How to lead the Young to decision for Christ — A Paper Read Before The College Conference, 1875, — By Pastor G. Malins, Of Newcastle
THE significance of the question which this paper proposes to answer lies, we assume, in the fact that ordinary methods and ministries have failed to influence the young for Christ, either to the extent of our desires, or in the measures we believe ourselves justified in expecting. The question implies the necessity of a class of agents, and a style of operation, more in correspondence with the persons to be influenced. We suppose it to be evident that there is a remarkable contrast between the old routine work among the young and the special efforts that have been made during more recent years; as also between the smallness of former spiritual results and the large ingatherings more recently enjoyed. The newer, more earnest, and better considered activities have rolled away the reproach of the past. A genius for adapting Christian efforts to special classes has been developed, and the young have come in for a large share of attention. Faith in the possibility of their conversion, and love to their souls, have given birth to new methods of work in the place of the old ones. The trim, hard-trodden highways are forsaken and new paths struck out, and the prose order of Christian work has been superseded by the poetry of Christian enthusiasm. Such men as Payson Hammond, and Josiah Spiers have done much by their successful mission to the children to dispel the delusion of Christian tories that "bread must necessarily be cast upon the waters to be found after many days." For long the conviction that work among the young must be pursued chiefly with a view to securing saving results in after years rather than at once sat like a nightmare upon the energies of Christian men. But recent conversions among the young upon a large scale have awakened multitudes to a degree of earnest, hopeful, and fruitful activity such as was never before witnessed.
The fact assumed by the title of this paper, viz., that the young can be led to decision for Christ, will not, as a general proposition, be disputed. It is only when it is assumed with regard to the very young people that grave questions are raised, and serious doubts entertained concerning its truth. As we pass from the teens down the numerals, heads are gravely shaken that are full of intelligence, and hearts tremble that are full of faith alone. It is manifest that the special efforts made to lead the young to decision for Christ do not enjoy the sympathy of the majority of the members of our churches. This is indicated with sufficient clearness by the suspicion and distrust with which the young converts are regarded by their seniors. The mention of their names for membership in the churches is often greeted
* The Editor is not to be supposed to agree with every opinion and statement contained in papers bearing their author's name. This excellent paper is printed by the desire of the Conference of the College, and it is hoped that it will draw forth other articles upon the same subject. The point on which all Christians are not agreed is the value of the labours of Mr. Hammond: we neither endorse nor criticise them.
383
with incredulous sidelocks, if not with an open and avowed suspicion that never falls to the lot of older persons, with no better credentials of fitness. And this is witnessed at a time when, more than at any previous period, the Holy Spirit has roused a deep, wide-spread, earnest, and intelligent concern for the salvation of souls, and when the manifold well-tested and reliable results among the young rebuke such distrust. It does not come within the legitimate scope of this paper to dwell at length upon the misconceptions upon which such distrust rests, though they are not difficult of discovery. When we hear such men as the gifted Gilfillian dubiously, and almost scornfully, asking, "How can these young people decide for Christ in an hour? Are they aware of the objections raised against the gospel accounts in almost every part of them?" we reflect at once that the fallacy consists in supposing that a rational appreciation of the external evidence of the truth of the gospel is necessary in order to decision for Christ—a supposition which, if true, would not only unchristianise the children of the churches, but three-fourths of their entire membership. Our hope lies in One who can supply a demonstration of the truth of the gospel to the soul, which supersedes the necessity of rational conviction by the force of external evidence. "It is by the manifestation of the truth to every man's conscience in the sight of God." On the other side the difficulty is palliated by the development theorists, who insist upon the existence in the soul of a life germ, left undestroyed by the Fall, to which only a graduated and suitable ministry of truth is needed. Or, again, we are met by the baptismal regenerationists, who plead against the necessity of conversion by the truth because of a life that trickled sacramentally into the soul of the child from the sacred fingers of the parson. In all these views we detect important and dangerous errors. The first fails to recognise the demonstration of the Spirit, the second denies the lost condition of the soul, and the third denies the absolute agency, sufficiency, and simplicity of the truth. We take for granted the truths which these errors tend to negative, and proceed to enquire—What is requisite in the persons who would lead the young to Christ? what are the special truths to be made prominent? and what is the special style of agency best fitted to give effect to the truth.
I. Our first enquiry is, What is requisite in those who would win the young for Christ? The first indispensable requisite in the person who would lead the young to decision for Christ is a deep and hearty love to Christ and to them. Love to Christ, which inspires desire for his glory in their conversion to him. Love to them, which is fruitful in endeavours adapted to accomplish this end. Love to them must be of that particular kind which is fresh, frank, genial, and young in its expressions. It is not enough for us to possess a love which will interpret Christ to ourselves, but love which is creative of analogies that, bearing an affinity to their youthful natures, will enable us instrumentally to interpret Christ to them. Children must be reached chiefly through the imagination and the emotions, and love alone is the genius that creates the forms of truth and breathes through them the contagion that can move young hearts. Let us not forget that children feel deeply, even when they do not understand very clearly: a cold intellectual nature may throw forth streams of very beautiful thoughts, but they will fall like icicles
upon the warm and susceptible natures of children. Children soon know who loves them, and if we have to strain ourselves from a mere sense of duty towards them, though they may not understand the philosophy of it, they will feel its truth. Love only will make efforts natural, enthusiastic, and easy. If we have only as much of this precious commodity as will suffice to fill the shop window we shall soon be sold out, for the demand for it is very large. It will matter little how rich are our intellectual stores, for we shall find but little market for them among the young, except love manufactures them. Love must weave the material, decide the pattern, and dispense it. Without this we shall fare badly in dealing with young people. They will fight shy of a dry, cold, ungenial minister or teacher. I remember that, when I was in Dublin, Dr. Urwick once said to me very playfully, "I feel it a duty to cultivate juvenility for the sake of my young people," and I remember that though he was often dry and uninteresting to the young in his pulpit ministrations, he was bright and genial as a spring morning in his associations with them at other times. If we cannot convince our young people that we truly love them, and cannot put it into a frank, genial intercourse with them, tempered and controlled by an earnest spiritual purpose, we shall stand at a great disadvantage in dealing with them. The first thing needful is to gain their confidence, and the second thing is to keep it, and the third thing is to use the advantage for leading them to Jesus, and all these must be done by love wisely manifested and maintained. God never ordained us evangelists to the young if he did not gift us with large, patient, loving hearts. If this be lacking we shall gain little influence over them, and in the time of their anxiety they will either keep their anxieties to themselves or else pour them into other ears.
2. If we would lead them to Christ we must have a well established certainty that they can be so led. We mean this remark to apply to the very young, because it is folly to suppose that any uncertainty can exist as to the conversion of the senior scholar.
Doubtless, the reason of much failure in our attempts to lead the young to Christ is to be found in the lurking, if not avowed, suspicion that the cases of professed conversion among them are not real or reliable. Whatever others may think upon the subject, we, who would lead the children to Jesus, must be possessed by the settled conclusion that as soon as they can know what sin is they can also know and trust the Saviour. Suspicion on the contrary will effectually paralyse our efforts; for it is not reasonable that anyone will lay himself out heartily and earnestly to do a work which he believes to be unlikely of accomplishment. If you have any doubt upon this subject, go and converse with the children who have professed conversion. This is the course which wisdom and honesty dictate. All we ask is that you will fairly apply the same measure to them that you apply in your estimate of older converts, and that you do not expect them to be experts in theological technicalities, but that you let them convey to you in their own way the story of their trust in Jesus. If you did this to any of the fifty or sixty young Christians in our church in Newcastle you would arrive at the conviction that they had as much title to be received as disciples of Jesus as you have.
385
3. We must have a deep sense of the importance of their decision for Christ in youth. If sin be a power in the soul, progressive and destructive, so also is the spiritual life a power progressively beautiful and beneficent. The same reasons which make the conversion of the adult important make the conversion of a child tenfold more so. There are possibilities of attainment in personal character, and of usefulness in the world open to the child which in the natural order of things are closed against the older convert. Moreover, if Godliness be beneficial in the man, it is especially so in the child. There is a beauty in the early morn that is not to be found in the mid-day, there is a beauty in the spring-time which does not belong to the summer, there is a beauty in the rosebud that is not found in the fullblown flower: and so there is a beauty in godliness in youth which does not belong to one in whom it begins its reign in older years. Where the young heart becomes the dwelling-place of supreme love to Jesus, its natural simplicities become holy and beautiful in a kind and degree that are not possible to him who has been perverted and corrupted by long years of transgression. And not only so, for the life of nature is only a partial symbol of the life of grace. Grace is permanent progress without total decline. There may be partial failure and temporary decline, but it is the nature of divine grace to evolve out of our humiliations the material for a richer life. The life-tide may have its ebbs, but it will have its corresponding flows. The waves may seem to recede, but it is only to make their mark further on. "With partial retrogression there is total progress." So in the history of the spiritual life: it may seem to recede, but that is a preparation for further advance in faith and love. Grace lays up honey in unlikely hives. "Out of the eater comes forth meat, and out of the strong comes forth sweetness." It is to the glory of grace that out of mistakes it enables us to organise victories, and out of failures to originate success. So that, whatever may intervene, when the spring-time of nature coincides with the spring-time of grace it becomes the commencement, preparation, and pledge of a riper spiritual manhood, which may mellow into a dignity, purity, and venerableness of character analogous to the natural period of grey hairs. On the other hand, the progress of sin in the soul is a terrible truth. Though the child be fallen from its birth, there is going on from day to day a downward progress, which, if not arrested, must end in irrevocable ruin, and even when arrested in later years, it is over the grave of many a buried power which in this life may never know a resurrection. Given then a Christ-like love, clothing itself in suitable expressions; given a firm conviction that children can be led to Christ, joined to a deep sense of the importance of that consummation and the moral fitness of the person who would so lead them is secured. We have never witnessed the union of these qualifications in the same degree in any man as in Payson Hammond, of America, and we have never heard of or seen more marked or abiding results than those of his works. Many thousands in the United Kingdom, and many more thousands in the United States of America, are fruits of his labours among the young. The Secretary of the Massachusetts Sunday School Union told us, when in Glasgow a few years back, that not less than forty thousand, chiefly children, had been received into the churches as the result of his labours. It may be asked,
where are all these reputed converts in Great Britain now? We answer, many of them in the churches, many of them outside, because though Jesus gathered the lambs with his arm and folded them in his bosom, the churches in their suspicion and distrust did not all imitate his loving example.
II. What are the special truths to be made prominent?
We contemplate necessarily something different from the ordinary Sabbath-school teaching, which is supposed to deal in the presentation of Bible truth in general. Work more directly evangelistic is needed among the children. The work we contemplate is not so much that of storing the mind with Scripture information as of applying truth, with the view of leading them to immediate decision for Jesus Christ. What, then, are the truths we must keep distinctly and impressively before them but sin and salvation, and both as seen in the personal Jesus! Sin seen in its opposition to him, and salvation in the finished work which puts it away. This is "the simplicity which is in Christ." It is useless talking generalisations and abstractions to children; though we are prone to do so, forgetting that they cannot attach any definite meaning to them. When we have spoken of redemption or imputed righteousness, do not let us be deluded into supposing that we have presented to them the Redeemer and the Lord the Righteous One. Nothing is more subtle or easy than the deception which puts a generalisation in the place of Jesus. Just as it is easy to hide God by theology, so it is easy to hide Christ under Christology. We must labour with all skill and simplicity to keep before them the personal Saviour with all his glorious love in the revelation his word and work make of it. Jesus the dead, risen, and accepted substitute, and sin in its essential wickedness, as displayed in its opposition to him. We were powerfully impressed some years ago with this special feature in the address of Payson Hammond, of America. One great element of power in his address was the clear and vivid presentation of sin and salvation at one and the same time, in one and the same work of Jesus. The one all-pervading thought you had in listening to him was—what a wicked creature I must be not to love and trust this Saviour. He had a wonderful power of awakening interest, and then exciting hatred to conduct that was precisely analogous to the sinner's treatment of Jesus, and bringing it home in application to his hearers. You would think he had taken Nathan's parable to David for his model. How skilfully Nathan adapted the parable to the case of David, and how cleverly and effectually he by it brought his sin home to him! Instead of rushing to his point with a bold unveiled home-thrust, he veiled the point of his sword till the right opportunity arrived. He employed a parable of the narrative kind, fitted to awaken every sentiment of honour, justice, and benevolence, which he knew to be slumbering in the heart of his royal bearer, and not till he had effected this and led him to pronounce his own condemnation in that of another did he thunder upon him the startling announcement, "Thou art the man," and David bowed his head with the confession, "I have sinned." This same kind of skill we should seek to attain in speaking the gospel to children. Sin must be shown in its reality and tremendous guilt, as mirrored in the glorious and tender love of him whom it busely rejects.
387
It is "sin, because they believe not on me." "They hated me without a cause." A little child is capable of appreciating the argument—if you can love your parents, relatives, and friends, who are infinitely less worthy of it than Jesus, and be grateful to them for benefits that are infinitely less than those which Jesus died to confer upon you, what a wicked heart yours must be if it cannot and will not love and trust Jesus Christ! This is the principal truth to which the Spirit bears witness, and he will honour, as he has done, the longing, earnest believing efforts, to bring it home to the hearts of the young. This preaching of a personal Christ is the great need of all, but especially of children. For just in proportion as the intellect is untrained, and the imagination and the affections are active, they are unfitted to grasp doctrinal statements, and so it is the more necessary, as far as human putting can do it, to present to them Jesus the loving one waiting to receive them in their sinfulness, and welcome and save them when they come. Doubtless we have all listened to addresses to children that were very quaint, original, and pleasing, but the conviction was unavoidably forced upon us, that the speakers did not aim distinctly at leading the young to decision for Christ. Mere talks about religion in the abstract, or about integrity and uprightness, and its rewards in this life, however prettily illustrated, may please but can never convert. A moral address to the unconverted is like trying to build a house by beginning at the top. It is madness to seek to form Christian character where no life through faith in Jesus exists. Lessons in morality are not the seed of the kingdom, but dry old husks which lost their germ when Adam fell, and he who sows them with the hope of reaping a crop is a fool for his pains. The only convincing or converting power for old or young is the cross of Christ, where divine love is seen judging sin and putting it away for ever by the sacrifice of himself.
III. It is time to inquire what kind of agencies are best fitted to give effect to the truth. We should be sorry to say anything which would seem to underrate the Sabbath-school, yet we are convinced that as now organised and in operation its aim is not sufficiently direct to hope to secure the conversion of the young upon a large scale. That the Sabbath-school has done a work which was sadly needed, and achieved results the extent and value of which eternity alone will disclose, we gladly and gratefully admit. Nevertheless, its teaching is too general, its aim too indefinite, to secure results such as we desire, and believe to be capable of accomplishment. The past few years have developed a style of agency more fitted to secure, and more fruitful in saving effects, than was ever before witnessed among the young. Not that these efforts can ever displace the Sabbath-school: they are supplementary, and generally begin where the Sabbath-school teacher ends. The evangelist to the young takes his stand upon the facts already taught and known, to illustrate, apply, and drive home with a view of securing immediate decision for Jesus Christ. Special services, where hymns of a simple, cheerful gospel character are sung, and where addresses bright with gospel allegory, illustration, and anecdote are given, and all directed to produce conviction of sin and immediate trust in Jesus, are commended, by extensive and abiding results, as the most effectual way of winning the young to Jesus. The ordinary ministry of the pulpit,
or of the Sabbath-school, has accomplished but little when compared with the labours of such men as Payson Hammond, and Josiah Spiers. Even the labours of our honoured and beloved brethren, Messrs. Moody and Sankey, have resulted in no such awakenings among the children as were witnessed under the ministry of Payson Hammond a few years ago in Great Britain, and as are continually reported from America at the present day. The gospel preached in both cases is the same, and the men who preach it are equally earnest and gifted, but the one casts the net into the sea for small and great, while the other carefully provides that the meshes of the net shall be so small as to catch and keep the little ones. The lesson is that if we would win the children for Jesus it must be by the gospel presented in special adaptation to their young years. If Sabbath-school workers could be persuaded out of their "As it was in the beginning, is now, and ever shall be" style of work, to adopt occasional variations in school services, our schools might become spheres of greater and more permanent blessings. Permit us to give an example in point. About two years ago a feeling of deep dissatisfaction was expressed by our teachers with the smallness of the results of their work, and earnest prayer was offered for the salvation of the young. These prayers were answered in the conversion of a few of our scholars. Our desire was quickened by the visit and powerful addresses of Mr. Moody, and we began to feel that some different method of bringing the truth home to them must be adopted. We agreed to lay aside the ordinary teaching for one Sunday afternoon, and to hold instead thereof an evangelistic service. Two or three short, earnest, pointed addresses were given, and gospel hymns sung at intervals. We varied the proceedings by requesting two or three of the boys who had been recently converted to tell their fellow-scholars how they had been led to Christ, and why they believed they were saved. We then requested two or three to follow one another in prayer for the conversion of their fellow-scholars. We finally requested all those who were decided for Christ to confess it by standing up; at the same time we begged those who were not Christians to keep their seats. I shall never forget the solemnity of that first meeting, or the touchingly simple outpourings of heart of those lads in prayer for their friends. At the close of the meeting we requested all those who were anxious about their souls to go into the vestries for conversation, the boys into the deacons' vestry and the girls into the pastor's vestry, when about twenty-six, of about equal numbers of boys and girls, arose and did so. Nearly all of these we afterwards baptised. We continued those meetings at intervals, and we received, chiefly as the result of those meetings, about fifty children into the church, from seven years of age and upwards. When asked what was the means of their awakening, they invariably referred to the testimonies or the prayers of their fellow-scholars, or to the fact that when those were asked to stand up who were decided for Christ they were obliged to keep their seats. My brethren will, of course, consider all the circumstances of their own cases before they decide upon the wisdom or pursuing a similar course. There are plants that we cannot force. If the Spirit of God is working we must watch his workings, and seek to work in harmony with him. When the wind blows we can spread the
389
sails to catch the divine breeze, but we cannot make it blow. We may get to the mountain top, like Elijah, and pray for the rain; we may send out the servant—faith—to watch for the first small cloud in the sky, and when the sign appears ring out the message down the mountain side to the watchers below to prepare for abundance of rain; but we cannot manufacture the cloud or create the rain.
Permit me a few words, in conclusion, upon the importance of personal dealing. When impression has been produced, it should be immediately followed up with the view of consummating it in decision for Christ. We cannot individualise, vary, and apply truth to suit the needs of newly-awakened minds in the same degree in public address as in private. We must get them alone, if possible, and find out their difficulties, and speak home to them with a freedom, directness, and loving earnestness, such as is otherwise impossible. For this reason the enquiry meeting at the close of the public one is important. Its chief value consists in the opportunity it affords of following up impressions while they are fresh. We are persuaded that these after-meetings, as they are called, if rightly conducted, are admirably fitted for leading the awakened mind to decision for Christ. Once get them to commit themselves to the expression of their anxieties, and a great barrier is broken down. We have watched young people who have long struggled against their convictions, who, as soon as they once gave expression to their anxiety, broke down, and yielded themselves to Jesus Christ. We are persuaded that there are many young people in our schools and congregations who have spiritual anxieties that come and go through years, who, if afforded the right kind of opportunity to give expression to them, and encouraged to use it, might, humanly speaking, be led into the peace of the gospel long before they are so led. Pardon us for relating a personal incident. When a very young lad we were under very deep anxiety of soul. Our mother attended the Hyper-Calvinistic chapel, and our father the regular or Moderate Baptist chapel. We sometimes went to the one and sometimes to the other, so that we knew the ministers well, and both in different ways did us much harm. We were troubled with awful questions about election and reprobation, for the solution of which we used to ply the Moderate Baptist with a multitude of difficult questions. These questions, however carelessly they seemed to be put, veiled the most terrible anxiety and sadness of soul, which we did not disclose. Instead of dealing gently with us, to find out our real state of heart, and seeking to show us that these doctrines had nothing to do with the open and hearty welcome proffered by the Saviour in the gospel, he became offended with us because we did not accept his explanations, and shunted us off with the prediction, uttered in the hearing of another, that we should become an infidel. After this we united with a few boys, like-minded in their desire for salvation, in reading the Scriptures, and in prayer for divine grace, when lo! the Hyper-Calvinistic minister heard of it, and, with beetling brow, demanded what business we had to pray. "You," said he, "should attend the means of grace," (by which he meant Providence Chapel,) "and, peradventure, God may bless you." We were dumbfounded and distressed beyond measure. We were never so afraid of a man in our life. We thought he perhaps,
25
being one of the elect, had been favoured with a sight of the roll, and secretly knew that our name was not there, for his discourses had filled our untrained imagination with wild fears about that awful record. He caused us years of suffering, for which we forgive him, as we hope he has repented of it. We cannot but feel that our own case represents in some degree that of many others, and that if there were more well-considered methods devised for securing personal converse with the young, a larger number might be gathered unto Christ at much earlier periods than is generally the case. We of course speak from the human stand-point. We are sure that final results are secured, but results, so far as we have to do with them, depend upon the use of right means for securing them. A personal converse with the young, however arranged to suit given circumstances, is indispensable, if we would lead the young to Christ upon a larger scale.
With the mention of a very common hindrance to early decision for Christ, I will close this paper. Many of the young get the idea—an idea confirmed by the example and requirements of older persons—that if they become Christians they must crush all the buoyancy out of their young life and say farewell to all the innocent amusements to which their healthy natures prompts them. No wonder that their fun-loving natures shrink from a religion which puts their top-spinning, marble-playing, and romping propensities into the "Index Expurgatorius." This is not Christianity. It is a libel on Christianity. The religion of Jesus was never designed to hush the young glee, stop the flow of the life-blood, and spread paralysis over the fresh energies of the child. There is about as much sin in their fun as there is in the frisking of a lamb, and the two are just as natural. The generation has not yet died out—but we hope it soon will—represented by the deacon who, having opposed with all his might the admission of a little boy into the church on the ground that he ought to wait till he was established, came running into the minister's house one day in a most triumphant state of excitement, exclaiming, "There, I told you what it would come to, there is Johnny So-and-so running down the hill as hard as he can, playing at horses."
We have received into the church at Newcastle about sixty young people from seven years of age and upwards with confidence, a confidence which, after nearly two years, we have no reason to regret. Assuming, then, that these young people can be led thus early to Jesus, that evangelistic efforts specially directed to them have been crowned with unexampled and abiding blessing, let us honestly, heartily, and believingly lay ourselves out for its accomplishment. Let us seek them as precious jewels for the Master's crown in the day of his coming. Let us give all the encouragement to those whom the Master has endowed with the gifts of head and heart for this special work. Their conversion will obviate the necessity of seeking to save them from the firm grasp of the devil in older years; it will impart growing strength and earnestness to the church for the fulfilment of her mission to a lost world, and lessen the number of those who come into our churches—able indeed to rejoice in the grace which snatched them as brands from the burning, but able only to lay the wrecks of wasted lives upon the altar of service.
