Spurgeon's "Treasury of David." — A Review By Dr. Culross
THIS is the third instalment of Mr. Spurgeon's Work on the Psalms, and completes half his undertaking. The plan pursued is the same as in the previous volumes. There is first a brief introductory notice of the particular Psalm under discussion, telling its occasion and contents; then an independent commentary on the separate verses; then a collection of explanatory notes and quaint sayings quoted from all quarters; then a series of hints to the village preacher; and lastly, a list of books on the whole Psalm, or part of it. The result is a work containing a vast mass of thought, so arranged as to be easily available for consultation. No critic, however unfriendly, will hesitate to acknowledge the great value of the work as a whole, and its helpfulness at once to the private Christian reader and to the student. It displays remarkable vigour, fertility of mind, and religious earnestness, consecrated to the Lord for the service of his church.
The introductory notices are executed with great felicity, and to me, for one, form the most delightful part of the work. Occasionally commentators have approached the Psalms in the same logical temper in which they might have approached the Epistle to the Romans, and have even prepared their logical mould beforehand, into which everything is crushed and squeezed and forced to take the shape they have previously determined. Mr. Spurgeon carefully guards the peculiar individuality of every Psalm, and treats it as a living plant, growing in its own soil of experience, and under its own particular conditions, which are lovingly and sympathetically unfolded. So it comes to pass that David, Solomon, Asaph, and the rest, down even to Jeduthun the
* The Treasury of David: containing an Original Exposition of the Book of Psalms; a Collection of Illustrative Extracts from the whole range of Literature; a Series of Homiletical Hints upon almost every Verse; and Lists of Writers upon each Psalm. By C. H. Spurgeon. Vol. III. Psalm LIII. to LXXVIII. London: Passmore and Alabaster, 4. Paternoster Buildings. 1872.
361
doorkeeper, are not so many abstractions to us, or stone-people, like the figures in a sculpture-gallery, or mere repetitions one of another, like images of clay cast in the same mould, and varnished from the same pot, but living, breathing persons, each with his own bosomful of thought and emotion. Of different men, or of the same man in different circumstances and moods, we have thus a succession of sketches exquisitely fresh and life-like. Collected by themselves they would form a delightful little volume.
The commentary is marked by Mr. Spurgeon's best qualities. It is clear, terse, often pungent, and full of homely sense. It would be easy to gather from it racy sayings almost as good as proverbs, bits of wise humour, and touches of nature that make the whole world kin. If it does not enter into linguistic, critical, historical, or theological disquisitions, nor exhibit wealth of learned and irrelevant information—as if a historian of the Peninsular war were to illustrate the career of Wellington by telling us about the geology and botany of his various battlefields—everything in it is fitted to elucidate, less or more worthily, the subject in hand. In saying all this, I pay tribute not to the human instrument, but to the grace that inspired the Psalmist, which is the same grace that prepares the expositor. Of course it is not possible that a single mind should be able to enter fully into the various truths and spiritual emotions which come out so variously in the book of Psalms—the book is immeasurably too broad and profound for such a thing to be possible—nor can study give the results of life-experience; but the value of this commentary arises hence, that Mr. Spurgeon has written what he himself has seen with his own eyes and felt in his own heart. This is a far more helpful thing than to have laboriously and learnedly reproduced second-hand the experience of other people, even if it should turn out that he has now and again missed a meaning, or brushed off the dew and sweetness from some verse or line. And it has also secured nerve and originality.
In his essay on the aversion of men of taste to evangelical religion, John Foster points out the unfortunate effect of that peculiar theological diction or jargon which had become too characteristic of the pulpit, which gives an uncouthness of mien to a beauty that should attract all hearts, and sometimes provokes a smile of pity where it would have been desirable to plant an arrow in the conscience. There have been men—and perhaps the class is not yet extinct—to whom even a certain twang is of the essence of religion, and for whom a text of Scripture loses something if repeated in a natural tone of voice. A little of the cheap and easy wit one sometimes meets with consists in borrowing a stock of religious phrases and applying it to subjects which are intended to be made ludicrous; and the customary reward is a laugh. Both by his preaching and his books Mr. Spurgeon has done much to give naturalness and manly vigour to the literature of evangelical religion; his English is English, simple, clear, homely, and nervous, always the exact counterpart of his thought.
Another sore evil of a different kind he has done something to correct—namely, the worship of mere taste. A keen-eyed American, who visited this country some years ago, Ralph Waldo Emerson, declared the doctrine of the Church of England to be, "By taste are
ye saved." I have not seen in this volume any sacrificing of truth, or force, or pungency on this altar. The moral idea (as it ought) appears to rule the composition.
Some great questions of the age are dealt with in the Commentary, indirectly and briefly, yet in a way calculated to stimulate further thought. I single out from many questions which occur to me that of Inspiration. There is no formal discussion of it, and no setting forth of a theory. The whole treatment, however, proceeds on the assumption that we have the words of God before us, on every one of which we may lay the fullest stress. But, with true insight, Mr. Spurgeon perceives that each particular psalm is none the less an accurate expression of the experience, thought, emotion, and mental mood of its writer. We have not a mere speaking-trumpet, filled with the breath of God: —but a man of like passions with ourselves, passing through a particular experience, while all that is special to him of strength or infirmity, is made the living, throbbing vehicle to utter the divine thought to us. Thus, in his commentary on the fifty-ninth Psalm, and on the words, "Scatter them by thy power; and bring them down, O Lord our shield," Mr. Spurgeon remarks, "This was a righteous wish, and if it be untempered by the gentleness of Jesus, we must remember that it is a soldier's prayer, and the wish of one who was smarting under injustice and malice of no ordinary kind."
Another and kindred question I would refer to. Mr. Spurgeon holds very unmistakably that the prophets and psalmists of the old covenant all looked and spoke Christward. In this—however he may conflict with the modern Sadducee—he only follows the Lord himself, who found "things concerning himself" in all the Scriptures, from Moses downwards. I would not say that Mr. Spurgeon's application of the principle is never mistaken. In more than one instance it might be argued that he is too hasty, or has been unconsciously led away by the sound of the English words. But speaking broadly, he guards against a mere blind application—which is mis-application and abuse—of the principle, and which brings suspicion on the truth itself. Thus, in the preliminary notice of the sixty-ninth Psalm he says, "If any enquire, Of whom speaketh the psalmist this? of himself or of some other man? we would reply, Of himself and of some other man. Who that other is, we need not be long in discovering: it is the Crucified alone who can say, In my thirst they gave me vinegar to drink. His footprints all through this sorrowful song have been pointed out by the Holy Spirit in the New Testament, and therefore we believe and are sure the Son of Man is here. Yet it seems to be the intention of the Spirit, while he gives us personal types, and so shows the likeness to the First-born which exists in the heirs of salvation, to set forth also the disparities between the best of the sons of men and the Son of God, for there are verses here which we dare not apply to our Lord; we almost shudder when we hear our brethren attempting to do so."
Commentators, generally speaking, have exhausted their first strength by the time they have reached the point where this volume begins; and with few exceptions, no great writers have taken up single Psalms included here. "Some six or seven of them," Mr. Spurgeon remarks, "are specially notable, and have therefore been expounded and preached
363
upon on all hands, but the rest remain almost untrodden ground in sacred literature." The consequence is, that the gathering of illustrative extracts from other writers has become a much more laborious task than heretofore. The difficulty is one that is likely to increase as Mr. Spurgeon proceeds with his Commentary. The authors named in the preface, whose "pith" is extracted and embodied in the present volume—"not without much expense of money as well as toil"—are not familiar even by repute to the majority of modern English readers—Venema, Le Blanc, Lorinus, Gerhohus, Musculus, Martin Geier, Mollerus, Simon de Muis, Vatablus, Turrecremata, Marloratus, and so on. It is with humour half kindly, half grim, that Mr. Spurgeon remarks, "The neglect of these voluminous expositors is not very censurable; for as a rule they are rather heavy than weighty." To Mr. Gracey, and his other coadjutor in this department, Mr. Spurgeon returns deserved thanks. Very few have any idea how much is meant in the words, "I can truly say that I have never flinched from a difficulty, or spared exertion in order to make the work as complete as it lay in my power to render it, either by my own endeavours or the help of others."
The part of the work which I am least able to appreciate is the "Hints to the Village Preacher." It appears from testimonies received that numerous students have already found help in this department. On the whole I would say that it is best for the village preacher not to buckle on Mr. Spurgeon's armour, but to go forth simply with his own scrip and sling, "in the name of the Lord of hosts," very thankful that he can pick up so many smooth stones from this brook. I speak with diffidence; but, on the whole, I should think it best that he should aim and sling them himself, or be content to sling at a venture. Still, an opinion is not to be set against facts.
As a specimen of most interesting exposition, I would call attention to the sixty-eighth Psalm. Extracts must fail to give any idea of the succession and momentum of the thoughts here. I fix on a single line almost at random: "Ethiopia shall soon stretch out her hands unto God." This is the commentary: "Cush shall hasten to present peace-offerings. Sheba's queen shall come from the far south. Candace's chamberlain shall ask of Him who was led as a lamb to the slaughter. Abyssiuia shall yet be converted, and Africa become the willing seeker after grace, eagerly desiring and embracing the Christ of God. Poor Ethiopia, thy hands have been long manneled and hardened by cruel toil, but millions of thy sons have in their bondage found the liberty wherewith Christ made men free; and so, thy cross, like that of Alexander* of Cyrene, has been Christ's cross, and God has been thy salvation. Hasten, O Lord, this day, when both the civilisation and the barbarism of the earth shall adore thee, Egypt and Ethiopia blending with glad accord in thy worship!" By the way, there is a remarkable "Fragment" on these words, entitled, "The Prospects of Ethiopia," by a remarkable man, the late Mr. Jameson, of Scone, which Mr. Spurgeon would have been delighted to meet with; as also a sermon from the line in the seventy-fourth Psalm, "A man was famous according as he had lifted up axes upon the thick trees."
* A strange mistake. Read Simon.
The volume is well got up, and extremely low priced. Indeed it is only by a still larger sale than the previous volumes have had that Mr. Spurgeon can be screened from pecuniary loss. "I cannot hope," he says, "to be remunerated pecuniarily; if only the bare outlay be met I shall be well content; the rest is an offering to the best of Masters, whose word is meat and drink to those who study it." May the offering be accepted.
[We desired to make our readers acquainted with our Work, and therefore thought it best to invite the criticism of an independent reviewer. We asked our friend Dr. James Culross, of Highbury (late of Sterling), to judge the Work impartially, and even severely, if he saw fit. We are highly grateful with the review, and exceedingly grateful to the reviewer.]
