The kind of Sermons most blessed to Conversion
A PAPER READ AT THE COLLEGE CONFERENCE BY T. TARN, MINISTER OF NEW PARK ROAD CHAPEL, PECKHAM.
THE conversion of sinners is the great design of the gospel, and the grand object of the Christian ministry. It is a cause of humiliation, however, that the direct results of preaching are not more commensurate with the efforts put forth. We are often painfully aware that our words have fallen powerless among the people, and with saddened spirits we have frequently to retire from the scene of our ministrations, saying, not murmuringly, but mournfully, "Who hath believed our report, and to whom is the arm of the Lord revealed?" Instead of the conversions outnumbering the sermons, generally the sermons outnumber the conversions. The fact gives a solemn interest to our present inquiry concerning the kind of sermons most blessed to conversion, for perhaps partly to this source our limited amount of success may be traced.
At the outset we would remark that by the term conversion we do not mean the development of some germ of good in the heart, like the latent life which manifests itself in the seed when the proper influences are brought to bear upon it; but rather the result of an entirely new creation in man, which revolutionises all the affections, gives a nobler turn to the aspirations, and completely changes the ruling principle. It comprehends the three elements of regeneration, repentance, and reformation, or a new nature implanted in the soul, a complete revolution in the mind, and a radical change in outward life. It is a turning of the whole man from sin and self to purity and God. This change can only be wrought by supernatural power, for man has no ability either to convert himself or others. Human instrumentality, however, is generally employed by the Holy Spirit, and especially the preaching of the gospel; it pleases God, "by the foolishness of preaching, to save them that believe." Although God does, by "the foolishness of preaching," convert men, it is not often that he uses foolish preaching. He does not reverse the natural order of things in dealing with human souls, and consequently he clothes the most likely means with the requisite power to accomplish the desired effect. In the kingdom of grace, as well as in that of nature, there is always observed a just adaptation of means to ends. Those sermons are most blessed which are in themselves best adapted to influence the heart in its varied states and relationships.
Thus diversity of mental constitution and character in our audience will necessitate a difference of treatment. Some will be arrested by those sermons which flash and crash like the elements in a thunderstorm, others will be more affected by the words which fall softly, and serenely, like a sunbeam upon a flower, or like the dew upon a thirsty leaf. We must not cultivate exclusively one style of preaching, or we shall only reach one class of mind. Versatility must be sought, so that we can speak successfully to every heart, whatever its relationship to truth. Some are on the mountain-top of pride and vainglory: to such we must
say, "Come down from those heights of self-sufficiency, lest God hurl you into the deep abyss." Others are in the valley of despair: to them in cheerful tones the invitation must be given, "Come up hither, for here is the abode of peace and hope." Some are ignorant, and need to be taught the first elements of truth; others know the way, and require exhorting to walk therein. Some are pressed beneath the load of guilt, and need to be directed to the sin-bearer; others are careless about their guilt, and need to be reminded of the sin-punisher. The gospel is an instrument of many strings, and if we would bring forth soul-stirring music we must not confine ourselves to one chord. Our tone must be varied, being here sweetly compassionate, and there righteously indignant. "On some having compassion, making a difference. Others save with fear, pulling them out of the fire." Sermons which have not this appropriateness will never reach the heart.
Because of this diversity of character and relationship to truth, and because of the extreme difficulty of tracing subtle spiritual influences, it is with diffidence we attempt the selection of any distinct kind of sermons as being most blessed to conversion. It very frequently happens that several sermons are useful to the same soul, one arousing to a consciousness of guilt and danger, another presenting Christ as the way of escape, and a third leading the soul to rest on his finished work. We should probably say in such a case that the last sermon was blessed to conversion, but had any one of the discourses been wanting, the saving change would not have been effected. We believe, however, that there is one kind of sermons which God honours above the rest, upon which most clearly and unmistakably he sets his supreme seal of approval.
In trying to ascertain their characteristics we shall first map out some broad and well-defined lines of preaching, in following which we may confidently expect to effect the conversion of men, and then, gradually narrowing down the inquiry, fix upon the kind of sermons most likely to be successful.
Sermons which contain clear and explicit statements of cardinal truths, such as the total depravity of man, the necessity of regeneration, &c., will most certainly be blessed to conversion. These doctrines may be grey with age, but they still retain the abounding vigour of their youth. Their power is perennial. Any departure from them is sure to detract from success in winning souls. David refused to go forth to the fight clad in the unwieldy armour of Saul, he would rather trust the tried but unpretentious "sling and stone"; and, though the Philistines and even the armies of Israel might deride his choice, he went forth and brought the giant to the earth. If we go to attack the giant, sin, clad in the cumbrous mysticism of modern thought, and armed with the sword of philosophic speculation, our foe will laugh and triumph; but if we go with that simple weapon, with which, we trust, our hands are not unfamiliar, victory shall attend our steps, and rejoicing fill the camps of Israel. There may be the temptation to broach some new doctrine, just to show the people that we think for ourselves, and are not utterly devoid of originality. It is generally counted an intellectual feat to resurrect an ancient error and set it forth as a new truth, and those men who have performed this feat are admiringly held
365
up to the world as original thinkers; but observation testifies that, when the old doctrines of the gospel are excluded from any church, so far as conversion work is concerned, "Ichabod" may be stamped upon its walls. "Them that honour me I will honour" is the divine proclamation, and if we cut and carve and alter the central truths of God's word to suit any whimsical notions of our own, he will withhold true success. A well-known preacher of rather lofty aspirations has said, and the testimony is especially valuable as coming from such a source, "I have been tempted to modernise Christian preaching, to give up old names and adopt new ones, and to resort to various plans of persuading men to become Christians, and to-day I bear witness that all the good which I have heard of in connection with my ministry has been more or less distinctly traceable to old methods, and old words, and old doctrines, and old expostulations. God seems to have given nothing to my modernised gospel, to my newly-labelled preparations, but to have set special honour upon the old ways in which our fathers trod with so firm and progressive a step." Whether there has been a revolution of opinion in the mind of Dr. Parker since these words were penned some years ago we will not venture to say, but the sentiment expressed is precisely that for which we contend.
We would select from among the fundamental doctrines of the gospel those having reference to the person and work of Christ, as being specially conducive to conversion. Christ is the sum and substance of truly successful preaching. When Christ is faithfully uplifted, then is his promise verified, and men are drawn to him. The discourse of Peter on the day of Pentecost was a plain unvarnished statement concerning Christ, and its power was attested by three thousand converted souls. One secret of the marvellous success which attended the ministry of Paul, was, doubtless, his determination to preach neither speculative philosophy nor cold morality, but a living, loving, life-giving Christ. "The Jews require a sign, and the Greeks seek after wisdom, but we preach Christ crucified." He would not pander to the vitiated tastes of his hearers. He might have gained their applause by his wisdom and eloquence, but there was more music to his ears in the broken cry of a contrite sinner than in the plaudits of the multitude. And the men who have apostolic success in our days are the men who are apostolic successors in this respect at least. Christ is their one great, all-embracing theme. Whatever may be a man's genius or mental power, unless he is true to the cross of Christ, he will never reach the depths of the soul, he will never get such a firm hold of fallen humanity as permanently to raise it from its degradation.
The person of Christ must be presented in every aspect, and his work viewed from every standpoint. His character in all its spotlessness and self-sacrifice, his vicarious sufferings in all their power to melt and win the heart, his atoning death and life of intercession, the yearning love for sinners which even now throbs in his bosom, all must be unfolded in the clearest possible manner. Christ is the living centre towards which all the lines of our preaching should converge. As the name of Phidias was so skilfully carved in the shield that the shield must be destroyed before the name could be erased, in like
manner let the name of Christ be so thoroughly inwrought into every discourse that it cannot be removed. In preaching Christ we address ourselves directly to the wants of men: all the voices of the soul find in him their answer. They are full of unrest, and true rest can only be found in him. They are bearing the burden of guilt, and he alone, who "died the just for the unjust," can remove it. They tremble in presence of the dark, mysterious future, and only Christ can make it bright and delightful to contemplate. They have secret aspirations and yearnings which they do not themselves understand, and in Christ alone can they be realised. He is the infinite God, and can therefore satisfy their yearning for the infinite; at the same time, he is perfect man, and can render that *human sympathy* which they need. We only speak to the heart-throes and fears, to the soul-strugglings and inspirations of men as we preach Christ crucified. If we would awaken penitence for sin and deep hatred to it, if we would awaken loyalty and love to God, if we would awaken determination and devotion in his service, we must clearly present Christ. No doctrines of the gospel are so successful in converting souls as those which cluster more immediately around the cross of Christ.
As men must feel their need of a Saviour before they will accept the Saviour offered, we are led to the conclusion that those sermons which first set forth the righteous demands of the law and then reveal the substitutionary work of Christ, will be pre-eminently blessed to conversion. If anxious souls formed the majority of our readers, that sermon would be the most useful which uplifted Christ the Saviour; but as long as the greater portion of our audience is careless and unconcerned, so long must the preaching of Christ be preceded by the preaching of the law. Men are living in a state of "false peace," which, if they did but rightly understand it, is only the oppressive calm which precedes the storm. The notion of fancied security must be dispelled, and the "refuge of lies" swept away. Fearlessly and vividly must the position of the sinner be portrayed to him, and his guilt charged home upon himself. This was the characteristic of that far-famed discourse of Jonathan Edwards, entitled, "Sinners in the hands of an angry God," during the delivery of which men clutched the backs of the seats as though apprehensive of sinking into the yawning pit beneath them. That sermon was the means of extorting the cry for mercy from many hearts, and was the commencement of a great and gracious revival. Indeed, an analysis of all the sermons of that able and eminently successful man will show that their distinguishing feature was the depicting of "the terror of the Lord" before the presentation of his lovingkindness.
This truth, together with the kindred truths which emanate from it, has been banished from many pulpits, and the eternal punishment of sin is either practically ignored or boldly denied. The refined lips of the modern pulpit would be defiled by the utterance of God's threats against the wicked, and the ears of the respectable few would be pained. I believe that the working of this evil leaven is more wide-spread than is generally conceived, and it is not difficult to account for the extreme rarity of conversions where such ideas obtain. We are taught in the sixty-first of Isaiah that he who is anointed to preach must proclaim not merely "the acceptable year of the Lord," but also "the day of
367
vengeance of our God." The law, however, must be preached intelligently and wisely, never being allowed to degenerate into a mere savage denunciation of punishment. "Knowing, therefore, the terrors of the Lord, we persuade men." Not "we frighten," not "we threaten," but "we persuade men," as the angels persuaded Lot, to flee for refuge, to lay hold upon the hope set before them.
As the Old Testament dispensation was antecedent to the New, and was essentially necessary to prepare the way for it, so must the preaching of the law prepare for the reception of the gospel message. It may be objected that the law can give no pardon, no healing, no satisfaction, no peace, and why should it be preached? If it cannot proclaim pardon, it can certainly convince of sin, and arouse to a sense of the need of pardon. If it contains no healing balm, it can at least reveal the extent of the disease and the necessity for a remedy. If it affords no true satisfaction, it can induce a deeper thirst. If it can shed no beams of peace upon the heart, it can increase the desire for peace. "Wherefore the law is our schoolmaster to bring us to Christ," where pardon, healing, satisfaction, and peace are alone to be found. God's method of restoring Elijah when under the cloud of depression contains a deep lesson for us in dealing with the unconverted. Wind, earthquake, and fire were successively sent as the harbingers of his coming. God was not in them, but they were not, therefore, useless, they were preparing the prophet's mind for the gracious manifestation. It came in "the still small voice." After the exhibition of power came the whisper of love, and that voice was all the more melodious and welcome because of the fierce storm which preceded it. The "still small voice" of love which sounds so sweet and clear from Calvary's Hill will exercise a greater power upon the sinner's mind after he has heard the thunder peal and seen the lightning-flash of Sinai. The one shall constrain him to exclaim, "Who shall hide me from the wrath of God?" The other with dulcet tones shall fall upon his ears: "Here is an hiding place from the wind and a covert from the tempest." The sermons which conduct the sinner to the "place called Calvary" by way of Sinai's hill will be most blessed. I would adduce as the most perfect example which I have ever seen of this kind of sermons, a discourse in the New Park Street Pulpit, entitled, "A Call to the Unconverted." It is based on Galatians iii. 10—"For as many as are of the works of the law are under the curse: for it is written, Cursed is every one that continueth not in all things which are written in the book of the law to do them." Its author says—"So greatly was it owned of God at the time of its utterance that it has been reprinted as a little book, so as to be circulated in another form, at the usual price of a sermon." It will well repay earnest and thoughtful study as a model of the kind of sermons most blessed to conversion—viz., those which first shut the sinner up to condemnation, and then reveal to him the substitutionary work of Christ.
Some attention must be paid to the presentation of the theme, for a sermon may contain the very line of truth which has been indicated, and yet if it is not rightly exhibited and applied, it will be powerless to affect the soul. Everything in the sermon that attracts notice to self must be avoided. However charming the flights of imagination, however correct the rhythm of sentence, however musical the cadence of
voice, they are become as "sounding brass or a tinkling cymbal," if they themselves engross the attention of our hearers. Of all men he is one of the most despicable and impotent, who, by high-sounding sentences, polished periods, and glittering gaudy imagery, seeks to glorify the preacher rather than uplift the Saviour. Such sermons may please, but they will not profit; they may attract, but they will not convert. Hear the apostle Paul on this point: "Christ sent me to preach the gospel, not with wisdom of words, lest the cross of Christ be made of none effect." The pulpit is no place for a display of fireworks. Sermons are not intended to tickle men's ears, but to touch and transform their hearts. The cross, if concealed even by beautiful flowers and gorgeous ornaments, "will be made of none effect." We must not decorate it with tinsel, or try to beautify it with paint. Gild the diamond and you destroy its brilliancy; paint the rose and its delicate tints vanish away. Sermons that even contain fitting truth will only be effective to conversion as they are free from the artificial tricks of oratory and the pompous displays of erudition. The most brilliant sermons are not the most blessed, neither are discourses in the form of beautifully feeble essays the most powerful. Truth must come from the soul in the clear and terse language of strong conviction and irrepressible earnestness and feeling, and then will it be forcible and successful. "My speech and my preaching was not with enticing words of man's wisdom, but in demonstration of the Spirit and of power."
While the sermon should not attract undue attention to the preacher, it must be such as to waken and sustain interest. Dull, heavy, prosaic sermons are more likely to induce sleep than to lead to conversion. A man will never be converted if he is not interested in the proclamation of truth. This is really the first step. Men come to the sanctuary with their minds pre-occupied with worldly thoughts, and it is our duty to dislodge these by the thoughts which we shall introduce. For this purpose nothing is better than a good, striking illustration, or occasionally an anecdote, which will light up the line of argument and relieve the monotony. Smooth preaching, without any ruggedness, will always fail in this. When the attention has been secured, then the sympathies must be enlisted. If we strike the chords of mutual sympathy, and travel the road together with our hearers until we come to the necessary point of divergence, then perhaps they will accompany us to our journey's end; whereas if their antipathies are roused we part company at once. A study of Paul's discourses will show with what effect this principle may be used. Having gained the outposts, we must next seek admittance to the citadel of the heart. There are several avenues of approach. We may reach the heart through the reasoning faculties, or through the imagination; but, generally speaking, those sermons which are addressed to the emotional part of man's nature are the most successful.
But perhaps the point on which greatest stress ought to be laid is the directness of appeal which should characterise every sermon to the unconverted. Much power is lost by dealing in generalities. Some men brandish the "two-edged sword" of truth in the air, very gracefully, I admit, and you see it glitter in the sunshine, and fancy what execution it could work; but they never strike home with it.
369
They exhibit the truth, but do not apply it. Next to the truth itself contained in the sermon, nothing is so important as the close application of it. If we examine those sermons which have been most used to the ingathering of souls we shall invariably find that they were personal and direct in application. After the parable is unfolded we must not fear to say, "Thou art the man." This is doubtless one main cause of the success of Mr. Moody in the North; for if his sermons are remarkable for anything, it is for their specific, personal, soul-stirring appeals. The testimony of Dr. Arnot on this point is very explicit. He says, "The doctrines which this evangelist proclaims are precisely those with which evangelical congregations in Scotland have long been familiar. The exposition of Scripture is neither more clear nor more profound than the use and wont among us. The difference lies in the application rather than in the development of the gospel. Of the two points brought out in the brief report of Philip's discourse to the Ethiopian—he 'preached unto him Jesus'—it is in the 'unto him' that the strangers seem to excel. Jesus, with all that the mighty name implies, has been held forth in this favoured land with great fulness for a long period; but we seem to lack the courage to apply what we preach. We fail to shut in each person and shut him up to Christ. The Lord himself is on this point the model preacher. He was pleased indeed when Peter confessed the true doctrine—'Blessed art thou, Simon Bar-jonas; for flesh and blood hath not revealed it unto thee;' but the Master afterwards came to closer dealing. 'Follow thou me;' 'Lovest thou me?' As they lay iron upon iron while both are hot, in order to welding, so did he lay thou and me repeatedly upon each other, with nothing between, and so fixed the fickle disciple to the Almighty Redeemer, that no power could ever afterwards draw them asunder."
It is on the close personal dealing that the blessing seems mainly to have fallen. Sinners are lovingly, yet forcibly, brought face to face with a beseeching Saviour, so that they cannot escape, as they have been wont, to the right or to the left. They are compelled, as it were, to come to a decision; and many have in these circumstances yielded and submitted to the gospel. We must try to make every man who hears our message feel that it is meant especially for him, and so apply the word to his heart that he shall have no loophole of escape. There are multitudes in the valley of indecision who must be pressed to immediate decision for Christ.
In listening to sermons that have been largely blessed, we have been conscious that beside the appropriate truth clearly presented and suitably applied, there was a mystic and indescribable yet cogent force giving intensity and power to the utterances. For want of a better name it is designated "unction." Some men possess it in a remarkable degree, and indeed it is an essential element in a soul-winning sermon. It seems to be generated by a vivid apprehension of eternal realities, a due sense of responsibility, implicit faith in the power of the truth, full and prayerful reliance upon the Holy Spirit, and an intense yearning for the salvation of immortal souls. This is our great need as ministers of the word, and for this should we earnestly seek. It will temper our most indignant reproofs of sin with
a holy sorrowfulness. It will give an incisiveness to our arguments and an impressiveness to our appeals. It will give a sweetness and tenderness, a pathos and glow to all our utterances, and pervade them with a holy, winsome power. When we speak of the just demands of the law, and the doom which awaits the ungodly, it will render our words, though condemnatory, yet not repulsive; when, after that, we point to the atoning sacrifice of Christ, and close with a loving and earnest appeal to flee from the one and embrace the other, our words will thrill and vibrate in the hearts of men, they will strike new chords of sensibility which we never supposed to exist, and, softened and subdued by the melting tones, men will be led with broken hearts and contrite spirits to put their trust in the Saviour of mankind.
