Menu
‹ Chapter 36 of 203 ›

The Bible in the School

7 min read · Chapter 36 of 203

"I STAND here as counsel for posterity." In this assumed capacity Mr. Edward Miall contended, in the year 1858, for the non-interference with education on the part of government, and that all education should be religious. The Congregational Board was based upon these principles, and might have held its own had its management fallen into the right hands, and had the churches throughout the country proved true to their convictions in this matter.

There was much less of presumption in Mr. Miall's declaration than would appear now, although he has thrown up his brief. He had reasoned himself up to the position he then took, and appealed to principles which he declared to be "indefeasible." Doubtless he was right; and he has only shifted his ground from the pressure of a temporary expediency. Nonconformists failed to make good their position, for their schools in numberless instances languished for want of proper support, and their teachers lost heart for want of sympathy and union.

The Congregational Board, having courted and obtained government aid, is now an integral part of the national system. With few exceptions the men who were the foremost leaders in the crusade against national and secular education, have accepted the former, and now contend for the latter. Given a national system, it must of necessity be secular, or the conflicting sects will make it suit their own ends. There can be no compromise between national and secular, on the one hand, and voluntary and religious, on the other. This was admitted by the delegates to the Educational Conference at Manchester, a week or two since.

Now, I should like to propose a few questions for earnest consideration, and which may induce a spirit of caution, and temper the zeal of some of our leading Nonconformists who are clamorous for the exclusion of the Bible.

1. If the Nonconformists, as a body, accept a national system and reject the Bible from all state-aided schools, will not the children of ordinary parents grow up in utter ignorance of religion? And is not this the infliction of a grievous wrong? Why should they be taught the histories of all other nations and be kept in ignorance of the history of the Jewish, the most wonderful nation in the world? How can we justify the teaching of the geography of all other countries, and the exclusion of the narrow strip which skirts the western shores of the Mediterranean Sea? Why should it be possible for a teacher to give an oral lesson on the Darwinian theory of the descent of man, and not allow his

* We insert this paper because we believe that it states the opinion of many dissenters. We ourselves feel the question to be a very difficult one, and do not yet see our way. We do not agree with the Manchester decision, but are unable to see any practical escape from it as things now are. One thing, however, we do regret, and that is that the Nonconformists should have quitted their old safe standing-place for another, which is, to say the least, extremely questionable. Education cannot be dissevered from religion, and therefore does not come under the province of government. This was the true principle, and having left it we are at sea. Yet it would be hard to say how we could help being washed from our rock.—Ed.

8

scholars to read even the Mosaic account of the creation? Is it rational to concede the liberty to the teacher of instructing the children in every cosmogony excepting the only inspired one contained in the book of Genesis? Are they, so far as the day-school teaching is concerned, to grow up in ignorance of the sublime facts which make up the gospel record? Is every query proposed by young enquirers as to the destiny of the race to be silenced, because, forsooth, the answers are contained in the Bible? Are they to learn nothing of the claims of God, as expressed at Sinai, demonstrating the guilt of the race, and the provision of God in the sacrifice of Cavalry, by which alone those claims are met?

2. How can we compensate our scholars for the loss of the highest of all moralities, the morality of the Bible? If education consists as much in moral culture as in didactic teaching, where is the wisdom of excluding the only divinely authoritative factor? Educate the young in all the philosophies, ancient and modern, the classic lore of Greece and Rome, the antiquities of Egypt and Assyria, and the rise and fall of modern empires, if you will; you only reach the intellect. Inculeate the moralities demanded by an imperfect civilization, and which rest only upon human authority, and you have no guarantee that they will work a moral revolution. Given a bias towards evil in the child, from the fact of the depravity of its nature, an advanced education is only a more potent agent in promoting the development. The crimes of history, at which the world stands aghast, have been committed by men of the highest intellectual attainments. Withdraw from a child the only divine rule of life, and the result will be most lamentable.

3. Will not the proscription of the Bible from the school weaken the artless faith of children in its divine origin and authority? Is it impossible to draw the line with such clearness that an ordinary child may detect the difference between the politico-ecclesiastical expediency which excludes the Bible, and the conviction that it is not God's voice to the conscience? A child of ordinary capacity will argue its unimportance from the prohibition to read it at school, and he will find no difficulty in drawing the inference that the prohibition should be made absolute, and that it should never be read at all. An education purely secular is the handmaiden of a Godless scepticism.

4. Is the exclusion of the Bible practicable? If it is not formally read in the school, how can a Christian teacher be prevented quoting it, either directly or indirectly, or from allowing it to mould his teaching? A man who has studied his Bible, and so imbibed its spirit that it has become the most potent element in his Christian character, cannot disguise the fact. He will make it felt in any sphere he may occupy, and especially in teaching. No restrictions can absolutely prevent a teacher from employing, in some form or other, his own Biblical knowledge, and so employing it as to impress others with his own peculiar views. The exclusion of the Bible can only be made absolute by ignoring its very existence, and by preventing any reference to it by incidental allusion or dim hint. Moreover, prayer must be strictly prohibited, lest the teacher should embody in it any scriptural promise.

5. Will not Christian men refuse to teach under such restraint, regarding it as an unjust infringement of personal liberty, and an unwarrantable interference with the conscientious discharge of Christian

119

obligation? No true Christian would accept an appointment under which he is commanded to ignore his rights as a man, or prove false to his duty as a believer in the Lord Jesus Christ. We have justly complained of the proscription of the Bible by the tyranny of priestly influence or ignorant superstition. But the principle is the same, whether the Bible is excluded from the people of a country, as fatal to Papal domination, or from the children of a village school, as inimical to sectarian supremacy. Let the Government yield to the clamour of persistent partisans, and banish the Bible from State schools, and they will practically eject every godly teacher to whom a clear conscience is of more importance than the emoluments of office. Let them assign the education of the young to irreligious men, and the next generation will become infidel.

I am aware it is proposed to establish religious schools, but I ask, in all sincerity,—

1. Is it not unreasonable to attempt to supplement the secular teaching of the day-school by religious teaching of an evening, when the strength and patience of the children are exhausted? Is religious instruction so attractive that children will forego the pleasure of play to attend an evening school? Is it right to interfere with the time devoted to the preparation of home lessons, or to withdraw children entirely from the home circle? Is it prudent to detain children in the vitiated atmosphere of a school for a greater number of hours than their general education requires? Would it be possible to secure the attendance of children at a voluntary religious service, when compulsion, is necessary in many instances to secure their attendance at the day-school? Moreover, is it possible to secure a sufficient number of competent voluntary teachers, and at such an hour of the evening when children might reasonably be expected to attend? The whole scheme is fraught with insuperable difficulties, and must, I think, be abandoned.

2. Is the Sunday-school equal to the task of imparting religious education to the whole of the juvenile population? In the first place, our churches have not the rooms in which the children could be taught, and they have not at command a sufficient staff of competent teachers to instruct them. But granting an effort on the part of the church to meet the necessities of the new condition of things, would not the time at command prove altogether inadequate? If the children read the Bible in the day-school, the knowledge thus acquired prepares their mind for the religious teaching of the Sunday-school. If the whole devolves upon the Sunday-school teacher, the limited time which he has at command will reduce the religious teaching of the nation to an almost inappreciable quantity.

Too much must not be expected from the parents, for large numbers are sadly deficient in Biblical knowledge, and many of them have neither time, inclination, nor ability to instruct their children. The home library is most meagre in many instances, the prices of good books being beyond the means of the parents.

Nor must the minister be supposed equal to the task of instructing children from the pulpit. Few preachers have the tact to interest and instruct children in their ordinary sermons, and our places of worship,

moreover, are not adequate to the accommodation of a large accession of children.

It seems to me, therefore, that we are forced back to the position of 1843, when the Congregational Board was formed to secure a sound education, involving religious culture without State interference and control. In the present temper of religious parties, mutual concessions being impossible, the Bible must be excluded from State-aided schools, but let Christian men of all denominations originate and maintain, in a high state of efficiency, popular schools in which the Bible shall be read and taught in its integrity, and thus avert the disastrous consequences to the thought and life of the nation, which must inevitably result from a system which ignores divine revelation.

BIBLICUS.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate