Menu
‹ Chapter 24 of 206 ›

Confirmation Again

3 min read · Chapter 24 of 206

MR. ALFRED POTTER, the Rector of Keyworth, Notts. has published a reply to our review of his "Dialogue on Confirmation," and it can be had of Mr. Macintosh, of Paternoster Row, for one penny. It is almost as good a tract as his former one, of which he tells us, "If you had dismissed my tract on confirmation with the remark that it was worthless, I could have understood your meaning, and remained silent." Now, our politeness would have forbidden such a remark, but if it will gratify Mr. Potter, we will come down to the level of his understanding, and oblige him by saying that both his first tract and his present reply are worthless. Fearing, however, that the gentleman will not be quite satisfied with the verdict which he invites, we shall be presumptuous enough to add a few sentences more. Evidently he thinks we shall be astounded at his buckling on the harness and coming forth against us, and that our alarm at his publicly exposing us will be extreme. We can assure him that he has no cause to fear for us, our equanimity is unruffled, and no feeling is awakened in us except the very smallest amount of amusement. A worthy neighbour of the Vicar tells us that the remarkable array of texts at the bottom of the pages of the reply has caused no small amusement, since they appear to have been culled at random, and are about as appropriate to the late eclipse of the sun as to the subject in hand. Some writers feel that it gives an air of importance to their pages to stud them with references, but when the references are babysit the result is one step removed from the sublime.

How does the rector rectify himself in the matter of the maimed quotation from Calvin? Why, by merely saying that the words were "unintentionally omitted"!!! We are bound to believe his reverence, and we do so according to the measure of our faith. It is, however, a singular accident by which a man leaves out that part of a sentence which is not in accordance with his own views. Accidents in the literary world are evidently more propitiously arranged than those upon railroads. The rector feels that the accident was so trivial that he has no need even to say that he is sorry for it; on the contrary, he is the accurate man beyond all doubt, and that wicked Reviewer is the guilty party. What if the rector did accidentally misquote Calvin, he was even then nearer the mark than the flippant being who dared to quote

* See the "Encyclopædia Britannica," eighth edition. Art. MATTHEW HENRY.

Calvin's utterances concerning Confirmation in the Church of Rome, and show that they were applicable to the immaculate Church of England. The rector has the effrontery to affirm that Calvin approved of Confirmation, as practised in the Church of England, because he (as we admitted) believed in the primitive laying on of hands, and declared that a sort of Confirmation was practised in the early church. To us it is as clear as daylight that the censures of Calvin, which we quoted, are applicable to any Confirmation which pretends to bestow spiritual gifts; they were aimed primarily at the practice of the Church of Rome, they are quite as applicable to the rather more obnoxious ceremony of the Anglican Church. Let our readers turn to the passage quoted in our article and judge for themselves. The confirmation which Calvin would have allowed is widely different from the misleading, injurious, and utterly unscriptural ceremony which Mr. Potter, and his like, try to bolster up. As the Institutes of Calvin were written before the present service-book of the Anglican Community was extant, few persons out of Bedlam would have brought Calvin into the question on one side or the other. Having however introduced that great reformer's opinion, the reverend gentleman was answered by us according to his folly by a quotation dead against him, and now he turns round in devout horror, and cries out, "This was meant for the Church of Rome and not for the Anglican ceremony." We cannot help answering, "O sapient rector of Keyworth, of course it was! Who but you would have dreamed otherwise? How could Calvin in his Institutes have formed a judgment upon your precious prayer-book which was not then in existence? But what he said of the Roman Confirmation is true of yours, and more true still, for he who compares the prayer-book and the missal upon confirmation, will find the prayer-book to be the worse of the two."

The advice gratis which his reverence gives us upon being flippant, etc., is worthy of a man who expects obsequious homage from the downtrodden serfs among whom he is the parson, but we think he makes a slight mistake when he considers unholy familiarity with sacred things to be the right name for plain speech concerning a Rector and his worthless Tracts.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate