Menu
‹ Chapter 131 of 203 ›

On Vicarious Preaching — By Vernon J. Charlesworth

8 min read · Chapter 131 of 203

SOME time ago a ministerial conference was held in a provincial town and the large attendance of the clergy excited the surprise and wonder of the simple rustics of the neighbourhood. Many uttered the question, "What does it all mean?" and very varied were the answers received. We have been favoured with two which are stamped with an originality quite their own. One sage rustic remarked that, "The parsons be out on strike." What the object of the strike might be; whether it was to secure an advance of pew rents, to oppose episcopal control, or to reduce the number of sermons per week, was of no concern to the bucolic mind. The answer was regarded as satisfactory by those who had not considered the chances of a clerical lock-out. Another wondrously wise individual was persuaded that "The parsons be met to change sermons;" and this solution of the problem was followed by the ready rejoinder, "Our parson gets the worst of it every time." However absurd these dialogues appear to our readers, they suggest the two-fold suspicion with which ordinary mortals regard the clergy, viz., that they are "ambitious of preferment for its gold" and preach other people's sermons. That the clergy have done much to provoke and even justify these suspicions, few will deny. The antipathy of the working classes to religion will retain its hold until their minds are disabused of these beliefs. Our regret is that all ministers are made to suffer in this way, as it is believed they are all tarred with the same brush. This is manifestly unjust and highly detrimental to the cause and progress of truth. Our business in

377

this paper is to deal with the question of vicarious preaching, not for the purpose of confirming the suspicion that many ministers preach what they never wrote, but to indicate the extent and the pernicious influence of the practice, and to call upon ministers to make as little use of written sermons as possible. We know that many men who can preach an effective written sermon are bewildered into the utterance of the merest twaddle if they attempt an extemporaneous address. When the habit of reading has been acquired the preacher is easily deluded into the belief that he cannot do without his manuscript; and so becomes the slave of his paper, but that this is a delusion many have proved. The most efficient preachers are those who think out their subject in the spirit of prayer, and allow their thoughts to clothe themselves in appropriate language under the inspiration of the hour. The man who talks to his people has the key to their hearts. Our own experience has taught us which method of preaching is the most effective. The ethical essay, polished in diction, may charm the intellectual few, but it is calculated to induce sleepiness in the many, whereas the "cut and thrust" sermon commands the attention of all, if only to parry the blows. Our immediate purpose is not to condemn the practice of reading, but to expose a class of delinquent preachers who, without acknowledging the obligation, piratically appropriate the labours of other men.

There are several sources of supply which are resorted to without any qualms of conscience by those who regard the Christian ministry in its professional aspect only. There are "Helps for the Pulpit" of every variety, and "Stems and Twigs" of the tree of doctrine. There are "Homilists," "Analysts," and "Lanterns," for pulpits and preachers, and there are "Hints" and "Outlines" in rich profusion. This ready-made material would supply the ministers of our churches for the next century if the art of sermon-making were lost to-day. We do not complain of the legitimate use of these helps any more than we should complain of an artist for gaining suggestions from the etchings of the masters; but when they are employed to such an extent as to supersede the study of the Bible, and to check the inventive faculty, we regard them as pernicious in the extreme.

Sermons of remote or obscure authors have been made to do duty in modern pulpits. It was the custom of a noted minister in London to treat his people occasionally to a sermon by the Reformers or the Puritans; but as he made no secret of the authorship his congregation were satisfied. Not many years since the fame of a new preacher was heard in all the churches. His sermons were regarded as masterpieces of pulpit eloquence, but his career was brought to an abrupt termination by the discovery that his preaching was vicarious, and that he was the living mouthpiece of divines who had lived generations back. A minister may presume that the members of his congregation, are ignorant of ordinary sermon literature, and if he be unscrupulous he will turn their ignorance to account. I have before me a sermon which a learned D.D. of the Establishment has both preached and published as his own, though he has taken it from a volume by a Baptist minister. Probably the doctor was pleased with the effort of his obscure Baptist brother, and thought his sermon worthy of being rescued from the comparative obscurity of a dissenting constituency, and, therefore, he delivered it to his own fleck in the ordinary course of his ministry. When he resolved to publish a volume he must either have forgotten the authorship of this particular sermon or ventured to run the risk of detection. In either case the doctor must be held blameable.

American and foreign sermons are in great demand by some preachers who do not scruple to preach them as their own. The chance of detection is slight, and the certain gain counterbalances the risk. Doubtless, in one respect, the congregations are the gainers, for no man would preach a stolen sermon inferior to his own. Three instances of gross plagiarism have come under our own notice. In the first, an Independent minister not only preached a sermon from the "American Preacher," but sent it for publication to a weekly religious

paper. It went forth to the world bearing the name of its English foster-parent, who must have feared detection from the moment he saw it in print, if he had any conscience. The publisher, being a personal friend of the preacher, refused to expose the gross deception when his attention was called to it. In the second instance a rector obtained his last sermon from the same source and preached it to his congregation. After his death it was published, with his name on the title page, as an appropriate memento. In the third instance, a clerk in holy orders delivered a sermon taken from the same volume to an audience in South London, and afterwards published it, with several flattering testimonials from the local clergy. Is it unfair to assume that such instances might be multiplied? We think not.

The occasional exchange of sermons by friends is a source of supply of which some avail themselves. We do not complain of this, provided due acknowledgement of the mutual obligation be made, but when this expedient is adopted, because men have not the industry to make all their own sermons we charge them with gross deception and forgery.

An advertiser, who styles himself a "Benetched Clergyman" offers to "lend his weekly sermons," which he describes as "original, earnest, evangelical," to any fellow cleric for "half-a-crown a-piece, or four for a post office order for ten shillings," but he adds an additional demand for "mutual confidence." This proviso suggests that the transaction will not bear the light, for if the business be legitimate why should he insist that it must be carried on with the utmost secrecy?

The demand for ready-made sermons has created a corresponding supply, and a thriving trade is carried on in these sacred wares. Circulars are issued soliciting subscriptions for single copies or a quarter's supply. Sermons, doctrinal, practical, and experimental are sent to order, also special sermons for anniversaries, and the successive festivals of the ecclesiastical year. Every variety of style is adopted to suit the elite of a west-end congregation or the unlettered ploughmen of a rural parish, and all the intermediate gradations of society, social and intellectual. In a circular before us we are offered sermons by "clergymen only of known ability and long parochial experience" at the following rates:—

| | £ | s. | d. |

| --- | --- | --- | --- |

| "A Quarter's Sermons | 0 | 15 | 6 |

| Or if paid at the commencement of the Quarter | 0 | 13 | 6 |

| A Specimen Sermon | 0 | 1 | 6 |

| Missionary Society, National School, Church Building, each | 0 | 2 | 6 |

| School Feast, Rifle Corps, Church Music, each | 0 | 5 | 0 |

| Visitation Sermon | 1 | 1 | 0 |

| Special Sermons as required." | | | |

A guarantee is given that "no duplicates will ever be sent into the immediate neighbourhood of a subscriber," and it is strictly enjoined that "no subscriber may lend any copy of a sermon, nor preach it out of his own parish without the consent of the editor." Thus the parties to the transaction mutually bind each other to prevent exposure of the deception. The sermons are lithographed in imitation of a plain hand-writing which is easily read, and which prevents the occupants of the gallery from indulging the suspicion that their pastor is preaching a discourse purchased for the occasion. We heard recently a Non-conformist minister make the following confession of one of the most daring expedients ever adopted. He said that, in his early days, he was a slave to his manuscript. On one occasion he found himself when some miles from home committed to an engagement to preach a special sermon. Not being provided with the usual sixteen pages 8vo. in deep mourning, and failing in his efforts to find a substitute or gain a release from his engagement,

379

he entered a bookseller's shop and selected a sermon by a popular divine which he purchased for a penny, and delivered to an admiring congregation with as much of energy, if not of satisfaction and comfort, as he would have done had it been his own. The trick was discovered, and, for several days afterwards, the study table of the delinquent parson literally groaned beneath the weight of the copies of the identical sermon sent anonymously through the post

There is no absolute guarantee of originality in an extemporaneous discourse, for we knew a minister who repeated from memory a sermon published by the Religious Tract Society in one of the largest chapels in London. The imposture being detected, the Secretary of the Local auxiliary duly supplied the members of the congregation with copies of the same sermon to the surprise of those who heard it.

We blush to record these facts, but their exposure will do no harm, and possibly may induce some young aspirant to the ministry to confirm the resolution to eschew manuscripts altogether and preach with as few written notes as possible. Earnest preaching is the great want of the age. Polished diction and florid rhetoric, if destitute of the unction which comes from conscious sincerity and divine assistance, will fall powerless on the ears of the congregation. No wonder the weakness of the modern pulpit has proved an attractive theme for social gossip and newspaper articles. The charge of weakness is easily sustained, and it is our firm conviction the secret lies in the fact that much of the preaching is vicarious. The questionable expedients to escape detection stamp the efforts of these plagiaristic parsons with the brand of insincerity, and conscious insincerity is a barrier to their usefulness. God cannot hold fellowship with those whose ways are not clean in his sight, nor smile upon their efforts. Those who regard their pulpit reputation as the primary consideration are actuated by a false motive, and must signally fail, sooner or later.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate