Menu
‹ Chapter 58 of 203 ›

Future Punishment — By The Rev. G. Rogers

32 min read · Chapter 58 of 203
Future Punishment — By The Rev. G. Rogers

A LECTURE DELIVERED TO THE STUDENTS OF THE METROPOLITAN TABERNACLE COLLEGE, IN REPLY TO A SERIES OF LETTERS IN "THE CHRISTIAN WORLD," FROM THE REV. EDWARD WHITE.

[A series of letters in opposition to the generally received opinion upon the subject of Future Punishment, having recently appeared in "The Christian World," the author of the following lecture requested permission to insert letters in reply, provided no one else had been accepted for that purpose. Communications with this particular view having been declined, they were embodied in the present form, and delivered to the students of the Metropolitan Tabernacle College; and are now published with some hope that they may serve to guard others against one of the prevailing errors of the present times. The name of Mr. White has been unavoidably introduced; but it has been solely as the representative of a particular theory, and as its principal advocate. While some have the courage to oppose, others should not be wanting in courage to "contend for the faith which was once delivered unto the saints."]

MY object here is not so much to advocate the eternity of future punishment as to oppose the theory which Mr. White endeavours to substitute in its place. The subject is one which is not to be regarded with indifference. Truth in all things should be our first aim, and especially in the things of God. Mr. White evidently considers it to be important to have clear and correct views upon this subject, and is without doubt conscientious in his efforts to rectify the prevailing opinions respecting it. He owns that "the endless misery of unregenerate men would be a paramount truth of revelation." Such it has generally been considered to be, and that conviction has had its influence upon nearly all other doctrines of revelation. It has had its effect upon our views of the character of the Divine Being, upon the first principles of his moral government, upon the fall of man, and upon all the distinguishing peculiarities of redemption by Christ. We look for harmony in the scheme of redemption as well as in all the other works of God. We expect its parts to be well balanced and adjusted, that no one doctrine should be out of proportion with the rest, and that there should be no violation of the love of order and symmetry implanted in the human mind. Our views, therefore, of any paramount truth of revelation must affect our views of the whole. According, for instance, to our estimate of the person of Christ, will be our estimate of the character of his mission. The two main subjects of revelation are ruin and recovery; which must be supposed to

[THE SWORD AND THE

[TROWEL. APR. 1, 1879.

be in proportion to each other. The recovery must be measured by the ruin,

and the ruin by the recovery. Whether the measurement be taken from the

top of a mountain to its base, or from the base to its summit, the distance will

be the same. Diminish the depth and you diminish the height. In this way

our views of future punishment must influence our estimate of the grace of

God in redemption, and of the dimensions of the whole work. The same measur-

ing rod must be applied to the whole temple of truth. If the desert of sin be

endless misery, the pardon and the whole means of pardon must be measured

by the same rule; if it be temporary only, the shorter rule must be applied on

both sides. Reduce the scale for a part, and it must be reduced for the whole.

On this account it is of immense importance that we should have correct ideas

of the extent of future punishment, and give to it our most serious and careful

consideration.

The eternity of the future condition of the wicked has been the fixed and all

but universal belief of the New Testament Christian church from the first day

until now. Attempts have occasionally been made to disturb that belief; but

far less than upon most other paramount truths of revelation, and their force

has soon been spent and their influence forgotten. There are few errors for

which some authority might not be found in some one or other of the ancient

fathers; which however has no weight so long as there is a whole cloud of

witnesses on the other side. If the question is to be decided by the testimony

of Biblical critics and learned divines, we have no fear for the result. There

have been men, such as Turretin, Owen, Jonathan Edwards, and a host of others,

whose acquirements, to say the least, have been as great as those by whom

their convictions on this subject have been assailed. Nor have we any greater

advantages for investigating this subject than our forefathers; since no new

discoveries have been made upon the nature of man or the principles of divine

government. None of that sensational recoil from the possibility of endless

misery which has been avowed by some in our day interfered with their plain

and honest interpretation of the Scriptures; nor did they feel that such a doc-

trine was out of proportion with the fundamental principles of the gospel, but

in perfect harmony with them.

The prevalent opinion has included the one idea of eternal punishment. To

this all descriptions of the future condition of the wicked have been referred,

such as perishing, being destroyed, tormented, cast into a lake of fire, and the

second death; much as the future condition of the righteous, though spoken of

as a rest, an inheritance, a kingdom, a city, and eternal life, is included in the one

idea of endless bliss. The latter remains unassailed. The dispute is solely con-

cerning the former. What have we in its place? With some, immediate annihila-

tion at death; with others, temporary suffering succeeded by eternal happiness;

with others, temporary suffering followed by annihilation. This last is the

theory adopted by Mr. White, and which he undertakes to substantiate and

defend. Punishment and annihilation are the two ideas for which he contends;

the punishment varying both in degree and duration according to guilt, and

the annihilation of necessity the same in all. These two things are one only

when viewed in opposition to what the reward of a holy life would have been.

They are not one thing positively to be included in one term, whether that term

be perishing, or destroyed, or any other; except the two things had first been

separately affirmed, and then designedly expressed by one term. Suppose Mr.

White to have proved that some of the words for future punishment signify

temporary suffering and some annihilation, he has not even attempted to prove

that any one word contains fully his two ideas. We should have had the

terms, which he has claimed as exponents of his particular views, assigned to

their several parts, and his theory shown to be the result of the whole. Instead

of this, we are left without the clear testimony of Scripture upon his own com-

pound idea; and can safely affirm that it is not more clearly contained in the

words he has criticised than the one idea of our own.

I. Mr. White maintains that the soul of man is not necessarily immortal

TROWEL, APR. 1, 1870.

FUTURE PUNISHMENT.

177

He admits it to be capable of immortality, because he holds this to be the fruit of the mediation of Christ on its behalf. If made, therefore, for all it is capable of, the soul of man was made for immortality. It was doubtless made so at first, and what it lost by sin in this respect, it is supposed by Mr. White to have regained in Christ. Immortality he maintains is a gift to the soul depending upon its own conduct; and is not therefore essential to man, but an accidental property. Its immortality in fact is not within itself, but ab extra, and the soul is always in itself mortal. If a principle of immortality could afterwards be given, it might be given at its creation. It is not impossible for God to create souls so far like himself as to be necessarily immortal. "What he makes he can unmake," is no hindrance to his making what in its very nature or by his own decree he cannot unmake. The new life in the believer is a principle of this kind.

"So far as the argument from Immaterialism is concerned," we are told, "it is equally good for coral insects as for mankind." It is intended by this to suggest that the one is naturally in itself as mortal as the other, we demur to the statement: since the one is capable of development and desires for immortality which could not be predicated of the other. "The intellectual and moral arguments," it is added, "for a survival of men's souls in death are somewhat stronger, but they are full of uncertainty in the face of physical facts." They are stronger than the arguments from physical facts, and yet they are rendered uncertain by them, as though the stronger were subject to the weaker; and no evidence whatever has been adduced to show that the soul cannot in itself be immortal. Intellectually the soul is capable of continuing for ever. There are no signs of a termination of its natural growth. The more it knows the more it is capable of knowing, and the more it desires to know. As a moral agent the stamp of immortality is still more indelibly impressed upon man. The law under which he is placed demands a perfect and unending obedience. These demands are not lessened by transgression. The law still retains its hold. Sufferings are no equivalent for obedience when involuntarily endured; and annihilation is no punishment to the tormented, but a reward. If the wicked acquiesce in their sufferings, they can scarcely be said to suffer in spirit; and if they continue to rebel and blaspheme the God of heaven, the reason for the continuance of their torments would continually increase. If an eternity of misery be supposed to be contrary to both the justice and the mercy of God, much more may this be affirmed of temporary punishment and subsequent annihilation. Admit the immortality of the human race to have been essential, either by necessity or decree, at its first origin, that eternity was a foregone conclusion before man had done good or evil, and that the consequences on either side must be eternal, and the eternity of punishment becomes inevitable. Admit that immortality was a gift which God could recall, then he holds creatures in existence solely to torment them. In the one case, the immortality was given for bliss which they have perverted to suffering; in the other, God continues them in being that he may take vengeance upon them before he annihilates them.

II. The rule of interpretation which Mr. White has laid down for his guidance in endeavouring to ascertain the teaching of Scripture upon this subject is—that "the meaning which comes out from the literal sense of the main current of expressions employed in the document shall always be taken as the ruling sense." It might be supposed from this that the compound idea of suffering and annihilation was the one ruling sense of the main current of expressions employed in Scripture upon this subject, and upon that the whole controversy would turn; and yet no single expression is shown necessarily to contain this compound idea. Death for instance may be without suffering; and perishing or being destroyed denotes gradual, rather than instant, annihilation at the termination of great suffering. The rule of interpretation itself as here stated is ambiguous. If it means the literal sense of the current of expressions as they are found in the Scriptures, there can be no objection to the rule; but if it means the literal sense of the current of expressions, as they are found elsewhere, a very different law is laid down. In the one case words are to be interpreted

12

[THE SWORD AND THE

THOWEL, APR. 1, 1870.

according to the ancient classics, and in the other according to Scripture use. To understand the meaning in which an author uses any word we look for the meaning he has given it elsewhere. The meaning of Scripture words is best ascertained in the same way. The literal sense of a Greek word may not be its ruling sense in the Scriptures. Who would presume to make the literal sense of the Greek words for faith and regeneration and sanctification and church, and heaven, the ruling sense in Scripture, and confine our ideas to it? And yet the same rule would apply here, and in all other instances as much as to words denoting future punishment. Mr. White knows well enough that the Greek of the New Testament is not derived from the classics, but from its colloquial use by men of very different notions and pursuits. It has been adopted in the New Testament for a use wholly foreign to its original formation. The literal sense in the one, therefore, is not to be the ruling sense in the other. The Scripture sense may generally be gathered from the literal; but it is not to be ruled and much less limited by it. All Scripture must be interpreted according to the analogy of faith, and not according to the analogy of Greek usage. It is here that Mr. White runs off the line. He makes the literal sense of Greek words the ruling sense of Scripture, to which occasional passages that will not yield of themselves must be subjugated by force. His rule of interpretation has evidently been framed to suit his own purpose, and shows the precise point at which modern theology is deemed by many to have gone far astray.

III. Let us examine the words of Scripture which are said to "require us to believe that the wicked will die, perish, be destroyed, in the literal sense of those words." The first of these is death. The literal sense of this word is manifest to all, and its literal meaning must ever have been the same. Its consequences may be differently viewed, but the fact to all men is the same. It means separation of the two principal parts of men's being; but it does not necessarily mean either suffering or annihilation. Whatever opinions may be formed of the state of man immediately after death, are apart from the literal meaning, since the word for death, in nearly all languages, has reference to its present aspect only. It teaches nothing of the future. We must learn its meaning in Scripture from Scripture. It was threatened to man in Paradise as the punishment of disobedience. "This curse," says Mr. White, "we take in its most obvious sense of extinction of life." He says "it is the only sense which could have occurred to Adam as he might have seen insects, birds, and other animals die." We can hardly suppose Adam to have witnessed the death of animals before he had received a law for his guidance, or if he had, that he would suppose death to him would have been precisely the same thing as to them. So far as the extinction of natural life was concerned it might be the same; and yet hardly so, if the human body is to be raised again. If, moreover, death signifies the extinction of the life of the body, it does not prove that it signifies the same thing when applied to the soul, unless it can be shown that their natures are the same. Besides, even upon Mr. White's theory the parallel between the death of animals and of men is not sustained. Death to the one is the immediate extinction of life; death to the other is prolonged misery prior to the extinction of being. If the death threatened to Adam meant extinction of life, his existence would have terminated on the day of his transgression, according to the instructions he had received, "In the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die." This has usually been interpreted according to its actual fulfilment, to mean the loss of the Divine favour, and the sentence of natural death upon himself and his whole posterity. The former is known throughout the Scriptures as the death of the soul." "You hath he quickened who were dead in trespasses and sins." "Thou hast a name that thou livest, and art dead." It is this spiritual life that was lost in Adam and is restored by Christ. It is life in Christ; he is our life; it is a life which we live by faith in him; and because he lives we shall live also. Instead of this we are now required to look upon death and life in this connection as non-existence and immortality, as physical results chiefly if not entirely. But what are existence and non-existence abstractedly considered?

TROWEL. APR. 1, 1870.

FUTURE PUNISHMENT.

179

Immortality in itself is neither good nor evil. Left to itself it would be an evil. Life in God, not from God, is the real life of man. It is a life of immortality dependent for the whole benefits and blessing of that immortality upon God; the loss of whose favour is its punishment, and the enjoyment of which is its reward. An immortality of holiness and bliss we take to be the immortality forfeited by Adam and regained by Christ. The subject of which these two things are predicated is the character of the immortality and not the immortality itself; and the contrast is between an immortality of misery and an immortality of bliss. To say that immortality was lost in Adam is to say that he lost what he never had. The title to it might be lost, and that title be restored by Christ; but the title and the immortality are not the same thing. Nor could Christ be our immortality. Our spiritual life may come from union with him, but our immortality must be entirely within ourselves. There is no escape from this and a thousand other difficulties, but in the admission of the natural and original immortality of the soul. Even those to whom immortality is said to be given in Christ are said to have died as well as others, as "the dead in Christ," and "Abraham is dead and the prophets," and even Christ himself died. Does death here mean extinction of life, as in animals? Much has been made of the second death as a proof of annihilation; which is in itself contradictory and absurd. If the first death be extinction of life, there can be no second; and if the second be extinction of life, it can be no death in comparison with the first. The second death is that which follows a second resurrection, and is the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone. "Death and hell were cast into the lake of fire. This is the second death." What can be more evident from these words than that the lake of fire is both death and hell! It is not said hell first and then death, but death and hell; and much less that there would be such a change of scene, as would be involved in extinction of being. Nor is this obvious signification affected by the next verse, "And whosoever was not found written in the book of life was cast into the lake of fire," since the life here is obviously opposed to death in the previous verse, and the lake of fire is the same. Again, "shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone: which is the second death." Would we know what the second death really is? It is the lake that burneth with fire and brimstone. No language could be more clear. "Unless born twice, men will die twice," Mr. White informs us; that is, if death be to men the extinction of life, they will be twice born out of nothingness, and twice return to nothingness again. "There will be a mighty difference," he says, "in the doom of those who knew not, and of those who knew their Lord's will." Yet if there be not this mighty difference in the death of animals, death to men and animals cannot be the same. There is not, therefore, according to his own showing, the same law in this respect to animal and to rational beings. "The ignorant good men among the heathen," it is added, "regenerate by the Spirit, but little instructed in truth, will be saved with all the good men who were born of the same Spirit under the full light of revelation." This is surely more than Mr. White knows, unless he has received a special revelation upon the subject. He who confidently affirms that men may be saved without faith in Christ and regenerated without the knowledge of inspired truth, is not much to be trusted as a faithful and judicious expositor of the written word.

A second word upon which the new theory rests is the Greek word olethros, translated in our version destruction, and which is used by Plato to signify extinction. We are not told that it is always used by Plato in this signification, or that it is ever used by him in the particular sense to which Mr. White endeavours to apply it. If it be intended to insinuate that Plato taught the annihilation of the wicked, it can serve only to mislead; since he speaks far more clearly of their everlasting punishment. This, however, is of little or no moment. We are not of Plato, but of Paul. In the second of Thessalonians i. 9, Paul says, "Who shall be punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord, and from the glory of his power." In this word "destruction" Mr. White maintains annihilation to be contained. "Destruction," he

[THE SWORD AND THE

THOWEL. APR. 1, 1870.

says, "means destruction, and nothing else." Very true! but does it mean his idea of destruction, or our own? If destruction means annihilation, why should it be styled everlasting? Annihilation of necessity is final; as the same thing, once annihilated, can never exist again. Of that which has ceased to be, nothing can be predicated; nor of the nothingness that followed any more than of the nothingness that preceded the term of its existence. We ask again, then, whether everlasting annihilation be not unmeaning, contradictory, and absurd? It must either be affirmed of an existing or non-existing being. If of an existing being, he must ever exist, or something everlasting may be predicated of that which is temporary only. If of a non-existing being, something is predicated of nothing. To say that the effect of annihilation is everlasting or eternal is absurd, as it is a negation of all effect of which the affirmation is made. This may seem to be mere sophistry, but we maintain that in everlasting destruction and in everlasting punishment there must be some reality of which the everlasting is affirmed; that annihilation (which to the the wicked is not lasting destruction or punishment), without the addition of the term everlasting, would alone have conveyed its whole meaning; and that the only proper interpretation that can be given to the phraseology employed is everlastingly being punished and destroyed. We observe further of the everlasting destruction in the passage under consideration, that there would have been no need to add "from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his power" if it had been temporary only. That in relation to which it is everlasting destruction is everlasting; and a conscious banishment from it to everlasting is implied.

Let us look now at the term itself that is here used for destruction, and see whether annihilation is necessarily its Scripture meaning. In 1 Thess. v. 3, it is thus used by the same apostle to the same people: "When they shall say, Peace and safety; then sudden destruction cometh upon them, as travail upon a woman with child; and they shall not escape." Destruction is here opposed to peace and safety, and it is that from which there is no escape, annihilation would be a way of escape, and mark the emendation in the reading, "Sudden annihilation cometh upon them, as travail upon a woman with child." For, 1 Cor. v. 5, we read, "To deliver such a one unto Satan for the destruction of the flesh." Whatever the destruction of the flesh may mean here, it cannot be annihilation, unless we suppose that to be in the power of Satan. In 1 Tim. vi. 9 we read, "They that will be rich fall into temptation and a snare, and into many foolish and hurtful lusts, which drown men in destruction and perdition." This would mean drowned first in annihilation, and then in perdition. The apostle explains his own meaning to be, "pierced themselves through with many sorrows." These are all the instances in which the word olethros occurs in the Greek Testament. Is it not marvellous, then, that one who professes to give the ruling sense of Scripture words, and to place no reliance upon their exceptional use, should not find even an exceptional use for his own interpretation of one of his favourite terms?

Upon the Greek word apollumi still greater confidence is placed in support of the annihilation theory. Great authorities are quoted to show that when applied to the living it always signifies to destroy life; that is, of course, annihilation, for it is in defence of this alone that it is adduced. In relation to other objects we are told it has the sense of loss; when applied to men, of annihilation. An instance is given in a literal translation of 1 Cor. xv. 17, 18, "But if Christ has not been raised from the dead your faith is vain, ye are yet in your sins, and as a consequence, those who fell asleep in Christ were annihilated (apolonto)." Let us see how the same apostle uses the same word elsewhere in the same epistle, according to our rule of adopting the sense of words in Scripture writings themselves in preference to their classic usage. In 1 Cor. i. 18 we read "The preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness; but unto us which are saved it is the power of God." This in both instances is a reference to men in this life. The one were then saved and the other were then perishing, but not being annihilated. We have the same word in 2 Cor. iv. 3, "But if our gospel be

TROWEL, APR. 1, 1870.

FUTURE PUNISHMENT.

181

hid, it is hid to them that are annihilated." 1 Cor. viii. 11, "Through thy knowledge shall thy weak brother perish (be annihilated), for whom Christ died?" 1 Cor. x. 9, 10, "Neither let us tempt Christ, as some of them also tempted, and were destroyed (annihilated) of serpents (apolonto). Neither murmur ye, as some of them also murmured, and were destroyed of the destroyer," annihilated, apolonto, by the annihilator. This last word is a derivative of the term previously considered. In Matt. iv. 38, we have the disciples waking their Master in the ship by saying, according to the invariable rendering when applied to the life of man, "Master, carest thou not that we are annihilated?" Matt. x. 6, "Go rather to the lost (the annihilated) sheep of the house of Israel." In Luke xv. 24, the Father, by the new translation is made to say of his restored prodigal, "This my son was dead, and is alive again, was annihilated, and is found." In all these instances we have strictly adhered to the rule of the object of the verb being living men. Whether therefore, in every such instance it has but one meaning, and that meaning is annihilation, judge ye. Supposing even it could be shown to have but the one meaning of annihilation, it says nothing of its being preceded by a long period of suffering, and, therefore, only half answers Mr. White's design. In proof of the immortality of the soul being the result of union to Christ, the well known words in 2 Tim. i. 10 are quoted, "Who hath abolished death, and hath brought life and immortality to light by the gospel." It is in reference to those who are saved by him that he hath abolished death, not death as an extinction of the present life and similar to that of animals, but death beyond this life whatever that may be; and hath brought life, the real life of man, that for which he was originally created, and immortality to light by the gospel. To bring to light immortality implies its prior existence, and to make manifest that which before was obscurely known.

We are next referred to the figures employed as illustrative of future punishment as chaff burned up with unquenchable fire, tares bound up in bundles to be burned, a stone grinding to powder, a tree cut down and cast into the fire. It is admitted that in these cases chaff as chaff is annihilated, and so of the tares and trees; but what evidence is there that this was the point of comparison intended? There was no design surely to teach that men were chaff, and tares, and trees, and that their end would be the same! The end of those substances answers neither to Mr. White's idea of the future condition of the wicked nor our own. These figures are obviously intended to show how easily God can avenge himself of his adversaries.

Upon John xii. 25, "He that loveth his life shall lose it; and he that hateth his life in this world shall keep it unto life eternal," we have this comment, that "The life which a man shall lose hereafter, if he save it on earth by avoiding martyrdom, is that natural life which he sought so to preserve. The life which he shall keep for life eternal is the life which he lost for Christ's sake here. That is his life as a human being." The Greek word here used for life does not necessarily mean natural life. It is used by our Lord, when almost immediately afterwards he says, "How is my soul troubled," and in Acts ii. 27, for "Thou wilt not leave my soul in hell." It is natural life which a man loses by martyrdom, but is it the same life that he gains by that loss? If he lose this life as a human being, how could he keep it unto life eternal? In the corresponding passage in Mark viii. 35, the antithesis is more complete, "Whosoever will save his life shall lose it; but whosoever shall lose his life for my sake and the gospel's, the same shall save it." The Greek word for lost here is that which we have been told always means, when its object is a living man, annihilation. The reading therefore should be, "whosoever shall annihilate his life for my sake and the gospel's, the same shall save it." To suppose life in this instance to be existence merely, is destructive of all gospel meaning and absurd. "He that loveth his existence shall lose it; and he that hateth his existence shall keep it unto existence eternal," is cold, dry, and barren theology. Besides, is it existence that man ought not to love, and existence he ought to hate for Christ's sake? Quite the reverse! The life here is obviously a life of ease and

[THE SWORD AND THE TROWEL. APR 1, 1870.

pleasure; which if made the chief end here, will be lost hereafter; and which if abandoned here for the gospel's sake, will be gained hereafter.

These are the principal texts upon which Mr. White founds his theory of annihilation preceded by a season of protracted suffering; how far they answer that purpose let others judge. They do not in our opinion affirm even the general principle, and much less define and substantiate his own particular scheme.

IV. Let us see now how those texts are dealt with that are considered to be most opposed to this theory.

Here we are again reminded of the many expressions of which we are informed the literal and obvious sense is "that wicked men shall all miserably lose their lives in hell." This phraseology is ambiguous, as it might mean lose their present lives in hell, or the life for which they were created and might have regained in Christ; or lose their lives in hell as the woman lost her piece of silver and found it; or lose their lives in hell by being utterly annihilated in both body and soul. This last we presume to be the meaning here, but it is evident here, and throughout his whole reasoning, that Mr. White has great difficulty in finding words and phrases both in and out of the Scriptures to convey his own particular ideas. He says indeed, "The expressions employed are precisely those which would be chosen if the doctrine here maintained were intended to be taught. There are no other words in which it could be taught." Now we ask whether if in so many words we had been told in Scripture that the punishment of the wicked was not eternal, that a period would come in which those sufferings would cease, that they would be followed by annihilation or utter unconsciousness of pleasure or pain; such sentiments would not have been more clearly taught? We ask for one plain declaration to be produced from the whole Scriptures of annihilation succeeding a long period of suffering to the wicked hereafter; and we ask in vain. What becomes of the assertion then, that "there are no other words in which it could be taught"? Yet the question is concluded to be so plainly and incontrovertibly settled by the expressions that are employed, that all other passages that do not accord with their meaning are to be regarded as exceptional, "not correctly reported by the writers or copyists, but are examples of verbal imperfections." It is a matter for some congratulation that there is no necessity for suggesting such an alternative on the other side.

In dealing with texts in favour of the new theory, and with texts in opposition to it, we find different rules employed by Mr. White. The rule for the interpretation of the former texts was "the literal sense of the main current of expressions," and here repeated as "the plain grammatical sense of the general current of Scripture language." Now that we have come to texts in opposition, the rule is "that each writer in the Bible is best explained by a careful consideration of his own phraseology." This is the rule by which we proceeded in examining the former passages, and which Mr. White proposes to apply specially to the three great texts for everlasting torments. The fallacy or sophistry concealed under this arrangement is, that having, as he supposes, shown from the literal meaning of words and their classic usage, that one class of texts teach annihilation; the other class of texts that could not be dealt with so well upon this rule are to be interpreted on the principle that one part of Scripture is to be explained by another. The opposition texts, in fact, are to be interpreted by those which are deemed favourable, and not the favourable by those which are in opposition. The opposition texts are said to be much fewer, but they will be found, we think, to be far clearer and more decisive. Their testimony is not inferential but direct. It is admitted by Mr. White that, "considered apart from all other Scriptures, they are well fitted to bear the meaning put upon them by those who approach the Bible with a belief in man's natural immortality. Neither do I profess that here or elsewhere the Bible, in its many books, is all that I should have expected it to be." It is evident, therefore, that the Bible is not as a whole so entirely of Mr. White's sentiments as he could wish it to be. There is one remark we wish to make before proceeding to the

TROWELL. APR. 1, 1870.

FUTURE PUNISHMENT.

183

examination of the texts which are acknowledged powerfully to suggest everlasting torments, and that is that supposing such an idea to be derogatory to the justice and goodness of the Creator, why should there have been the least intimation of it in the Scriptures? and why should we not have been cautioned against ever entertaining such a thought? It is not to be supposed that Mr. White is more jealous of God's honour than God himself is. It would, without doubt, have been clearly enough so stated in Scripture if eternal punishment were not true, and certainly we should not have had such declarations upon the subject as we have now to consider.

The first of these is in Matt. xxv. 46: "These shall go away into everlasting punishment: but the righteous into life eternal." The same word is here used in the original, both for everlasting and eternal. The same eternity is affirmed of the punishment of the wicked as of the life of the righteous. They are the words of Christ, and if it were not so, he would have told us. There is no qualification in the one case, as there should have been if the eternities were not the same. If the word for eternal means temporary duration in the one proposition, it does so in the other; if real eternity in the one, it means real eternity in the other. It is in vain to say, "that which is eternal is not always everlasting," and so endeavour to discriminate between everlasting judging and the eternal effect of a judgment, since it would equally apply to the righteous and the wicked. It is in vain to speak of annihilation as part of eternal punishment, since it is no punishment to the tormented, and to speak of punishment extending beyond existence is absurd; and annihilation might just as much be eternal happiness to the righteous as eternal punishment to the wicked. It is in vain, too, to go back to other expressions in Matthew's writings which are supposed to be in opposition to this one. They are chiefly figurative, and amount not altogether to a single proposition like the one before us; and should, therefore, be interpreted by it, and, in fact, are in harmony with it.

The second text is in Mark ix. 44, 46, 48, where the same words occur thrice. "Where their worm dieth not, and the fire is not quenched." Here is something that dieth not, and something that is not quenched, and both spoken of in reference to the punishment of the wicked. Upon the supposition of annihilation after suffering, the "worm," whatever it might be, of the wicked must die, and the fire of their torment be quenched. We do not want to know what meaning such words might have in the writings of Isaiah, but what is the interpretation which Christ put upon them, and the impression they were calculated to produce in the minds of those to whom he addressed them? They are not certainly such words as he would have used if he had not intended to produce in them the fear of everlasting torments. "For every one shall be salted with fire," which immediately follows this declaration, Mr. White says, "perhaps signifies that the dead bodies of the wicked, like that of Lot's wife, will be preserved as an abiding memorial of their awful punishment in hell, but not necessarily for an absolute eternity." This is a comment upon Isaiah, "And they shall go forth and look upon the carcasses of the transgressors." What next? It has the credit at least of keeping to the literal sense.

The remaining of the three principal texts in opposition is in Rev. xiv. 11, "The smoke of their torment ascendeth up for ever and ever." "The terms here used," it is acknowledged, "are those which are often used to signify endless duration." It is also affirmed that they are often used to signify "long but limited duration," and for this we are referred chiefly to the Old Testament. They evidently refer in every instance to the full duration of that to which they are applied. When applied to that which is necessarily limited, as to the Mosaic economy, they could have no other meaning. They signify always duration as far as possible, and as there is no impossibility in the eternal punishment of the wicked, they can have no other signification. The chief question, however, is—how is the same phrase used elsewhere in the same book? We adopt here Mr. White's own rule, "Each writer in the Bible is best explained by a careful consideration of his own phraseology." The same phrase occurs thirteen times in the

[THE SWORD AND THE

TROWEL, APR. 1, 1870.

Book of the Revelation. In the first chapter, "Hath made us kings and priests unto God and his Father; to him be glory and dominion for ever and ever." And again, "I am he that liveth and was dead; and behold I am alive for evermore," the same phrase precisely in the Greek. Chap. iv.—"Give glory, and honour, and thanks to him that sat on the throne, who liveth for ever and ever;" and again, "Worship him that liveth for ever and ever." Chap. v.—"Blessing and honour, and glory, and power, be unto him that sitteth upon the throne, and unto the Lamb for ever and ever;" and again, "Fell down and worshipped him that liveth for ever and ever." Chap. vii.—"Blessing, and glory, and wisdom, and thanksgiving, and honour, and power, and might, be unto our God for ever and ever." Chap. xi.—"He shall reign for ever and ever." Chap. xv.—"Golden vials full of the wrath of God, who liveth for ever and ever." Chap. xxii.—"The Lord God giveth them light: and they shall reign for ever and ever." Here this phrase is applied nine times to God or the Lamb, and once to the redeemed in heaven. In three other instances it occurs, and these are in reference to the punishment of the wicked. Chap. xiv.—"The smoke of their torment ascendeth up for ever and ever." Chap. xix.—"Her smoke rose up for ever and ever." Chap. xx.—"Shall be tormented day and night for ever and ever." There is not one instance in this book in which this phrase signifies a long and limited duration. There is not the slightest reason for concluding that it does not mean the same thing when applied to the wicked as to God and the redeemed. Surely we may say, "The expressions employed are precisely those which would be chosen if the doctrine here maintained were intended to be taught. There are no other words in which it could be taught." We challenge our opponents to give us anything like such plain Scripture testimony on the other side. Nay, we challenge them to show us how the eternity of future punishment could have been more clearly expressed in the Greek language than it has been in the New Testament.

An attempt, however, is made to gainsay it, upon the same principle of interpretation but differently applied. "The Apocalypse," it is said, "like all other books is best interpreted by itself," and then, instead of explaining the terms in dispute by their use in other parts of the same book, recourse is had to other references in the book to the same subject, as "being excluded from the tree of life" "losing the crown of life," "being blotted out from the book of life," and "the second death;" all of which may be expounded in harmony with the "for ever and ever," as much, and as we think more, than in opposition to it. The second death, we have before shown, precludes the idea of annihilation; even upon the rule here laid down, "that there cannot be a second of anything unless it be at least of the same kind and genus as the first." There cannot be two annihilations of the same thing; and if the second only be annihilation, it cannot be of the same kind and genus as the first. Suffering and annihilation cannot be different species under the same genus; since nothing in common can be predicated of them. "Death and hell being cast into the lake of fire," implies their continued existence and not their extinction. "There shall be no more death," which Mr. White applies to the wicked, is applied in Scripture to the righteous only. It does not follow that because judgments against the enemies of the church are begun on earth that they end here. "The smoke of their torment ascending for ever and ever," is designed to show that it does not end here, and is in fact without end. All allusions to the "for ever and ever" out of this book cannot be admitted as witnesses against those which are contained in it.

It is not needful to review the supposed advantages that would result from the general adoption of Mr. White's opinions. We can judge of them better when we see them. Intellectually we have no fear of the old truths being eclipsed by the new. Much has been said about "men thinking for themselves," as though those who think differently from others thought more than those who think in harmony with them. Notoriety may be more easily acquired by thinking differently from others; but it is seldom solid and abiding.

TROWEL. APR. 1, 1870.

I. O. U.

185

Experimentally we should anticipate no improvement from the proposed doctrinal changes. We question much whether they would ever produce a more stalwart, noble, manly race of Christians than the old doctrines have done. We should prefer those experimental views of both the law and the gospel that acknowledge the justice of eternal punishment, and the grace of deliverance from it, to those which refuse to acknowledge such justice and such grace. As creatures already guilty and condemned, we are not impartial judges upon our own case, and have rather to learn what is the judgment of God than of our own reason upon it. It is impossible, we think, for one truly enlightened to see any limits to the justice or the grace. Practically, too, we look with suspicion upon the benefits that are confidently anticipated from the prevalence of the new views. The evils that have risen from the received doctrines, and the beauties and glories that will be revealed both in the church and the world, the instant these mists have been removed and scattered to the winds, are glowingly described; but at present, to say the least, they are imaginary only. Thousands and millions have been saved, and the saved have found no hindrance to their faith, and hope, and love, and joy, in the preaching of the old doctrines, and it has yet to be seen what better can be done by the new. If there be a complete revolution of the church for the better near at hand, which we earnestly hope there may be, it will not come, we feel assured, from the wisdom of men, but by the power of God.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate