Reviews
The Student's Handbook of Christian Theology. By the Rev. BENJAMIN FIELD.
Hodder and Stoughton.
WHEREIN this is a handbook of Wesleyan divinity, we need hardly say that we
differ widely from its teachings, and as Wesleyanism flavours the whole work, we
can only recommend it in the matter of theology to those of our readers who are
of the Methodist persuasion. This, however, being premised, we rate the work
very highly, as being scholarly, well-arranged, and carefully executed. Upon
those truths, which are common to all Christians, its testimony is full and sound.
That part of the truth which it specially defends is vigorously contended for, but
in attacks upon the Calvinistic side of truth, statements are made which it would
be hard to prove;—for instance, we think that no one who knows much of his
fellow Christians, would assert that Calvinism has a manifest tendency to destroy
holiness, and tends to destroy our zeal for good works. Those who hold our
views upon the points in debate have been, and are, quite as sedulous to glorify
God by personal holiness as their opponents. To assert the contrary, is to deny
plain facts, and to exhibit the Pharisaic spirit, which cries, "Stand by, for I am
holier than thou." Upon the doctrine of the eternity of future punishment, our
author gives no uncertain sound, and as this is just now becoming a bone of con-
tention, we shall quote him in full, after again remarking that brethren of Armi-
nian views will find this book a most admirable compendium of their opinions:—
"It is argued that immortality was not one of the original attributes of human nature, but
is secured for us through the atonement of Christ. All, therefore, who fail to accept the
blessings of that atonement finally perish in annihilation. And to support this view, the
Scripture terms 'to perish,' 'to be destroyed,' 'to die,' when applied to the future state of the
wicked, are interpreted as meaning the total extinction of being. It may suffice to reply, that
if there are some texts in which certain words are used, which, taken by themselves, are capable
of such a meaning, there are others, many others, in which both the future existence and the
eternal punishment of the wicked are most plainly declared. And while the death, loss,
destruction, and perishing of the soul are quite susceptible of a meaning in harmony with
[THE SWORD AND THE
THORNE. MAR. 1, 1870.
eternal existence in torment, the latter cannot possibly be made to bear a meaning in harmony with the future annihilation of being." . . .
"THE TERMS EMPLOYED TO DESCRIBE FUTURE PUNISHMENT, WHEN HONESTLY INTERPRETED,
CAN SIGNIFY NOTHING SHORT OF PROPER ETERNITY.
"First, we have the word aiōnag, (aiōnios,) which strictly and properly signifies eternal,
ever existent, and, throughout the New Testament, is applied indiscriminately to the duration of future was as well as of future blessedness. Thus we have 'everlasting fire' (Matt. xviii. 8, xxv. 41); 'everlasting punishment' (Matt. xxv. 46); 'everlasting destruction' (2 Thess. i. 9); 'eternal damnation' (Mark iii. 29); 'eternal fire' (Jude 7); 'everlasting life' (Matt. xix. 29; John iii. 16); 'eternal life' (Luke x. 25; John iii. 15); 'everlasting habitations' (Luke xvi. 9); 'eternal in the heavens' (2 Cor. v. 1); and many other instances. Now, surely, it is natural and fair to understand the term, in each occurrence of it, as having the same extent of meaning; and far from fair to take it as meaning strict and proper eternity when applied to heaven, and as meaning only an indefinite period of time when applied to hell. Besides, in one passage (Matt. xxv. 46), there is an evident and pointed antithesis between life and punishment, and of both it is affirmed that they are everlasting, the same Greek word being used in both cases, though improperly varied by our translators. Ought not this one passage to be enough to decide the point? Who that heard the 'Faithful Witness' use one word on both sides of the alternative could hesitate about his meaning by it the same thing?
"Secondly, we have the words εἰς τὸν aiōnag, 'for ever,' applied to future punishment; 'the mist of darkness is reserved for ever' (2 Pet. ii. 17); 'the blackness of darkness for ever' (Jude 13). And that this signifies nothing less than eternal duration is evident from the use of the same term in other places: 'Christ abideth for ever' (John xii. 34); 'God blessed for ever' (Rom. ix. 5); 'his righteousness remaineth for ever' (2 Cor. ix. 9); 'shall live for ever.' (John vi. 58.)
"Thirdly, we have the phrase, εἰς τοὺς aiōnag τῶν aiōnos, which is generally translated 'for ever and ever,' and might perhaps, be rendered, 'through the durations of durations.' This form of speech is very intelligible, and may be properly called the superlative. What is 'the holy of holies' but the most holy? 'or the heaven of heavens,' but the highest heaven? And what are 'the durations of durations' but that duration which is the greatest of all—that is, proper eternity? 'The smoke of their torment ascendeth up for ever and ever' (Rev. xiv. 11, xix. 3); 'tormented day and night for ever and ever' (Rev. xx. 10.) Nothing can be more evident than that this is used to indicate an unlimited duration; for it is employed: (1.) To point out the eternity of the Most High. (Rev. iv. 9, 10, v. 14, x. 6, xv. 7.) (2.) To indicate the everlasting praise which shall be rendered to him. (Rev. v. 15, vii. 12.) (3.) To mark the endless duration of his government. (Rom. xi. 15.) (4.) To describe the endless duration of the blessedness of the righteous. (Rev. xxii. 5.) And it is for Socicians to show where the apostles have used this phrase in a sense manifestly limited."
The Shepherd of Israel; or, Illustrations of the Inner Life. By Rev. DUNCAN MACGREGOR, M.A., Minister of St. Peter's, Dundee. Nisbet and Co.
THE first title does not indicate the nature of the work, but the second is accurate. We have here a series of soul-winning sermons worthy of McCheyne. The illustrations and anecdotes are abundant; the scriptural expositions are clear, and the spirit of every discourse earnest and affectionate. The book is saturated with the gospel, and cannot, with God's blessing, fail of its purpose of saving sinners, a purpose which is apparent on almost every page. Happy is Dundee to have such a preacher. O si sic omnes.
Shiloh. By Rev. DANZY SHEEN. London: G. Lamb, Sutton Street, Commercial Road.
MR. SHEEN, a Primitive Methodist Minister of great repute and usefulness,
was one of the alumni of our college, and we take great delight in his prosperity and growing talent. He has in this instance produced a very tasteful little work, which may be had in neat cloth for one shilling and sixpence, or in very elegant binding for two shillings. The matter is spiritual and edifying, the style pleasing and flowing. An abundance of well chosen poetical extracts adorns the volume, and we entertain great confidence that its circulation will be extensive, and will do much good.
Until the Shadows Flee away; a True Tale of the Last Century. Oliphant and Co., Edinburgh.
A STRANGE tale, if true, affording clear evidence that in the last century the world had foolish heads and mad spirits in it. We like the description of some of the personages, and the style is fresh and vigorous.
TROWEL, MAR. 1, 1870.
REVIEWS.
139
Scenes in the East. By the Rev. H. B.
TRISTRAM, M.A., LL.D., F.R.S. So-
ciety for Promoting Christian Know-
ledge, 7, Great Queen Street, Lincoln's
Inn Fields.
TWELVE coloured photographic views of
places mentioned in the Bible, with de-
scriptive letter-press, making, with its
gorgeous binding and bold type, a
splendid book for a present, fit for a
palace. The scenes are admirable, and
the descriptions not less so. It is in
every way a first-class work.
The Joy of Suffering. A Sermon. By
HENRY SIMON. H. K. Lewis, 136,
Gower Street.
WE have suffered, and can testify that
there is a point where suffering and
pain are the vestibule of bliss. When
they bring men as near to Jesus as they
have carried us, they are not angels in
disguise, but seraphs all unveiled. This
sermon will help a little way to the un-
derstanding of what we mean; but after
all, the furnace is the only place for
learning this lesson.
A Book for Grandchildren. By GRAND-
FATHER (Felix Friendly). Nisbet &
Co., Berners Street.
A VERY good little book for the young-
sters, with much of interest; and no
foolish stories such as some juvenile
books are filled with. We are glad to
welcome it for its fresh and earnest
spirit.
The Literary World, weekly, one penny.
James Clarke & Co.
HERE we have masses of what Dr.
Hamilton was wont to call Bibline, or
the essence of books. Readers with
large means will find this journal a judi-
cious guide to purchases, and readers
with small means will find it an admir-
able substitute for a library. It is little
less than literary prodigality to issue
such a serial for one penny: it is not
selling brains, but giving them away.
We only regret that every now and
then we think we see traces of a latitu-
dinarian spirit with which we have no
sympathy.
Pastoral Addresses. By JOHN HORS-
BURGH. John Bayne, Lever Street,
Edinburgh.
THE highly esteemed author of these
addresses was pastor of the original
Baptist church in Edinburgh. We have
perused the addresses and the accom-
panying memoir with much pleasure.
We are glad to have so profitable a me-
morial of one who as an apostle wrought
with his hand and preached the Word.
Those who knew Mr. Horsburgh best,
valued him most. Skillful in his profession
and faithful in his preaching, he will be
greatly missed in each circle.
Alone in London. By the Author of
"Jessica's First Prayer." Religious
Tract Society.
A VERY useful and charming little book,
quite worthy of the established reputa-
tion of the authoress. The drift of the
tale is to commend hospitals for children,
a scheme to which we wish abundant
success. The story is charming for its
pathos and truth, and the moral of it is
beyond all praise. We would gladly
welcome more such bijou books from
the same pen.
Harrison's Original Sacred Melodies,
Hymns, Chants, Anthems. Frederic
Warne & Co., Bedford Street, Co-
vent Garden.
VERY fair music, and such as have taste
in that direction will be glad to hear of
any addition to our sacred psalmody.
We question if any of these composi-
tions will be immortal or widely popular,
but they will be of service and are quite
worth the notice of our musical readers.
Four years in a Cave. A Tale of the
French Revolution. Wm. Oliphant
and Co., Edinburgh.
A VERY interesting, though improbable,
story of the times of terror in France,
during the Revolution. The little book
is well-written and neatly bound, so as
to make a suitable present for little
maidens, who will, we hope, imitate all
that is good in the conduct of the
heroines of the tale, and be thankful
that we are living in better days.
Bible Wonders. By the Rev. RICHARD
NEWTON, D.D. S. W. Partridge &
Co., 9, Paternoster Row.
A VERY capital, interesting, and in-
structive book for the youngsters.
Plenty of little pictures, anecdotes, and
illustrations. Suitable for a Sunday-
school library.
[THE SWORD AND THE TROWEL. MAR. 1, 1870.
Commentary on the Holy Scriptures; Critical, Doctrinal, and Homiletical. By JOHN PETER LANGE, D.D. Translated by PHILIP SCHAFF, D.D. Vol. V. T. & T. Clarke, Edinburgh.
WE have never seen a critical commentary more to our mind than this one on the Epistle to the Romans. It is certainly worthy of a place in the library of every Bible-student. It will be especially useful to scholars acquainted not only with the ancient, but the modern languages; especially with the German, in which many of the best and most forcible terms are expressed. Ministers and students will find no little assistance in the doctrinal and homiletical portion. The latter, generally good, has rather startled us more than once by a daring departure from the scriptural thought and teaching of the text; for instance, on the first verse of the first chapter where the apostle speaks of being "called to be an apostle, separated unto the gospel of God," we are to sermonise thus—The necessity of a divine call for the ministry. I. The inner call by the Holy Ghost. II. The outward call by the authority and ordination of the church. The regularly called minister contrasted with the self-constituted minister and fanatic, SET APART UNTO THE GOSPEL. The Preaching of the Gospel. I. The chief duty of the minister, to which all others must be subordinated. II. The highest work in which Christ himself and all the apostles engaged. III. The inconsistency of connecting any secular calling with the holy ministry." As we read this we could not help remembering the apostle's declaration, which he made to the church at Galatia, that he received not the gospel from man, that he conferred not with flesh and blood, that he went not up to Jerusalem to them that were apostles before him, that he only saw two apostles when years after he tarried with Peter fifteen days, and that he was unknown by face unto the churches of Judæa. All of this was mentioned with the evident intention to disclaim the human element in his ministry and assert the divine. We want no other call than God's Spirit to the work; and as to human ordination, it is a relict of the Popish dogma of apostolic succession; and these are not the times to treasure
up rags of priestcraft as if they were robes of office in Christ's church. Of course, for special work of any sort, the church's voice is supreme as to its own order and work, but our authority is from above; our opportunity of exercising it is regulated by the church in her own borders, but outside we owe no allegiance to any but our Lord; and shall, as God helps us, "do good unto all men," for the world is our parish if we be true ministers of Jesus Christ. If this is to be a "self-constituted minister" and "a fanatic," to God be all praise; while we rejoice in the dignity of being thus like unto Paul.
Nor were we less surprised to mark the third division of the second homily, "The inconsistency of connecting any secular calling with the holy ministry." We had always regarded the apostle as being a tent-weaver, ministering with his own hands to his necessities and the necessities of those that were with him. We had dwelling in our minds remembrances of apostles fishing and of our Lord's helping them by his all-wise directions, and in our ignorance we had discovered no "inconsistency" with the public ministry of him who washed disciples' feet and "came not to be ministered unto but to minister." Away once and for ever from our midst with the notion that ministers should be a clique of non-workers, whose priestly dignity would suffer if they endured a day's toil. Thank God we have some men who to serve him work hard all the week and preach on the Lord's-day, and they are as consistent ministers as those of us who can, by the liberality and gifts of our churches, give all our time to the direct ministry of the word. The ordination of a D.D. we have no doubt needs the help of man, as we have not found it yet in the Bible; and we can conceive that anything so undignified as gathering up sticks for a fire, or casting out the lading of a ship, would be "inconsistent" with such eminence.
The Borderer's Leap, and other Poems. By JOHN GEORGE SPEED. Elliot Stock, Paternoster Row.
A MIXTURE of Byron and rubbish: bad theology, and worse poetry.
TROWEL. MAR. 1, 1870.
MEMORANDA.
141
The Prophecies of our Lord and his
Apostles. By W. HOFFMAN, D.D.
Berlin. Translated by MAURICE J.
EVANS, B.A. London: Hodder and
Stoughton, Paternoster-row.
A MOST painstaking, devout, and schol-
ary examination of the future of the
world and the church, as indicated by
the Lord himself, or his apostles. The
German style of thought, though well
rendered into our language, will make
the reading a little heavy to some, but
for such as wish to have a careful treatise
on the times to come, we can heartily
commend this book for its solid worth,
and earnest seeking after the mind of
the Spirit. Without endorsing every
conclusion of the preacher, whose dis-
courses are here translated, we agree
with so much that we sincerely wish the
book "God speed."
Christ and his Work; an Exposition of
Psalm XL. By JAMES FRAME.
Snow and Co., Ivy Lane.
WE are glad to meet with Mr. Frame
again as a writer on a chosen Psalm.
His remarks are always thoughtful and
edifying. He adopts a theory and works
the text into it; sometimes, as we think,
with rather too severe a turn of the
screw, but even then we are interested
by his ingenuity. Mr. Frame serves
his generation well by addicting himself
to such expositions. We are personally
obliged to him for this volume and for
his comment on Psalm xvi., from which
we have quoted in our Treasury of David.
Heavenly Love and Earthly Echoes.
By a Glasgow Merchant. Edmostou
and Douglas, Edinburgh.
A FAMILIARLY written and interesting
little book, with no pretentions to depth
of thought, but very readable from its
many practical illustrations and anec-
dotes. Earthly relationships in our
families supply the main course of
thought, and lead up our minds to the
higher fellowships of heaven. We
commend the spirit of the book most
highly, and think it will do good. Would
that all our merchants had found "the
pearl of price unknown," as has the
author of this work.
