Notices of Books
The Hero of Elstow; or, the Story of the Pilgrimage of John Bunyan. By JAMES CORNER, M.A., Vicar of the parish of Elstow. Hodder and Stoughton.
THE vicar of Elstow wants his church repaired and a stained glass window, and has therefore hit upon the idea of getting it done as a memorial of John Bunyan. Why not repair a Catholic chapel as a memorial of Martin Luther? or the Baptist chapel at Elstow as a memorial of Charles II.? We confess we do not see the congruity of the thing, and we wonder if anybody else does. We shall one day see a State Church set up in some of our colonies in memory of Mr. Miall, and a Conservative Club founded as a tribute of regard for Mr. John Bright. We have no doubt the vicar is an excellent as well as an ingenious man, and his book is a very respectable one, but his project is out of all character. If John Bunyan's ghost walks the earth it will haunt the church until the stained glass window is removed, if indeed it is ever placed. To help his own people build the new Baptist Chapel at Elstow is a far more suitable way of honouring "honest John's" memory, though, for the matter of that, he needs no help at all to hold his place among the men of England.
Thomas Binney: his Mind, Life, and Opinions. By REV. E. PAXTON HOOD. James Clarke and Co.
A Memorial of the late Rev. Thomas Binney, LL.D. Edited by the Rev. JOHN STOUGHTON, D.D. Hodder and Stoughton.
It was not meet that so able a minister as Thomas Binney should pass away without a memorial from the press; if it had been meet, it would not have been possible, for competing publishers would not have allowed the opportunity to lie unimproved. Fortunately for his own fame, Mr. Binney has not yet fallen into the hands of a regular biography writer, or he would have been buried in a huge mound of his own letters badly arranged, huge lumbering sentences of bombast, and a vast
aggregation of the opinions of nobodies about him. Mr. Paxton Hood has in a trice done for the departed all that is necessary, and has done it in a style at once attractive, popular, and admirable. We feel half inclined to ask for an early dismissal that Mr. Hood may sketch us in the same genial manner, and make us generous a use of any points about us worth noticing. The other memorial, edited by Dr. Stoughton, is good, but is more in the old, dignified, and dry style, and not one-half so likely to be read. Begging the pardon of the learned doctors who here contribute their token of remembrance, their joint labours may very well go down the stream, while Mr. Hood's memorial column remains.
We feel inclined to quote half the book, and mean to return to it before long for plunder, but meanwhile the paragraph from the Eclectic Review, in which the abuse heaped upon Mr. Binney is aggregated, strikes us as very fine. When we receive abuse in future, and we expect to have our share, as hitherto, we shall remember this paragraph with comfort:—"Some of our readers will perhaps be amused to see a collection of some of these flowers of rhetoric. Most of them are exotics, or at least are not to be met with every day in this country. Indeed, they are so uncongenial to our soil that the greater part perished as soon as they were planted. But by those who are curious about such matters, they may be found preserved in the hortus-siccus-like pages of the British Magazine, Christian Observer, Christian Remembrancer, 'Thoughts,' etc., by Dr. Burton, Regius Professor of Divinity in the University of Oxford, 'Reformation in the Church, Revolution in Disguise,' Oxford Herald, Standard, and Record newspapers, 'Circular Letter to the Bench of Bishops.' Some few, indeed, have been with much pains kept alive, and flower afresh every month, but they are sickly and drooping, and it is to be feared will not last long. Aliases of the Rev. Thomas Binney: 'One Binney,' 'Binney,' 'Master Binney,' 'T. Binney,' 'The Dissenting Orator,' 'The Weigh House Orator,'
287
'The Writer of Biographies and Addresses,' 'The Thing,' 'The Fly,' 'The Mouse,' 'The Wolf,' 'The Tiger,' 'The Person,' 'The Pope,' 'The Mouthpiece of an Evil Spirit,' 'A Spirit in Bondage to the Devil.' One writer says:—'It is, indeed, a signal proof of the tolerance which the Church (?) has secured in this country that Mr. Binney is not at this moment sitting in the stocks.' Descriptions of Mr. Binney's character and dispositions:—'It is my firm conviction that the expressions used by the person Binney were spoken under the "influence of Satan," and that the speaker was but the mouthpiece of "an evil spirit." I feel, therefore, bound to renounce all fellowship with the unfruitful works of darkness, and with the spirits that are in bondage to the devil.' 'The Weigh House corrosive sublimate.' 'The narrow-minded, uncharitable, and impious Mr. Binney.' 'The poisonous doctrine of such men as Binney.' 'The folly and ignorance.' 'The bitterness and the blasphemy of the Weigh House Orator.' 'There are many who agree with Mr. Binney in their hearts, but who will not venture on the shame of so revolting an avowal.' 'The contempt and disgust cast upon Binney by any heart capable of a moral feeling.' 'There are Dissenters who shrink from the contact of such a man as Mr. Binney—a very humble degree of right feeling is requisite for that.' 'Mr. Binney's charge:—The document which, of any that I have seen, bears the most resemblance to it in tone and violence, is the Bull of Pope Paul III., putting Henry VIII. under an anathema. I doubt not that Pope Paul was as sincere in his opinion as Pope Binney, and the one seems as well instructed as the other (notwithstanding the difference of the times in which they were born) in the duties of a Christian pastor. The ancient Pope—the modern Pope—the spirit of the two persecutors is the same; and it is the spirit of the first persecutor—the DEVIL.' The charitable Dr. Burton says:—'Mr. Binney, their intolerant descendant (a part of his address appears to have been spoken at Billingsgate), Mr. Binney, whose heart is untouched with the charity of the gospel, and whose conversion is not to be effected by human means!'"
Old-fashioned Stories. By THOMAS COOPER. Hodder and Stoughton.
One old friend has done well to collect these stories from the periodicals and other works in which they were scattered abroad. The most of these capital tales were composed in Stafford Gaol, where their author was confined for having been born a few years too soon. They are, as he cheerfully remarks, like himself, none the worse for that. A quiet, homely wit runs through all these stories, and they will merrily beguile a weary hour. We did not think Thomas Cooper had so much fun in him; we judged him to be an incarnate argument, but we are glad to see that he can touch the humorous string as well. If it be a weakness, it is certainly the nearest akin to virtue of all our infirmities, and, considering the innocent pleasure which it casts abroad, like spray from a fountain, we hope that all our friends will remain sufficiently human to relish it. We do not eat salt in lumps, but we like a taste of it, and believe it to be healthy; and in the same manner we do not want frivolities everlastingly heaped upon us, but a sprinkle of playfulness does us good, and no harm.
An Outline Study of Man. By MARK HOPKINS, D.D., LL.D. Hodder and Stoughton.
This is an attempt to give a philosophical description of man from outlines upon a black board; to show how he is built up by the influence of mechanical, chemical, vegetable, animal, mental, and moral laws. It is not a system of development, but of addition from without, in direct opposition to the Darwinian theory, and that, perhaps, is its principal use. Much as may be said in favour of Darwin's theory, much more may be said on the other side. In the one, higher forces are developed from lower; in the other, higher forces are applied to the lower. We like the idea of new forces introduced into man's being far better than growing up from beneath him; not merely because it is more consistent with the laws of cause and effect, but because it harmonises better with the relation into which man is brought with the higher powers by the word of God.
Sermons. By the late ROBERT S. CANDLISH, D.D. Adam and Charles Black, Edinburgh.
DR. CANDLISH is too well known to need any commendation from us. His praise is in all the Scotch, and in many of the English, churches. He was a bold and uncompromising advocate of the right of individual churches to have a voice in the selection of their own ministers; which deprived him of the patronage of high ecclesiastics, but gave him a warm and lasting position in the hearts of the people. The sermons before us may be taken, we presume, to be a fair specimen of his principles and feelings, as far as the perusal can supply the place of energetic delivery. They are strikingly characteristic, and are formed upon an independent model. The doctrinal, the expository, and the practical are admirably blended. The doctrines of grace are clearly avowed, and though not so prominently exhibited as we might have desired, there is nothing out of harmony with them. The sermon upon "The Simplicity that is in Christ" is in beautiful accordance with its theme. A capacity for superiority of thought and diction is evident throughout the whole volume, not needlessly displayed, but rather subdued for the profit of the hearers. We love to see great minds thus plain and familiar when speaking to other minds upon the things that belong to their everlasting peace.
The Pastoral Epistles. The Greek Text and Translation; with Introduction, Expository Notes, and Dissertation. By PATRICK FAIRBAIRN, D.D. T. and T. Clark.
WE welcome Dr. Fairbairn's contribution to our expository stores. The two epistles to Timothy and the letter to Titus needed a worthy commentary, and Dr. Fairbairn has ably supplied the lack. The work is for scholars, and they will value it highly.
The Introductory Class Text-book: a Course of Study for Intending Sunday School Teachers. By B. P. PASK. Sunday School Union.
IT is by no means an obsolete idea that anybody will do for a Sunday-school teacher, and yet no notion can be more absurd. We pity the youngsters who have to be taught by some teachers we have met with in our travels. Every teacher should use his utmost diligence to make himself "apt to teach," and full of information worthy communicating. "Out of nothing nothing can come." Many a Sabbath-school class and teacher, ay, and congregation and minister, have been conclusive proofs of this old adage. Teachers who will study Mr. Pask's book are likely to be efficient, but the majority of those who need it will never condescend to look at it, much less to study it. He has made a laudable attempt with considerable success, and we trust he will see great good of it. The following anecdote is noteworthy. "After a public examination of a charity-school in a certain manufacturing town in Scotland, a learned gentleman present was invited to put a few questions to the children. The gentleman proceeded—'Children, look at me—be very attentive—answer me this—hem! Is it not a fact that mutation is stamped on all sublunary objects?' The children, of course, remained silent."
Introduction to the Pauline Epistles. By PATON J. GLOAG, D.D. T. and T. Clark.
THIS is a kind of literary life of Paul, viewing him as an author, and entering fully into the character of his works. The introductions to each of the epistles are admirable summaries and keys to their contents. We are very grateful to Dr. Gloag, and also to the enterprising publishers, who deserve well of all Christian ministers.
