A Few Times of Pulpit History — By Edward Leach
"WHAT is the best way to preach?" asked a London minister of Mr. Binney. The reply was characteristic of the man. "Gather all your materials, and set fire to them in the pulpit." The gathering of the materials, when honestly and zealously done, implies activity of intellect, fertility of resource, ingenuity in adaptation, and perseverance of effort. To set fire to the materials thus gathered, requires an expenditure of enthusiasm only possible to the man who loves his work, and has an intense faith in his message. Given these two canons of pulpit method, and all other questions as to style, system, and delivery, are but of minor consideration. With these, a preacher may be both instructive and powerful—commanding respect for his intellectual acquirements and spiritual acumen; and ensuring the sympathy which sincerity deserves, and an earnest Christian hearer is not loth to give. Without them, he will become either a cold, unimpassioned pulpit essayist, or a slovenly workman who needeth to be ashamed of himself and his low estimate of the requirements of a Christian audience. Religion cannot fail to suffer in the hands of both these classes. Rationalism and scepticism will be the inevitable products of the one; disinterestedness, neglect, and lukewarmness, the consequences of the other.
The history of the pulpit would, if faithfully written, bear out the remarks we have made. It is a pity that some such history has not been given to the world. The materials are abundant; the subject is
32
[THE SWORD AND THE TROWEL. NOV. 1, 1870.
of thrilling interest; and if, as the past has amply proved, the pulpit be the mightiest agency in the world, the story of its influence in the conversion of men and in moulding the thoughts of past generations, would be one of the most useful and stimulating historical sketches ever written. It is this, indeed, which constitutes to practical minds, the only charm of church histories. The lengthy records of heresies with which the faithful have had to contend, are interesting only as affording the intelligent reader an idea of the disposition of men to follow after vain philosophisings, instead of clinging to the simple truths of the divine word. One page enlivened by the story of real work done for Christ, is of more service in exciting to greater faith and courage, than volumes of treatises on the heresies of the past.
Looking over two volumes recently published by Messrs. Hodder and Stoughton of notices of preachers and their sermons, ancient and modern*—a work that ought to be in the hands of every young minister, if it were only that he might study the best models of preaching—one is struck with the rich variety of talent and the charming diversities of style manifested in the great sermons of all ages. No two truly great preachers are exactly alike; there are diversities of gifts, and marked differences of style. It is well to remember that only he can be a great preacher who fulfils the New Testament law of the minister's functions—to warn every man, and to teach every man, "that he may present every man perfect in Christ," and also to "feed the flock of God, over which the Holy Spirit has made him overseer." The sinner must be earnestly entreated; the saint must constantly receive the culture of the preacher's fostering care. Mere essays proving the rationalism of belief, learned disquisitions upon some point of doctrine, elaborate dissertations upon difficult texts, are, if profound, not weighty with heaven's blessing. "We must retrace our steps," writes M. L'Abbé Mullois, chaplain to the Ex-Emperor of the French, "and return to a clear, plain, simple, and vivifying exposition of the gospel; for when religion is set forth in that way it is always attractive. We may have to study much to attain it, but when once Christianity is rightly understood, and we get thoroughly to know those with whom we have to do, we shall find it possible to acquire an influence over their minds and hearts, and easy to adapt our style to the intelligence of all. You should see the working classes when addressed by one of our great preachers; their countenances brighten, their eyes glisten, their bosoms glow. They understand, they are moved, they applaud." "You should start from the known," the same orator observes, "to lead them to the unknown," for that is the method which Christ adopted, and the most successful of his ambassadors have not failed to see that abstractions and speculations never elevated the soul even up to duty, still less to God. The greatest preachers have been the simplest.
It was so from the first. The discourses of the early teachers were homely in style, and free from that laboured reasoning which inevitably produces dullness. Not that they are in all other respects worthy of imitation. They lacked in skilful arrangement of their thoughts, and
* Masterpieces of Pulpit Eloquence, Ancient and Modern, with historical sketches of preaching in the different countries represented, and biographical and critical notices of the several preachers and their discourses. By HENRY C. FISH, D.D.
TROWEL. Nov. 1, 1870.]
A FEW LINES OF PULPIT HISTORY.
491
were frequently discursive. But, according to Mosheim, they "inculcated no other doctrines than those of the Scriptures, and avoided all vain subtleties and mysterious interpretations." "The reading of the Scriptures," says Neander, "was followed, as in the Jewish synagogues, by short and originally very simple addresses, in familiar language, the momentary effusions of the heart, which gave an exposition and application of what had been read." As Justin Martyr observes of the practices of the early Christians, "They incited the people to imitate the good examples they had heard." The fondness of the Greeks for rhetorical display led to the more careful preparation which the Fathers undoubtedly made for the pulpit. Sometimes their discourses were read from manuscript, and preserved for reading in the family. With others, so gifted, their sermons were delivered from memory; but the majority did, as we suppose the majority of ministers do now, preach from a well worked-out outline. The great temptation which affected the Greek preachers was not in the direction of an ambitious style, but of a proud intellect. The desire to unite the prevailing philosophy of the day with religion was sufficiently strong in the Apostolic age to necessitate Paul's admonition to avoid "oppositions of science, falsely so called," and to "beware, lest any man spoiled" the Colossian brethren, "through philosophy and vain deceit." The Greek and Latin preachers were largely infected with this evil, and the theory of a "hidden sense" in the Scriptures, led to the general corruption of religious belief. With the admission of false doctrines, came also (if not necessarily) the prevalence of evil and superstitious practices. The doctrine of justification by faith was beclouded and ultimately denied, and when this was gone, baptismal regeneration and other follies crept in. The preachers were men of culture and refined taste, and were diligent students. A few, however, the victims of superstition, refused to study, alleging that everything must proceed from the Holy Ghost. Against this indolence protests were made, Augustine being foremost in urging religious teachers to supply the means which God had ordained. "Let us not tempt him in whom we have believed," he observed at an ordination service, "in order that we may not be deceived by such cunning delusions of the evil spirit, to err so egregiously that we cannot go into the church to hear or learn the gospel, or that we cannot read the Holy Scriptures or hear other persons read and explain them, and that we should expect to be caught up to the third heavens, and there hear 'unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter,' or to see the Lord Jesus there and to learn the gospel from him rather than from men." But it was mainly the passion for an ornate style of oratory which destroyed the little spiritual power that was left in the pulpit. High-flown passages were pre-composed to secure the loud and boisterous applause of the impressible hearer, and as a consequence sacred eloquence was degraded and Christianity discredited. Chrysostom, whose oratory was unsurpassed, declaimed against these loud plaudits. "Nothing," he says, "becomes a church so much as quiet and order. Such noises belong to theatres, markets, and processions." And in one of his most powerful homilies he wisely observed, "It is the greatest praise, and praise enough, if one wicked man be converted to goodness; if one who heretofore had been negligent becomes, through our exhortations, a
[THE SWORD AND THE TROWELL, NOV. 1, 1870.
zealous Christian. Thus to me will accrue the greatest praise and comfort, and to you the greatest gain and spiritual riches." Tainted, as much of their preaching was with the current philosophy which fascinated most minds, the principles which some of the early Fathers laid down should have delivered them from its snares. Augustine insisted upon the importance of regarding the Scriptures as a divine storehouse. "The duty of the Christian pastor is to open the fountain of Holy Writ to the thirsty flock, and to supply them with its pure water." "The meetings which in the North African Church, as in many other places, were held on Saturdays, Augustine devoted particularly to the study of the Bible; especially because on that day he had more leisure than on Sundays, and the attendance was not so numerous, but consisted only of those who took a deep interest in an acquaintance with the Divine word. So Chrysostom often, in his preaching, broke off in the middle of an important investigation, which he promised to finish on the next occasion, in order that his hearers might have an opportunity, in the meanwhile, of reflecting on the subject, examining the Scripture, and conversing with one another respecting it."* With all this, however, there was much obscurity in some of their minds as to the nature of conversion. One man limited the power of the grace of God to the virtuous—the conversion, he taught, of a viciously-disposed man, was an impossibility. Justin Martyr, nevertheless, could declare, pointing to actual facts, "What shall we say of the numberless multitudes of those who by this doctrine (of the forgiveness of sin) have been converted from a life of unbridled excesses? for not the righteous, nor the moral, does Christ call to repentance, but the ungodly, the immoral, the unrighteous; for our heavenly Father prefers the repentance of sinners to their punishment." Not that the triumphs of the gospel were wrought wholly in the hearts of the immoral: for one of the Greek fathers acknowledges that "we can point out more of those who were converted from a life not altogether bad, than of those who were addicted to gross sins." This indisposition to believe in the conversion of the grossly immoral, was not peculiar to the earliest period of the church's history. Even in the present day, when missionary efforts among the degraded are, happily, more numerous than in past days of inaction, not a few professing Christians smile incredulously when they hear of profligates becoming chaste followers of the Lamb of God, and social outcasts sitting at the feet of Jesus "clothed and in their right mind."
Shorn of its energy, and unclothed with the beauty of that simplicity which is the charm of the gospel, the preaching of succeeding centuries, and during the middle ages, was powerless in winning souls to Christ. The union of church and state was the curse of the church, as it must ever be; and men of voluptuous tastes, loving position, influence, and the world, with sufficient genius to prevent their becoming imbecile dolts, and with insufficient to raise them into usefulness, sought the ministry, and succeeded in lowering its standard of excellence, and crushing its life and power. Here and there, doubtless, some honest labourer worked for his Master with the purest aim, and brought
* Neander's Memorials of Christian Life, p. 210. (Bohns.)
TROWELL. Nov. 1, 1870.
A FEW LINES OF PULPIT HISTORY.
493
trophies, obscure enough to the world, but exalted in the Saviour's
esteem, to his Lord. But history points to no bright gleam of sunshine
that lit up the prevailing darkness, and it is not until we get to
the age of the sturdy Wycliffe, that the cloud seems to pass from
off the pulpit. The power of the Papacy had crushed all life
out of religious services, and it was not until men began to seek the
debasement of the Pope, that the ministry assumed some of its
rightful dignity. Wycliffe was an undaunted opponent of the Papal
infallibility—that huge lie which the Romish church has so recently
gulped down. Lollardism brought back again to England the power of
the pulpit. The preaching friars brought in at least what quaint Fuller
terms "twilight religion." We need not refer at any length to the
position which the sermon acquired in the Reformation days. The
Reformers knew wherein their strength lay, and nobly did they exercise
the gifts with which they had been entrusted. Wycliffe's sermons, it
should be remarked, are peculiar for the contrast which they afford to
the lengthy discourses of post-reformation days. His style was purely
expository and practical. Having taken his text, he would expound its
various parts with brevity, and conclude with a pointed application.
As for honest Hugh Latimer, who does not know his vivacious, bluff
style? Such homely, incisive words as were his, sank deeply into the
memories of the people, and produced a power which was potent for good
in the hearts of those who received them, and not less potent for
mischief in those who, as Becon amusingly put it, "though swelling,
blown full, and puffed up, like Æsop's frog, with envy and malice against
him," were compelled to confess their admiration of his undoubted, if
not unequalled powers. What was the measure of the influence of such
men in the conversion of souls may be guessed from the numbers of
adherents to their doctrines, and the intense dislike they evinced to
the organised system of lies and impostures with which they had been
deceived. And, indeed, such a magnificent peroration as that of Bishop
Jewell's—the Bishop had occupied the chair of rhetoric in Oxford
University—in his discourse against the popish doctrine of Transub-
stantiation, must have stirred up the indignation of the people who were
fortunate enough to hear it. This famous sermon is known as the
"challenge sermon," and very appropriately has it been placed in the
two volumes of "Masterpieces of Pulpit Eloquence," we have already
commended to the notice of our readers. The poet Dr. Donne, too, was
a masterly and winsome orator, "carrying," it used to be said, "some
to heaven in holy raptures, and enticing others by a sacred art and per-
suasiveness to amend their lives." His sermons are full of genius, and
alas! (saith one poor Saxon) too full of Latin—the custom of the
age. Here is a worthy extract:—"As, therefore, it is not enough for
us, in our profession, to tell you, 'Except you believe all this,
you will be damned,' without we execute that commission before, 'Go
and preach,' work upon their affections, satisfy their reason; so it is
not enough for you to rest in an imaginary faith and easiness in believing
except you know also what and why, and how you come to that belief.
Implicit believers, ignorant believers, the adversary may swallow; but
the understanding believer, he must chew and pick bones before he come
to assimilate him and make him like himself. The implicit believer
[THE SWORD AND THE TROWELL, NOV. 1, 1870.
stands in an open field, and the enemy will ride over him easily; the understanding believer is in a fenced town, and he hath outworks to lose before the town be pressed; that is, reasons to be answered before his faith be shaken, and he will sell himself dear and lose himself by inches, if he be sold or lost at last; and, therefore, sciant omnes, let all men know, that is, endeavour to inform themselves—to understand."
The Christian church has not yet fully valued, though it may highly prize, as they fully deserve, the sermons of the Puritans. Bright as may have been many of the discourses of the Anglican pulpit, and worthy of attentive study, the Puritans carry off the palm for that luxuriance of spirituality, that masterly breadth of thought, and that extraordinary knowledge of the Scriptures, for which their names should be held in everlasting esteem. What their preaching was, we gather accurately from their writings. They created what Dr. Bushnell has called an atmosphere of their own—"a mysterious efflux, exhalation, or aerial development of personality." There was an aroma of holiness about their lives, the accent of conviction on their lips. They not only raised the character of the pulpit for spirituality, but raised the devotion of its occupants. Nothing can be more evident than that he who has an imperfect idea of excellence will fall short of success in his mission. Fortune has no generous gifts for the indolent and irresolute; it has but few favours for those who are contented with a mean platform in life. The Puritans set before them a noble standard of ministerial attainment, and were pertinacious in gaining it. Hence, their learning was great, their reading vast, their mental training remarkable. To have been, as they were, "mighty in the Scriptures," in the originals, and close and compact reasoners, able to defend with profound erudition disputed truths, and at the same time to preach with winning power and simplicity of purpose the way of salvation, they must have laboured with a perseverance almost incredible. And their influence was prodigious. Men of culture felt it; men of godliness were swayed by it; the "common people" were arrested by it, and won to the truths which they laboured so indefatigably to disseminate. "The Puritan preaching," remarks Dr. M'Cosh, "is unsurpassed for clear enunciation of divine truth, accompanied with close searching, and fervent appeal, which now shakes the whole soul, as the earthquake did the prison at Philippi, and anon relieves it by the command and promise, 'Believe in the Lord Jesus Christ, and thou shalt be saved.'" Some of their best passages are "more fitted than any composed by uninspired men to awaken the unthinking and arouse the careless, and compel them to think of the things which belong to their everlasting peace. . . . The preachers who have caught the spirit of the Puritans, but have avoided their technicality and mannerism, have commonly been the most successful in rousing the sunken and the dead from their apathy, and in stirring them to anxiety and prayer."*
The dark age which followed the Puritans and preceded the revival of religion under the ministrations of Whitefield and Wesley was dark indeed. The State clergy were, if moral, Socinians, and if immoral,
* Charnock's Works, Vol. I. Nichol's Ed.
THE SWORD AND THE TROWELL. NOV. 1, 1870.] A FEW LINES OF PULPIT HISTORY.
495
persecutors of the few who preached Jesus Christ. The Dissenting ministers were touched with the same heretical blight; and the pulpit, therefore, showed signs of decay and dissolution. Whitefield and Wesley were sent of God to arouse such zeal in the churches and interest in evangelical truth that all England seemed to catch the flame that had been "kindled by a spark of grace." Pulpits were at once closed against them, but, undaunted, they made Great Britain their platform, and in churchyards, fields, village greens, and highways, they addressed thousands who were touched to the heart. An Arabian proverb says, "He is the best orator who can turn men's ears into eyes," and this was the peculiar power which Whitefield's preaching had. It is believed that during the thirty-four years of his ministry, he preached publicly eighteen thousand times, and he was literally worn out in his Master's service. His energy of expression, and fervency of spirit, aroused the souls of the most careless. "My dear friends," said he, at the close of one of his most powerful sermons, "I would preach with all my heart till midnight to do you good, till I could preach no more. O that this body might hold out to speak more for my dear Redeemer! Had I a thousand lives, had I a thousand tongues, they should be employed in inviting sinners to come to Jesus Christ. Come, then, let me prevail with some of you to come along with me. Come, poor, lost, undone sinner, come just as you are to Christ. . . . The devil is in you while unconverted; and will you go with the devil in your heart to bed to-night?" Such earnest entreaties, such anxious solicitude for the conversion of souls, was strange to the people. They had been so accustomed to the hum-drum of the essay-style of amplified nothingness, that they were startled to find religion pressed upon them with such passionate ardour. John Wesley's appeals were equally moving, as the reader may judge from the following extract from his sermon on the Great Assize: "See, see! he cometh! He maketh the clouds his chariot. He rideth upon the wings of the wind! A devouring fire goeth before him, and after him a flame burneth! See! he sitteth upon his throne, clothed with light as with a garment, arrayed with majesty and honour! Behold, his eyes are as a flame of fire, his voice as the sound of many waters! How will ye escape? Will ye call on the mountains to fall on you, the rocks to cover you? Alas! the mountains themselves, the rocks, the earth, the heavens, are just ready to flee away! Can ye prevent the sentence? Wherewith? With all the substance of thy house, with thousands of gold and silver? Blind wretch! Thou camest naked from thy mother's womb, and more naked into eternity. Hear the Lord, the Judge, 'Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world.' Joyful sound! How widely different from that voice which echoes through the expanse of heaven, 'Depart, ye cursed, into everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels.' And who is he that can prevent or retard the full execution of either sentence? Vain hope! Lo! hell is moved from beneath to receive those who are ripe for destruction! And the everlasting doors lift up their heads, that the heirs of glory may come in."
The subsequent history of the English pulpit is too well known to need prolonged remark. Robert Hall's imperial gifts won the attention
THE SWORD AND THE
THOWEL. NOV. 1, 1870.
of the more cultured classes, and his felicitous style and complete
mastery of language made him an orator in whom the multitude
delighted. William Jay's native powers of eloquence were remarkable:
Brinsley Sheridan once enthusiastically observed, that Jay was the most
perfectly natural orator he had ever heard. He commenced his ministry
at the early age of sixteen, and before he had attained his twenty-first
year, had preached a thousand times. It is said that "so great was the
enthusiasm excited by his efforts, that in some instances the places of
worship overflowed, and the lingering multitude in the yard would not
disperse till the young speaker had bidden them farewell from the
window." Jay has, undoubtedly, had an important influence upon the
style of young preachers. His method of analysis is so perfectly natural,
his common sense so strong, his scriptural quotations so apt, and his
remarks so well sustained, that, in many respects, he is a model for
study. For one thing he deserves to be honoured: namely, for com-
bining good taste with the use of the purest evangelical phrases. John
Foster's essay on the "Aversion of Men of Taste to Evangelical
Religion," was, in our view, an extreme remedy for a simple fault; but
it did not a little good in ridding the pulpit of some of the whimsical
cant which is abhorrent to every manly soul. The wretched effeminacy
so loathsome among the Plymouth Brethren school—what Mr. Spurgeon
calls, "spiritual billing and cooing"—"sugar of lead"—"fulsome
sugarishness"—"effeminate canting, whining, dearing, and pretended
cestasies of affection,"* can only be eradicated by a strong hand. Jay
was free from such affectations, and raised a hornet's nest about him
by denouncing their use.
Of the pulpit oratory of the present day, we need not now speak, or
of the men whose gifts are second to none of any past age. We
thank God for them, and their work, and are hopeful of the future.
(To be Continued.)
