Menu
‹ Chapter 138 of 203 ›

SWORD AND THE TROWEL — September 1, 1872

18 min read · Chapter 138 of 203
SWORD AND THE TROWEL — September 1, 1872

Father Taylor, the Sailor Preacher.*

E remember a book bearing the title, "The Model Preacher," at least we remember the title of it, and that is sufficient for our purpose; for we question greatly whether there ever lived but one "Model Preacher," and whether the process of modelling in connection with preachers be not

among the "many inventions" which man has found out since he lost his uprightness. Let every man called of God to preach the word be as his Maker has fashioned him. Neither Paul, nor Apollos, nor Cephas are to be imitated by John; nor are John's ways, habits, and modes of of utterance to be the basis for a condemnation of any one or all of the other three. As God gives to every seed its own body as it rises from the soil, so to each man will he grant his own appropriate development, if he will but be content to let his inner self reveal itself in its true form. The good and the evil in men of eminence are both of them mischievous when they become objects of servile imitation; the good when slavishly copied is exaggerated into formality, and the evil becomes wholly intolerable. If each teacher of others went himself to the school of our one only Master, a thousand errors might be avoided.

With the previous paragraph before his mind's eye, the reader may safely accompany us as we take a survey of the ministerial history of

* Incidents and Anecdotes of Rev. Edward T. Taylor, for over Forty Years Pastor of the Seamen's Bethel, Boston. By Rev. Gilbert Haven and Hon. Thomas Russell. London: R. D. Dickinson.

25

a greatly useful, but highly eccentric man—"Father Taylor," the Sailor Preacher of Boston, in the United States. Not Father Taylor of California, who is a considerably younger man, but Edward Taylor, of the Bethel,—the man whom Charles Dickens thus described in the well-known passage in his "American Notes":—

"The only preacher I heard in Boston was Mr. Taylor, who addresses himself peculiarly to seamen, and who was once a mariner himself. I found his chapel down among the shipping, in one of the narrow, old, waterside streets, with a gay blue flag waving freely from its roof. In the gallery opposite to the pulpit were a little choir of male and female singers, a violoncello, and a violin. The preacher already sat in the pulpit, which was raised on pillars, and ornamented behind him with painted drapery of a lively and somewhat theatrical appearance. He looked a weather-beaten, hard-featured man, of about six or eight and fifty; with deep lines graven as it were into his face, dark hair, and a stern, keen eye. Yet the general character of his countenance was pleasant and agreeable.

"The service commenced with a hymn, to which succeeded an extemporary prayer. It had the fault of frequent repetition, incidental to all such prayers: but it was plain and comprehensive in its doctrines, and breathed a tone of general sympathy and charity, which is not so commonly a characteristic of this form of address to the Deity as it might be. That done, he opened his discourse, taking for his text a passage from the Song of Solomon, laid upon the desk before the commencement of the service by some unknown member of the congregation: 'Who is that that cometh up from the wilderness, leaning upon her beloved'?

"He handled this text in all kinds of ways, and twisted it into all manner of shapes; but always ingeniously, and with a rude eloquence, well adapted to the comprehension of his hearers. Indeed, if I be not mistaken, he studied their sympathies and understandings much more than the display of his own powers. His imagery was all drawn from the sea, and from the incidents of a seaman's life; and was often remarkably good. He spoke to them of "that glorious man, Lord Nelson," and of Collingwood; and drew nothing in, as the saying is, by the head and shoulders, but brought it to bear upon his purpose, naturally, and with a sharp mind to its effect. Sometimes, when much excited with his subject, he had an odd way—compounded of John Bunyan, and Balfour of Burley—of taking his great quarto Bible under his arm and pacing up and down the pulpit with it; looking steadily down, meantime, into the midst of the congregation. Thus, when he applied his text to the first assemblage of his hearers, and pictured the wonder of the church at their presumption in forming a congregation among themselves, he stopped short with his Bible under his arm in the manner I have described, and pursued his discourse after this manner:—

"'Who are these, who are they, who are these fellows? where do they come from? Where are they going to? Come from! What's the answer?' leaning out of the pulpit and pointing downward with his right hand: 'From below!' starting back again, and looking at the sailors before him: 'From below, my brethren, from under the hatches of sin, battened down above you by the evil one. That's where you come from!' a walk up and down the pulpit: 'and where are you going?' stopping abruptly: 'where are you going? Aloft!' very softly, and pointing upward: 'Aloft!' louder: 'Aloft!' louder still: 'That's where you are going, with a fair wind, all taut and trim, steering direct for heaven in its glory, where there are no storms or foul weather, and where the wicked cease from troubling and the weary are at rest.' Another walk: 'That's where you're going to, my friends. That's it. That's the place. That's the port. That's the haven. It's a blessed harbour—still water there, in all changes of the winds and tides; no driving ashore upon the rocks, or slipping your cables and running out to sea, there: Peace, peace, peace, all

391

peace!' Another walk, and putting the Bible under his left arm: 'What! these fellows are coming from the wilderness are they? Yes. From the dreary blighted wilderness of iniquity, whose only crop is Death. But do they lean upon anything—do they lean upon nothing, these poor seamen?' Three raps upon the Bible: 'Ah, yes. Yes. They lean upon the arm of their beloved,' three more raps: 'upon the arm of their beloved,'—three more, and a walk: 'Pilot, guiding star, and compass all in one, to all hands—here it is'—three more: 'Here it is. They can do their seaman's duty manfully, and be easy in their minds in the utmost peril and danger, with this'—two more: 'They can come, even these poor fellows can come, from the wilderness leaning on the arm of their beloved, and go up—up,' raising his hand higher and higher, at every repetition of the word, so that he stood with it at last stretched above his head, regarding them in a strange, rapt manner, and pressing the book triumphantly to his breast, until he gradually subsided into some other portion of his discourse.

"I have cited this, rather as an instance of the preacher's eccentricities than his merits, though, taken in connection with his look and manner, and the character of his audience, even this was striking. It is possible, however, that my favourable impression of him may have been greatly influenced and strengthened, firstly, by his impressing upon his hearers that the true observance of religion was not inconsistent with a cheerful deportment and an exact discharge of the duties of their station, which, indeed, it scrupulously required of them: and, secondly, by his cautioning them not to set up any monopoly in Paradise and its mercies. I never heard these two points so wisely touched (if indeed I have ever heard them touched at all), by any preacher of that kind before."

We are not so enamoured of Charles Dickens as to consider his verdict upon a preacher to be of any very material consequence with reference to the man's real usefulness: but as a judge of vivacity of manner, and power of style no better critic could be found. He, above most men, knew what would win the attention and touch the heart. For the innermost music which belongs to the world of the regenerate he did not claim an appreciation; his judgment exercised itself in another court, where we regard its dicta with respect.

This extract at once marks out Mr. Taylor as eccentric, and renders it all the more imperative that he should not be made a model. He was a man of his own order,—a glorious order too, but an order of one. He who should imitate him would not become a copy but a caricature. Mr. Taylor commenced his preaching while a prisoner of war in the hands of the English, at Dartmoor, and his discourses as a captive gave prophetic intimations of his future style. They were racy, and overflowed with mother wit. The sermon in which he mixed up George III., and the Prince of Darkness was such as none but an original preacher could have delivered. The text was "a poor and wise child is better than an old and foolish king."

"The youth began, blundering and tangled, but with the root of the matter in him: which root suddenly burst forth into rich blossoms and fruit. As he poured forth the river of his speech, and described the old and foolish king, with burning words of sarcasm and illustration, they all trembled for themselves and their youthful preacher; for his Boston—Richmond blood was up. The king their fathers had fought, for eight weary years, from whom they had wrested their independence, was then, though an idiot, 'old and foolish,' waging war against the sons of their fathers, and holding him and his associates fast in his

cruel chains. He blazed in similes, describing such a character. He fired broadside after broadside of wit and seriousness into the sinking craft. Seeing the peril in which his epithets were placing him, he cried out: 'You think I mean King George, I don't, I mean the Devil.' This hit was worse than all that preceded it, and set him down at once for being as adroit as he was bold, as capable of firing Parthian arrows as advancing shots. The officers could have found no fault with such a retreat, and the prisoners exulted in its tact and point. He was instantly voted their chaplain; and a note was sent to the Commandant petitioning for the privilege of having their own praying and preaching done by their fellow-captive. It was granted. Thus he began his life-work among his own brothers of the sea, in the hold of a prison-vessel, himself a prisoner."

When he obtained his liberty, and returned to his native land, he itinerated in the double capacity of pedlar and preacher,—a sort of spiritual Dr. Marigold, buying old rags, and extolling the robe of righteousness, selling tin wares and blowing the silver trumpet. In those days, one of his famous texts was, "Buy the truth and sell it not." His first regular recognised official holding-forth was before a quarterly Methodist Conference, assembled to judge whether or no he should receive a license to preach. It has been reported that upon this occasion he had the coolness to select as his text the words, "By the life of Pharaoh, surely ye are spies;" but his biographer says that although those words might have been worked into the sermon, the real text was a more humble but equally singular one, "I pray thee, let me live." He adds, that the triers saw that his fervour and talents were more than an offset for his defects: and, in answer to his prayer, they "let him live." We do not see how they could have done otherwise, for no Conference would have been strong enough to kill him. His tongue had been touched by a fire which no critics could quench: and had their verdict been against him the flame would but have burned the more fiercely.

After itinerating for some few years, the man and his mission met, and Father Taylor took up his abode in Boston, as a minister of the Methodist Episcopal Church, specially set apart to labour among sailors. His chapel, at first, held about five hundred hearers, and was immediately filled to its utmost capacity. He began in 1828 in full revival vigour, frequently preaching four times a day. He was then young, full of animal spirits, ardent, daring, and at the same time intensely desirous to do good. To him it never occurred to polish his style, and prune away its power: he spoke as his heart prompted him, and wrought as the Holy Spirit moved him. He did work enough for two men, and had a double blessing upon it. In a very short time Boston felt his power, and its wealth and culture were at his feet as well as its poverty and roughness. A noble Bethel was built for him, a house of large dimensions, a fit sphere for his operations. At the opening services, he said, "America is the centre of the world, and the centre of America is Boston, and the centre of Boston is North Square, and the centre of North Square is the Bethel." No man succeeds who has a mean idea of the sphere which he occupies. If a true man should find himself placed by Providence in Little Mudlicot, he would soon discover some peculiarities in the position which

393

would entitle it to his best exertions. Mudlicot to Father Taylor would have been the hub of the universe. As it was, "he made 'the Bethel' famous in all lands. He made that familiar name his own, so that, since Jacob, no one has arisen with whom that word was so closely identified as with Father Taylor. 'The Bethel' was no other seaman's chapel. It was his alone. He and it were almost synonymous terms. He was the Bethel, the Bethel was he. If a sailor in any part thought of one, he thought of the other. The blue and white flag that floated over it seemed to dance before the wandering eyes of mariners under every sky. The mighty man of God who preached beneath its folds equally presented himself to those floating souls at every port."

It was not at all wonderful that sailors especially, and other classes of the community in proportion, should flock to hear Mr. Taylor, for he was a man of great human sympathies, manly, bold, honest, childlike and outspoken; and, withal, a man on fire with love to Christ and perishing souls. His preaching never could be dull, the intense white heat of his nature prevented that. He was in earnest beyond all measure, and commanded the attention of all around him for that very reason. No ideas of propriety, or notions of delicacy, hung about him like fetters; he spoke to sailors, not to squeamish pomposities, and to "the sons of Zebulon" he poured out his great heart in a homely eloquence, which was all on flame. One who heard him in 1835, said of him—"His eloquence was marvellous: his control over the audience seemed almost absolute. Tears and smiles chased each other over our faces, like the rain and sunshine of an April day. Two characteristics gave tone and power to his marvellous eloquence. He had one of the most brilliant imaginations that ever sparkled and burned. His sermon was all poetry, though it came in bursts and jets of flame. It was like the dance of the aurora, changing all the while from silver flame to purple, and back again. But the secret of his magnetic power was not here; it was in his overflowing sympathies, that leaped over all barriers, and had no regard for time or place. There was no wall of formality between him and his hearers, any more than if he were talking to each one of us in a private room. He would single out a person in his audience, and talk to him individually, with the same freedom as if he met him in the street. 'Ah! my jolly tar,' turning to a sailor who happened at that moment to catch his eye, 'here you are, in port again; God bless you! See to your helm, and you will reach a fairer port by-and-by. Hark! don't you hear the bells of heaven over the sea?'"

The ludicrous was allowed considerable play in his discourses, and we think rightly so. Many count the use of humour to be unlawful in the pulpit, but our belief is, that the exclusion of it is far worse. There is no more sin nor virtue in a laugh than in a cry. To the pure mind, none of the powers of our manhood are common or unclean. Humour can be consecrated, and should be. We grant that it is a power difficult to manage, but when it is under proper control, it more than repays for all the labour spent upon it. Children do sad damage with gunpowder, but what a force it is when a wise man directs its energy. Mr. Taylor made men laugh that they might weep. He touched one natural chord, that he might be able to touch another:

whereas, some preachers are so unnatural themselves, that the human nature of their hearers refuses to subject itself to their operations. O ye who are evermore decorously dull, before ye judge a man whose loving ministry conducted thousands to the skies, think how immeasurable above you all he soared, and remember that with all his violations of your wretched regulations, he was one whom the Lord delighted to honour. Farthing candles rail at the sun for his spots, while they cannot be sure that those spots are not excessive light; and may be quite sure of another thing, that, spots or no spots, ten thousand such glimmers as theirs are not worthy to be compared with the stray beams of the great orb of day.

At the prayer-meetings Father Taylor was most at home, and, like a father in his family, cast off all restraint, and unveiled his inner nature with child-like unguardedness. Here we have a string of strange odd bits, such us must have made the meetings all alive.

His ejaculations were not always flattering. "Everyone has heard of the wealthy gentleman who, in the midst of a very warm meeting, made a speech, telling the sailors how much had been done for them, and how grateful they ought to be to the liberal merchants for all their goodness. As he sat down, with a feeling that the church would run itself for that year on this condescension, he was surprised by the enquiry, 'Is there any other old sinner from up in town who would like to say a word before we go on with the meeting.'

A visitor who was telling at a meeting an appropriate anecdote, which had appeared in all the religious newspapers of the country, was startled by Father Taylor's singing out, 'Lord deliver us from stale bread!' And still another, who was slow and dry in speech, was encouraged by the prayer, 'Lubricate, Lord, lubricate.'

One of his most remarkable displays of this kind was after an address by a visitor, who related the death of a very wicked man, a hardened sinner, who was blown up a few days before in one of his own powder-mills at Wilmington. He came down all crushed and mangled, and gave his heart to God; and now who would not say with the holy man of old, 'Let me die the death of the righteous, and let my last end be like his?' Father Taylor rose at one. 'I don't want any trash brought unto this altar. I hope none of my people calculate on serving the devil all their lives and cheating him with their dying breath. Don't look forward to honouring God by giving him the last snuff of an expiring candle. Perhaps you will never be blown up in a powder-mill.' 'That holy man,' he continued, 'that we heard of was Balaam, the meanest scoundrel mentioned in the Old Testament or the New. And now I hope we shall never hear anything more from Balaam, nor from his ass.'

Upon another occasion a brother in the meeting was suffering from severe temptation, and after a full account of his exercises, was advised to take courage from his own experience: 'For,' says Father Taylor, 'the devil was never known to chase a bag of chaff! You may be sure that there is pure wheat in your heart, or the Old Serpent would not be after you so hard.'

As he was going away to Europe, he gave the church a charge, and said, 'Brethren, you'll of course have some quarrel while I'm gone. Now, begin to quarrel with your sins. I give you full scope. Begin

395

now, and keep it up till I come back, or till you haven't one sin left.' When a brother from another church, who was afterwards associated with the Bethel meeting, and attended on Father Taylor through all his last hours, had spoken in meeting, Father Taylor introduced him by saying, 'He's an old navigator; he has given the devil the slip a thousand times, and worked dead to the windward of him, with the leeboard of grace from the Lord Jesus Christ.'

His own prayers were at all times most original, and were more like the utterances of an Oriental, abounding in imagery, than a son of these colder western climes. Think of his prayer at the dedication of a new church, "If any man attempts to sow heresy in this pulpit, or to preach aught but Christ and him crucified, Lord drive him out of the house and sweep his tracks off the floor." The Sunday before he was to sail for Europe, in his prayer he was entreating the Lord to care well for his children during his absence, meaning the Church. All at once he stopped and ejaculated, "What have I done? Distrust the Providence of heaven! A God that gives a whale a ton of herrings for a breakfast, will he not care for my children?" and then went on, closing his prayer in a more confiding strain.

Father Taylor, despite his willingness to pursue any and every reform which promised benefit to the poor people among whom he laboured, did not make the ordinances of Christ subservient to Total Abstinence, but kept things in their right places. His opinion of those abominable mixtures styled "unfermented wines" by some people, but more properly called "Essence of Stomach-ache," was exactly our own. He called the stuff "raisin water," which errs as a title in the direction of being too complimentary. So deeply did he lay this to heart that one of his last addresses contained the following admonition:—"When I am laid in the grave, I want the ordinance of the Lord's supper administered in the very same way in which the Saviour was not too good to administer it. I want the emblems of the body broken and the blood shed just as they came from my Master's hands; and, in my name, cast from this church any man who would come up to the altar with his dye-stuff."

Upon Father Taylor the common plague of ministers fell with its usual force. He was the victim of callers and gossips. He says himself that his "life was very much like that of a bear climbing a greased pole. He had his study and his books, and he was often among them; but, by the time he had opened one his door-bell would ring, and he must go down, hear a long yarn, and then bow the interrupter out as gracefully as possible, and then return to his books; but by the time one is again fairly opened, the door-bell jingles again, and down he goes scratching is head, and often not a little out of humour: and thus his life is spent in going from his study to the door, and from his door to his study."

"His work in one peculiar field is not generally known. Living at the North End, near by the lowest haunts of vice, he was often called to attend the sick-bed, the death-bed, and the funerals of the most wretched and abandoned of women. Protected by his eccentricity and his purity alike from any shadow of suspicion, shielded from all danger by his utter ignorance of fear, he always obeyed such a summons. At

all hours of the day or night he visited the foulest haunts of crime in this noble service; never with one harsh word for the fallen, never with any apology for their crime. A record of his prayers on such occasions would add vast treasures to the wealth of the Christian world. His warnings against trusting to a death-bed repentance were reserved for vigorous and prosperous offenders; but, when the sinner's life was ending in agony, he never forget that the first convert of his Master's cross was a thief, and that his first promise of pardon was given to a harlot.

He received many warnings, some anonymous, against venturing on such errands. The only notice that he ever took of such warnings was to lay aside his cane, which was elsewhere his constant companion, but which he never took with him when he visited the cellars and garrets of North Street. This was simple courage in the Christian soldier; but it was also the wisest prudence."

It grieves one's heart to relate that after many years of glorious service Father Taylor gradually withered. He faded by degrees during ten long years, losing slowly all his powers. It was as the Lord would have it, but, indeed, it seemed a sad way of ending a glorious career. To drift about as a poor hulk, with the armament removed, and the light in the binnacle extinguished, was very grievous both to the old man and his friends, and we sympathise with the Rev. Mark Trafton when he said, "How I wish he could have gone down after one of his tremendous broadsides, shaking the ship from kelson to truck, every spar quivering, and her colours nailed to the mast! or that a spark might have reached the magazine, blowing her in a moment to invisible atoms! or that in one of his adventurous flights to the upper regions, in full career, putting spurs to lightning, in his own startling phrase, he could have slipped in out of sight while we stood gazing after him, like the prophet of old."

So passed away one whom Emerson called one of the two greatest poets of the United States. He was a Pædobaptist, an Arminian, and a man of a thousand divergences from our line of things, which we believe to be more Scriptural than his, but, for all that, upon the coffin of a good man and true, with no grudging hand we cast a funeral wreath, and say, "Would God there were others who could fill his place!"

C. H. SPURGEON.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate