The Difficulties of Public Prayer — A Paper Read Before The College Conference, 1875 — By Pastor E. J. Edwards, Of Redruth
OUR Master, according to the evangelist Matthew, said to his disciples, "After this manner therefore pray ye," and added an example of prayer, now known all over the world. This command differs nothing in sense from the one recorded by Luke. Neither of them, we think, authorises the general use of set forms of prayer, but here we need not give our reasons, as our subject does not refer to prayer by form.
The readers of prayers may have difficulties: they who pray without forms confessedly have, by the wording of our title, yet the latter evince no desire to exchange their free method of prayer for its opposite, for though a canal may have nearly uniform width and depth and flow, and therefore present but few hindrances, a river, with its widenings and narrowings, its shallows and deeps, its falls and rapids, is richer in life and beauty. Whatever gain a form may be supposed to give, nothing can compensate for its deficiency in life, freshness, vigour, and variety, all of which may be had abundantly in extemporaneous prayer.
Convinced of the advantages of free prayer, we adopt it in private also. There our perplexities are slight, when compared with the difficulties encountered in public prayer. The nature of public prayer accounts for this. Persons, few or many, are gathered in the name of Jesus. One Spirit has drawn them together, and begotten in them a desire to worship God. Their souls are wishful to adore him as "The Lord, glorious in holiness, fearful in praises, doing wonders"—to praise him as the "God of all grace"—to thank him as the Giver of every good and perfect gift—to confess to him as the One who is faithful and just to forgive sin, and to cleanse from all unrighteousness—and to supplicate further favours at his hand, because he "satisfieth the longing soul, and filleth the hungry soul with goodness." There is no outburst of sounds in acclamation, no chorus of voices in praise, no confusion of tongues by each detailing his own wants in his own words; only one voice is heard, adoring, praising, thanking, confessing, and supplicating. This devotional act which adapts the language of one, speaking impromptu, to the worship of the many, we call "public prayer." Matthew Henry's comment upon a passage in the Acts of the Apostles very fitly describes such prayer, "One in the name of the rest lifted up his voice to God, and the rest joined with him with one mind; their hearts went along with him, and so, though but one spoke, they all prayed."
The one voice which is heard in prayer in our public meetings for
worship is usually that of the presiding pastor or minister. In the gatherings specially named "prayer-meetings," others, besides the minister, assist in the devotional exercises. It may be presumed, therefore, that the pastor is not alone in the experience of difficulty. We think, however, that in addition to special hindrances, the difficulties common to all who reject a form of prayer become greater in the experience of those who constantly conduct the devotions of the sanctuary in services arranged according to fixed order.
Very likely this increase of difficulty arises in part from the difference in the character of the services. Our prayer-meetings are not cast in one mould, but the other services for the most part are the repetitions of an arrangement of devotional acts, which follow one another with the regularity of the minutes of the hour. Strict conformity to regularity is expected; everything must be exceedingly proper; and thus we are affected by a restraint which imparts a tone to the whole service, the prayer included, whereby we cease to enjoy a homely freedom, and are conscious of a want of ease, the result of a painful carefulness. Those are happy who are never subjects of this bondage: perhaps their intensified spiritual life drives them out of the beaten track of a fixed rule into the untrodden paths of unusual arrangements; or perhaps their soul is strong enough to overcome the enervating influence of oft-recurring and never-varying services, and to deliver them from stiffness of act and feeling. One point is clear, namely, that entire freedom from a sense of restraint in all our services will greatly assist us in prayer, and will also aid in rooting up other difficulties, whose growth is fostered by it.
For there has arisen out of this strict adherence from year's end to year's end to a set order of service a custom which produces uncomfortable feelings in both minister and people, whenever the fires of devotion are at all low. Among attendants at our places of worship, and particularly among the initiated, this phrase is common,—"the long prayer." Probably it is so styled because it is the longest of the prayers offered in the service. Generally it does not belie its name—it is a long prayer, when the time it occupies is considered. A mind which by no means runs in a groove has written of the power of habit in the matter of preaching in these words, "Constant habit enables the preacher to give generally the same amount of matter on each occasion, the very slight variation almost surprises himself." A similar phenomenon presents itself to many minds in respect to public prayer. Without any indicator of the passage of time, the fifteen or twenty minutes usually allotted to the long prayer are occupied with a noticeable regularity. This precision of habit is no proof that he who has prayed audibly has enjoyed the exercise, or that the congregation's attention has been sustained: candid testimony on the part of pastor and people might often prove the opposite. In a prayer-meeting long prayers are regarded as a drawback, though their length does not nearly extend to that of the prayers in our other services. The subject is thus dealt with by Dr. Talmage, "In order to have a devotional meeting thoroughly interesting, we want the right kind of prayers. Let the first characteristic be brevity. We never hear a man pray over three minutes but we get tired. There may be occasions when, before God, in a public
557
assemblage, as on a Sabbath-day, when the wants and sorrows of a great congregation are to be presented as well as their joys, a man may pray seven or eight minutes; but it is a rare thing that any man is called upon to occupy the attention of the people so long." We may not approve of the limits named by this authority, but general observation and admitted facts suggest the following questions. If in one meeting a protracted prayer is out of place, why is it tolerated in another? Are we to suppose that its length is atoned for by its merit, or that it becomes bearable because in some meetings more than in others the grace of patience is in more lively exercise on the part of the people?
We know, and rejoice in the fact, that the spirit of prayer frequently rests upon persons so powerfully as to enable them to pray with acceptance, though at some length. The Spirit works upon the hearers so as to make the prayer theirs also, and in these cases the length is unnoticed; but at other seasons prayers of long duration are wearisome. Why should habit, like a taskmaster, refuse the minister and his people the right to turn to another form of worship? Why must they pray just so many minutes, and no less? The spirit of our Master's remarks on prayer should be allowed to have full weight here, as we recollect that his model prayer is exceedingly short: nor do the other prayers recorded in Scripture countenance length. If, then, the thanks-givings and the petitions to be presented in our public services are so numerous that much time is needed, but long and continuous prayers are in themselves irksome, and find no precedent in the Scriptures, might not the public prayer be divided into portions more nearly equal? Less true prayer is not our advice, and we might even pray more, if our words were fewer, if they were uttered, not to fill up-time, but to unfold in concise and heartfelt terms our present needs. "Be not rash with thy mouth, and let not thine heart be hasty to utter anything before God; for God is in heaven, and thou upon earth: therefore let thy words be few" (Ecclesiastes v. 2).
Another hindrance to the full enjoyment of public prayer is a tendency which prevails at times to pay undue regard to the critical powers of the hearers. The mind for the time loses sight of the solemn fact that prayer is an address to God, and it becomes engaged with the arrangement of words which shall gratify the intellectual tastes of the worshippers. In preaching, wherein men are addressed, it is held by most judges to be wrong to give more thought to the form of the expression than to the truth expressed; surely, then, to occupy the mind with an attempt to please men while speaking to God must be far worse. Dr. Dwight said, "Prayer is, of all kinds of discourse, that which least demands elegance of style. Every professed ornament it rejects with disdain. The simplest, plainest, and least artificial manner of uttering his thoughts alone becomes the character of a suppliant." And a living writer, Mr. Spencer Pearsall, is of opinion that "public prayer should be marked by severe simplicity," and that "a rhetorical passage or a fine word will interrupt the devotion of the people, and prove a stumbling-block in the ascent heavenward." He adds, "This simplicity is violated by those who are fond of pomposity and mouthing." These quotations in no way recommend carelessness of diction in prayer. Rather
be it the aim of all, upon whom the honour devolves, to attain by practice a style which shall neither offend nor dazzle the hearer. A truly graceful person is so without an effort, because education and practice have made becoming manners the habitual accompaniment of his movements: in like manner may we be masters of a style of speech simple and correct, in which our mind shall habitually clothe our utterances without effort. There will then be little fear of embarrassment in finding proper words. The love of admiration is, however, so great that nothing short of divine grace can completely deliver us from the temptation to please our friends by the language of our prayers.
A simple and dignified style in prayer is promoted by an intimate acquaintance with the devotional parts of Scripture. Frequent perusal of these is in itself a blessing to the believer, and a greater one still to him who prays in public, because it begets a familiarity with the noblest devotional expressions. Care must be taken not to fall into the error of some, who pray by stringing together quotations from the Bible, impressing us with the idea that their chief aim is to show their knowledge of it. A dish composed wholly of sauce would produce nausea, while another which is nutritious without sauce is rendered more palatable by its addition. So let Scriptural phraseology be judiciously used, and it will impart increased zest to what is already a fear of fat things.
Sometimes men have so far forgotten the nature of prayer, that their sentences have been framed almost exclusively for the ears of their human auditors. A prominent member of the congregation is referred to in terms evidently intended to make him comfortable. The spirit which prompts such a prayer is as vicious as that which allows a person so to speak of the conduct of one or more present, that they cannot fail to note how perfectly the prayer is adapted to their naughty ways. Prayer of this kind arises scarcely at all out of a desire that the culprits should be blessed, but from the wish to let them know that their offences have been marked. The law of sin in our members may be inclined to these displays of servility or spite, and Satan may help the old nature in the effort, but a really gracious spirit will check the advancing words, and earnestly seek grace to be delivered from the slightest tendency to debase prayer to so low a use. Concerning such prayer, "Set a watch, O Lord, before my mouth, keep the door of my lips." (Psalm cxli. 3.)
The difficulties hitherto named are those connected chiefly with the process, and in part with the spirit in which we engage in public prayer. Those now to be considered range in a higher sphere.
When our mind dwells soberly upon what public prayer is, we discover the exalted position which it holds in the realm of our spiritual life. In preaching we speak to men; in prayer we speak to the Infinite One. Regarded in this light prayer is higher in its sphere than preaching, and is one of the most solemn and sublime duties in which men can engage. Our difficulty here is to maintain in spirit this exalted but true estimate. We are not in danger of being too reverential, but through frequent attendance in the holy place we are in danger of becoming less mindful that he whom we profess to worship is the Lord God Almighty. To lose our confidence of approach, as of children fully
559
and lovingly accepted, would be heart-breaking; to have it blended with holy awe in the presence of the Highest is our desire; and we believe that as the Lord manifests himself more fully to us we shall both draw nearer in love and bow more humbly in reverence.
"Who know his power, his grace who prove
Serve him with awe, with reverence love."
The indifference with which frequently the preliminaries of a public service (as the devotional parts are sometimes named) are treated is a painful evidence of this difficulty. It would appear that all the attention is concentrated on the sermon, for which talent of course is selected: the other portions of the service have to take their chance.
Forgetfulness of the high nature of prayer is manifested also by the striking contrast between the often exhaustive study for preaching, and the frequent utter disregard of preparation for public prayer. This neglect may be looked upon as the cause, in great measure, of the next difficulty.
What soul does not feel sometimes, and painfully too, its inability at the time of prayer to give utterance to words which shall bring the hearers into communion with God, either in adoration, confession, thanksgivings, or supplication. The way of access is open, our great High Priest is waiting to receive what we may intrust to his hands, and we know that we cannot fail of acceptance, when approaching the Father through the Son: yet our cry is, "We know not what we should pray for as we ought," and we seek encouragement in the assurance that "the Spirit also helpeth our infirmities." At the conclusion of the prayer it appears to us, on reflection, to have been but a forced mental effort. At such seasons as these our mind is conscious of using time-worn expressions, and we lament that both heart and mind seem to have run dry. We cannot reach the fresh springs at such times: here lies a frequent difficulty.
Another of our cares springs from the desire that the words of our month and the meditations of our heart may be acceptable with the Lord, and at the same time present to our hearers a proper variety of topics. We find it difficult to avoid leaning too much to the human side.
To cure these evils the remedy of a strengthened spiritual life must be applied. The lack of reverence, and the absence of the spirit of prayer, are ills which disappear when the soul is in a healthy and vigorous state. In view of our needs in public prayer, we need that the Lord should invigorate our spirits. Communion with God is the best means to this end. "They that wait upon the Lord shall renew their strength."
While we thus remember the Lord we must also remember those for whom we plead. It is profitable to turn the attention, before prayer, towards men, as well as towards God, in order to bring ourselves into fuller acquaintance and deeper sympathy with their wants.
The advantages of a twofold course of this kind are so apparent that we need advocate its use with but few words.
A child at variance with a parent is not the proper person to be the mouthpiece of the rest of the family, in order to express their love, willingness to obey, and desire for favours. Neither are a cold heart, a
burdened conscience, and a weak faith the fit characteristics of one who is to help others to plead for love, and pardon, and fellowship. Our own speaking-terms with the great King must first be arranged. The way of access should be cleared of all personal impediments. The high priest of Israel offered his own sacrifice first, before the people's; he entered into the Holy of Holies with atoning blood for himself, before he took that in, which atoned for the people's sin; and he who has to lead others in public prayer to the throne of grace will best do so, if he has himself but recently returned thence, with his heart sprinkled from an evil conscience, his countenance beaming with glory, and his hands laden with blessings of grace and mercy, just received at the hand of his Father and Saviour. One so blessed will be ready again to enter into the holiest, by the blood of Jesus, with the spiritual offerings of the people.
In drawing near to our Father in heaven to present our people's tribute of gratitude and love we shall be wise to let our utterance describe no more than we feel; but we shall be happy if our adoration and praise, truthfully expressed, not only equal the spiritual aspirations of our hearers, but surpass them. To restrain our soul's communion with our Lord to the lower flight of weaker spirits is not required of us. If by waiting on the Lord our strength has been renewed, and we can mount up with wings as eagles, piercing the clouds of guilt and gloom, until we enjoy the fulness of glory of our Sun of Righteousness, let us do so. Let our heart present its treasures of spiritual gold and frankincense and myrrh at the feet of our incarnate God, and if our gift exceed our people's it is not likely that jealousy will take hold of them, but rather a laudable desire to be able to offer such gifts also to their Redeemer. As the greater includes the less, so will it come to pass that prayers which express the hearts of the most mature Christians will not be unsuitable even for the babes in grace.
In adoration and praise we may go in advance of the congregation as far as our heart will allow, and beckon them onward; but in presenting their confessions and petitions at the throne of grace we must remain with them, and get as near to them by sympathy as possible. This nearness is to be attained by previous meditation upon their need. We may as well expect to preach profitably as to pray profitably, without consideration beforehand of a congregation's requirements. In our contemplations individual cases should be carefully remembered. The limits of public prayer preclude the mention of individuals, except occasionally by request, or under special circumstances, as of bereavement, but general utterances based upon the need of a particular case will very closely touch many experiences. Our range of observation in selecting these typical cases should be wide enough to include the varied phases of life which come under our notice, lest we concentrate upon one that intercession which belongs to many. Nor should the eye of the mind rest upon our own sphere only. It is right that our hearers should, through our prayers, be led to take an interest in other parts of the one true church, and to sympathise with the wants of the nation, of all nations, and of the world. We hear the echo of a voice long silent saying, "I exhort, therefore, that first of all supplications, prayers, intercessions, and giving of thanks be made for all men" (1 Tim. ii. 1).
561
With such a field for intercession, so crowded with the subjects of distress, and need, and sorrow, can it ever be that prayer degenerates into the utterance of oft-repeated sentences, or becomes the pointless effusion of religious jargon? It is possible, when antecedent preparation by meditation is habitually neglected. To say that previous thought is unnecessary, because dependence is placed upon the aid of the Holy Spirit, is but an idle excuse. If a person is called upon suddenly to lead in public prayer, he may cast himself on God, and expect to have given him in the same hour what he shall say. When, however, he knows that in a coming service he will have to speak for a certain congregation at the mercy-seat, and gives no previous thought to the states of the people, and their possible requirements, expecting to receive inspiration at the moment of prayer, he must not be disappointed if he find that the chariot wheels of devotion drag heavily, and that it is painful work to urge the laggard steeds heavenward.
It is not suggested that the prayer should be precomposed, for then it would cease to be extemporary; nor do we even wish it to be unalterably prearranged. The right plan, we conceive, is to bring ourselves beforehand into sympathy with the congregation's wants and desires, by thinking upon their condition, and then to rely implicitly on God the Spirit to help us to bring those wants before the Lord in prayer.
This twofold preparation by communion with God and meditation upon the need of the people will surely give the devotional spirit becoming the act of leading others in prayer, and will suggest suitable topics drawn from their present circumstances. It will likewise lead to point and variety in prayer, for, by the Spirit's teaching, it must of necessity be eminently adapted to the requirements of the worshippers.
If after preparing in this way it should appear that the spirit of prayer has not rested upon us, the appearance may be but a false one. Have not sermons, which cost much pain in delivery and seemed to be devoid of all unction, afterwards been known to have been channels of much blessing? So may our broken and laboured utterances in prayer, when their faults are not the result of neglect of thought, or hardness of heart, be at times the fittest expositions of our hearers' feelings.
More often than not, however, when the time of prayer arrives, the way Godward is clear, and, as the Holy Spirit leads, the sentences come forth as a band of servants, not to attract by their livery, but by their suitability to convey the desires of the people heavenwards. The hearers' sympathies are enlisted; the prayer becomes theirs, and the end of your public effort is answered.
Prayers which proceed from hearts enjoying the uninterrupted light of Jehovah's countenance, which are the result of the Holy Spirit's teaching, which lift up the aspirations and desires of the people into the presence of God, while they follow in thought until they see their petitions spread before the throne of grace—these are the prayers which bring blessing, and which we desire to offer. There is One who gives such hearts, such teaching, such ability to pray, and to him we cry,
"O Thou by whom we come to God,
The Life, the Truth, the Way,
The path of prayer Thyself hast trod,
Lord, teach us how to pray."
