Infidelity in London — By G. Holden Pike.* — [Part Ii.]
IT appears to be so much easier to believe in an eternal Creator and Governor of all things than in any of the infidel systems, specious as some of them may be, that we half wonder why scientific men do not more often take refuge in Christianity, if merely for the sake of escaping from the real difficulties which must beset them in the mazy paths of their own choosing. The much-talked-about "Natural Selection," and "Development," so far from making hard things plainer, and natural phenomena more easily understood, carry with them such surprising difficulties as are absolutely dumfoundering to common minds, though even contradictions may weigh light as feathers with those great votaries of science who reign in an atmosphere never breathed by the vulgar multitude. To select only one difficulty—human speech. Could speech ever have been "developed" gradually and surely from the utterances of primeval mammalia? Does saying it could have been so developed abolish any difficulties? We have an answer ready to our hand in the volume on Modern Scepticism previously quoted: "Let us conceive the whole race of man to be, and to have been from the beginning, not indeed deaf, but congenitally and irreversibly dumb, with no more power of articulate expression than a horse, or let us say a dog. What would the development of human reason have been under such conditions? How, then, is it possible to conceive that the wondrous faculty and instrument of speech was ever invented and
* Our excellent contributor is alone answerable for the facts of his own papers. We have not the shadow of a doubt as to his accuracy, but we prefer to leave each article which bears a name to the responsibility of the writer himself.—ED.
perfected by mammals of infra-human faculty and development, and that they were afterwards through this invention developed yet more highly, until they attained to the dignity and advancement of humanity? Such infra-human mammals must have been more miraculously endowed in order to such an invention than ever man himself has been."
But to return to our immediate subject. London infidels are in many instances found to be extremely bitter in maintaining their opinions, and to be even offensive in their opposition to gospel truth. Men who will call loudly enough for mercy in the hour of threatening death, may be seen laughing and mocking among dissolute companions during public services in the street. But ignorant infidels are not alone to be blamed: they are rather to be pitied as the dupes of more knowing deceivers. We must go in the spirit of true philanthropists to the many-headed spring of the evil, and then instead of wasting time and strength over anything short of effective effort, we shall do what we are able in counteracting the stream of poison poured forth. It is a thing to be lamented, on their own account no less than on account of the country at large, that the working classes of London, as well as of other cities, should be imposed upon by numbers of small democrats, and noisy half-educated lecturers, who, often through being pecuniarily interested in their work, apparently derive a kind of satisfaction in dispersing their blighting doctrines, and in so destroying the happiness and usefulness of those whom they deceive. These infidel lecturers find much to say about the "Intolerance of Christianity," and, to make their position stronger, their creed includes some large professions of fair play, though their own narrow bigotry continually appears on the surface.
Some few years ago, there flourished a certain undertaker in London, who being afflicted with the common disease of furor loquendi made quite a pastime of "holding forth" in an institution near his home classically designated the Athenæum. This Athenæum was a rendezvous for infidels of the district, and lectures against Christianity were frequently given. The gifted savant, though an undertaker, made some professions of charity and liberality, and also delighted to pass among all men as a person of straightforward integrity. He would doubtless have regarded with high scorn any who supposed that he could descend to a mean or underhand subterfuge. But with what inquisitive eyes some people do go about. It did not escape the notice of a certain city missionary, also signally gifted in readiness of speech, and who visited thereabout, that this cultured undertaker had caused the device of "I. H. S." to be inscribed and borne upon his hearses! What? Was not this appropriation of a Christian motto a little inconsistent? The inquisitive missionary decided on going to the Athenæum, thinking he could find something to say bearing on the subject, and something which might benefit a congregation of infidels, though it might fall far short of the soaring intellect of the speaker-in-chief. Accordingly a night was set apart for this purpose of visitation, when the undertaker was found to be lecturing, and lecturing too on so original, if not striking, a theme as "Found!—a Better Book than the Bible!" Nor was the subject alone remarkable. Some of the able lecturer's remarks were uttered with a profane boldness at
539
which probably some of the less-seasoned frequenters of the Athenæum shuddered, while only listening. He said; "Jesus Christ never died to save man, and man needs no Saviour, nor is there any truth in Christianity, because so many of its professors are inconsistent." The inquisitive and ready-tongued city missionary heard these extraordinary utterances, and his tingling ears and heart-swelling indignation appear to have occasioned his sitting uneasily in his chair. The undertaker was evidently mistaken, as all undertakers are liable to become mistaken when they thus neglect their business to handle theological difficulties; and why should not a city missionary, meek Christian though he might be, set even a great tradesman right. He rose in the body of the hall: the eyes of the audience were turned in one direction, curious to see what so humble a creature would do. First, there would of course be a faint cheer; then a good many hisses, all of which were needless, for the intruder wished merely to tell a little story. Had even extreme boldness been needed, that missionary would have been equal to the occasion, for he has spoken of Christ in the more than plague-stricken wards of the Lock Hospital, so that a room filled with infidels could not equal the horrors of the former place. Now, however, he desires to take exception to those words of the undertaker just quoted, e. g.: "At the time of the French Revolution the leaders adopted the motto, 'Death is an eternal sleep.' This motto they placed over their public buildings, their churches and their tombs. Now, if I as a Christian teacher had gone to France at that time, and adopted the Atheistical motto, and placed it over my door for the sake of getting into favour with the infidels, what would you have thought of me?" This was a straightforward appeal to manly self-respect, and as such was easily comprehended by the cultured intellects of the Athenæum. What punishment would have been deserved under such circumstances as those described? The response came ringing from all parts of the hall, "You ought to have been scouted." An advantage was undoubtedly gained when the people answered just as the speaker desired. But what of that? All frequenters of the Athenæum were safe enough. When or where were Free-thinkers ever found dealing in such double-faced humbug as corresponded to that French revolution illustration? Very good. And now Mr. Missionary has something further to say: "You are all very right, I ought. But your lecturer is guilty of precisely such a crime! He has adopted the Christian's motto, 'I. H. S.,' which means 'Jesus the Saviour of men'; and he has put this motto on his Gothic hearses. Now let him first go home and pull off that motto, before he comes here to find fault with Christians for their inconsistency with their principles; for as long as he has that motto on his hearses you must necessarily regard him as himself an inconsistent man." The able undertaker did not go to the Athenæum in any way prepared for this surprising turning of the tables. The hubbub of confusion which ensued, however, may at least have supplied an excuse for his remaining silent.
But our friend had not yet done with diverting adventures. The Christian missionary who thus presumed to baffle a public character, seemed ever to stand in the way, ready to spoil the effects of that public character's best efforts. The paltry affair of merely placing religious
devices on hearses might soon be forgotten, were that all. It was not all! This missionary's memory, joined to the fund of illustration he possessed, made his presence even more than undesirable. It was absolutely annoying. But men of knowledge and influence must hold on their way and preserve their temper. The undertaker won a living among Christians, so that it would, perhaps, suit his policy not to be too hard. He would still lecture, but it should next be on the more liberal subject of "The Benevolence of those who have rejected Christianity." Benevolence among Atheists? Yes; though a man be an unbeliever, and even an unbelieving undertaker, it is pleasant to pass through the world as a genial and large-hearted fellow. The lecture was delivered, and scarcely had the cheers of an admiring audience died away, than that ubiquitous meddlesome city missionary was, as usual, on his legs. What! Another story? Yes, Mr. Missionary had another story to tell, a very seasonable one, too, for it was illustrative of "The benevolence shown by men who have rejected Christianity." He said: "A poor family lost several of their children in succession by scarlet fever, which occasioned them great pecuniary distress. At their request I waited on the undertaker they employed, to beg of him to reduce his charges on the last interment on account of their distress. He was out. I saw his wife, but she positively refused to do so, and would not abate one penny. I had therefore to raise the money among my friends who professed Christianity. But the undertaker was an infidel." Shouts of "Name!" from the indignant auditors were now heard. "Shall I tell you the name of the man?" continued the speaker. The only reply was "Name!" "That man," replied the missionary, finishing his speech: "That man was your lecturer, and this is the practical confirmation of what he has been telling you." Thus the good work of the itinerant evangelist proceeds. It is a warfare both offensive and defensive, and great victories are not wanting.
In these infidel lecture-rooms the agents of the City Mission do more than speak; they distribute hundreds of tracts and handbills on the fallacies of infidelity. With few exceptions these are taken by the men, though occasionally the spirit of unbelief is shown, when the distributors of the little messengers have their papers thrown back to them. Or a venturesome Atheist may perhaps offer to dispute on a given evening, and then, when actually pressed to do so, will find that he has miscalculated his strength, and so makes a timely retreat. On one evening, a man, whose hairs were become grey in a bad service, rose to give an account of an experiment tried by a certain surgeon, who, sympathising with the advanced liberalism, magnanimously devoted a few spare hours of his valuable time to the furtherance of "science." This enlightened surgeon minutely examined the brains of several dead persons in order to discover traces of mind! His researches were completely unsuccessful, and therefore was it not plain to any but the most unreasonable and prejudiced, that mind or spirit become extinct at death? Now, an argument so curiously original against the doctrine of the soul's immortality, might have passed current with customary honours had it not been for a circumstance, perhaps unforeseen on the part of the speaker. That same meddlesome and talkative evangelist, who had ventured even to rebuke a literary
511
undertaker, happened to be present, and, as might have been expected, he neutralised the intended effect of the last speaker's words, appropriating as his own what fun the discussion afforded. "Your surgeon," he said, "was as great a fool as the boy who cut the bellows open to see where the wind came from, and one experiment proves as much as the other!"
Secularism was started in London some years ago, and probably this specious system has been more readily embraced than some others by persons who have received religious trainings and backslidden from early teaching. Secularism would seem to be a sort of middle-way, into which the doubting are invited to walk. It does not shock people's finer instincts like Atheism, and has not so many subtle turns to exercise and perplex feeble intellects as Pantheism. Its leading doctrine is,—make the most of this life, eat, drink and enjoy yourself, for you know nothing about any other state beyond the present world. In fact, Secularism is a short-life-and-a-merry-one kind of creed, and one such as is likely to be embraced by those who are ready to accept any second-hand belief which grants them licence to indulge in sensual gratification. It professes to make the most of life; but, probably, not a few by embracing its principles, have made the worst possible use of this world, even in pecuniary matters!
Many who read these lines may perhaps remember the dingy little depôt in Fleet-sreet, whence, during some years, the publications of Secularism emanated; and which, happily, in course of time was necessarily closed. The organ of the system, The Reasoner, was issued weekly at a penny, and was then started as a full-priced weekly newspaper, until, through lack of support, its publication was discontinued, the office being now occupied by ordinary publishers. All right-thinking Christians must regret that men like some of the leading exponents of Secularism—men whose knowledge and abilities eminently fit them to act as the friends and the guides of the working classes—should seek to satisfy the cravings of their higher nature by straying into the uninviting ways of this already effete system. Yet while thoroughly assured that the ethics of the Secularist can never satisfy those whom they delude, we should in justice distinguish between them and the rampant blasphemy and coarse democracy of certain Atheistical fanatics, who unfortunately have ready access to the ears of large numbers of the working classes. The more moderate system is destructive to the soul, in common with its horrible competitor, but it is not so disgustingly repelling to decent people.
Secularism accepts and appropriates much of the morality of the Bible. It will introduce many of the sacred precepts into its every-day life, though it rejects all notions of inspiration, disbelieves in a future state, and without wishing directly to acknowledge the humiliating fact, the creed appears before us as Deism re-habited and re-named. Though it preaches liberality, theory and practice do not always harmonise even with Secularists. All classes of unbelievers, and especially such as are deficient in knowledge, are intolerant towards others, and impatient under contradiction. How else can we account for the frightful blasphemy and insanely violent language too frequently heard in "Halls of Science"? Freedom of opinion and of discussion?
What does it mean when pleaded for by men who become enraged if a wife be found reading a Christian book, or infusing into her children's minds the life-lessons of the Bible?
The more persons become familiar with infidelity as it really is, the less will they incline to a belief in the heart-sincerity of those who embrace any one set of the conflicting tenets. In the majority of instances, we may fear that poorly educated persons imbibe the sentiments of leading authors of the sceptical school, and then in pride or obstinacy defend them in very desperation. It is well, nevertheless, that conscience often capitulates when hard-pressed. The faintest spark of a love of something better may sometimes be fanned into a living flame if the proper means be used.
One evening a man, who resided in Southwark, attended a missionary's meeting for the special purpose of lauding Paine and Voltaire as writers whose moral sentiments surpassed in beauty anything of the kind found in the Bible. What this objector to the Gospel had to say was listened to with deference, and then he was asked if ever he had read the volume he contemned. Yes, he had read the Bible in common with other books. "Have you a family?" asked the missionary who was presiding over the little assembly. Yes, the speaker possessed a wife and little ones. Which then would he recommend to them,—the life-companion who was dear to him and the children whom he loved—Infidelity or Christianity? The company may have looked curiously to see what shape the infidel's answer would assume, but they could little have suspected what its import would be. What was their astonishment when the champion of unbelief, of a few minutes before, burst into tears, and then cried, "I never heard that kind of argument before. I would rather give them the Bible than any infidel book." Such are the victories of kindness and patience which hard-working evangelists achieve in their daily work.
The manner in which infidels are taken, as it were, in their own meshes by skilful disputants, would form both an instructive and piquant chapter in the annals of street evangelisation. Some years ago there lived in London two boorish shoemakers, who were commonly found pursuing their craft on Sabbath mornings. Besides being avowed infidels they sympathised with Republicans and Chartists, meanwhile stoutly maintaining that the Bible hindered the progress of mankind. Would nobody volunteer to go and tell these desperadoes of their errors and duty? It was scarce to be expected that genteel church-goers could think, even, of turning aside from their pathway of respectability to do anything so unfashionable. Talk of the Gospel to unwashed cobblers on a Sabbath morning? Impossible! Then in regard to the city missionary; he had been warned by a friendly voice not to venture near so notorious a den as the shoemakers' room. Why? The men were sheer heathens and probably dangerous! Yet, notwithstanding these kind warnings, the evangelist ventured into the forbidden precincts; and on entering the apartment he was not directly insulted; on the contrary, he met with a negative sort of civility by being allowed to stand for some time unnoticed. As it would have been unwise to have begun at once about religion, a conversation respecting America was first introduced. The speaker having once lived in the New
543
World, remembered having worn pegged boots there. Ay, to be sure, America was the place for good workmen. "I wish I had gone ten years ago," said one of the men, though in rather ungracious tones. An advance in the right direction was made when the visitor referred to the great numbers of places of worship with which America abounded. "It may be all the worse for that," growled one of the men. "I am sorry to hear you speak so," was the reply; "You know the Scriptures assure us that righteousness exalteth a nation." This remark provoked quite a fierce explosion of wrath—"I don't mind what the Bible says . . . People who talk most about religion are the greatest liars, and they are the hardest men I ever worked for!" "Ay, that they are!" put in the other man, who hitherto had remained silent. From the conversation which now followed, it appeared that the first speaker, like so many ill-informed objectors to the claims of religion, had never read the pages of inspiration he so vehemently denounced. On being driven into a corner in the argument, he could say nothing more effective than, "I have read quite enough of it." In truly commendable good temper and moderation the missionary replied, "that is not the open answer I expected from you, you have declared the Bible to be false and foolish: have you come to that awful conclusion after close and diligent study?" "Indeed, I have other things to study," cried the shoemaker, impatient over this interruption in the morning's labour; "I don't want to know anything about it—I am busy just now." One might turn from such a place, and from such a man when in a bad temper, heart-sick and despairing; might almost conscientiously resign such to their fate as incorrigible, or say something hastily which might provoke them beyond reclamation. Only by special tact, blessed by heaven, can seeds of truth be sown in this not always sterile soil of unbelief. The visitor continued: "You appear to be a hard-working man, and to possess some knowledge of your line of business. Now, about ten days ago, I purchased a pair of shoes for eight shillings and sixpence. Do you think I gave too much for them?" "No, if they were a good pair," said the man. "Do you think them a good pair?" enquired the other emphatically. "Show them to me and I'll soon tell you." "They are at home;" still answered the other, "cannot you tell me whether they are good or bad without seeing them?" "None but a fool would ask such a question!" said the man. Not ask such a question? Why not? Here was surely a very unaccountable circumstance. A craftsman thoroughly initiated into the mysteries of a certain trade, confesses inability to judge whether articles are good or indifferent without first handling and testing them! In the meantime, a book, which likewise he has never read or examined, he unhesitatingly pronounces to be an imposture! "I am but a stranger," now said the visitor, "yet I cannot forbear telling you that the Scriptures have given me great peace, and I sincerely desire your peace and happiness. This has brought me to your house, and has kept me waiting here for nearly an hour, and this it was that made me pass by your long ungracious silence after I entered your room." Now, even shoemakers love victory in argument; but here one was unmistakably defeated. All that men can do in such circumstances, is to retail a few thread-bare objections to Christianity, and make a show of intelligently comprehending what
they profess to believe. It is likewise very galling to be silenced before fellow workmen. "I'll tell you what," cried the man, who all through had maintained the argument, "had you come in preaching and canting, I would have chucked you through that door." Clearly perceiving his defeat, however, he was in no mood for continuing hostilities. In a surprising manner he gracefully surrendered the position. He even rose from his seat to offer the visitor a chair, and probably for the first time in his life, listened attentively to the gospel. That man in time became a real convert, a devoted Christian, and a diligent student of Scripture. While such things are occurring, shall we not take courage? How many gems may be won for the seeking. How many souls, living on husks, and shivering in rags of their own patchwork, might wear the wedding robe and sit in their Lord's banqueting-house, were the messengers abroad to compel them to come in.
Since writing the above, we have looked into Thomas Cooper's new volume, which is modestly entitled, "Plain Pulpit Talk." The author's name has long been associated with scepticism in England. Once a sceptic himself, he has passed through the ordeal of unbelief, and has now for long enjoyed that unwavering faith in Christ which has prompted him to devote the remainder of his life to the work of benefiting doubters in Revelation of all shades. These discourses—"The Sunday work of one who took it up from a sense of duty, without waiting for man to appoint him"—will be eagerly read by a large class. The racy English, original thoughts, and forcible arguments will please the scholarly: the telling illustrations, chaste similes, and affectionate earnestness of the author, will attract less cultivated readers. Even among men of genius, few are found so gifted in speaking to the unbelieving as Thomas Cooper, and therefore we gladly appropriate his argument on "God's work must be worthy of himself," and with it conclude this article:—
Let us come back again. God is our moral Governor: he must govern by law; and there must be penalties for the breaking of the law, or law would be virtually abolished, and his whole moral universe be a chaos of disorder. Now, Man, as the moral subject under the Moral Governor, had a law to keep, and under a penalty: he broke the law, and the penalty must follow—"Stop!" cries our respectable rational friend; "I object altogether to the institution of a moral agency. I don't see why God could not have made the universe without making moral agents. I most decidedly think it would have been a happier universe without them, for, then, we should have had no anxiety about our condition in the future—none of this torturous state of responsibility, this constant plaguing sense that we have something to answer for, and therefore, one must be very particular in one's conduct and speech and thought." If you will think a little, my rational friend, in lieu of talking lightly, I venture to say that you will soon come to the conclusion that God could not have concluded his creative work worthily of himself without making moral agents. God made the glorious suns and rolling globes in space, but if he had left them all tenantless, that would have been a termination of his creative work unworthy of himself, for it would not have increased the happiness of his
* Plain Pulpit Talk. By Thomas Cooper. Author of "The Purgatory of Suicides," "The Bridge of History over the Gulf of Time," &c., &c., &c. Hodder and Stoughton.
545
universe, and he would have been shut in with selfishness. God made this earth, and clothed it with beautiful flowers; but if he alone saw them, that would not increase the happiness of his universe. If God had ended by creating the flowers, it would not have been a termination of his creative work worthy of himself. God made the animals, and in them the increase of the happiness of God's universe began, so far as our earth is concerned; but theirs is not an exalted happiness, they cannot consciously receive the love of their maker. If God had stayed his creative energy in the creation of animals, that would not have been a termination of his creative work worthy of himself. God chose to create moral agents; beings capable of contemplating his wisdom, capable of obeying their Maker by their own will, and so honouring him by willing obedience; capable of consciously receiving his love, and growing in the conscious enjoyment of it, to all eternity. That is a termination of God's creative work worthy of himself.
Possibly some unbeliever may scan these lines. To such we say, do not rest satisfied with merely doubting Christianity. Be sure you are right. Weigh the best things of your system against the Christian's peace and hope, and deal honestly with your own heart. Test a question with such tremendous issues free from the prejudice which perhaps you have taken second-hand from infidel writers and lecturers. Test your principles before death comes to test them for you! BE SURE YOU ARE RIGHT!
