Menu
‹ Chapter 166 of 193 ›

Christian Spiritualism a Delusion and a Snare — By Arthur Pridham

14 min read · Chapter 166 of 193

THAT the editor of the Christian Spiritualist (Dr. Sexton) is personally sincere in asserting the compatibility of what goes under the name of "Spiritualism" with a genuine Christian faith I readily believe, but that, with such convictions as he avows, he and they whom he represents are themselves living members of the body of Christ, I am compelled sorrowfully to doubt, by reasons which will presently appear.

In a small book,* which received a friendly and favourable notice in the September number of this journal, I have endeavoured to expose, by an ample citation of their own recognised authorities, the true character and working of modern spiritualism generally. My book is declared, indeed, by Dr. Sexton, in his latest number, to be "a most ex parte and unfair production;" but a bare assertion cannot alter facts. The "movement which has produced such tremendous effects upon modern society," to use his own description of spiritualism, has by no means been "condemned unheard," as he complains, although it is but too probable that what will be evident to a true and unprejudiced Christian reader of that work may be at present hidden from his eyes. Leaving, however, what I have already stated to the judgment of the Church of God at large, I turn now to examine the grounds on which a so-called "Christian spiritualist" claims recognition as a partaker and fellow-worker with those who love the Lord Jesus Christ in sincerity, and who are, by grace, true servants of the living God.

Expostulating with Mr. Spurgeon on his too ready acceptance of the testimony of the Spirits Tried, Dr. S., while admitting the variety and often contradictory character of the spirits' communications, protests earnestly against the conclusion that "spiritualism as a whole is opposed to Christianity, and is a delusion of the devil." "Where their teaching," he says, "is erroneous, let it be at once unhesitatingly condemned; but when in accordance with truth, it would be the merest folly in the world to reject it, since it might prove a valuable auxiliary to us in the work in which we are engaged." Until Christ be in accord with Belial the teachings of spiritualism will never be "in accordance

* The Spirits Tried, or Spiritualism Self-convicted, &c. Yapp and Hawkins.

535

with truth," as will soon be shown conclusively. Meanwhile, with reference to the above extract, it will at once occur to the Christian readers of this paper how very differently a true servant of God estimated such "auxiliaries" from beneath when similarly importuned (Acts xvi. 16-18). It is necessary to bear in mind, in considering the subject now before us, that Dr. S. was until recently an active propagandist of secularism, and that his supposed "conversion" was, to use his own terms, "from scepticism to spiritualism." A knowledge of these facts will enable us to refer this bold attempt to identify his creed and his actual pursuits with the faith and work of genuine believers to its true cause; to his present destitution, namely, of the faith of God's elect.

"From darkness to light, and from the power of Satan to God" is the true order of a genuine conversion, with the blessed accompanying effects of forgiveness of sins and fellowship with all his saints (Acts xxvi. 18; Col. i. 12-14.) Now, it is a standing character of these, both in old and modern times, that they sit down at his feet and receive his words (Deut. xxxiii. 3; 1 Pet. ii. 2). And it is by this test that I propose to try the validity of this writer's claims. Since Dr. S. has chosen, as a motto for his journal, a text from the epistle to the Ephesians-a text to which further reference will soon be made-he accepts of course Paul's writings as inspired truth. Now Paul declares explicitly that they who deny the resurrection of the dead are without the true knowledge of God (1 Cor. xv. 34). But, says this convert from scepticism to spiritualism, "The truth that there is no such thing as death, is the noblest consolation that has ever blessed humanity!" But if this be true, there are assuredly no longer any "dead in Christ," and as a necessary consequence there can be no resurrection of the dead. Here, then, we have at once a deep and irreconcilable difference between Christian spiritualism and apostolic truth. If spiritualists speak, as they sometimes do, of resurrection, they do not mean the quickening of this mortal body, but the assumption of a certain fabled "spirit-form," which occurs, they say, on the decease of this present life. And I may here, before proceeding further, caution young believers generally against the danger in these days of being misled by words. Resurrection, heaven, hell, redemption, peace, and many other evangelical expressions are to be met with in the Christian Spiritualist, but let none think that they represent in such pages Scriptural ideas. "THE HEAVEN OR THE HELL IS WITHIN US!" exclaims one of these apostles of delusion in the midst of a florid and verbose harangue on "spirituality of soul" in the September number. This may suffice as an example.

Let us look now more closely at the root and basis of this monstrous hybrid which assumes the name of Christian spiritualism. The system represented by Dr. S. "is built," he would have us believe, "upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner stone"! Great is the long-suffering of God, and there is hope always that the blasphemies of ignorance may be forgiven, but in truth to claim for modern spiritualism such a base as this is to make Christ the minister of sin in a new and utterly outrageous sense. For what, on his own showing, is spiritualism? It is a seeking to the dead (or, as he chooses to phrase it, "the denizens of the other world," for with him, as we have seen, there is no death) for consolation, for protection, for direction, and for counsel. They are sent, he dares to say, by the Father of spirits "on errands of mercy and love to his erring children on earth." Heb. i. 14 was but as a dead letter to him, he avers, until he read it "in the light of spiritualism." That is to say, God's angels, whom the Holy Ghost pointedly distinguishes from men, both in the chapter from which he quotes, and especially in the one immediately following (without now referring to other passages of Scripture), not only in respect of their original creation and nature, but also in their relation to God and to the heirs of his salvation, are, in the language of this pseudo-Christian teacher, the spirits only of departed human beings! I am far from charging Dr. S. with inten-

tional deception or dishonesty, but in the service of such a cause as he espouses, God's truth, if used at all, must of necessity be falsely used. We find, accordingly, that lie follows lie in the pages of this sincere (I could fain believe) but utterly misguided writer, by a kind of natural sequence, as in the example now before us. For not only is the spirit of truth contradicted by this arbitrary change of angels into departed human spirits, but the Son of God is treated in like manner by the assertion that such spirits are sent back on errands of mercy to this earth. Can he have overlooked or forgotten the reply of Abraham to Dives in the parable of our Lord? (1 Luke xvi. 27-31).

Now, this dealing with the dead is, in the language of the Bible, necromancy - a form of departure from the living God which has ever been peculiarly hateful in his eyes. His curse has been pronounced upon it from the first. It forms a special count in his fatal indictment against the Canaanites, and when Israel practised it, with other like abominations, Jerusalem was laid on heaps. (Deut. xviii. 9-14; 2 Kings xxi. 11-13). Yet a man who expects the confidence of Christians as a teacher is not ashamed to say that whosoever "does not see the hand of God in spiritualism must be blind indeed." Has God then changed, that his own hand should cancel thus his ordinance of judgment, and make that a virtue in a Christian which in an Israelite was a mortal sin? For we are not now dealing with typical and temporary ordinances, but with the lasting moral relations of our Maker to ourselves. "This is my beloved Son, hear him," is the voice which now calls to us out of the excellent glory. Does the Lord, then, now by his Spirit, who is sent to guide us into all truth, refer us for our choicest consolations to the spirits of the dead? It would weary my Christian readers to dwell longer on this point.

But, argues Dr. S., modern spiritualism cannot be of Satan, because it is beneficial to mankind, and it belongs to the devil to injure rather than to bless. Dr. S. is a man of culture and ready faculty, a rhetorician by profession, who chooses the "oration" as his favourite method of instructing men. But wisdom of words is most usually foolishness with God, and such reasoning as he has offered to show that the prince of darkness cannot be the author of modern spiritualism proves him to be in knowledge far below the weakest babe in Christ. For how did that old serpent first prevail, if not by means of lying promises of good to man? And does one who claims companionship with God's true servants in their work require to be taught that it is as an angel of light, and as counterfeit ministers of righteousness, that Satan and his ministers have ever practised most successfully within the vineyard of the Lord? But I must quote here his own words: "It was not the habit of Satan in days of old to do good, or to help in any way to benefit mankind. His practice then was to work evil, to shut out the light of God's countenance from men, and to prompt to error and crime. If we now find him doing the reverse of all this, teaching mankind that a God exists who is their Creator and Father, and to whom they will be accountable hereafter for deeds done in the body, then a very different question arises, viz., How are we, when we see the purest and holiest truths taught in connection with any movement, to know that the devil may not after all be the prime mover of the whole thing?" There is a characteristic shamelessness belonging to all anti-Christian teachings, of which the teacher may often be quite unconscious, because the darkness in which he is walking has both blinded his eyes and neutralised his moral sense, and on the above extract this unlovely trait is broadly marked. For the writer cannot be so ignorant of the letter of the Bible as not to know that it is by the Holy Ghost sent down from heaven, and not by departed spirits from the grave, that the knowledge of truth, both present and to come, can be communicated to mankind. We have already had before us some specimens of what are here unblushingly called "the purest and holiest truths." We have weighed them in the balance of the sanctuary and have found them to be flatlies against God's written word.

But, indeed, this "difficult" and palpably ensnaring question admits of a

537

ready and a very simple answer, and it is this: God only is good and doeth good. "Whatever," to quote from another paper on the same subject,* "is not or God is against him in its operation and effect. Jesus Christ is the Son of the Father in truth and love: the Holy Ghost is the witness who reveals him, and the Scriptures are his open testimony to all who have an ear to hear. God's word is truth. All science or knowledge, therefore, purporting to benefit mankind, which opposes that word in its plain significance is false science in the sight of God." (1 Tim. vi. 20.) Now, that modern spiritualism, or necromancy, which falsely claims to be a teacher of the way of peace and happiness to men, is a thing essentially contrary to God has been already shown. Then, whatever its pretended benefits to men, it is most evidently of the father of lies, that old serpent which deceiveth the whole world. (Rev. xii. 9.) It stands in the same category with many other false gospels that are in the world. For anti-Christ's are many, and often borrow Christian names, but all will be found on due examination alike contradictory of the true record which God has given of his Son.

Let us note, also, the pitiable self-contradiction of this clever but much deluded mind. "Spiritualism nowhere lays claim," says Dr. S., "to be a mode of salvation, neither does it possess any fixed principles with regard to revealed religion." But just now he told us that its mission is to teach mankind the existence of God, the certainty of a future life, the doctrine of personal accountability, &c.; things which Christians usually think have some connection with "revealed religion." I do not stay to comment further on the gross impudence of this Satanic travesty of the "principles of Christ," (Heb. vi. 1) but remark that not only is it true that spiritualism lays no claim to be a mode of salvation, but also that it annuls entirely the Christian idea of salvation by its utter denial of the cross of Christ, while, as we have seen, its heaven and hell are subjective impressions merely, not eternal facts. It is not a mode of salvation most assuredly, but that it is a "heresy of destruction" (2 Pet. ii. 1), must be clearly apparent to the readers of this paper, and has been more largely proved elsewhere.

And may I not fairly ask the writer, in the presence of God's universal church, why he, who claims by profession to be a true disciple of the Lord, has ventured to connect the name of God and of his Christ with a system which, while pretending to confer unparalleled benefits on men, has, by his own admission, nothing to do with either salvation or revealed religion? Is it, then, an error to believe with John and Paul that all fulness dwells in Christ, and that in him are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge? For, according to Dr. S., "the noblest consolation that has blessed humanity" is quite apart from salvation or revealed religion!

It is by the word of his truth that God of his own will begets his real children to himself. (1 James i. 18; 1 Peter i. 23.) The inspired Scriptures are, as the word of Christ, the appointed pasture of his flock. God only can bless men, and his true blessing is tasted by those, and those only, who receive it in the gospel of his Son. Yet Dr. S. is not afraid to say that spiritualism, with its necromantic teachings, "has rescued thousands of sceptics from the brink of Atheism, and planted their feet upon the firm rock of Christ!" I mourn and stand amazed at the infatuation that can so express itself. In respect of verity, this declaration may vie with the assertion of another spiritualistic writer, who puts "the healing power now possessed by hundreds of mediums" on a par with Elisha's restoration of the dead to life! Faith, says the apostle comes by bearing, and bearing by the word of God. "Thousands of atheists have their feet planted on the firm rock of Christ," says Dr. S., "through hearkening to the voices of dead men!"

Is there no solution of this strange and monstrous incongruity? There is, alas, a sufficient as well as truly sad solution. The deceivers of the last times

* Spiritualism: What is it, and whence comes it? Yapp and Hawkins.

are themselves deceived, and DREAMERS is their characteristic name (2 Tim. iii. 13; Jude 8). And even as in natural dreams all contemplated objects are distinctly cognizable, and to the mind of the sleeper are realities so long as his dream lasts, so it is with these men. Themselves still in the darkness of nature, they see nothing clearly but their own imaginations. They may occupy themselves with spiritual things, and handle fearlessly the words of God, but until enlightened from above they have no true perception of what they confidently claim to know and teach (1 Tim. i. 7). Their elaborate arguments are but as delirious ravings in the estimation of a sober mind, while their great swelling words of vanity, which tickle the ears and steal away the hearts of the unwary, allure those who hearken to them far away from the true and only source of life and peace.

With reference to the distinctive boast of modern spiritualism—that it is the only effective opponent of materialism—it is well to notice and remember carefully that these apparent contraries proceed originally from one and the same evil source. Both are false, and both therefore are of the father of lies. They differ in this, that one is the denial of truth, the other the assertion of falsehood; and of these two evil things the latter is by far the worse. For a negation gives no rest to any mind, while a lie may and does give a false rest to a deluded soul. The subject is a truly awful one, but it is incumbent on all who are really Christ's to gird well their loins with truth in these perilous and evil days, and to look these methods of the devil fairly in the face. The keys of death and Hades are in the hands of our risen and exalted Head. He is Lord of the living and also of the dead, and he has spoken of an hour in which all who are in the grave shall hear his voice and shall come forth. In the meantime the spirits of the disobedient dead are kept in Hades, and the spirits of the just are with the Lord. To those on earth whom he is not ashamed to call his brethren his angels are sent forth to minister; but that the spirits of the dead are thus employed is an idea without any countenance from Scripture. To suppose that such spirits come, as is asserted, in answer to necromantic invocations, is to make Jehovah a consenting party to the violation of his own commandment, and a blesser of the thing which he has cursed.

But true as this is, it is not less true that even as God sends his holy angels forth as messengers and ministers of grace, so also Satan, within limits known and fixed of God, is permitted to employ in like manner his ministers of fraud and wickedness. We know, by an express declaration of the Spirit, that to speak lies in hypocrisy is a part of their appointed work. We know also, on the same authority, that miraculous powers are to be put forth by such (1 Tim. iv. 1, 2: Rev. xvi. 14). God intends to send a strong delusion upon those who stumble at his word of righteousness and refuse his embassy of grace. They who love leasing rather than God's saving truth will, alas, be helped to their desire. A lie will address them, and they will believe a lie. It is, therefore, no marvel if lying spirits be (as I cannot doubt they are) judicially allowed to imitate the voices, and even personate the forms of those whom men perversely seek in wilful disregard to God's commands. But it is what these voices utter that reveals unmistakably their origin. Dr. S. may be ignorant of the fact, or may possibly ignore it purposely, but there is in progress of formation a positive creed of spiritualism—a gospel of Satanic falsehood, as opposed to the true witness of the Holy Ghost. Full evidence of this has been given in the Spirits Tried, and need not, therefore, be repeated here.

I reach, then, on a full consideration of this subject, first, the general conclusion that modern spiritualism as a whole is essentially of Satan, and secondly that of all its phases that which is falsely called Christian spiritualism is the most Satanic, because the most deceptive and the most elaborately false. It presumes to associate the sacred name of Christ with that which utterly dishonours him, and is on that account to be more watchfully observed and diligently shunned than that which openly blasphemes his name.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate