Menu
‹ Chapter 136 of 201 ›

The Baptismal Service Practically Considered

10 min read · Chapter 136 of 201

An Article extracted from "The Irish Church Advocate" of July 1st, 1875.

THERE is in our fallen nature a conservatism of corruption. We hold error with persistent tenacity, but our grasp of truth is weak and variable. It is to this special corruption the prophet Jeremiah alludes in the remarkable words—"Pass over the isles of Chittim, and see, and send unto Kedar, and consider diligently, and see if there be such a thing; hath a nation changed their gods, which are yet no gods? but my people have changed their glory for that which doth not profit."—Jer. ii. 10, 11. This conservatism of corruption was also illustrated in the conduct of the whole line of the kings of Israel, of each one of which it is written, "He departed not from the sin of Jeroboam, the son of Nebat, who made Israel to sin." And the same evil tendency of our fallen nature was more largely exemplified in the apostasy of Christendom from the purity and simplicity of apostolic truth and worship, to the antichristian and abominable idolatries of Popery, and in the desperate tenacity with which multitudes still cling to these abominations, notwithstanding the Scriptural light which is now so widely diffused, and which exposes their real character. But to come nearer home, the history of our Prayer-book, and especially the history of our Baptismal Service, affords another illustration of this conservatism of corruption, which crops up in every period of the religious history of man.† The English Reformers of blessed memory, who were God's honoured instruments for delivering our church and nation from Popery, were not infallible. They were cut off by the cruel hand of persecution before they had reached the maturity of knowledge towards which they had made great progress at the close of their ministry. Bishop Poynet's Catechism, which was written in the last year of Edward's reign, and which expresses the most matured conclusions of the Reformers, shows how thoroughly they were being emancipated from the sacramentalism and sacerdotalism which constitute the very virus of Popery. Taking a sober view of that most important document, we are warranted in the persuasion, that if the progress of reformation had not been stayed by the martyrdom of its originators, the objectionable sentences in our Baptismal Service, which have occasioned such strife and evil in our church, would have been expunged. We need hardly say that the paragraphs to which we allude are, the declaration of the regeneration of the infant, and the thanksgiving to Almighty God for the supposed benefit.

* When we preached our well-known sermon upon Baptismal Regeneration we were favoured with so abundant a measure of abuse, that the charge of slander and vituperative declamation brought against us in this article sounds very mildly in our ears. The article is thoroughly Irish, and we reprint it without alteration, as containing one of the best justifications of our sermon ever issued from the press. If our antagonists will only keep on answering us in this way we shall not need to utter another syllable.

† Pretty strong. Surely it verges on vituperative declamation. We heartily endorse it.

Now, we remark, in the first place, that these paragraphs afford slanderous tongues strong ground for misrepresenting the true doctrine of our church, and impugning the morality of the whole body of our evangelical ministers. A sermon by "C. H. Spurgeon," which has reached a circulation of one hundred and ninety-five thousand, affords a painful illustration of this evil. In pages 8, 9, we read :—

The form for the administration of baptism is plain and outspoken, seeing thanks are expressly returned unto Almighty God, because the person baptised is regenerate. "Then shall the priest say, 'Seeing now, dearly beloved brethren, that this child is regenerate and grafted into the body of Christ's Church, let us give thanks unto Almighty God for these benefits; and with one accord make our prayers unto him, that this child may lead the rest of his life according to this beginning.'" Nor is this all, for to leave no mistake, we have the words of the thanksgiving prescribed, "Then shall the priest say, 'We yield thee hearty thanks, most merciful Father, that it hath pleased thee to regenerate this infant with thy Holy Spirit, to receive him for thine own child by adoption, and to incorporate him into thy holy church.'"

This then, is the clear and unmistakable teaching of a church calling itself Protestant. Here is a professedly Protestant church, which, every time its ministers go to the font, declares that every person there receiving baptism is there and then "regenerated and grafted into the body of Christ's church."

"But," I hear many good people exclaim, "there are many good clergymen in the church who do not believe in baptismal regeneration!" To this my answer is prompt. Why, then, do they belong to a church which teaches that doctrine in the plainest terms? I am told that many in the Church of England preach against her own teaching. I know they do, and herein I rejoice in their enlightenment, but I question, gravely question, their morality. To take the oath that I sincerely assent and consent to a doctrine which I do not believe, would to my conscience appear little short of perjury, if not absolute, downright perjury; but those who do so must be judged by their own Lord. For me to take money for defending what I do not believe—for me to take the money of a church, and then to preach against what are most evidently its doctrines—I say, for me to do this (I judge others as I would that they should judge me), for me, or for any other simple, honest man to do so, were an atrocity so great, that if I had perpetrated the deed, I should consider myself out of the pale of truthfulness, honesty, and common morality.

The whole of this vituperative declamation is founded upon a misrepresentation. It assumes that baptismal regeneration is the doctrine of the Church of England* which every one of her ministers is bound by solemn engagement to teach; and to hold this ground for criminating the whole body of the Episcopal clergy, Mr. Spurgeon suppresses the fact that the highest ecclesiastical tribunal in the land has ruled, that baptismal regeneration is not a doctrine which every man who has honestly accepted the Prayer Book is bound to teach. With this judgment before him, Mr. Spurgeon must be fully aware that every minister of the church is as free to denounce the figment of baptismal regeneration as he is.† To retort Mr. Spurgeon's accusation, we have only to quote

* And very naturally too, since the writer admits under the head of secondly that "the paragraphs alluded to in their plain grammatical meaning teach the doctrine of baptismal regeneration," etc.

† Yes, and then they go on teaching it all the same in words whose "plain grammatical meaning" cannot be misunderstood. Can Acts of Parliament make it right to teach what you do not believe? Has any man a license before God to teach a

415

his own words, "We question, gravely question the morality" of such a mode of argumentation as this, based as it is upon the suppression of a fact which neutralises the conclusion.*

Secondly—But we ask, why retain in our baptismal service these objectionable paragraphs, which not only give a plausible ground of accusation to the enemies of our church, but which sorely wound the consciences of many of its best friends, both of the clergy and laity? It cannot be denied that the paragraphs alluded to in their plain, grammatical meaning teach the doctrine of baptismal regeneration, and require a laboured explanation to justify our church from the charge of holding that dangerous error. The writer knows for a certainty that these objectionable statements in our baptismal service with the cognate sentences in our church catechism, have driven many of the best members of the church into dissent, and he has invariably found that this is especially the case in times like the present, when persons are awakened to a sense of their religious responsibilities. One of the questions discussed at the recent clerical meetings was, "the best means of advancing and rendering permanent any signs of religious awakening among our parishioners." Of all the means of securing such a desirable end, the revision of the Prayer Book, particularly in the baptismal service, is, in our judgment, absolutely essential.

Thirdly, we abhor, as involving a rejection of the highest principle of morality, the saying, that one of the uses of language is "to enable us to conceal our thoughts." The tongue, as the organ of speech, is spoken of in Scripture as the glory of man; but it is only such when its truthful utterances announce the revealed will of God. Hence, all ambiguity of expression, especially in the things of God, must be displeasing to the "God of truth;" and if one has unwittingly been betrayed into such an abuse of language, the error, when it is exposed, should be promptly corrected. "If the trumpet give an uncertain sound, who shall prepare himself to the battle?" Hence the apostle says, "Seeing then that we have such hope, we use great plainness of speech." It is a dangerous presumption to use before God, in the administration of a divine ordinance, words which are calculated to convey to the mind of the general hearer a contradiction to the truth of God. "Be not rash with thy mouth, and let not thine heart be hasty to utter anything before God: for God is in heaven, and thou art upon the earth, therefore let thy words be few."

Fourthly. Another evil resulting from the retention of the objectionable sentences in our baptismal service is apparent in the general tone of the preaching of our ministers. We know assuredly that a very large proportion of the clergy are tainted with the error of

doctrine in one form and denounce it in another? We said nothing about "the highest ecclesiastical tribunal in the land," because our notion of right is founded upon the rule of a higher tribunal still. A man may hold his living by law and be almost a Romanist, but this is universally condemned by evangelicals; what is the reason why the evangelical, who is equally inconsistent with the Prayer-book should be excused?

* That fact has no connection with the conclusion. We say that a man who teaches a doctrine which he does not believe is dishonest, and so he is whether the ecclesiastical courts sanction or condemn his doing so

baptismal regeneration. While they justly censure the presumption of Revivalist preachers in stating the exact number of persons who were converted at this or that particular meeting, they, with singular inconsistency, hold that every infant upon whom they have sprinkled the water of baptism has been made a subject of the new birth, of which the Lord Jesus speaks in John iii. as an indispensable qualification for the kingdom of heaven. When one points out to them the characteristics of regeneration, or the new birth, as set forth in Scripture, as a new creation, the imparting of a spiritual and indestructible life, involving a total change in the principles, the tastes, and the conduct, and point out, as a simple matter of fact, the total absence of any such change in the great majority of the baptised, they tell us, in opposition to the whole current of Scripture testimony, that regeneration, or the new birth, is a totally different thing from conversion—that it is only a change of state, but not necessarily a change of character—in fact, they make regeneration to be a word without any definite signification, but that, whatever it is, it is inseparably connected with baptism. Hence the solemn words of Jesus, "Verily, verily, I say unto thee, except a man be born again he cannot see the kingdom of God," lose all their power, and instead of pressing on their hearers the indispensable necessity of the new birth, they preach to them as if they had already received the blessing; that they are clothed with the garments of salvation, and that all they need is to tack upon them some ornamental fringes of good works. This radically erroneous tone of the preaching of a very large number of our ministers, is one of the worst results of retaining the more than ambiguities* of our baptismal service, which are made instrumental to the positive inculcation of one of the most radical and dangerous errors of the apostate church of Rome.

Fifthly and lastly, we ask, what benefit can be secured by the retention of the objectionable paragraphs in our baptismal service? Their removal would not impose a burden on any man's conscience. If some have persuaded themselves that baptismal regeneration is a true doctrine of Christianity, and that they are bound to teach it, the proposed omission would leave them at liberty to do so. But as the service now stands, it does impose a burden which many have found too grievous to be borne. To compel a minister on pain of the forfeiture of his ecclesiastical position to utter words which, in their plain, grammatical sense, assert a doctrine which he abhors, is nothing more nor less than an unjustifiable tyranny over conscience. It may be said, let those who reject the doctrine of baptismal regeneration leave the church; they have perfect liberty to do so. Not so, for they do not believe that it is the doctrine of our reformed church, as it was in the days of Edward VI., and they have been released from the legal obligation of teaching it. To abandon the church of their fathers under such circumstances would, in our judgment, be an act of schism. Let not the friends of revision be discouraged—our demand for the removal of the objectionable paragraphs must ultimately be conceded—but let there

* More than ambiguities! What does this mean? When a witness before the court utters more than ambiguities what does he utter? This is a mild way of saying what we said without ambiguity.

417

be no compromise; we demand the total excision of the declaration and thanksgiving, and nothing in the way of explanatory prefaces or rubrics can meet the exigencies of the case, or put an end to the discontent which prevails among the great majority of churchmen.*

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate