Menu
‹ Chapter 142 of 203 ›

Clergy and Laity

9 min read · Chapter 142 of 203

THERE are three main ways in which the relations between minister and people may be adjusted. The first is to reduce the minister into a condition of utter dependence, subjection, and servility to his flock, by taking him from the position of a leader and turning him into a mere fag. A picture in the Royal Academy's exhibition of a season or two ago not unaptly represented the nominal leadership, but real slavery, wherein many a holy man is well nigh tortured to death. A guide was portrayed in the act of conducting a party of soldiers over a trackless swamp. He is a little in advance, picking his steps with evident painfulness and precision, while the band of armed men press on close behind with bayonets pointed in dangerous proximity to his bending, jaded person. He is a guide, he looks like a fugitive. The next is to make the minister a master, a lord of God's heritage, by investing him with sacerdotal supremacy, enthroning him in an authority absolute, uncontrollable, and unapproachable, and reducing the people of his charge into a blindly submissive flock of followers. The third is to regard both the minister and the church as respectively possessing inalienable rights, which are not of themselves antagonistic, and may be exercised in their different spheres with perfect harmony, and without

417

the one impairing or curtailing the other. This last method at once strikes every judicious mind with a sense of equity, and appeals to every practical man as an arrangement capable of contributing to the highest good of all. Instead of setting one oar to work, and keeping the other inactive, it puts both the right and the left oar into fair and equal motion, that from both sides the propelling force may come to speed the good boat by an even course over the waters.

In the bustle and hurry of church activity, or in the apathy and obstruction of church stagnation, it is impossible always to maintain this theoretical balance of power. The "come" and "go," the "give" and "take," the ceaseless action and reaction of countless influences ever stirring in church life, are sure to tilt for a while the authority of the pastor or the church into undue preponderance. The vast variety, too, of the circumstances of the churches, the diversity of the gifts and temperaments of the pastors, preclude the possibility of laying down any hard and fast law with regard to their individual functions. Love is the only divinely given bond to bind every man in his appointed place, and all in one harmonious whole. Nevertheless, it cannot be disguised, and must never be overlooked, that the very absence of precisely defined rules has allowed such scope to the designing and ambitious, that the powers safely entrusted by the people to the sincere and honest have been turned by the unscrupulous into whips of scorpions; and the liberties and prerogatives frankly and cheerfully accorded to the meek have grown, through the manipulations of the tyrannical, into iron bands. The successors of presbyters have sunk into prelates, and the successors of pastors have degenerated into popes. The fact of such a development, or rather degeneracy, having been possible, doubtless points to an inherent fault in the churches themselves. No such steps as these could ever be taken did there exist in the churches a strong consciousness of freedom, an intelligent view of their rights, duties, and responsibilities. No error could be thrust upon them did they themselves uphold the truth. No strange ritual could be instituted among them did they maintain the primitive simplicity of worship. No doubtful practices could be started in their midst did they cherish in their hearts and lives the wholesome precepts of Christ and his apostles.

But here is the very pith of the difficulty. The vast crowd of church members do not independently investigate the evidences, principles, doctrines, and facts of our faith. Many, and these often the most amiable and beautiful in their lives, are led rather by a Christian instinct, than by an enlightened Christian intelligence. Could the average members be well instructed, thoroughly grounded in the great leading truths of our common Christianity, so strong a breakwater would hereby be formed that the waves of clerical aggression might beat against it in vain. But when church members cannot give a reason for "the hope that is in them," even "the lame" can make them an easy prey. Yet the real strength of the pastor resides in the vigour of the people. Wherever the pastors have gained head against the people, wherever they have succeeded in centralising the power in their own hands to the silencing or weakening of the voice of the people, wherever they have grown through combination into the conviction and practice that they constitute the church, at that point poison has touched the body,

as the angel smote Herod, and the thews and sinews of its strength for holy enterprise have shrunk into feebleness and corruption.

In sharp contrast with this elevation of a class to the detriment of the whole, the unwearied tenderness of apostles and apostolic men towards the individual members of churches rises before us. Throughout the New Testament there are descriptions scattered here and there, which, could the reality underlying them be reached and fully brought into view, would appear in many respects to the easy going ecclesiastics of the present day, novel and extraordinary. The very names and epithets, fresh gathered from the social, political, or, in one or two instances, from the religious world around, which the first pastors appropriated to themselves, denote a depth and intensity of self-abnegation and devotedness to the kingdom of Christ and to the meanest of his followers, that would startle and scandalise the common-place piety of the day. When the apostle took up the epithet ὕνθος, slave—which is rather euphemistically rendered servant in our version—and applied it to his relation, position, and service in the churches as well as in reference to Christ, we seem to forget that it was in those days, as in our own, a word steeped in the dark dye of degradation, connected with all that is most despicable, low, and benighted in our race. The word ὑπρὶρν, minister, is certainly a step above doulos, but still connected with drudgery, servility, and the most menial offices, hardly ever rising, except in princely and imperial households, to a degree of moderate respectability. It by no means blunts the edge of these epithets to say that in princely households servants reflected some beams of their master's dignity, and consequently Paul must have been invested before the eyes of others with highest honour as the minister of Christ. Alas! Christ was then a prince unacknowledged, despised, unknown; the world had executed him; and his minister was accounted the off-scouring of all things. Yet the apostle and his fellow workers took kindly, cheerily, loyally to the usage they received, and to the names that best of all described their services. Nowhere in their writings is there found a single hint, except in condemnation, of that arrogant ambition which soon afterwards sprouted forth, and bore such fatal fruit among the churches of the East and West. Even when they assume the titles bestowed upon them by the Lord, they wear them in a spirit so meek that they seem jealous lest a single spark of pride should be visible in the exercise of their authority.

As "Pastors," they take heed to feed the flock; as "Overseers" or "Bishops," they abstain from the very appearance of being lords over God's heritage; as "Ambassadors," they beseech; as "Fathers," they carry their spiritual children in their arms. How easily the thorough ecclesiastic could find in these epithets, even in the mildest of them, a pretext for the most unbounded pretensions, is seen by a single example. Chrysostom is discoursing with great fervour in his treatise De Sacerdotis, concerning love to Christ as the noblest of all passions that can animate the human breast, when in a moment he glances off with the proud prelatic words—after saying that he who has the oversight of souls must be like Saul among the Hebrews—"Not only must I seek here for the measure of head and shoulders, but as great as the difference is between rational men and irrational animals, so

419

great let the distance be between the Pastor and the people of his charge, not to say even greater." But another magic word is needed, and the only equipment needed by the shepherd is a staff; the clearest mark of a bishop is a mitre; the most conspicuous feather in the ambassador's character is his thirst for homage due exclusively to his master; and the infallible sign of the spiritual father is his strenuous endeavour to keep all the Christian world in a state of spiritual babyhood. Of these encroachments on the liberties of the people, the words clergy and laity, remain in our tongue to this day, as unmistakable proofs. They are both derived from a Greek source, clergy from κληρος a lot or inheritance, and laity, from λαος the people. Throughout Christendom the ministers of religion styled themselves the heritage of God—his peculiar treasure. With equal modesty and hardihood they termed all others laity, and in process of time, ingenious minds, finding that laos, people, was too respectable an origin for this word, they added insult to injury by inventing a new paternity for it in laas, a stone. Concerning the influence of these words, we are not disposed to set on foot any new theory, like that of the philosopher, who attributed all the diseases, to which human flesh is heir, to the universal use of salt. Yet the trite observations that the world is ruled by names, and I suppose the Church too, receives a singular illustration in the history of the words in question, for the men who wielded them succeeded in turning the Church upside down. Even in our own day the spell and glamour of clergy and laity are not quite broken, but hold fragments of their ancient mystic force over some who lay claim to an eminent share of the intelligence and religion of the community.

At present the general question is one of most vital importance to all sections of the church of Christ. For it is impossible to close the eyes to the strong tendency setting in in several quarters to isolate ministers of the gospel more and more from the people, and to invest them with at least some of the characteristics of a distinct class or caste. By such means it is easy to perceive important ends would be secured. The official might be trained into a better official, and a closer solidarity between individuals of the same profession might awaken and sustain a more enthusiastic esprit de corps, their interests might be more sedulously advanced and protected, and in some respects a more imposing array might be presented, and a stronger influence might be brought to bear upon the external phases of society. But these are not such unalloyed good things as to hinder one from looking their decidedly pernicious consequences straight in the face. For the ground cannot be widened between minister and people without the people taking less interest in his work, and giving him less sympathy and help. Isolation from the people produces in the pastor ignorance of their mental and spiritual condition, their habits of thought and life, and takes out of his hand one of the main keys wherewith the door is to be opened for his appeals to their reason and conscience. The attitude of separate classes to one another is ever that of rule or subjection—division destroys equality. But the relation of Christian to Christian in church fellowship, and especially of the Christian minister to his people, is founded on brotherhood, and everything that makes him less a brother renders him less fit to be a minister. Finally, it is impossible to sever from such a

class the semblance and some of the traits of sacerdotalism. Their natural development is more of the priest, less of the pastor.

Happily, our churches are well constituted to resist and repel all pretensions of this kind, should they ever approach our borders. The church members are not helpless before the majesty of an Act of Parliament or a judgment of the Privy Council: they have a sharp and effective remedy always at hand. So strong, so omnipotent, are they in their control over their own affairs that it almost seems that excess of jealousy regarding their individual rights makes them shy of combining to secure the common objects of the denomination. Were this extreme narrowness of spirit abandoned, and ministers and delegates entrusted by the churches with distinct powers, then the manifold empty and irresponsible discussions of Association and Union meetings might give place to grave and fruitful deliberations, which would tend to call forth to a greater extent the latent resources of the churches for the practical advancement of the kingdom of Christ. While thus far concessions might be wisely made to the exigencies of the time, no one need unfasten his hold of these four truths which ever stand as immutable supports of the rights of the disciple and the liberties of the church:—First, that no vicarious function is committed to the minister which is not equally allowed to the humblest disciple; secondly, that no mystic secrets are entrusted to him which are not open to all the faithful; thirdly, that no superior sanctity belongs to him, which is not also attainable by all: and, fourthly, that there is no divine favour exclusively shown to him which is not the portion of all those who truly seek God's face.

DEMOS.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate