What to Read? — A Paper For Young Men — By B. W. Carr
THE divine Lawgiver of antiquity has left on record that famous saying, "Man liveth not by bread alone, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of God." That word inspired is alone fitted to support our spiritual nature. But we have a mental and moral constitution as well as a physical organisation. And I think it must be obvious to every thoughtful person that we all have a necessity to feed our minds with knowledge as well as to supply our bodies with nourishment. In respect to both, it is a matter of deep importance that we should know the best market to resort to, that we should be able to discriminate between the wholesome and deleterious produce exposed to common view, and that we should carefully observe those rules prescribed by wisdom and experience in partaking of the bread-stuffs and luxurious fruits adapted to promote our health and strength. LITERATURE is the subject we have in our mind's eye—literature in the broad, general acceptation of the term. What thoughts does that one word "literature" suggest? The world's great library of old books and new books, pamphlets and newspapers, periodicals and reviews, a plentiful supply on every conceivable topic, a host of volumes
15
and heaps of printed paper—poetry and prose, philosophy, speculative and practical, history and fiction, tomes upon tomes of the sacred, the profane, and the miscellaneous. In the midst of all I see man!—thinking man, panting for an atmosphere suited to his nature, hungering for substantial food to satisfy the cravings of his inner life, thirsting for congenial streams to slake his intense, feverish, ardent desire for knowledge. Woman! I catch a glimpse of her too; she is continually peering in. With hasty, hurried step, she enters the dingy room. With quick and piercing eye she scans those dusty shelves. Struck with a catching title, she will be first to seize the fresh book, to cut its folded leaves, and scan its motley page. So like our common mother Eve is she, of eager appetite for fruit of knowledge that is "pleasant to the eye and desirable to make one wise." And then abroad she lightly trips, no bookworm, no recluse. What suits her not for the sunny fields, for the fertile garden, for the social intercourse of her fellow-creatures, and the dutiful fulfilment of her tender vocation, she rejects; and well she may. Therein she is right. But oh, it is bewildering to think of the number of books! They increase more rapidly than the readers. My friend "Censor" touches me on the shoulder, just to notice that all books and pamphlets are not literature. Parliamentary papers, law reports, political squibs, professional treatises, sectarian squabbles, and tradesmen's advertisements, all come out on printed paper, without the slightest claim to take rank in the great domain of literature—that true literature which must be universal in its sympathy to obtain a peerage among the aristocracy of talent, which demands universal homage. As Wordsworth says—
"Books, we know,
Are a substantial world, both pure and good;
Round these, with tendrils strong as flesh and blood,
Our passions and our happiness will grow."
If, then, the vast resources of literature be capable (as I suppose few would presume to question) of augmenting our pleasure, of raising our character, and of enlarging the sphere of our abilities, is it not obvious that in their use a grave personal responsibility rests upon us, that in their abuse there is an evil to be seriously dreaded, and that in the choice we make our moral welfare is very considerably at stake.
Not many of our young friends would like to confess that they considered their education completed on the day they left school; but we are afraid it would not be uncharitable to accuse them of acting on that presumption. Henceforward they adopt no settled plan, pursue no systematic course of study, and look back upon the discipline they were subject to in childhood as a trammel from which they have escaped, rather than cherish it as a habit which it is desirable for them to keep up. For our part, we remember nothing in our earthly pilgrimage more distinctly than the transition period when we were not quite certain whether we were a boy or a man. The twenty or thirty years that have intervened bear witness to a vast change in what we venture to call the temper of society. Our fathers thought us green at twenty, but we are disposed to pay court to our children, and to utilise their abilities when they are five years short of that advanced age. The
lines are fallen to them in pleasant places, so far as they escape the severity of training we had to endure, but the profit that will accrue to them is more than doubtful if they do not become a law unto themselves, and voluntarily observe the statutes they are not compulsorily bound to obey. Books were our best friends, and we do not know how to introduce our young friends to better acquaintance, if they are only choice and select in the company they keep. Ah, there is the rub! We can imagine ourselves standing in a library of wills and probates, conscious that the perusal of some of them might show our title to a large property, but uncertain and ignorant in which to look. Or we could picture ourselves sick and infirm in a library of medical works, aware that in some of them our symptoms are stated and the remedy prescribed, did we but know which book to select, or whither to turn our eyes. Can we not equally imagine that in the presence of a vast concourse of books there are some which might acquaint us with truths more precious to the soul than gold of Ophir; others which might correct the very worst points of our disposition; and those again which might inspire us with fresh views of life, and shape the whole tenor of our future career in this world; to say nothing of books more sacred, which can unfold to our hearts the hallowed mysteries of the world to come. A lecturer once said, "There are thoughts and passions existing only on silent, senseless paper, the perusal of which might make you raise your hands in astonishment, or split your sides with laughter, or weep tears of tender sympathy, till your very eyes were bloodshot. Bound up in mouldy sheepskin are words of magic power, which require nothing but eyes and hearts to make them converse with you." And yet in reading for the useful you may waste your time over the useless; while you seek light, the shades of darkness may envelope you; in making experiments upon health you may foster disease.
Let us stop a moment to take breath. Are there no tracts or pamphlets, lectures, or essays, which we can recommend you to inspect as suggestive of a good course of study? Well, we suppose there are. Thomas De Quincy published some "Letters to a young man whose education had been neglected," which it would be worth the while of other young men to peruse. If you can pick up an "Introduction to English Literature from Chaucer to Tennyson," by Henry Reed, it will repay your perusal. Dr. Arnold found in him a congenial spirit, and that is some recommendation to his talents. By all means lay out a shilling upon Robert Aris Willmott, for his "Pleasures, Objects, and Advantages of Literature" may whet your appetite; and if you perchance need an emetic, inquire at the Young Men's Christian Association if they can supply you with a copy of the lecture which the late Sir James Stephens gave them at Exeter Hall as a cavent to "desultory reading." With these tractates in one's hand, at a period of life when the disposition is supple, the imagination vivid, the memory retentive, and a purpose of life unfixed by circumstances and capable of resolute direction, one might point his compass to some purpose.
Our forefathers used to classify learning. Following Lord Bacon, they divided it into three parts, and identified them with three branches of the human intellect. History, which they allied to memory;
17
Poetry, which they accounted the daughter of imagination; and Philosophy, which they feigned to be the offspring of reason. Of science they made no account. It was excluded from the enchanted circle. The fashion of our age is to extol science at the expense of literature. Lord Carnarvon has just been giving an address to the members and friends of the Birkbeck Scientific and Literary Institution, complaining of the undue preference. He warns them against the danger of attempting to try every principle, impulse, and faith, by a rigidly scientific standard. No doubt the temptation is imminent. Religion, literature, and art are placed in the background, while chemistry and mechanism occupy the fore-front. Be it remembered, however, that the great and noble authors of antiquity had won their imperishable fame before the ingenious race, whose faculties took a practical turn, had made their appearance at the foot of Mount Parnassus. Then the Muses adjudged them unfitted, by their harsher erudition, connected as it was with squares, and cubes, and curves, to breathe the serene atmosphere of pure literature. The decision has been given, and we cannot afford to discuss its propriety. The construction of a steam-engine no more entitles a man to the laurel crown than the manufacture of patent boots. For "Thomas Babington Macaulay," statesman, poet, historian, the doors of Westminster Abbey are open, and his ashes may rest in peace nigh the spot where "Rare Ben Jonson" was laid. But for George Stephenson there is no room in Poet's Corner. It is useless to murmur. What need of jealousy on the part of those who in their life-time have been paid in gold, so long as their more gifted brethren, who sparkled like stars to light and cheer the world beneath, were content to labour on with secret satisfaction, but without sordid pay, till they should receive posthumous honour in the admiration and homage of grateful millions of their fellow-men? I am prone to think that this last reflection will serve to narrow, as well as to render conspicuous, the object I have in view. We do not aim to be the Mentors of those who aspire to a seat even in the Lower House of Representative Men, to whom literature is a charm and an idol; but we ask for the ear of many who covet the true blessing of good books for the inward light and peace which they are capable of diffusing through the mind. Taste is requisite—taste both natural and acquired—in order to possess a thorough relish for "the sublime and the beautiful." That taste should be indulged according to the present attainments and opportunities any one may possess; but to avoid and abjure every species of reading which tends to vitiate the finer susceptibilities of a cultivated nature is the paramount duty of a conscientious student. We want recreation as a perfect relief from business; yet we want at the same time a helpful stimulant to just those faculties of our nature which business does not call into play. And any one who would educate himself thoroughly must give, as far as he is able, a measure of cultivation to all the elementary faculties of our common nature. Were you to be constantly cramming your brain with facts, and never weighing them in the scales of judgment, you might become a walking dictionary, but no one would account your opinion worth asking. Or were you to be constantly arguing, without much acquaintance with
2
those facts that are the basis of reason, your logic would be always at fault, and everybody would vote you a bore. But were you to attend to both of these, and yet neglect altogether the imaginative, never indulge the flights of fancy, or follow the poet in his rapturous sallies into the spirit-world, you would be a dull, heavy fellow, whom no genial man would seek for a companion.
With diversity of culture, however, it is not a whit less important that you combine unity of object. Discursive reading is so gross a fallacy that I might almost call it a foolery. Let the errors of great men be accounted beacons to warn little men. Here and there some aspiring genius has essayed to carve his name on every pillar of the Pantheon. The author usually fails when he rambles from his true vocation. Old Samuel Johnson was grammarian, critic, and moralist, and these pursuits harmonised very well; but he saw no reason why he should not be a poet. If Milton emulated Homer, why should not Johnson rival Juvenal? He did not succeed, though I suppose he thought he did. If you ask the publishers and booksellers they will tell you that there is no demand for "London," a poem, by Dr. Johnson. On the contrary, the scholar who has singleness of purpose may call as many savans to his aid as possible, the more the better. Shakespeare had one design. It was to enrich and elevate the stage. But what an exact historian he was! how he practised the art of reasoning! His sketches of human nature are the most real and life-like. Yet what grotesque fancies he has! He revels in the fabulous and fantastic. He excels in the highest branches of poetry, and he equally excels in the pretty love ditty and pleasant song. All this might have exposed him to blame, instead of raising him to fame, had he been fairly chargeable with attempting too much. But as he grouped the whole round one centre, he produces a unique but ever varied charm. Were we talking tête-à-tête with any young man, we should say, "Choose your study, sir. Till you have done that, you are not a student, read as hard as you may. Construct the reservoir first, and then you can discreetly multiply the pipes you lay down to feed it."
Old books are the best books. This is more than an opinion, it is a truism. The proverb says, "With the ancients is wisdom." Your scientific man is constantly inquiring for new books and new editions of those volumes published by living authors. If you pick up a scientific work fifty years old, and ask his opinion of its merits, he will tell you that it had a good run in its day, but it has been exploded by new discoveries. That is all very well with science. But your literary man talks in quite a different strain. He does little more than glance at new books, while he reads and ponders, studies and digests, the old ones. He never dreams of the Iliad being superseded by anything the poet laureate can bring out. Montgomery's "Satan" never had a chance of competing with Milton's "Paradise Lost." The idea of Bulwer or Henry Taylor eclipsing the bard of Avon would be preposterous.
If you really wish to discipline your minds, to sharpen your wits, and to train your reasoning faculties, just begin this way. Read, not as a diversion, but read as a study, Lord Bacon's Essays, Locke on the Understanding, and Butler's Analogy. You will then have laid a
19
tolerably substantial groundwork. I have known young men, who in boyhood had missed the advantage of a liberal education, talk of beginning Latin, or beginning Greek, as a little speculation on their own account. They never did anything more than begin; soon, indeed, afterwards they left off. Let your pretensions be moderate. If you aim at nothing higher than a sound acquaintance with English literature, your attainment of that object would be very creditable. Whatever department you resolve to explore, go as high up the stream as possible, and drink as near the fountain-head of learning as you can. It is a shame that the essayists who flourished in the early part of the eighteenth century should be overlooked. Addison may be accounted a prince among them.
Poetry you need considerable training to appreciate in its most elevated and elevating flights of pure imagination. Remember this, literature is a lifeless corpse without the living soul of poetry that animates every nerve of the historian, the critic, and the preacher. Would you make the acquaintance of Dryden, Thompson, and Cowper (to say nothing of Chaucer or Cowley), you must choose your opportunities, when you can resign yourself wholly up to them. Challenge nothing; do not disturb yourself to make a remark upon their caprice; just mount on their wings; put implicit confidence in their guidance; let them carry you wherever they like. It will be time enough when you have dropped down to earth again and feel the solid ground under your feet—it will be time enough then to reason over the journey you have made, and consider what has produced the deepest impression on your minds. By the bye, this bit of counsel I have transcribed from an old scrap-book of mine. How it found its way there I cannot recollect. If the words are my own, well and good; if they are wholly or partly borrowed, I deliberately endorse them. It is a good plan to read poetry, especially blank verse, out aloud. The rhythm will then be agreeable and impressive. I like Mr. Willmott's story: "William Pitt had a nation's cares weighing heavily upon him to distract his brain, while the roar of contending factions added no little to the wear and tear of office; yet he would often make his escape and indulge in absolute retirement with some favourite author. A visitor called on him one day, and found him reading Milton aloud with strong emphasis, and so deeply engaged in 'Paradise' as to have forgotten the presence of any other people in the world, except Adam and Eve."
There is an obvious advantage in basing your studies upon the old standard works. Reading confers no benefit upon you if it fail to exercise a powerful influence on your character. If the authors with whom you become familiar are such as all intelligent men defer to, then the sentiments and sympathies you imbibe are cosmopolitan. They fit and adapt you for any good society anywhere; but if the rill of knowledge and bigotry at which you slake your thirst be small and obscure, then it is only within a narrow circle of very peculiar people that you may ever dare to open your lips.
Before we finish this chit-chat with our young friends, there are a few remarks which may aid such of them as have followed us thus far. Those who live in the metropolis, or in any of our leading provincial towns, will readily find access to large libraries on easy terms. Let
them avail themselves of the privilege. Still there are some few books they will find it expedient to buy. Fortunately for them, the standard works are the least expensive. The late Mr. Charles Knight published a small series, entitled, "Sketches of the History of Literature and Learning in England, with specimens of the principal writers," which it would be desirable to purchase. The six volumes can be procured for about as many shillings. They will acquaint you with the character of our most worthy authors, and help you to survey the catalogue at any library with an intelligent eye.
No remarks we have made are intended to disparage modern writers. We only advise you, as our Mentors advised us, that your tastes should be formed by the old ones. Justly to criticise the men of the present, we must have an extensive acquaintance with those of the past. It is the exclusiveness against which we inveigh—the ignorant exclusiveness with which so many people are wont to catch at new books as new lights. There is a moral evil connected with this habit. Authors, like men in general, are ruled by circumstances. When they all belong to one generation, they are all cast in one mould, so they all imbibe common prejudices, and they all inherit common partialities. True it is, the men of bygone times reflected in like manner the habits of thought and action peculiar to their day; yet were that their sole title to notice, their works would not be likely to come across us. The volumes that survive the wreck are those that belong to all time; and the descriptions they furnish of nature are as permanent as the creation, and as constantly revived as the seasons. The portraits they give of man exhibit him as he was, and as he is, undraped and undisguised. Those are the best books beyond dispute which weather the storm, and float gallantly on the ocean, generation after generation, while the smaller craft are sinking beneath the waves every day.
There lie beyond us, however, higher interests, upon which we must muse with awe; and a destiny for which we must prepare with seriousness, if we would face it with cheerfulness. Read whatever else we may, there is one book which it were folly to slight, and fatal to neglect. As George Withers quaintly says,—
For many books I care not, and my store
Might now suffice me, though I had no more
Than God's two testaments, and then withal
That mighty volume which "The World" we call.
For these well looked on, well in mind preserved,
The present age's passages observed,
My private actions seriously o'erviewed,
My thoughts recalled, and what of them ensued,
Are "Books," which better far instruct me can,
Than all the other paper works of man.
And some of these I may be reading, too,
Where'er I come, or whatsoe'er I do.
