Notices of Books
Biblical Commentary on the Old Testament. The Prophecies of Jeremiah. By C. F. KEIL, D.D. T. T. Clark, Edinburgh.
Our ministerial brethren and more learned readers will be glad to hear of the issue of the second volume of Keil on Jeremiah. The scholarship of these commentaries is of the highest order, and of course they are therefore only useful to the few, but by that few the many are instructed, so that really a boon is conferred upon the entire church by their publication. Messrs. Clark have now published 120 volumes of their Foreign Theological Library,—a vast undertaking indeed; many societies have attempted far less, and have failed. The whole series can be purchased for £31 10s., a princely present for a minister, and by the way a very opportune gift to the library of our new College should anybody feel moved to present it. We earnestly request that two persons will not insist upon doing it; to prevent any contest about the matter we shall be happy to act as referee.
From Darkness to Light. By FREDERICK WAGSTAFF. Kempster and Co., 9 and 10, St. Bride's Avenue.
This is one of a series called the Home Library, each of which is marked price sixpence, post free. This is an amusing temperance and Templar tale, and is sure to be widely circulated among abstainers. The engravings are about as
bad as any we have ever seen, but a book in a strong stiff cover for sixpence cannot be expected to contain works of art. Another book of this series is, "Recitations in Verse," by Harriet A. Glazebrook. Here we have water, water, everywhere. One of the songs upon water in Paradise, and water from the smitten rock asks questions which we should have thought could never have occurred to a temperance poet and a reverend!
Would Eden thus have smiled
Had wine to Eden come?
Would Horeb's parching wild
Have been refreshed with rum?
And had Eve's hair
Been dressed in gin
Would she have been reflected fair?
Had Moses built a still,
And dealt out to that host
To every man a gill,
And pledged him in a toast,
How large a band
Of Israel's sons
Had laid their bones in Canaan's land!
We hope that this is meant to be funny, and that there is some mysterious sense in it, which we are unable to discern. We heard a brother defend total abstinence the other evening upon this ground among many others—that when dead, teetotallers' bodies would keep longer than other people's. That may have been an argument of weight with some people, but it produced a roar of laughter in the quarter under our notice. Is it not a pity to make a cause ridiculous by a silly advocacy of it?
233
Guide to Christian Evidences. By Dr. BREWER, author of "Guide to Science," &c. Jarrold and Sons.
An admirable compendium of argument, well fitted to be used as a textbook in our schools and in the junior classes of our Colleges. When we say this we do not mean that it should be confined to such institutions, for it would be well if every Christian studied the work and had its cogent reasonings ready to hand in this day of abounding scepticism. Dr. Brewer has done good service by issuing such a valuable handbook.
The Tiny Library. Partridge and Co.
This library now consists of twenty-four little bijoux at sixpence each. Each one is prettiness itself as to binding, is printed in large type so that little readers may not try their eyes too much, and contains some nice story with an excellent moral. Such treasures for sixpence Solomon himself never dreamed of. Whoever conceived and carried out the idea of this tiny series deserves the thanks of every English child.
Messrs. PARTRIDGE also issue the British Workman Series of small books at twopence each, which we most heartily commend for cheapness and interest. We hope the series will obtain a world-wide circulation. Lost in the Snow—a telling temperance and religious story bound in limp cloth for sixpence, may be bad of the same enterprising firm.
The Life of Luther. By A. L. O. E.
The Book Society.
This delightful little book contains the essence of D'Aubigné's history of the Reformation, so far as it concerns Luther. Readers of the works of A. L. O. E. know that she has peculiarly rich gifts as a writer for the young, and will be fully recompensed if for that reason they purchase this little work. We should like every child to read it. We are not half careful enough to instruct our children in the history of Protestantism, and so the rising generation glides into Popery. The reading of such a work as this must do the juveniles great good.
Religion and Science. A Series of Sunday Lectures on the Relation of Natural and Revealed Religion; or, the Truths revealed in Nature and Scripture. By JOSEPH LE CONTE, Professor of Geology and Natural History in the University of California. Bickers and Son, 1, Leicester Square.
SOMETHING good at last has come from Leicester Square; and we heartily thank Messrs. Bickers and Son for this publication. Bating a few expressions, this is a book after our own heart. We would have every student read it. It goes thoroughly into the subject, but is in so popular a style that it makes most attractive reading. The nonsense of the modern savans will do little harm if such books are widely scattered as an antidote. California is rich in mental gold if it has many men of the same type as Mr. Le Conte; a liberal importation of such precious metal will enrich our own nation. We wish we knew the cost of this book, and as we do not, we hope the publishers will advertise it in our columns, and then our thoughtful readers will do well to make the purchase. We mention this because to many price is no small consideration.
The Parable of the Prodigal Son. A Homiletic Exposition. By the Rev. FERGUS FERGUSON, M.A. Hamilton, Adams, and Co.
VERY plain and telling sermons upon that parable which above all others contains the quintessence of the gospel. Working men beginning to read this book would be sure to read it through, it is so thoroughly popular in its style; in fact, it rather errs in that direction, and contains a few passages which we, who are by no means squeamish, should not have recommended the preacher to retain in the printed copy; for instance, the ridiculous story of the fisherman touching iron when the preacher mentioned the swine, spiritualised into touching the nails of the cross. We only wish that the mass of ministers were in danger of going too far in the direction indicated, and we congratulate Mr. Ferguson upon being in so happy a peril. His book is one which it has been a pleasure to read.
Sir Donald McLeod, a Record of Forty-two Years' Service in India. By Major-General EDWARD LAKE. Religious Tract Society.
WE are glad to see this pleasant memoir of an eminent Baptist brother, who has but recently been taken from among us. His character was never more correctly estimated than by a native gentleman who said, "If all Christians were like Sir Donald McLeod, there would be no Hindoos or Mahomedans. A nobler Christian philanthropist or statesman has not yet trod the plains of India." The Religious Tract Society has done well to issue this record, and we are glad that they do not conceal the fact of his having been a Baptist: we generally find that unsectarian societies are very careful to ignore any fact in our favour, and therefore we are glad to see some honesty and courage left among undenominationalists. Nothing has more seriously tended to lower the tone of religious principle than the effort to produce works entirely free from any religious peculiarities; the colourless, soulless product has never compensated for the manliness destroyed by its production.
The Living Epistle, or Gathered Fragments from the Correspondence of the late Caroline Blackwell. Shaw and Co.
THIS is a collection of living epistles. The writer would seem to have been a Plymouth sister, and this gives a peculiarity to her expressions (among the rest there is too much DEARING for our taste); but her letters are weighty and powerful, full of Scriptural remarks and experimental utterances. We have found much profit in reading these "fragments," so far as we have gone, and are promising ourselves a great treat in looking over the rest. A delightful aroma of the Lord Jesus perfumes these letters, and therefore they will be acceptable to many of those who love HIM. We rejoice that the epistles of such an elect lady have been preserved; they do not pretend to literary ability, deep thought, or erudite remark, they are simply the letters of a well instructed Christian woman written to her friends.
The Doctrine of Eternal Punishment Vindicated against Recent Attacks. A Tractate. By the Rev. PROFESSOR WATTS, D.D., Assembly's College, Belfast. Belfast, William Mullan.
A TRENCHANT essay in vindication of the Scriptural doctrine, which is now so frequently assailed by persons whose views of sin are superficial, and "in whose minds the sentimental is largely in excess of the judicial."
Echoes from Distant Footfalls; or the Origin and Unity of the Human Race. By Rev. J. BOYES, F.S.A. Hodder and Stoughton.
NINE very sensible lectures upon the antiquities of our race, dealing most wisely with the supposed geological proofs of its extremely remote origin. Here we have much learning, and an equal measure of piety. The little book will be useful.
Facta non Verba. A Comparison between the Good Works performed by the Ladies in Roman Catholic Convents in England, and the unfettered Efforts of their Protestant Sisters. By the Author of "Contrasts." Isbister and Co.
THE author of "Contrasts" formerly did good service by calling attention to our Orphanage, and to other works of like order, and contrasting them with government expenditure and its results. We are glad to see him again at work, for he writes to purpose, and always has a practical end clearly in view. This book contains brief memoirs of some of the grand female workers of our day, such as Annie Macpherson, Johanna Chandler, Elizabeth Gilbert, Sarah Robinson, and Mary Whately. We have taken a long extract, and inserted it in the earlier part of this present number, in the full belief that hundreds will by reading it be led to purchase the volume. No Christian worker ought to be ignorant concerning the noble works which philanthropic women are performing at this good hour. The book before us supplies all the information needful as an introduction to the work of these eminent ladies.
235
A System of Christian Rhetoric, for the Use of Preachers and other Speakers. By G. W. HERVEY, M.A. Houlston and Sons.
WORKS upon rhetoric and homiletics have been very plentiful of late, and if men do not talk and preach better it is not for lack of instructors. Mr. Hervey has produced a large volume, upon a sufficiently comprehensive plan to be rightly called a system. He is evidently a gentleman of much learning and extensive research, and we pity the reader who will leave his pages without benefit; still we do not think that this volume will ever be much read or exert any great influence. It is full of good things, and abounds in finger-posts which direct the reader to lines of reading and thought, but somehow or other it does not strike us that it was written by a practical man. We do not know who the Rev. George Winfred Hervey may be, but we do not picture him to our own mind as a master in the art of addressing his fellow-men: if he be so he has carefully kept out of his book those warm personal touches which impart warmth and interest to the matter and vivacity to the style. Theoretically he is at home with his subject, and thoroughly versed in its literature: he is also rich in apt quotation, and fitting anecdote. Here is one from a foot-note. "Dr. Matthew Byles being asked why he did not preach politics, replied, 'I have thrown up four breastworks, behind which I have entrenched myself, neither of which can be forced. In the first place, I do not understand politics; in the second place, you all do—every man and mother's son of you; in the third place, you have politics all the week; pray let one day in seven be devoted to religion; in the fourth place, I am engaged in a work of infinitely greater importance. Give me any better subject to preach upon than the truths I bring you, and I will preach it on the next Sabbath.' The index of figures at the end of the volume contains a number of uncivilised words, such as Aganactesis, Amphidorthosis, Allœosis, Epitrochasmus, Paradiegesis, and the like. It is really dangerous to have a book lying about which contains such a menagerie of untamable brute words; those given above are only a
few little tame ones—think of a Præ-pizeuxis or an Exouthenismus getting into one's library. We sincerely hope that no student of this index will try to pronounce such jargon till he has cut his wisdom teeth, and then he had better have them soldered in before he begins.
The Old Book Tested, Popular Queries About the Bible. By the Rev. JOHN WHITE, Belfast. Hodder and Stoughton.
An earnest vindication of the sacred Word, proving its sanctifying, elevating, and stimulating power upon human minds. Mr. White has struck out an interesting path of thought, and has kept to it well. There are in this book nine popular discourses, which could not have been heard without much establishment in the faith. We are right glad to hear in Mr. White's lectures the true ring upon the atonement and kindred doctrines, there are plenty of Congregational churches in which this would be a novelty. We read the other day that the Rev. Empty Brainbox had resigned his pastorate of the Independent Church at Sleepyton, and in his farewell sermon had given as a reason "that he had outgrown the creed of the Congregational body, and felt the necessity of greater liberty than he could obtain among the Independents." What upon earth did the man want? Congregationalists are to be found who believe anything, and some who believe nothing, and limits of creed would seem to have vanished into thin air. We suspect that the cupboard was getting bare, and hence the desire to shift quarters. "Doth the wild ass bray when he hath grass? or loweth the ox over his fodder?"
Little Folks. Cassell, Petter, and Galpin.
THIS magazine at sixpence per month is out of all comparison the best illustrated and most amusing of all juvenile periodicals. It is absolutely gorgeous in pictures. We marvel how it can be produced at the price; the engravings must cost a mint of money. The volumes make a magnificent gallery of art and library of instruction for the little folks.
Everlasting Punishment and Modern Speculation. By the Rev. WILLIAM REID. William Oliphant and Co., Edinburgh.
THIS is a most clear and convincing treatise upon a subject which has unhappily taken possession of the Christian public, to the exclusion of far more profitable themes, at the present time. It includes the whole Scripture proofs of the eternity of future punishment, and refutes all the arguments that could possibly be adduced against it. It is calm, forcible, and conclusive to all who are anxiously inquiring, What saith the Scriptures? No such thoroughness of statement and Biblical research has appeared on the other side. We have been left to gather the wonderful discoveries of modern thought upon the subject from pamphlets, periodicals, and religious newspapers, as they are called. Hence partial views have been given in all of them, and a fair and full investigation in none. The belief of the eternity of future punishment has hitherto been one and almost universal, but a variety of theories have been propounded of late to be substituted in its place. Some are for immediate annihilation at death, some for temporary punishment to be followed by annihilation, some for temporary punishment to be followed by a new probation, and others to be followed by restoration to innocence and bliss. Each sees insuperable difficulties in the theories of others while agreed in the one point that punishment cannot be eternal. It is a presumptive argument, to say the least, that the old doctrine is not false, because no opposite can be found that is agreed upon to be true. May we not judge too of doctrines as of men by the company they keep? Some few who are in all other matters sound in the faith may have been troubled in mind upon this subject, but in general it is associated with speculative notions of other revealed truths, and certainly with less evangelical faith and fervour than the sentiment to which it is opposed. Its effect, in fact, upon all our ideas of sin and holiness, and consequently of the remedial scheme of redemption, is one of the strongest objections against it. Universalism, which is the most favour-
ite, as it is supposed to be the most merciful idea, is particularly subversive of all the first principles both of law and gospel. The difference between good and evil, according to this theory, between atheism and the worship of the true God, between the utmost degree of profanity and the highest degree of piety, between the rejection and the reception of salvation by Christ, between Nero and the Christians that were burned for his own personal gratification, is simply a question of time. Wait a while. All in the end will be equally holy and happy. The evil will work out the good. Impiety will eventually grow into piety. The germ of heaven is in hell. Only give it time to develop itself, and it will burst as from a bitter bud into all the blessedness of heaven. Where, then, is the essential difference between sin and holiness, being under the law and under grace? They are of the same species, only one is of longer growth than the other. How subversive is all this of the fundamental distinctions of good and evil, and how clearly it shows from whence it comes! Awful, therefore, and revolting to human reason as the eternity of future punishment may be, it is in harmony with all the principles of the divine government, and as such is clearly revealed in the Scriptures. There are two questions to which its opponents have hitherto given no satisfactory reply. The first of these is, supposing the Scriptures were intended to teach eternal punishment, how could it be taught in stronger language than may be found in the Scriptures? And the second is, supposing eternal punishment to be derogatory to the divine character, why have we not been cautioned against the very idea?
Flashes of Thought; being One Thousand Choice Extracts from the Works of C. H. SPURGEON, Alphabetically Arranged, and with a Copious Index. London: Passmore and Alabaster, 4, Paternoster Buildings. Price 6s.
THIS volume consists of well-chosen extracts from our own works, and therefore we cannot say anything about it, bad or good, except this—let all who think well, buy it and review it for themselves.
237
Bible Truth and Broad Church Error.
By WILLIAM RITCHIE, D.D., Dunse.
Hodder and Stoughton, 27 and 31,
Paternoster Row.
"BROAD CHURCH" is here used not in
opposition to High Church, but to
clear and definite views of gospel truth.
Bible truths and church errors are the
two things placed in opposition to each
other. Bible and church teaching
should ever be the same, and it is hu-
miluting to think that in this nine-
teenth century of ours there should in
some quarters be so deep and broad a
gulf between them.
The title of this book may well make
us blush for the age in which we live,
and the more so because we feel that
the accusation it conveys is too true.
We welcome it, however, as an antidote
to the evils it deplores. Modern errors
are here brought to the test of Bible
truths. We have first a concise and
clear statement of each great Bible
truth, and then an exposure of the wide
departure from it in modern times.
This is as it should be. As in the treat-
ment of diseases the first thing is to as-
certain what is the healthy and normal
state of the part affected, then how far
there has been a deviation from it, and
then what has been the cause of that de-
viation, that the remedy may be applied
to the origin of the disease, however
far it may be from the seat of its most
painful effects; so the doctrinal diseases
of the church are scientifically dealt
with in this volume. The doctrines of
the gospel are exhibited in their healthy
state, then in their diseased state in
Broad Church views, and the remedy is
sought in a return to the first principles
of the gospel of Christ. The principal
subjects which are thus treated are the
inspiration of the Scriptures, the in-
carnation, atonement, and justifying
righteousness of Christ, the fatherhood
of God, the duration of future punish-
ment, the extent of redemption, and
the restitution of all things. The op-
posing theories investigated and refuted
are those of Colenso, Bushnell, Maurice,
Robertson of Brighton, Ward Beecher,
and Dr. Young. We would advise all
those, and their name is legion, who
have been captivated with the aberra-
tions of these writers to give ear to the
instructions of this book, and give glory
to the Lord their God before they cause
darkness, and before their feet stumble
upon the dark mountains. This book
is an uplifted standard against a flood of
error; we rejoice that the author has
been enabled to set it up by the help of
the good Spirit of God. Those especially
who are troubled with doubts upon the
eternity of future punishment, will here
find such plain teaching of Scripture
upon the subject as leaves nothing
further to be desired. Upon some
themes of equal importance the author
is less forcible and explicit than upon
others, but as a whole he has furnished
an invaluable guide to those who are
asking for the old paths, where is the
good way, that they may walk therein?
Derry and Enniskillen in the Year 1689:
the story of some famous battle-fields
in Ulster. By THOMAS WITHEROW,
Professor of Church History in
Magee College, Londonderry. Bel-
fast, Wm. Mullan.
THIS book should have a London pub-
lisher. It gives details of a portion of
history which no Protestant would let
die. We see no reason why it should
ever be forgotten. Mr. Witherow has
evidently worked with great spirit upon
a congenial task, and his publishers
have worthily embodied his researches
in a handsome volume. Every Ulster
Protestant is of course deeply interested
in this story of the courage and endu-
rance of his ancestors, but the interest
does not end there: every lover of our
common country rejoices to remember
the struggles by which our liberties
were secured to us.
Memoir of John Lowering Cooke. By
CHARLES H. H. WRIGHT, M.A. Nis-
bet and Co., 21, Berners Street.
ONE genuine tale of this kind is more
interesting, as well as more instructive,
than all your religious novels. No real
good can come from mere fiction, or the
effect would be greater than its cause.
This is one of the many striking in-
stances of converting grace, which are
not wanting in this any more than in
the apostolic age, and which are inva-
riably the result of the same truth and
the same Spirit. It is the experience of
a Christian soldier amidst the tempta-
tions of ransacking cities, and the dan-
gers of the battle-field.
The Man of Sorrows and The Fainting Warrior. By C. H. SPURGEON. Embossed for the College for Blind Sons of Gentlemen, Worcester. May be had of Messrs. Passmore and Alabaster, 4, Paternoster Buildings, London; and at the College, Worcester. Price 3s. each.
THESE two of our sermons have been embossed for the use of the blind. They are printed in the same letter as ordinary books. Those of our readers who have sightless friends who are able to read should present them with a copy. As the production of such books is costly, we need purchasers to encourage the issue of more. We hope they will do good.
Christian Ethics. By H. MARTENSEN, D.D. T. and T. Clarke, George Street, Edinburgh.
THIS is one of the best of the foreign series of publications by Messrs. Clarke, of Edinburgh. We are indebted for it also to Mr. Spence, who translated it from the Danish language. Such a Northern Light does not often come into view. It might be supposed that little need be said upon Christian ethics, since they are the natural outgrowth of Christian principles, and are clearly defined and enforced in the New Testament; nor would there have been any occasion to look for their explanation and defence elsewhere, if they had not been greatly perverted from their original source and design by modern writers. To restore Christian ethics to their scriptural place and influence is the design of this treatise. The author has evidently been a diligent observer of the frequent use that has been made of this subject in recent times, with the view of setting aside greater and even more important truths; and with a deep and patient research, not inferior to that of any to whom he is opposed, he has shown the utter instability of the purposes to which it has been applied, and rescued it as a weapon of defence from their hands. Men of modern thought may here see where they are, and where they ought to be; how they came to be where they are, and how they may return to what they ought to be. Though in some parts
professedly controversial, it is instructive throughout to all who desire clear and extensive views of the whole system of divine truth; nor is a correct view of Christian ethics in an inferior degree conducive to that end, it holds place in the front rank. Morality without Christianity there may be, but the morality of Christianity is peculiar to itself. The one, when perfect, is the cause of justification; the other, however perfect, is its effect. The only drawback to the general acceptance of this book is the frequent use of scholastic terms, which to some may be deemed needful to give precision to the arguments founded upon them. The soundness of its views of Christian ethics overrides all other considerations.
"Talk they of morals? Oh, thou bleeding Lamb! the grand morality is love of thee."
Pages from the Life of the Apostle Paul. By WILLIAM and ELIZABETH BENNETT. Harris and Co., 5, Bishopsgate Street Without; S. W. Partridge and Co., 9, Paternoster Row.
THIS is an excellent guide to a consecutive view of the labours and travels of the great Apostle of the Gentiles. It is an account of the outer rather than of the inner life of that greatest of mere men, as all references to his doctrines and their experimental influence are carefully avoided. It is well adapted for Bible-class and Sunday-school teachers, as a ground-work upon which their own particular instructions may be founded.
Paul and Christ. By J. M. CRAMP, D.D. Yates and Alexander, Symond's Inn, Chancery Lane.
A VERY fairly compiled history of the apostle Paul, with the argument to be drawn therefrom. After the larger works on the same biography there is small hope of advancing anything fresh or very striking, but there remains the possibility of condensing, and putting into a readable form for congregational use, the matter which is the common wealth of the church. The writer has done this with more than average success, and his book is therefore well worth a perusal.
239
Review Exercises in the Sunday School:
their value and methods. By Rev. H. C.
TRUMBULL. Sunday School Union.
TRUTH is fastened upon youthful minds
only by frequent repetition. We must
tell children the same thing twenty
times, because nineteen times won't do.
"Tell me the story often,
For I forget so soon:
The early dew of the morning
Has pass'd away at noon."
It is both grievous and startling to find
how little some children know, who,
nevertheless, have been to the Sabbath-
school for years; either there are many
inefficient teachers abroad, or else their
modes of teaching need amendment.
This little book advocates frequent re-
hearsals of the same lessons, and regular
examinations of the classes, and we like
it so well that we would have all our
teachers read it, and practise its sug-
gestions.
The Banner Unfurled. Choice Selec-
tions from Christian Writers. Edited
by E. A. H. Partridge and Co.
"THE profits arising from the sale of
this book will be devoted to the pur-
pose of training a missionary for
China." This object speaks for itself,
and stays our critical knife. The ex-
tracts have been made with opened
eyes and spiritual taste.
The Pictorial Dictionary of the Bible.
New Edition, profusely Illustrated
with Biblical Maps and Chromo-
lithograph Engravings, etc. W. R.
M'Phun and Co., Glasgow and
London.
We have before us four shilling parts
of this work, and certainly there is a
great deal of matter for the money.
Some of the engravings would have
improved the volume if they had been
left out; they are executed in a style
of art which deserves to become ex-
tinct, or else the plates are so worn that
the beauty has long since gone. A
young fellow with thirty shillings to
spare could do better with his money
by letting it rest till he had enough to
purchase a really standard work than
by taking in these numbers, but at the
same time the Pictorial Dictionary
contains much valuable information,
and is an instructive assistant to the
Bible Reader. We should greatly
prefer Smith's or Kitto's; but if these
should happen to be above our reader's
means, they will be much helped by
consulting M'Phun's Dictionary. There
are to be thirty parts, issued monthly,
and many will thus be able to purchase
a Biblical Dictionary who otherwise
would be without one, and therefore
we wish the enterprise success.
