Menu
‹ Chapter 192 of 201 ›

Influence of Bishops in the Past

11 min read · Chapter 192 of 201

SHOULD the reader desire to estimate the influence of the bishops, let him cast his eyes over the recorded ecclesiastical history of the first thirty years of the present century, and he will hardly find an unfortunate or objectionable policy of the minister for the time being that did not receive the support of the bishops. As long as the government opposed the abolition of slavery, they, with few but most honourable exceptions, voted with the Government. Lord Eldon once, when speaking to a friend in the House of Lords on the question of negro slavery, remarked, "that the consistent behaviour of so many of the bishops in defending it gave him great satisfaction, as he was now fully convinced that there was nothing in the institution of slavery contrary to the principles of Christianity."

Belsham, in his "History of Great Britain," remarks that—"It is not to the credit of the Established clergy that their names have been associated with some of the most disastrous measures in the history of the country. To the latest period of the war against America (the War of Independence) they were, next to George III., its most obstinate supporters. Out of the twenty-six English bishops, Shipley was the only prelate who voted against the war faction. To the commencement and during the protracted continuation of the French revolutionary war they were mainly instrumental in supporting the government. There was but little disposition on the part of the people to interfere in the politics of Europe, and it is more than probable that this country would have maintained peace had the clergy been instigated by the bishops to make it a pulpit question to avoid the war. It was only by the unfounded alarms they disseminated respecting the security of property and social institutions that the contest was made popular. Watson was the only bishop who ventured to raise his voice against the French crusade, and even he, finding his opposition to the court fixed him in the poorest see in the kingdom, in the latter part of his life appeared to waver in his integrity.†

Another example of the unholy alliance which then existed between Church and State was the support the bishops gave, either by their vote or silence, to the iniquitous and cruel laws then in vogue in England. As late as the early part of the reign of George IV. there were no fewer than one hundred and eighty-six crimes punishable by death. The older among our readers may probably remember seeing on their road to the City, on the morning after each sessions terminated, four, five, or six criminals hanging in front of Newgate, and considered it no uncommon sight. Many efforts were made by philanthropists to stop the frequency of these ghastly spectacles, if not by the abolition of the punishment of death, at least by mitigating the severity of the laws. How severe they were may be judged by the fact that, during the thirty years from 1790

* Disestablishment, from a Church Point of View. By W. Gilbert, author of "Shirley Hall Asylum," "De Profundis," etc. London: Tinsley Brothers, 3, Catherine Street, Strand. 1875. A work containing much information with which all Dissenters should be familiar.

† Church, State, Law, and Representation. Effingham, Wilson and Co.

569

to 1820, no fewer than six hundred and twenty-six persons had been capitally convicted under the Bank of England Act, and more than two thousand transported. The efforts of the "humanitarians," as they were termed, were strenuously opposed by the majority of the judges, on whose shoulders the mantles of Scroggs and Jeffreys seemed to have descended; and all efforts to mitigate the severity of our criminal code for many years remained unabated.

It might have been imagined that, in virtue of the office they held, the Christian attribute, mercy, might have been developed in the breasts of the bishops, and that they would have used their influence in its behalf in the House of Lords. They, however, as a body, were either silent in the matter, or personally assisted the judges in their opposition to a more merciful code of criminal laws. This statement, from the far more humane administration of justice in the present day, may be considered by the reader as somewhat exaggerated, but such is not the case, as the following example will show, as well as the quality of the excuse sometimes offered for the reverend lords,—that they must have been taken by surprise, and had not been allowed time fully to consider the subject. So far from this being the fact, the agitation for a reform in our sanguinary criminal code was considered for more than thirty years before the question came fairly before the House of Lords. It may be held to have commenced after the execution of Mary Jones, who was convicted of having stolen a piece of cotton cloth, value eight shillings, from a shop door in Ludgate Hill in 1780. The poor creature's case appeared to have excited great commiseration at the time among the population generally, and among them many members of the peerage. There were, however, two notable exceptions—the law lords and the majority of the bishops.

Mary Jones was a native of Cornwall. Her husband, then an artisan, had formerly been a sailor, and as the Government was sorely in want of seamen at the time, he was pressed, and sent to sea. His wife, a woman of unblemished character, made, with an infant at her breast, the journey on foot to London, to find her husband, and if not successful, a relative she thought would give her shelter. She was disappointed in both cases: and after wandering about the streets for some days in a starving condition, she, driven to desperation, purloined from a shop door the piece of cloth mentioned above. The cry was raised, and the master of the shop rushed out of his house in pursuit of the thief, who it appeared had repented of her crime, and was returning to the shop with the cloth in her hand. At her trial she was found guilty, but the jury strongly recommended her to mercy on account of her previous good character. All, however, was of no avail. The judge, "one of the good old British school," would not endorse the recommendation of the jury; the "majesty of the law" had to be avenged; the poor woman was cast for death, and hung at Tyburn, the infant being taken from her breast at the foot of the gallows.

This execution was the cause of an agitation, having for its object a modification of the severity of our criminal code. They were no blind enthusiasts who headed the movement, asking for unreasonable alterations in the law, but men of standing, as well as honourable politicians. They commenced by applying for the abolition of the punishment of

death for stealing secretly to the value of five shillings. For many years, however, Romilly, who to his honour headed the movement, was unable to get it entertained by the House of Lords—the judges were against it. It was, of course, urged that the English were always "a law-abiding nation," and ought not to oppose the opinion of the judges. So powerful was the opposition in the House of Peers to this very slight concession to the opinion of men of common humanity, that it was not until May, 1810, thirty years after the commencement of the agitation, that the bill for the abolition of the punishment of death for secretly stealing to the amount of five shillings was brought up for second reading in the House of Lords. It was, however, most energetically opposed by Lord Ellenborough, who denounced it as an innovation in the laws of England, which, as they stood, might be considered as most just and merciful.

It might be imagined that in such a cause the bishops, as representatives of the Christian principle in the House of Peers, might have exerted themselves in the cause of mercy. Only eleven persons, however, voted in favour of the abolition of the punishment of death, and none of those on the Episcopal Bench. It may also be stated that during the thirty years' agitation the bishops as a body never assisted in the movement; nor, it is said, can a single instance be found in which a member of their bench openly encouraged those trying to effect a more humane administration of the law. In 1811 the same bill was again introduced into the House of Lords with no better success than before, that eminently Church and State judge, Lord Ellenborough, heading the party against it. On this occasion, as before, no bishop was present, nor did any member of that reverend body appear to take the slightest interest in the matter. Out of the House how little the bishops exerted themselves in favour of the bill may be judged from the fact that only thirty-seven peers voted on the occasion of the second introduction of the bill into the House, ten for the abolition, and twenty-seven against it; of these last, it is said, there were more than one bishop. The bill, however, in spite of the opposition of Lord Ellenborough and the majority of the judges, and (to speak in the most complimentary terms possible) the indifference of the bishops, ultimately became law, without any of the terrible effects predicted by several of the most eminent law authorities of the day arising from it. When the bill for the abolition of the punishment of death for stealing in a dwelling-house to the value of forty shillings was brought before the Lords, the opposition of the bishops was open and undisguised. On the second reading it was thrown out by their votes.

In the year 1804, in consequence of the intense spiritual ignorance which existed in Wales, and where, had it not been for the energy of the Nonconformists, Christianity might possibly have become extinct, a Dissenting minister, the Reverend Thomas Charles, shocked at the scarcity of Bibles in the Principality, took a journey to London in the hope of bringing the subject under the notice of some of the leading philanthropists of the day. After much difficulty he succeeded, through the agency of a friend, in obtaining an introduction to the Religious Tract Society, and various schemes were suggested to carry out Mr. Charles's wishes, when a Baptist minister, the Reverend T. Hughes,

571

remarked, that as Bibles were much wanted in other districts besides Wales, it would be better to form a society expressly for the purpose. The suggestion was adopted, and it was resolved that a Bible Society should be established, the working committee to be composed of an equal number of Churchmen and Nonconformists.

It might be imagined that so praiseworthy an institution—one so consistent with the soundest principles of Protestantism—would have been readily supported by the clergy of the Church of England. Such, however, was so far from being the case, that it would, perhaps, be impossible to name, since the commencement of the Reformation itself, a more uncompromising or rancorous opposition than was shown by the church clergy against the Bible Society, fraught as it was with every element of good. Every opprobrious stigma, every term of abuse which could be found in the vocabulary of the establishment—which those acquainted with the polemical literature of the day will know was very extensive—were hurled against it. And this was the more remarkable as the movement was not solely confined to Nonconformists, but large numbers of the Evangelical section of the Church of England laboured in the movement, shoulder to shoulder with Dissenters of all denominations. The abuse heaped by the heads or leaders of the State Church clergy on the Nonconformist members of the Society was insignificant when compared with that hurled at the Evangelicals, without, however, driving them from their partisanship in the cause of the dissemination of the Bible, unfettered by State control. It should also be stated that the Evangelical party were not the only members of the Church of England who supported the Bible Society. Great bodies of the laity also took an interest in the movement, and among them many of high social position and influence; of these may especially be named the Duke of Kent, the father of our Queen. He appears, possibly from his relationship to the king, George III., the supreme head of the Church, to have been considered particularly obnoxious. To such an extent was the feeling against his Royal Highness carried, that on one occasion the Archbishop of Canterbury positively censured him in the presence of the king, reminding him, “that he that is not with us is against us.” The Archbishop, however, gained nothing, for the king took the part of his son in the matter, sorely to the annoyance of the primate. Mr. Skeats, when speaking of the opposition shown by the Establishment against the supporters of the Bible Society, says:—

“Reproach, however, was the mildest form in which the opposition to the Society was clothed. Denunciation followed denunciation. The Bishop of London opposed it because Dissenters of any sect could be admitted on the committee, ‘and when,’ he said, ‘admitted into religious society with us, they will—and it is natural—endeavour to gain the ascendancy, and supplant us wherever they can find the opportunity.’ The Bishop of Winchester denounced it because it was not formed with a sufficient security to the Church of England. Dr. Herbert Marsh, Margaret Professor of Divinity, and afterwards Bishop of Peterborough, addressed a memorial to the Senate at Cambridge, protesting against the constitution of a society where an equality of power and interest between Dissenters and Churchmen was admitted, in which there was an imminent danger that

the pre-eminence of the Established Church would be gradually forgotten and lost. 'That Churchmen,' he added, 'by their association with Dissenters in this modern Bible Society would increase both the political and religious importance of the latter is too obvious to require illustration.' Dr. Wordsworth said, 'that the Society would have only a baneful operation, calculated to interfere with, impede, and retard the inestimable interests of piety and peace, and true religion.' 'Supply these men with Bibles,' said a country clergyman '(I speak as a true Churchman), and you will supply them with arms against yourselves.' 'Dissenters,' said another, 'can now get Bibles more easily than ever.' By others it was gravely urged that without the liturgy men were left in doubt whether the principles of the Established Church should be embraced by them or not, that they wanted a guide to lead them into the church, and unless they were supplied with the Prayer-book, the Bible might be misapplied to doctrines and discipline most discordant to the Church. It was also especially urged by Mr. Marsh, that the political consequences of the Bible Society might be dangerous to the State."

The agitation of the Established Church as a body against the Bible Society lasted for no less than fifteen years, the two archbishops, nearly the whole of the bishops, and a vast majority of the Church clergy taking an active part against this most praiseworthy attempt to place the Scriptures within the reach of all classes of the population, so that all might profit by its teaching. Fortunately never has the proverb, "Magna est veritas et prævalebit" been more completely exemplified than in the working of the Bible Society, never an association of men that has rendered more benefit to mankind. But beyond the advantages which have accrued from it a moral may be drawn, bearing on this little work—That where Churchmen and Nonconformists work together in one common good cause, how vast is the amount of benefit which may accrue from their co-operation. And if so much good has been eliminated by a union of Churchmen and Dissenters, what may not be effected from a union of the kind when religion is released from State control, and all sections of Protestants can work cordially and energetically together?

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate