy and Titus for regulating the offices of the church have we any mention made of councils. Elders or bishops, deacons, and churches are frequently mentioned, but councils never. The word often occurs in reference to Jewish councils, but never in connection with the church of Christ, and is not to be found in any of the epistles. Neither in the examples of New Testament churches have we any sanction for general councils. As there is no command to apostles or elders to meet in conclave for the solution of difficulties or the advancement of the faith, so there is no instance of their having done so. If it had been a part of their duty, ample instructions for the conduct of such an assembly would have been given, and we should have expected to see them occasionally illustrated in the Acts of the Apostles; but in no instance have they so acted, and we are left alike without rule and without example respecting them. The council as it might be considered, for the choice of an apostle in the place of Judas, was evidently not convened for that purpose, and consisted not of apostles only, but of a large company of the disciples. The conduct of Peter on that occasion is very questionable. He had obviously received no authority for the proceeding, or there could have been no need to cast lots. He had been told with others to wait until the Spirit had been given before they took church action. No disapprobation of the choice of Matthias is expressed, but neither is there any approving confirmation. Paul was the apostle chosen by Christ to complete the twelve; nor is it likely that so high an office in the church could be filled by any except Christ himself.

The nearest approach to an ecclesiastical council in the New Testament is the account of a conference at Jerusalem recorded in the fifteenth chapter of the Acts of the Apostles; but a little reflection will suffice to convince every unprejudiced mind that the resemblance is in appearance only. The occasion of this council was the attempt of some men from Judea, in opposition to the will of Paul and Barnabas, to enforce circumcision upon the Gentile converts to Christianity at Antioch. The church at Antioch, consisting probably of both Jews and Gentiles, requested Paul and Barnabas, and certain others, to go to Jerusalem and ascertain whether these men had really, as they professed, received such a commission from the church in that city and from the apostles. That council did not, therefore, originate with the apostles, but with the people; neither did the apostles act in it upon their own authority, but as representatives of the will of the people. The subject in dispute was one which belonged to Judaism rather than to Christianity, was peculiar to that people and to those times, and had nothing to do with the church in general. It did not affect the essential doctrines or discipline of the Christian church. The assembly before which the question was argued consisted of the church, the apostles, and elders. In this order they are specified, the church being first. To the church, too, all the appeals are made, as though its judgment was principally desired. "All the multitude kept silence, and gave audience to Barnabas and Paul." And when James, who presided, not Peter, though he was present, gave his opinion, "it pleased the apostles and elders, with the whole church;" and "they wrote after this manner: The apostles, and elders, and brethren;" and, "it seemed good," they write, "unto us." Here is no assembly of divines, no separated meeting of presbytery, no authority of apostles, apart from the church; and the united decision of the whole assembly is expressed, not as an imperial decree, but as a recommendation to brethren. Compare this with the ecclesiastical councils that are supposed to be justified by it, and what have they in common? Had the apostles and elders of churches been known to have met in council with closed doors to issue their decrees respecting any of the heretical doctrines and disorderly practices that appeared in their times, some pretext might have been given for such councils in our day; but the only council that is recorded seems rather to condemn them.

Mosheim, in his "Ecclesiastical History," speaking of the first century, says:—

"The churches in those early times were entirely independent; none of them subject to any foreign jurisdiction, but each one governed by its own rulers and its

[THE SWORD AND THE

TROWELL. JAN. 1870.

own laws. For though the churches founded by the apostles had this particular difference shown them, that they were consulted in difficult and doubtful cases, yet they had no juridical authority, no sort of supremacy over the others, nor the least right to enact laws for them. Nothing, on the contrary, is more evident than the perfect equality that reigned among the primitive churches; nor does there ever appear in this first century the smallest trace of that association of provincial churches, from which councils and metropolitans derive their origin. It was only in the second century that the custom of holding councils commenced in Greece, from whence it soon spread through the other provinces." Ecclesiastical councils, we here learn, had their origin in Greece, as early as the second century. They probably rose from a sincere desire to promote the peace and extension and spiritual welfare of the churches. There is scarcely any part, indeed, of the great apostacy from the primitive simplicity of Christianity that may not have risen from the purest motives; so needful is it to make the strict rule of Scripture rather than our own pious suggestions our invariable guide. To the Greeks, who had known the advantages of the political union of independent states, a confederation of churches and of their pastors would naturally suggest itself, and considerable benefit might be supposed to result from it, sufficient to lead to its adoption in other countries. These by the Greeks were called synods, and by the Romans councils. However innocent at first, they soon became the source of incalculable evils. From being subject to the churches they began to assume authority over them. Superiority of rank and influence in churches and their pastors was a necessary consequence of the new arena of conflict and control. New orders of ecclesiastics arose, until the whole constitution culminated in the infallibility of one supreme pontiff. It was a dark day in the annals of church history when the first thought of an ecclesiastical council arose. The church then began to forge the fetters with which for centuries it has been enslaved. The supremacy once obtained, there has been less disposition to renew a general council than to rely upon the decrees of the past; and it has only been upon a great emergency, or when the demand became almost irresistible, that general councils have been held. They are called œcumenical or general, in distinction from provincial or national councils, which have been more frequently held. The last œcumenical council was held at Trent, a city in Germany, in the middle of the sixteenth century, for the purpose of making a grand demonstration in favour of Romanism in opposition to the wide-spread effects of the Lutheran Reformation. The decrees of that council were directly aimed against the innovations introduced by the Reformers, and instead of rectifying these abuses which had been fearlessly exposed, unblushingly reaffirmed them, made them more stringent, and threw a greater amount of authority around them. The sole object in fact was to re-establish the despotic authority of the Pope, under the pretence of healing the divisions and restoring the peace of the church. There were prelates who recommended more moderate and conciliatory measures, but the Papacy had secured its defenders in sufficient numbers to ensure, while seeming to allow the utmost freedom of debate, all that it desired. The decrees, for the most part, were without doubt, previously prepared, and the wise and deliberate advice of a council meant nothing more than its submissive adoption of the dictations of its supreme head. Upon nearly all matters affecting the dogmas and discipline of the Romish church since that period, appeals are made by its most ardent defenders to the Council of Trent.

The situation of the church of Rome at the present time is in some respects analogous to what it was when hard pressed by the Reformation on every side; nor is it improbable that this may have suggested another council for regaining its ascendancy. Its plans have been laid, its forces marshalled, and its decrees, which, after much pretence of anxious and prayerful discussion, will be adopted, have been already recorded. The times however are altered. The Spain, the Italy, the Germany, the France, the England, of the middle of the sixteenth century, are not the Spain, the Italy, the Germany, the France, the England, of the present

TROW. JAN. 1570.

A WESTERN DROVER'S STORY.

41

day. Romanism is essentially the same. It cannot change without ceasing to be. It has no intention by the proposed council to reform itself, or to suffer itself to be reformed by others. Nor is it perhaps desirable that it should. Rome's downfall will be more hastened by declaring itself to be what it really is. In order that it might retrace its steps all the way back to the simplicity of the first church within its walls, many centuries would be required; and to attempt to accomplish it by a single bound, would be self-annihilation. We are glad on the whole that the council will be held. It means evil, but God may mean it for good. It professes to abide by the decisions of former councils, and merely to supplement them by asseverations of the continuance of its own immaculate purity in the midst of the increasing degeneracy of the age, and of its paternal yearnings to restore the wandering prodigals to its embrace. That it will gain aught by the attempt, we have no fear. The good which we hope will result from it will be, that it will serve to undeceive those who maintain that the Roman Catholic religion is not what it formerly was, and on that account are disposed to show it more favour; that those who are half involved in it will pause and retrace their steps, when they see that the submission of their opinions, and the consignment of their immortal interests to the infallibility of a man like themselves, is the only prospect set before them; that those who have partly disentangled themselves from the spiritual thralldom in which they have been held, will make a vigorous effort to burst all their bonds; that ecclesiastical councils will be less prized by all denominations of Christians for the settlement of doctrinal differences and church irregularities, and will be encouraged so far only as they contribute to the fraternal interchange of thought and affection; and finally, that prayer will be made without ceasing, that this movement on the part of the church of Rome may so serve to bring it to the light, that its deeds may be made manifest that they are not of God, and that all may look to him alone who is the Light of the World, and the Life of Men.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate