Menu
‹ Chapter 53 of 206 ›

Calvin and Serbetus as Religious Reformers — By G. Holden Pike.—Part Ii

16 min read · Chapter 53 of 206

OF the minor events mingling with Calvin's life at Geneva we cannot speak at length. In 1547 the Reformers had some serious difficulties with the Libertine or Opposition party, and open insurrection was only prevented by Calvin's personal exertion. After this he came into contact with Socinus, having answered some questions propounded, little thinking that the name of his interrogator would give an appellative to a system of theology the antipodes of his own. Then we find the festival of Christmas and other feast days abolished in the Republic, and abolished under the sanction, if not at the instigation, of Calvin. In 1549 death removed his wife, to whom he was warmly attached; and though his bearing in this affliction excited the wonder of beholders, and especially that of Viret, who by a like blow had been prostrated, we cannot ascribe Calvin's seeming apathy to want of feeling, but rather to sustaining grace, and to his consistency in putting the doctrines he preached to the test of every-day experience. Calvin, it is true, was sparing of affectionate expressions, but not of kind actions. After his wife's death he cared for his step-children in a manner every way commendable.

Historians and lecturers have hitherto followed one in the wake of another in traducing Calvin's memory, so that if the general public have not set the Reformer down as a sour-faced, crabbed-souled theologian, without generosity in his nature, and without music in his soul, it has not been for want of assumed data whereon to found their opinions. How often these representations have been the offspring of sheer ignorance history is gradually showing as her treasures are opened by industrious research. Thus, in 1862, a well-known Independent minister ventured the following assertions in a lecture at Exeter Hall: — "Well was it for Germany that Luther could provide for her hymnody. Had he been as unmusical as Calvin, the church song of Protestantism in its entireness would have been as harsh and repulsive as is that of the churches which call Calvin their founder. . . . Calvin was utterly destitute of musical sensibility, as every page of his works and every element of his character indicate." It now transpires that Calvin was not only possessed of a taste for music, but that he zealously laboured in providing suitable sacred songs and appropriate music for the church; and the "British and Foreign Evangelical Review," after quoting the above passage, observes:—"We find that Calvin laboured during twenty-three years of his life in this cause (psalmody); and as we found that he was the first who ever provided the words of the whole book of Psalms for the use of the people in the praise of the sanctuary, so now we find, in reference to music, that he was also the first who ever produced a true and distinctive psalmody. His psalter is a monument of beauty, which all succeeding ages have used as a mine and a model. The tunes are the common inheritance of the Protestant churches, and are familiarly known to all lovers of psalmody as unsurpassed for simplicity, beauty, and grandeur by the music of any country or of any age."

Passing over several years of Calvin's life we have now to deal with

155

that celebrated and sad event, which, perhaps more than any other connected with the Reformation, has been made a bone of contention among religious partisans. The death of Servetus is now regretted by all sections of the church, though all are not agreed as to the origin of his punishment. It is a truism to affirm that the leaders of the Reformation blundered in adopting the principles of persecution; but, unfortunately, all parties supposed it was their duty to repress error by civil authority, as much as it was their duty to promulgate truth by books and by preaching. It has so long been the fashion to link the name of Calvin with the "murder" of Servetus, that being too often ignorant of attendant circumstances, the Reformer's friends have allowed Unitarians to glory in their martyr with a show of triumph creditable to neither party. Half-informed writers have supplied "impartial" histories of the Spaniard, written in a strain of virulent partiality; and we have listened to their diatribes until time has brought a vindication. From documents recovered at a comparatively recent date from Genevan archives, it appears that the death of the Spanish doctor was not so much the work of the Reformers as of the civil magistrate. While not acquiescing in the justice of his doom, we yet heartily subscribe the opinion that Servetus was an "obstinate and unprincipled heretic." Too long has Calvin's fame been sullied with the odium of having burned this restless fanatic. The Reformer was only a unit in the business. Awakened Switzerland, in conjunction with Geneva, demanded the physician's life, accounting him a blasphemous and political firebrand.

Of the personal character of Servetus we possess many independent testimonies. He did not want parts and culture. He may even be ranked among men of genius. A native of Arragon, his father lived in easy circumstances, and intended Michael for a lawyer. He was studying the French code when the Reformation began to stir the religious mind of France. Having a taste for the curious and the speculative in theology, he forsook the law to set himself up for a religious reformer. His bold and proud spirit was not content to be the ally of minds superior to itself; but must, by one effort, head the Reformation. He did not lack industry; for he completed a laborious course of reading, including the Scriptures and the Fathers, the result being, his producing a system of theology, or rather of neology, calculated to startle the church by its daring profanity. Though vain of his powers, and obstinate in holding the most horrible opinions, the courage of Servetus was not equal to his mental capacities, or he would have published his first work in France, instead of leaving Tolouse, and settling at Basle, where he explained his views to Œcolampadius, who denounced them as anti-christian. Meeting with little encouragement at Basle, Servetus went to Strasburg, and as a stripling, but just turned of twenty, published an heretical book on the Trinity, which made its author's name notorious on account of the shocking doctrines advanced. The foundation of this atrocious system was a combination of Socinianism and Pantheism; but in his first brochure the author did not always clearly express his meaning. A revised edition of the work appeared two years subsequently, which defended former opinions while apologising for some instances of youthful ignorance. Considering himself in the van of the Reformation, Servetus violently denounced the corruptions of Rome.

He found fault with the Protestants; but Rome was antichrist, and the pope an impostor.

The astonishment and indignation created by the appearance of this treatise were beyond description. The coarse manner in which things sacred were assailed won the reprobation of Reformed and Papist in common. Melanethon was careful to state that the book was not printed in German territory. Lutherans were indignant at being accused of ignorance of the meaning of justification, and by an author who apparently assumed infallibility. Papists were shocked at his impiety, while all alike regarded him as a beast of prey crept in among the sheep. Threatened alike by Catholics and Protestants, Servetus fled from Strasburg, and sought safety at Basle, where he would have been roughly treated had he not been shielded by the protecting care of Ecclampadius. For a time he averted the gathering storm by retiring to Paris, and as some accounts say by travelling through Italy, meanwhile dispersing books by the way. As a student of medicine he might probably have won distinction, for his acuteness half revealed to him nature's secret of the circulation of the blood, and by referring to this mystery he may have aided Harvey in completing the discovery. As a scholar at Paris he was now poor, and for the purpose of raising funds sufficient to obtain a diploma he accepted a situation as corrector of the press to certain eminent printers at Lyons, and by this means was able to take a doctor's degree. At Paris, Servetus won a name for skill in physic and in the pretended science of astrology. Though celebrated as a physician, his domineering behaviour to fellow students brought him into ill odour, necessitating a flight from the capital, and a settlement near Lyons. Removing to Vienne in 1540, he resided with a friend and former pupil, the bishop of the diocese. On being appointed public physician he might have remained in affluent circumstances till the end of life, had not his constitutional vanity suggested an attempt to win wide distinction. This vanity and this self-conceit were of no ordinary character. If a reformation must be effected, Servetus must be its centre. He imagined himself to be a subject of prophecy, and the Michael depicted as fighting the beast in the Revelation. This being so, he should act a chief part in ushering in the millenium which many supposed to be near at hand. While inflated by such ideas, no wonder that his industry was untiring. Besides amending his own works, he published a translation of the Bible—mainly the work of another. For a time Calvin and he corresponded, but being as widely separated in theology as the poles are asunder, they came to warm words, the physician roundly abusing the pastor, besides crowning his insults by sending a copy of the Institutes scrawled over with manuscript notes of heresy and blasphemy.

Servetus denounced Trinitarians as atheists, and from the time of his death to the present day Socinians and others have made capital of his calamities, condemning his opponents off-hand without making allowance either for the times or for the occasion of the catastrophe. Profiting by the experience of three centuries, it is idle and unfair to condemn any for not acting up to our standard of liberality. In these days it is not possible to realize the alarm with which the Reformers regarded Servetus. In their eyes he was a very Satan going about to uproot the Gospel. Sufficiently bold in impiety to apply the fifty-third of Isaiah to Cyrus,

157

he had not the moral courage calculated to win the respect of a great opponent like Calvin. At Vienne he took an assumed name, and entirely ignored the authorship of the heretical books which he had already published. Yet, while thus passing his days in the communion of the Romish Church, Servetus was secretly engaged in printing his notorious work on the Restitution of Christianity. The publication of this treatise entailed considerable danger; but, on being bribed, a printer was prevailed on to undertake it.

The life of Servetus after this date is a tragical story. His first apprehension before the authorities at Vienne had its origin in the correspondence of two friends, one Trie, a Protestant of Geneva, and Arney, a zealous Papist of Lyons. Arney took pains with his epistles, the object of their composition being the reclamation of a heretic. Arney used subtle means to undermine the faith of his friend. He sneered at the Genevan Church, and condemned its discipline. These letters at length provoked retaliation. Trie pointed out that order reigned in the republic, that crime and false doctrine were assiduously repressed, and then triumphantly asked, where is your authority at Lyons when heretics are shielded in your midst, and such as Servetus are allowed to vend blasphemy at your very doors? This letter, his detractors with shameless effrontery affirm, was probably written at Calvin's suggestion, or perhaps at his dictation. Could such an assertion be sustained, a clear case of treachery against the Reformer would be established; but the letter must only be accepted for what it professes to be—the communication of one friend to another, though the writer may have obtained part of his information from public discourses or from private conversation. In this letter Trie enclosed some leaves of the work of Servetus, and the result was the citation of the latter before the Council of Vienne on a charge of heresy, the summons not being served till the accused, obtaining an inkling of what was coming, opportunely burned a quantity of papers. Not yet satisfied, and moved with zeal to destroy a heretic, Arney sent to Geneva for further evidence, and Trie obtained from Calvin some manuscript notes of Servetus, which showed that his sympathies were anti-pædobaptist. In reply to a third application, Trie revealed the name of the printer of the Restitution of Christianity. Ory, an inquisitor under the Archbishop of Lyons, and the Archbishop of Vienne were engaged in the prosecution. The printer was acquitted and the corrector of his press escaped. As the examination proceeded, Servetus showed the weak side of his character by giving false evidence, so far as he imagined it would be safe to do so. He even denied that he was the person cited. Attempts were made to prove him a baptist from his own manuscripts; and probably he would have disowned the handwriting had not the subtlety of Ory proved superior to his own. On seeing some letters he had written to Calvin he shed tears and multiplied falsehoods. Anon, the trial leisurely proceeds, and the prisoner is confined, but in an easy manner. Then the judges are amazed at hearing of the culprit's escape. By throwing a night dress over his other clothes, Servetus deceived the gaoler and passed out of captivity.

Now, had Servetus suffered death at Vienne as a heretic, as a victim of popery, posterity would have heard little or nothing of the affair.

The fact of his having fallen before a Protestant power has interested Papists in the case, besides encouraging swervers from the faith of all shades to make his death a means of reflecting odium on the heads of the Genevan Reformers.

But to continue the narrative. One day in July, 1553, Servetus, as a foot passenger, entered Geneva. Why he should have risked passing through a city where so many dangers lurked can never be satisfactorily explained. He may have been travelling to some safe destination; or he may have thought that by concealing a name, already too notorious, he should be able to take refuge and pass unrecognised. Lodging at a comfortable inn, he spoke gaily with the landlord, and not before staying some weeks was his arrest by order of the Council effected.

It is necessary to take particular notice of the general aspect of affairs in the Genevan republic on that summer afternoon when Servetus entered the city. The bulk of the citizens were only nominally Protestant. The religious changes had been welcomed because the squabbles between successive bishops and petty princes had wearied the populace until they won civil freedom and release from the thraldom of Rome by siding with the Reformation, which at first was more a political convenience than a spiritual awakening. The city being a republic, offered itself as a fit asylum to those noblest of all patriots, the men who sought to free their fellows from the slavery of error. A formidable phalanx of those in authority arrayed themselves as the Reformers' enemies. A conscientious impartiality, stern and uncompromising, had provoked the opposition of the Captain-General Perrin. Though a loose liver, Perrin hated the tyranny of Rome, and thus had been among the first to welcome Calvin's installation, apparently supposing that whatever régime might be imposed, the sitters in high places would be exempt from its inconveniences; but when Perrin committed a moral offence he was condemned to forfeit the penalties demanded of meaner citizens. The artificial restraints put upon vice were distasteful to many well-to-do burghers. Feuds were of frequent occurrence in the Council, and these even extended to the street. Remembering former disagreements, Servetus hated Calvin, and hated him as only controvertialists of that age could hate opponents. His lively powers of perception at once enabled him to apprehend the state of parties in the Republic; and the survey must have shown him a crisis offering opportunities of revenge both on Romish persecutors and on the Reformer, whose "Institutes" Servetus would have superseded by an unintelligible pantheism. This visit to the city could not have been without an object; for had it been merely a halting, that halting need not have been so prolonged. He despised the "Old learning;" but, if possible, he entertained a still greater contempt for the doctrines of the Reformation, and if not animated by the base passion of revenge, he was vain of intellectual strength and covetous of power. It is not unlikely that Servetus supposed he could ally himself with the disaffected; for it is believed he corresponded with the Libertine party. It is difficult to imagine what higher object could have detained a man to whom the dearest triumph conceivable would have been the overthrow of Calvin, and the enthroning of his enemy in a Republic, whence that enemy could have hurled defiance at the Romish fanatics, who even

159

then were roasting his effigy and destroying his books over a slow fire at Vienne. Extravagant as these designs may now appear, they probably did not seem far from realisation when Servetus entered Geneva. Many important victories had recently been won by the Libertines. The refugees—the most Christian portion of the population—were deprived of arms. In addition to being disfranchised, the ministers were excluded from the Council of Twenty-five. The every-day peace of the Reformers was interrupted, the Reformation itself was threatened, and its abettors were required to act in self-defence or ignominiously surrender. The gravity of the crisis was increased by a dispute then in progress between Calvin and the Libertines respecting an excommunicated man of the name of Berthelier, whose sentence being reversed by the Little Council, the ministers refused him the Lord's Supper. These elements of discord only wanted a powerful mind to unite and control them and they would have entangled Calvin and his work in superlative difficulties. In the eyes of the Reformers the Spaniard was a roving blasphemer, whose writings were no less an insult to God than they were a curse to man. Not to have detained such a man would have appeared as unjustifiable to the judgment of Calvin as the allowing of robbers and murderers to live unmolested. The latter, indeed, took life and goods; but here was one whose life-work consisted in undoing souls and perverting the Reformation. Such was the social condition of Geneva, and such the nature of the combustible materials among which the firebrand Servetus found a resting place in the memorable summer of 1553.

From what has been advanced it will appear that the friends of a leading excommunicated citizen were the allies of Servetus. Hence his trial turned not merely on the pivot of false doctrine, but having voluntarily ejected himself to the ordeal, his name became the rallying cry of a faction who were distracting the well-disposed, and threatening the city with ruin. By procuring the arrest of such a man, Calvin was not so much moved by animosity as he was by a desire to save the Republic from that anarchy to which his enemies were hastening it.

Servetus being arrested, it remained with the Little Council to conduct the prosecution. As they went on it became openly manifest that the Spaniard's principal object was to strike at Calvin's ascendancy. Calculating too much on his influence over the disaffected, he challenged the most sacred doctrines, or denounced them as diabolical inventions. Then, it further appeared that Servetus himself was not so much the object in dispute as the discipline of the Reformation. Berthelier, on the one side, as a hater of Calvin and his system, and Colladon, a warm partisan of the pure faith, on the other, waged a public warfare of words, representative of the antipathy entertained by each party for the other. Servetus had originally some friends in power, but by dreadful blasphemics he alienated many, and we question the taste of writers who reproduce the prisoner's hideous assertions. Calvin's share in the matter began with an examination of the accused; which being ended, the proceedings assumed the form of a State trial, conducted by the Attorney-General. Calvin undertook to produce the testimony of the Fathers against certain things advanced by Servetus. The original charge was founded in heresy, but this the Attorney-General supplemented by preferring several political charges. In the meantime, "Calvin," says

Rillicit, "disappeared before the general interest of the reformed churches." Had the accused man been arraigned merely as an enemy of Calvin, in the manner in which party writers would have us believe, the case must have fallen to the ground; and this is proved by documents lately brought to light in the archives of Geneva. Then, moreover, the prisoner's violent language and insolent bearing led the judges to convict him as a person of dangerous, seditious tendencies. Geneva was committed to the Reformation. To touch religion was to undo the State; and the stability of the Commonwealth was so bound up with the Reformers, that Calvin's office and power could not be curtailed with impunity. A slight examination of the constitution of the Council of Twenty-five will show that a conviction on religious grounds only would not have been possible, for the majority of the judges were anti-Calvinists, who sacrificed private sympathies to public safety.

While information was being sought from Vienne as to the reasons of the late conviction of Servetus, the Libertines endeavoured to awaken a feeling of commiseration for him; and it was in counteracting this effort that the pulpits resounded with warnings to the populace not to harbour pity for one so inimical to peace and righteousness.

On the completion of the trial it was arranged to hold a written disputation between Calvin and Servetus; and the papers were submitted to the judgment of the Swiss churches, who unanimously voted the heretic worthy of death. In the final decision of the Little Council only five were for an acquittal, though but seven of the assembly were Calvinists. It must therefore be remembered that the judges were far from sympathising with the Reformer. While the trial was about, we find them restoring a citizen to religious privileges in spite of the Consistory over which Calvin presided. Are we to suppose they would have burned a culprit to please their chief pastor, with whom, on a very sore question, they were at open strife?

Thus fell Servetus—by the Protestants, cry the Romanists; by Calvinists, echo half-way Protestants; a victim of the age, and of his own ill-controlled passions, says the surer testimony of history. It will be unnecessary to detail the particulars of his last hours, the cause of his punishment, not the events of his life, being the subject in hand. Posterity regrets his doom. Nevertheless the case, as above related, will not correspond with the countless cases of Romish persecution. The procedure of the papacy was to try by a spiritual court prior to handing over its victims to the temporal power. It was otherwise in this instance. Servetus was arraigned before a civil tribunal, of which Calvin was not a member, and wherein his friends numbered only as seven to twenty-five. The affair, it is true, begun in a theological quarrel; but it ended in a conviction for blasphemy and seditious practices. Then comes the common objection—men should not be put to death for opinions. Though this is admitted, the admission would have been accounted extreme weakness in the Reformation age, and, in this respect, Calvin, as his supporters must admit and deeply regret, was not taller than his fellows; yet for this weakness we can no more justly condemn him, than we can reasonably cast reflections on his writings because they were written in the sixteenth century, or because they discover an ignorance of the Newtonian philosophy.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate