On Teaching Temperance in Elementary Schools
BY W. R. SELWAY, ESQ., SCIENTIFIC LECTURER TO THE PASTORS' COLLEGE.*
IF an apology were needed for bringing before an Education Section of the Social Science Congress the subject of the teaching of temperance in elementary and other schools, it would be found in the circumstance that the duty of the schoolmaster is now, fortunately, regarded as being something more than is comprised in imparting instruction in the art of writing, the structure of language, or in the power of arithmetical computation.
The teacher who most fully meets the requirements of the day, is one who not only possesses the requisite moral force, but actually exerts it in training his or her pupils in those habits of thought and correct action, which may enable the child to more fitly take its place in the social scheme, and in after days to discharge the duties of life with benefit to itself as well as to those with whom it may be brought into contact;—these correct habits not only comprising truth-speaking, and acting, and what are usually known as moral duties, but a due regard to the laws affecting the physical welfare of the body, and those sanitary arrangements which lie within the reach of every enlightened citizen, and upon the due observance of which so much of the health of mankind depends.
It will also, doubtless, be admitted that an important part of school-training should be to throw around the young the shield of warning, both by precept
*Read at the Social Science Congress held at Leeds, 9th October, 1871.
525
and example, against everything which is either in itself an evil, or which, being innocent, may under some circumstances become the parent or fruitful source of mischief and crime.
The intelligent teacher of children will have no difficulty in discovering amid the social customs by which he is surrounded, very much that it would be most desirable the men and women of the future should be taught to avoid and warned against encouraging; knowing, as teachers so well do, indeed, as every reflecting person knows, that the habits and impressions formed or received in early life, are almost indelibly stamped upon the mind; to be eradicated in after life with great difficulty, even if they can then be removed, or overcome at the expense of great mental pain and anxiety.
This country of ours is at this time suffering from an evil which may be truly characterised as appalling—the fearfully prolific parent of much poverty, physical degeneration and suffering, pauperism, immorality and crime; an evil which, although terribly influencing mind and morals, is purely physical in its origin, and is entirely within human control. The source of by far the greater proportion of this evil, if we may rely upon the entirely disinterested evidence of judges upon the bench, magistrates, coroners, medical men whose labours lie mostly among the poor, city and other missionaries, members of Boards of Guardians, indeed, of all who mingle much with the masses of the people, is to be found in the habit of drinking intoxicating liquors—a practice which, although it may not be in itself condemned as immoral, yet, from the physical nature of the intoxicant, is sure to have a greater and more injurious effect upon the nervous organisation of some than it may have upon others.
The evils arising from intemperance, which itself follows the habit of drinking intoxicating liquors, have become so apparent and so sad as to excite the commiseration of all thoughtful well-wishers of the people; and statesmen, as well as divines and philanthropists, are awaking to the necessity of enacting laws, and of providing, if possible, safeguards to restrain or prevent the continuance of the ravages of this habit.
It would appear that one of the safest and wisest courses in relation to this matter would be to prevent the habit of using these drinks from being formed (which it is certain could easily be done), by training the young of both sexes to abstain from them; nor do we see that any valid objection can be raised to this course, as whatever opinions may be held as to the advisability, or otherwise, of persons in adult age relinquishing their use, who may have for many years been accustomed to them, and with whom the habit may have become second nature; there are, it is believed, very few who will not readily admit that children would, from every point of view, be at least as healthy and well without these drinks as with them.
The testimony of eminent medical practitioners to the opinion, that to persons in health the use of intoxicating liquors is altogether unnecessary, is borne out not only by large numbers who have, after arriving at years of maturity, given up the habits of a lifetime; but by multitudes of persons of both sexes, who have never been supplied with them as beverages, and who have grown up from the cradle to adult age, continuing with perfect health and safety the custom of abstinence in which they have been reared.
The opinion of those best qualified to form a correct opinion upon a question of dietetics has been, therefore, so far confirmed by an experience extending over so wide an area, as well as such a lengthened period of time, as to dispel any fear which might be entertained as to the perfect safety to the health of children of rejecting the drinks in question; indeed, a teacher who should make enquiries, as he ought, in order fully to appreciate the importance of the subject, would not fail to discover that total abstinence has now been so extensively practised, and for so great a number of years, that the statistics of life assurance show (other things being equal) the human body to enjoy greater immunity from sickness, and to have a longer average duration of life, when it is not subject to the influence of intoxicating liquors.
The importance of making young persons acquainted with the elements of human physiology, and the laws relating to the physical well-being of the race, has long been felt; and many enlightened and ardent physicians, and others, have frequently urged that these subjects should form part of the regular course of instruction in all our schools. Here and there a schoolmaster, more than usually active in his profession, and feeling that no portion of his tuition is second in importance to this, has given lessons upon it, but the efforts have been comparatively feeble and the result consequently small. It is earnestly to be hoped that the important deputation of the Council of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, which a few months since had an interview with the Vice-President of the Council, for the purpose of urging the advisability of including elementary natural science among the subjects for which payments are to be made, under the authority of the revised code, will have succeeded in making such an impression upon that minister, as that ere long, in all schools which receive Government assistance, the principles and application of natural science may be taught; and that every school board in the kingdom will also provide for the same kind of tuition. The editor of the Lancet exclaims, "What an amount of suffering might be saved or mitigated if the most elementary laws of physiology were generally known and acted upon by the next generation of men and women!" How true this is will be at once appreciated by those who reflect upon the great amount, according to the statistical teaching of the Registrar-General, of physical suffering and premature death which spring from preventible causes, due not only to the want of general sanitary arrangements, but to the gross ignorance of the people, who do not understand the importance of such arrangements when provided by the authorities, or sufficiently appreciate the necessity of putting into practice the most elementary scientific truths regarding air, light, water, warmth, and the preparation and use of pure and wholesome food.
As upon the due observance of the laws of Hygiene so much of the comfort and happiness, and, it may be, morals of the people largely depend, too much stress cannot be laid upon the importance of teachers affording this instruction by means of short and simple lessons or lectures; and when this shall be done, the relation of intoxicating liquor to the body must take its due place in the round of instruction. As the teacher would necessarily explain the action of the atmosphere upon the lungs, and its result in the circulation of the blood; the important function of the skin, and the necessity for cleanliness and frequent ablution; so would he explain the expenditure of force in the motion of the body and its parts, and the need of food to renew the energy from time to time; and would explain the delicate organization of the nervous system and brain, showing the rapid and direct action which spirit always exerts upon them, taking care at the same time to show that the same intoxicating principle exists in fermented drinks as well as fortified wines and distilled spirits. He would, of course, necessarily warn his pupils against their effects, and it would be of the utmost importance to their young minds that he should force home the lesson by exhorting them to avoid the risks, which so frequently follow upon their use, by abstaining from them altogether.
The mischiefs following the use of strong drink are so great, that no one will question the importance of lessening the consumption of it. It swallows up the earnings of the labourer and artisan, and too often prevents him from obtaining a due and sufficient supply of wholesome and nutritious food for the sustenance of his own strength, and for that of those dependent upon him; hence a large proportion of the weak and ill-nurtured children, who speedily succumb under attacks of epidemic and other diseases, and thus the death-rate of the country is raised in no slight degree by the quantity of beer which is imbibed in it.
It is not an entirely hopeless task to win men from their pernicious habits, as is proved by the results of the self-denying labours of numerous warm-hearted men and women who devote much time to their reclamation; but, how
527
much better would it be for the State, if the money uselessly expended upon these drinks was diverted into channels of industry, and laid out in the purchase of good food, upon articles of clothing, for books, or in paying for the education of children: all of which advantages and many more would necessarily follow, were the children of the present generation trained so as to ensure their being sober men and women.
It is scarcely necessary, although to prevent misapprehension, we may here stop to remark, that it is by no means intended to be implied that all children who may drink intoxicating liquors as their daily beverage will grow up to become intemperate men and women; but, we think it cannot be too often insisted upon, that drunkenness is of slow growth, no human being probably ever having become drunk on the first occasion of taking the drink. Very many of the youths of the day will, we do not for a moment doubt, even should the habits of their father be perpetuated in them, grow up and worthily fill their several stations in life; yet it is not to be denied, and should not for a moment be shut out from observation, that if the present state of things continues, the intemperate drinkers of to-day will be replaced by those who are now innocent of the slightest suspicion of taint in this matter, and the experience of the past warrants the assertion that very many of these will by imperceptible stages, more or less slowly as the habit fastens upon them, fall into the condition of the intemperate.
To prevent this sad calamity of any one healthy, vigorous, and joyous because innocent child, becoming the miserable, dejected, trembling, wretched, and unhappy being, known as a drunkard, is surely worthy of the efforts of every lover of his kind, and especially of those who will, to a very great extent, stand in loco parentis to a large number of the children who, by the compulsory powers of the Elementary Education Act, will be taken from the streets, or from their worthless parents, and forced to observe the discipline, and receive, as far as possible, the tuition of the school.
That it is possible to convey to children such instruction in this matter as will enable them to see the evils of intemperance, and the advantages of temperance, their young and susceptible natures leave no doubt. No training is so successful as that begun soon, and no example is so forcible as that which is placed before them in early life, by those whom they respect for their knowledge, and love for their goodness. The vast numbers of children and youths joined together, to strengthen each other in resisting a common habit, in the innumerable Bands of Hope scattered throughout the country, abundantly prove that the question is not only capable of being understood, but that the practice may be followed without inconvenience, or rather with positive pleasure, and with benefit to young people.
The teachers of elementary schools will, in the course of their duties, have frequent occasion, while explaining the doctrines of social economies, to show that money expended in the purchase of articles which fulfil no useful purpose is so much capital diverted from productive channels, and that even if it be conceded that intoxicating liquors are luxuries which mankind are entitled to use as a solace or enjoyment, yet the expenditure for them in this country is so out of proportion to that for any other single class of productions, that the economist cannot but regard with dismay the amount of the earnings of the people which are absorbed by these so-called luxuries. And the teacher who would show his pupils the right method of disbursing the wages he may hereafter receive for his labour, must surely feel the importance of teaching that this is a head of expenditure which ought to be restained within the narrowest limits, and that it would be still better if it should form no part whatever of the many demands which must be met from his earnings. If further it can be shown that these drinks are dangerous luxuries, having a manifest tendency to lead those who take them to an increasing indulgence, which, in a large number of instances, culminates in drunkenness and its concomitant crimes and evils, then it becomes the duty of all instructors of the young, not only to urge them to
take care of their earnings, but to warn them of the consequences which it is more than probable will follow if they form and continue the habit of taking these drinks.
The subject, it will be seen, is of wide application, comprising sanitary or dietetic relations, the repression of crime and violence, the right use of money, the moral training of the young, and, it may be added, intellectual power, inasmuch as it requires no inconsiderable amount of decision or force of character to be enabled to resist the influence of a very prevalent custom, and the too often injudicious—although it may be well meant—recommendation of friends or companions not to be singular, but to do as others are doing: such friends forgetting that while singularity is not excellence, excellence is frequently singular.
It remains only to be said, that it is not desired or meant to be suggested, that temperance teaching should be instituted as a separate branch of tuition in elementary schools, but only that managers of schools of all grades, and for both sexes, should see to it, that the teachers have such an enlightened appreciation of the importance of this subject as to be both able and at all times ready, in giving general and collective lessons in those branches of ethics or physics to which the matter properly attaches, to add words of instruction, counsel, or warning, as the occasion may be seen to demand.
It is to be hoped, further, that in preparing future editions of reading-lesson books, the editors will eliminate from them the erroneous matter pertaining to the production and action of intoxicating drinks which too many of them yet contain, notwithstanding much improvement which has of late years taken place; also, that those school-books may have introduced into them sounder scientific knowledge in relation to these drinks, and by apt illustration, by narrative and incident, awaken the interest of the pupil in reference to a matter which must be regarded as of the first importance to the future physical and moral development of the English people.
