Why we cannot unite with the Anglican Establishment — From A Lacture By Pastor W. Sampson, Of Folkestone
WHEN one looks at this body, which the lecturer, to whom I now reply, identifies with the one fold of the Catholic Church, there is so much in it unlike Christ, that the temptation to enter it is very small indeed. Thank God men are often better than their creed, and rise far above the system with which they identify themselves. It would be superfluous to acknowledge the goodness, the devotedness, of many members of the Establishment. It is their piety that has preserved it, and not one word shall fall from my lips, that even a perverted ingenuity can construe into a charge against the individual members of the system. I frankly acknowledge that the great difficulty I have had in making up my mind to speak on this subject to-night, was the fear that I might give pain to some godly, pious people, whom I would not willingly injure on any consideration. But when I found that the whole body of Nonconformists are spoken of as being outside the one fold of Christ's Catholic Church, duty forbade me to let the statement go by unchallenged, and if in discharging that same duty, and shewing why we as Nonconformists do not belong to that body, for which this title has been assumed, I am obliged to say things that may press hard on some: I do so, not willingly, but because in the interests of truth it is needful
to say them. And it is quite time that members of the Establishment should know that many things are done openly in it, that seem to us not only inconsistent with the character of a Church of Christ, but utterly opposed to the character of Christ himself. I speak not now of those evils that may be inherent perhaps in every establishment. It is, perhaps, essential to an establishment that it should claim for itself many things that belong to the nation. It is, perhaps, a necessity of the contract made between the two parties, the Church and the State, that by the very condition of the union, the church should have exclusive privileges. Of these things I do not now intend to speak. I do not want to enter into a discussion of the abstract merits of the union of Church and State. But look, a lecturer stands here and prays that we may return to the Communion of which he is a member. Well, apart altogether from our conviction, that a State Church is not good either for the Church, or the State, we say there are special reasons why we should differ from you. See, my dear sir, I might say to the lecturer, your church, the one fold, &c., is so constituted that I,—Nonconformist though I am, might go into the market to-morrow, and if I only had the money, I might buy the right of putting into scores, and hundreds of churches, any clergyman I chose, to act as pastor of the little flock gathered around him there. I take up the Times newspaper almost any day, I look through the advertising columns of Church newspapers, belonging to any and every party in the Establishment, for there are parties even here, and it matters not to what party the paper belongs,—I shall be pretty sure to find in it advertisements offering for sale the right of presentation at the next vacancy, and you all know I am not exaggerating in the least when I say, the inducements to purchase set forth in these advertisements usually are,—there is "good trout fishing," "a meet for hunting in the neighbourhood," "population very small," "no Dissoners in the village," "the present incumbent very old." Have we not all seen such advertisements? may we not see them day by day? Think of it, realise to yourselves what these things mean. The matter has come lately before the public. Many of you have read the description of the sale, when Falmouth Rectory was put up for sale, or rather, let us be particular, the right to present the living to some one when a vacancy occurs. Now it so happens that the right was not sold; it is still in the market. Suppose for a moment or two we transform ourselves into an auction room and put this living up for sale. "Gentlemen, I am honoured with instructions to submit to public competition the right of presentation to the valuable living of Falmouth. Gentlemen, it is not every day such an opportunity for making a splendid investment presents itself. This church was made a parish in the reign of Charles II., and in the 22nd year of that most religious king an Act was passed which gives to the person of Falmouth and his successors for over, a tax of 16d. in the £ on all houses, shops, warehouses, cellars and outhouses, then and thereafter to be built. Be good enough to see, then, gentlemen, what an extraordinary property this is. As the town increases and prospers, and no doubt it will increase and prosper much, so this property will increase. 16d. in the £, gentlemen, on all houses, shops, &c., now existing and that may hereafter be built. And, gentlemen, this is not all: every coasting vessel that passes the Black Rock shall be obliged to pay the person 2s. Every other vessel 2s. 6d. Every year, the parish and the trade are extending, and really I cannot tell you to what extent it may grow. Now, gentlemen, it is this property, this really extraordinary property, that I have to put up for sale. I am very glad to see so many gentlemen present to-night. Doubtless, you have sons whom you are anxious to see settled well and respectably in life. Such a chance as is presented to-night rarely offers. Let me tell you, gentlemen, that the present income of this property is £1,700. £1,700 gentlemen, absolutely safe, certain to increase. And, gentlemen, there, is no doubt that possession will very soon be given. The present incumbent, gentlemen, is 77 years old, and he is very infirm. We have the authority of Holy Writ to say, 'the days of our years are three-score years and ten, and if by
469
reason of strength they be four-score years, yet is their strength labour and sorrow, for it is soon cut off and we fly away.' Yes, gentlemen, 77 years of age. Yes, the silver cord will soon be loosened, and the golden bowl be broken. And now this valuable property is offered. Who'll bid? who'll bid? Don't hang back, gentlemen. Say something. Seventy-seven years old! £6,000 says one, £7,000 says another. Oh! but that's not half its value. Come, come, don't be afraid. I know, gentlemen, there is a great outcry in Falmouth about it, but they can't help themselves, and depend upon it, even if disestablishment come, vested interests will always be respected. Come, what shall I say? Thank you, £8,000, it is going, gentlemen, £8,000, £9,000, well we're getting on, £9,000, still below its value, gentlemen, £9,000 for this property, £1,700 a year, and the incumbent 77 years old. Don't be afraid, any one of you may bid. Why, the biggest blackguard in the room may have it, if he'll only give money enough." But a truce to this. I tell you I have scarcely exaggerated one bit. Some of the words I have used, are the very words the auctioneer is reported to have used. Is it not awful? Oh! I can fancy in that auctioneer's room, the devil himself leering with malicious joy, as the terrible scene is being enacted, and if it were possible for sorrow to be in heaven, must not the angels who rejoice over one repenting sinner, weep, weep sad and bitter tears? Oh Christ! Christ! Christ! thou, who when on earth didst drive the buyers and sellers out of the temple, saying, "My Father's house shall be called a house of prayer, but you have made it a den of thieves." Oh Christ! they sell for gold the right of preaching thy blessed gospel! they sell for gold the right of baptising into thy holy name! they sell for gold the right of breaking the bread and pouring out the wine in memory of thy agony and shame! they sell to the highest bidder the right of burying thy saints "in the sure and certain hope of a blessed resurrection!"
And well might we shrink from the awful scene. But remember that this scene was enacted just one month ago to-day, and every week similar scenes may be witnessed. And do not say, it is too bad to refer to those things, they are mere abuses, that men in the Establishment are disgusted with them as much as you are. Are they? I ask, then, what steps do they take to remedy it? I know when men recognise abuses, they set to work to create a public opinion to remedy them. What, I ask, are you doing to after this state of things? Don't tell me you do not like to call public meetings and create excitement; you can pack the biggest hall in London to overflowing, and get your leading men to speak there, lest, perchance, a single word should be struck out of the damnatory clauses of the Athanasian Creed. But where has a meeting been called to denounce an evil like this, or what steps have you taken to remedy it? Shall we be blamed, if we say your silence in the midst of it gives consent to it? You are responsible for the evils you take no steps to cure.
I refer to one point more, and only to one point more. We do not care to unite ourselves with this Church because we find to our intense sorrow that it is by its clergy, by its ritual, by its practice, leading this country back to Rome. How much farther it will go in this direction I know not, but I confess I cannot contemplate the future without a feeling approaching to alarm. Let me ask you to listen to the following extract from the Weekly Register, a Roman Catholic Journal. Speaking of progress, it says:—
"In England the work of conversion has continued during the past year with steady and not very slow steps. To name, or even indicate individuals who have been received during the past twelve months would be foreign to our purpose. This much we say (and say with truth), the fact being known to many Catholics in London, that the number of converts in London alone has been upwards of 2,000 during the past year, and they have during the last few weeks increased very much. Many, we are informed, have joined us, who are all but Catholics, and who had little need of instruction before they made up their minds to take the final, the long deferred, but the all-needful step. From every Ritualistic congregation in London there is a continual stream of
converts drifting towards us, and the number would be increased had we priests sufficient to look after those who are hesitating as to their future step in the right direction. In various parts of this country, different Anglican clergymen have been received into the Church to the number of some ten or a dozen, and at least as many ladies connected with the Anglican sisterhood have followed in the same direction. And of every twenty Anglicans who join the Catholic Church not less than seventeen have been prepared for the step by the teaching they have heard from Ritualistic pulpits, and by the practices they have got accustomed to in Ritualistic churches. Not only laymen but Anglican clergymen, have been seen devoutly hearing mass at Catholic churches, rather than go to their own places of worship where what they considered heresy was taught."
Is there one of us in this hall to-night surprised at this testimony? I think not, it is but what we all expect; and I am uttering but the sad truth when I say, that it seems that the one aim of the most active party in the Establishment is to bring the English Church as closely as possible into perfect uniformity with the Church of Rome. I have books at home—manuals for the young, for candidates for Confirmation, for preparation for the Communion—manuals that evidently have a large circulation: and written by leading members of the Ritualistic party, in which the Romish doctrines of the priesthood, the Sacrifice of the Mass, the transformation of the bread and wine into the actual body and blood of Christ, auricular confession, the power of the priesthood to forgive sins, are openly and unblushingly taught; and there is not a church belonging to the Establishment of this country but might be occupied by men teaching the doctrines for opposing which our fathers died, and the fires of Smithfield were lighted. The Bennett judgment has unprotestantised the English Church. And the Church Times is perfectly right when it says, "We are not blind to the practical effects of the judgment. It is a great advantage to the less courageous members of the High Church school to know that they can preach, without any fear of Civil and Ecclesiastical penalties, the primitive doctrines of the Real Presence, the Sacrifice of the Mass, and of Eucharistic Adoration. It is a great disadvantage to Monsignor Capel and his colleagues to have one of their favourite weapons wrested out of their hands in that they can no longer allege that English Catholics who preach these tenets are disloyal and alien from their own Church."
It must not be forgotten that, by that judgment, any man and every man in the English Church may preach the Real Presence, the Sacrifice of the Mass, and the Eucharistic Adoration; and the highest Court of Appeal in the land has decided that in so doing he will not be acting in opposition to the teaching of the Church. We cannot be united with a Church which will and does teach such doctrines for the Gospel of the grace of God.
And now I must draw rapidly to a close. The question has been publicly raised, and the prayer in this hall offered, that we Nonconformists might yet return to the one fold of Christ's Catholic Church. If the words are used in the only sense that can properly attach to them, we protest against the lack of charity that excludes from that fold Christian men and women simply because they are Nonconformists. With all humility and reverence, but with all confidence, we avow our belief that Christ the Good Shepherd has admitted us himself into his fold, and we will let no man come between us and our Saviour. If the words are used to mean the Church of England as by law established, we protest against the presumption of any man or of any party arrogating to itself a title that can only justly be applied to the whole. If the words are so used, then we on our side are obliged to show reason why we do not wish and should not wish the prayer to be fulfilled. The Church of Christ should not be a political organization, as this Church is. The Church of Christ should be pure, or should attempt at least to be pure: this Church admits the infamous traffic in livings, traffic in the very souls of men. The Church of Christ should teach only the word of God; this Church teaches the doctrines of Rome, and
471
therefore we cannot unite with her. Many other reasons I might have given. Let these suffice. I know full well that in occupying this position, and saying what I have said to-night, I shall lay myself open to many charges. Men who, with honeyed words upon their lips, can manifest the real lack of charity which excludes all Nonconformists from the one fold of Christ's Church, will doubtless charge me with being very uncharitable. Those who are members of a political Church, a Church made what it is, and continued as it is, and that cannot be altered from what it is but by political action, may call me that terrible thing, a Political Dissenter. But these things will pass unheeded by. I tell you what it is, brethren. The time has come when it is needed that we speak out. The rapid progress which this semi-popery is making amongst us calls for more earnest devoted Christian outspokenness. It seems to me as though a most determined effort is being made to induce Nonconformists, and especially Wesleyans, to amalgamate with the Church of England. One gets up and in persuasive tones declares that John Wesley lived and died not only a Churchman, but a Churchman holding the views that now distinguish the modern Ritualists, and from it the conclusion is deduced that Wesleyan Methodists ought to be Churchmen and Ritualists too. Another, not so wise and prudent perhaps, but animated with the same design, tries to frighten the Methodists into the Church, and when he cannot succeed, says, (and I give my authority for the statement: it is Mr. Barlow, J.P., a leading Methodist of Bolton, in Lancashire): "Well, your John Wesley is burning in hell, for his schism from the Church of England." Yes, depend upon it, there is a battle yet to be fought in this England of ours; a battle in which, when once it is begun, we shall have to draw the sword, and throw away the scabbard. Be it ours to be prepared for it; prepared by an intelligent apprehension of the great principles involved in the conflict; prepared by a knowledge of the skilful use of the great weapon, the sword of the Spirit, the Word of God: prepared by lives of holy, unselfish devotedness, to the great cause we hold so dear; prepared by loving sympathy with him whom we delight to follow as the Captain of Salvation. So prepared, we will fight the good fight of faith, praying always with all prayer and supplication in the Spirit, and watching thereunto with all perseverance and supplication for all saints. And so fighting, we shall come off more than conquerors through him who loved us and gave himself for us.
