Menu
‹ Chapter 37 of 201 ›

The American Temperance Crusade of 1874 — By A Friend Upon The Spot

17 min read · Chapter 37 of 201

THE American Temperance Crusade bore some resemblance to the romantic movements of the Middle Ages, from which its name is derived. If its object had been less worthy, and its promoters less intelligent, it might have been judged and condemned on the same grounds. It was characterised throughout by a wild tumultuous enthusiasm. The current of popular opinion became so swift and turbulent, that although it flowed in the right direction, great danger menaced the cause committed to its influence. The true friends of temperance, who had laboured on when public opinion either frowned or sneered, hailed the event as the dawn of the grand social era for which they had worked and prayed. Broken-hearted women, who had drunk deep of the dregs of the cup of shame and suffering, mixed by the debauchery of sons or husbands, or fathers, lifted their hearts to heaven, assured that the angel had come who would pluck their wretched friends from the indolence and vice which drink had engendered. Christian men, who believed that external reformation, apart from inward regeneration, would prove transitory, and, perhaps, be succeeded by a terrible reaction, strove to help on the movement despite their fears, lest, peradventure, they might be mistaken, and prove a stumbling block in the way of a salutary and beneficial reform.

The listless multitudes flocked to the daily prayer meetings, just as they would to a camp meeting, or any other assemblage where excitement and novelty were to be found.

Demagogues, like vultures, scenting their prey from afar, thrust themselves forward on every occasion, vying with each other as to who should say the wildest and most extravagant things.

Politicians, remembering how shortlived such excitements are, and knowing also the permanent gratitude their support would evoke, sought by every art known to them to capture the movement. The Prohibitionists grew confident, and calculated upon carrying their adherents to the fore-front of the political army. Democrats coquetted with the movement, by pretending conversion to teetotalism, some even claiming that twelve hours had changed the sot into a thoroughgoing abstainer, and so delighted were the earnest women, that while the smell of whisky yet lingered about their converts, they were welcomed as exponents of temperance views. Republicans claimed to have always loved the cause, and spoke of the liquor traffic and slavery in a breath, claiming to be ready to abolish the one as they had the other.

While the churches were sparsely attended at the morning and evening services, the temperance meetings were thronged to overflowing. It mattered not how poor the speaker might be, if he were sound; nor how good, if he counselled moderation and prudence. The one evoked sympathy and support,

* Having received this paper from an esteemed friend in the United States, although it is a little out of our usual line of subjects, we print it because it is in itself a very interesting record, and yet more because it shews what can be done by a people earnest, united, and thoroughly aroused. Considering how much they have had to suffer, we wonder mothers and wives have not done the like in England long ere this in sheer exasperation. We should be very far from wishing to see a display precisely similar to that which is here described, but, if wisely directed, a kindred enthusiasm might accomplish marvels. When the whole church shall be aroused, and all believers shall become intense in spirit, other evils, as well as drunkenness, will find the land too hot to hold them.

It is well to add that we do not mean to hold any discussion on the topic suggested. We give the paper, and there is an end of the matter as far as our pages are concerned.—C. H. S.

127

to the other they turned a deaf ear. The infallible way to crowd a church was to announce a temperance sermon. So absorbed was the public mind, that Christ and him crucified aroused but little interest even in the breast of professed believers.

The public very largely seemed to imagine that tectotalism was the one thing needful, and to account a man's conversion to sobriety to be almost as divine a phenomenon as the conversion of a soul to God. In most places the pulpits rang with praise of the crusade and maledictions of the saloon keeper; the drunkard was everywhere pitied, and consoled as a victim who had been more sinned against than sinning. He who ventured to remonstrate upon any part of the movement, was sure to be assailed with scornful words and uncharitable suspicions. The press at first contented itself with reporting speeches and incidents, with a little or no hostile criticism. The fear of a diminished list of subscribers was ever before their eyes, until the excitement abated, and then they ventured to mount the tribune.

In some of the cities startling incidents occurred. In one an ordinance, closing every drinking place, was passed in a single night, in the presence of a crowd of crusaders, who had demanded the enactment, with courage equalled only by the intrepidity of the Magna Charta barons. Having secured the ordinance, they astonished the assembled councilmen by singing the doxology.

In another, a solemn oath was taken that no intoxicating liquor of any kind, neither for medical nor convivial purposes, should ever enter the place again; and when suspicion was aroused that a load of the forbidden fluid was on its way from the depot to the drug stores, a valiant host overhauled the suspected contents of the dray. One woman, in Illinois, discovered that a doctor had prescribed some sort of alcoholic stimulant for her husband, and that a certain druggist had filed the order. Armed with a revolver, Mrs. W——— visited the drug store, and presenting the pistol at the head of an alarmed clerk, demanded the surrender of the prescription. The clerk told her she must see the doctor and get him to revoke the prescription; thereupon she visited the doctor, employing the same powerful arguments, and secured an instant revocation of the order. Many affirmed they would sooner see their children die than permit them to taste the accursed beverage. All declared they were enlisted for life in the holy war, and would never cease till death snatched them from the conflict.

Their modes of operation were extraordinary. 1. Street praying.—One afternoon we saw a band of twenty ladies take their station before a drinking saloon, where every blind was drawn down and no sign of life within was evident. One prayed, then all sang. Another prayed, and again they sang. We distinctly remember one of the prayers, it was very devoutly expressed, and struck as very direct and peculiarly personal to the publican within; it was in this wise:—"O Lord, pardon this saloon-keeper! Thou knowest how much misery he has caused by his sinful traffic. Lord, we wish him well; open his eyes to see his sinfulness. Lord have mercy on his poor soul. Forgive him for shutting his house and heart to us, thy servants." Sometimes the saloon-keeper was inordinately polite, gave thanks for their solicitude, and explained the respectable character of his establishment. Others resented the intrusion, and flung the feast at Cana, and Timothy's infirmity, together with the apostle's remedy, in the face of the crusaders.

One of the strangest features of the meetings of the crusaders was the indiscriminate use of the songs of evangelical Christians. Jew and Gentile, Unitarian and Presbyterian, Romanist and Baptist, worldling and Christian, sang in concert, "Rock of Ages," "Alas, and did my Saviour bleed?" "Sweet hour of prayer," "Oh, for a closer walk." The portinacity of the ladies was remarkable. It mattered not what was the state of the weather, indeed, the more inclement it became the more heroic were they: kneeling down on the kerb-stone in front of closed saloons, amid half-melted snow or slush, with rain, or snow, or hail descending upon them, they defied the elements, and asserted their willingness to suffer or die for the cause they had espoused. Strong men grow

hysterical in their feelings and extravagant in their expressions of admiration. Women stood aghast at the obdurateness of the Saloonatic (as he was called in derision) who could resist such a spectacle of self-sacrificing ardour. Many clergymen grew as passionately enthusiastic as the women themselves, one of them asserting his belief that they were "as much inspired as the holy apostles."

2. Another method was designated the parade. As many ladies as could be induced to go marched two and two up the main street with slow and solemn step, looking as mournful and devoted as Sisters of Mercy. This was designed to be a mute declaration of the numerical strength of the league.

3. In some places small companies of ladies, with the utmost self-possession, took their station inside the various saloons, and remained there through the day, spending their time in knitting and watching those who entered, and taking down the names of all who drank.

4. At the daily prayer meeting, noted publicans or tavern proprietors were prayed for by name. Reports were received from the praying bands and read to the assembly. All this time the moderate drinkers had nothing to say, they left the men who had catered for their depraved appetite in the lurch, and some of them, after having surreptitiously obtained their drinks by entering the back door of the rum shop, came forth inspired afresh with admiration for the temperance party. It is difficult to give an adequate idea of the extreme excitement which prevailed. A few straws will indicate the swiftness of the current. The McConnelsville ordinance (which was designed to stop social tippling altogether) having been passed by the city council of Akron, the people of that little city grew excited over the subject, and the pen used by the President of the Council in putting his signature to the document was put up to auction and sold for two hundred and fifty dollars. In a neighbouring town a clergyman debilitated by sickness, went to the drug store and purchased six or eight ounces of brandy. The fact was discovered, and well nigh terminated his pastorate. In another place a druggist refused to abandon the sale of alcoholic liquor, when the following incident occurred, which was published at the time in a leading paper, and, so far as I know, its veracity was never impeached. The druggist had locked his door, the ladies prayed, and with them notably one clergyman. His whole manner was that of angry virtue, he is reported to have prayed that God would strike the offender dead before morning and send him to the lowest hell. Another brother said in his prayer "that there was no hope of D—— ever being saved; that he had sunk too low." The older citizens tried to cool this fury, but without success. Some of the party even pleaded earnestly with the landlord of the hotel where the druggist lodged not to allow so great a sinner nor his clerk a lodging place. The next morning the obdurate druggist was about to turn his weary steps homeward, when a prominent lady waved the black flag in his face as a parting salute.

On the other hand, some few of the dealers in drink retaliated with vituperation and ribaldry; they fiercely impeached the purity and sobriety of the clergy, and flung at them portions of the Word of God with most horrible blasphemies, and they affected to see nothing in the movement but hypocrisy, madness, and political wire-pulling.

In some cases the women were assaulted and openly ridiculed, their characters were aspersed, and every item of scandal ever circulated at their expense was related afresh. Indeed, it was a wild time when good men trembled lest in the fray they should inadvertently hinder the work of God, and good women grew reckless through a zeal born of love of virtue, and hatred of vice; when bad men became either morose or hypocritical, and when even wise men were driven to say imprudent words and do foolish actions; when the scum of self-seekers and hypocrites sought cheap martyrdom or doubtful notoriety; yet was it also a time wherein the lifeboat was launched in prayer, and manned by brave and earnest souls, who knew not and seemed not to care whither it drifted, so that they could save wrecked and ruined men.

129

The ladies engaged in the movement were of all classes, from the highest to the poorest. Stately dames, whose known prudence and dignity forbade the idea of their ever assisting such an enterprise, became its leaders. Women of the world of fashion laid aside their gaiety and pleasure-seeking, and plunged nobly into the work. Those whose hands one would have thought were filled full enough with maternal and household cares spoke, and prayed, and worked as assiduously and constantly as the rest. Even Episcopal churches became the scene of temperance prayer-meetings, presided over, as they were all, by ladies. Baptists forgot close communings, and affiliated with any and all denominations. In a word, the condition was revolution. Persons who had never opened their lips in the ordinary church prayer-meetings poured forth melting and impassioned addresses to God in public. Those who for years had excused themselves from evening-services, or from attending church altogether, grew enthusiastic and were present at almost every meeting.

We now purpose showing the cause of the crusade. If this be fully appreciated we are well assured that the indiscretions of the campaign will all be forgiven at sight of the deep and terrible experience which stung American women into frenzy.

In that part of America where the crusade was most successful—the western part—moderate drinking is almost unknown; the liquors are adulterated and pernicious, maintaining almost as tenacious a hold upon the consumers as opium. They who drink of these liquors have one of two inevitable courses before them. If they drink to excess they will die as notorious drunkards; if they drink regularly without excess they will certainly be the victims of dyspepsia, or may eventually sink to besotted wretchedness. A certain writer remarks—"All who have heard the temperance lecturers of the Western villages will remember the vigour and fire with which these travelling orators always delighted to paint the deep and emulous depravity of those two classes of malefactors—viz., the rum seller and the moderate drinker. The drunkard was always much more kindly treated. He was always represented as a suffering innocent, who would reform and live cleanly if it were not for the temptations held out by the dealer, and the baneful example set by the cold-hearted aristocrat who 'only drank what was good for him.' These were the only speeches relished by the audiences, and consequently the only ones made. They pleased the wives and mothers of drunkards, who formed the bulk of the audience."

From one cause and another moderate drinking is in this region regarded as an impossibility. So deep-seated is this conviction, that those who have abstained all their lives, if they drink at all, "go on the spree," as it is called: that is to say, become filthily drunk. They believe that to drink is to get drunk, so they get drunk when they drink. Moreover, the physical constitution of Americans, it is argued, is so excitable and nervous that it is a moral impossibility for them to drink and yet have control of themselves. Then, again, the people believe that there never was, nor is anywhere, temperate drinking: English people are held up as a nation of beer guzzlers; Frenchmen are condemned as a race of intoxicated wine-bibbers. The Germans even are not spared, but Lager falls beneath the universal curse, and the Teutonic race is added to the list of drunken nations.

From one cause and another to drink at all in these States means loss of reputation, crime, disease, and death. The women of the west have suffered fearfully from this cause. I hardly know a family in this city from which I write but can relate experiences of a drunkard's delirium or incapacity. They know that if their son or father or brother abandons his temperance principles, there is little hope for him; thus they have been goaded by the memory of past agony, and stung by the fear of future suffering into one great effort, in which they cared not what they lost or incurred so that the ardent liquors which worked such ruin might be swept away for ever. Of course there were hypocrites and self-asserting people who pressed to the front, of course

9

there were stupid fanatics, of course there were frothy, gushing creatures, but the fact which gave the crusade its influence and sweeping power, was that women whose hearts had been broken and whose bodies had been wounded by their liquor-maddened relatives, were determined to bear it no longer. No man who knows the domestic history of this people, unless his heart be steel and his conscience dead, but must admit that the pathos of the crusade far exceeded its folly. The crusaders handled the liquor dealer roughly, it is true; it is true they practically forced entrance into the private rooms of grog-shops; it is true they prayed at a man whether he would or no; it is true they demanded a surrender of his casks and liquor; it is true that if he gave permission they rolled his whiskey barrels into the streets, and emptied their contents, and seemed to care little where he and his children would get bread; but the majority of the saloon keepers excited little sympathy, and were viewed as men who had forfeited their rights. If the women stepped out of their sphere, they had stepped out of theirs; if the women trespassed on their liberty, they had ruined those women's husbands, and heard their appeals either with indifference or mockery. Indeed, the grog-sellers had sold to their boys fresh from school, to their fathers when it was notorious that drink made them devils, to their husbands who now lie in the distant cemetery cold in death, with the shame of drunkenness as their unwritten epitaph. Most saloonists seem to have sold with a stolid resolve to get gain, caring neither to whom or how much they sold. When these men pleaded their rights, the community laughed them to scorn. The law spurned the men who had systematically violated both the rules of society and the instincts of common humanity. They proved great cowards in the heat of the war, as great cowards as their customers who have since recovered their self-possession, and now clamour for the repeal or modification of prohibitory ordinances, who whimper over "hasty legislation and impracticable schemes," and cry for their cups as they used to do for their mothers' breasts. The grog-sellers were always looking furtively and anxiously about for signs of the approach of the crusaders, asking of one another, with tremulous accents, "Will they make a raid on us to-day? What had we better do?" Some of them yielded to the pressure of the times, and signed a solemn pledge never again to sell intoxicants of any kind; whereupon the church bells were set a ringing, as if they celebrated a national victory. A few became active temperance partizans, and were led about the country as extraordinary trophies of the crusade.

Reaction has followed: yet we have reason to hope that the women's work has not been in vain. No doubt many drunkards have been reclaimed, but results cannot be stated with certainty; for drunkards are generally so morally depraved that their pledges are not always reliable. Of 500,000 men who have taken the pledge in the United States says Dr. Chambers, on the authority of the Band of Hope Review, "350,000 have broken it."

In most of the cities where prohibitory ordinances were passed they have been repealed, and in others they are practically a dead letter. Forbidden the saloon, they form drinking clubs and keep spirits or beer in a rented private room, where members of the club drink as often and as deeply as they choose. The law does not forbid buying drinks in bottles, so instead of the public saloon we have no end of pocket and private ones.

The reaction is as much owing to the friends as to the enemies of the crusade. First of all their strength was impaired by the fanaticism of the prohibitionists. Lewis, who claims to have originated the crusade plan, was openly and vehemently rebuked for his hostility to that party. Then the worldly element crept in. The temperance women started with the sublime and simple resolve to confine themselves to prayer and persuasion. At first their efforts had all the disingenuous, tender, and pious characteristics of Christian womanhood. The burden of their pleas was, "You dealers in intoxicating liquors are in a bad business; you know it yourselves, you are tempted and trammelled by the greed of gain. Be men, and abandon it now and for ever.

131

You know us, you know our husbands, and fathers, and sons; our heads are grey with sorrow; you and we have seen many of them go down to a drunkard's grave. Pity us! Pity yourselves! We have told our Father in heaven of our love, and pleaded for you. We trust not in a human arm; we do not threaten, we will not coerce, we trust alone in God, and the means within our reach, which it becomes us to use."

Their demeanour had all the pathos and beauty of a sorrow-stricken mother or an anxious sister. Many and many a man was subdued and affected. At length the worldly element crept in, political lawyers and others obtruded their services, men's committees of advice were formed. These counselled the spy system, advised appeals to law, and busied themselves to institute a reign of terror. Here was the fatal mistake—the spell which sanctified, although fanatical, womanhood had thrown around the saloonists and their customers was broken. The sacredness of prayer was lost sight of, and the liquor men laughed in scorn at a faith which, instead of moving mountains as it claimed to do, employed a myriad of legal sappers and miners, who could do no more than remove a trifling portion of the obstruction. The result was the same as that which we might expect if a minister preached against the vices of the age, pleaded in yearning tones for men to abandon their sins, and concluded by pointing to a dozen policemen seated behind him, and saying, "if you don't heed me, these men will lock you up." They began in the Spirit and ended in the flesh, they began with the divine ram's horns and ended with human battering rams. Before the former the walls tottered, before the latter they proved impregnable.

We read, I think it was during the thirty years' war, that a certain city resorted to a strange plan for the purpose of saving their ill-garrisoned town from pillage and flame. They clothed all the children in white, and sent them forth to intercept the conqueror and sue for peace and safety. The sight of the crowd of beautiful and defenceless children melted the heart of commander and men alike. Similar was the influence of the thousands of Ohio women as they pleaded with their national foes. But the politicians negatived their power, just as the influence of that German band of children would have been negatived if their fathers and brothers had come behind them armed to the teeth and hissing, "If you don't heed the children, you shall know the power of their fathers and brothers."

The reason politicians had more controlling influence than Christian ministers lay in the fact, as it seems to me, that the clergy were either as fanatical as the crusaders, or else lacked moral courage to point out the dangers which menaced the movement, for no man was an acceptable ally unless he pronounced in favour of the cause, without qualification or reserve. The few who dared to claim hearty loyalty in theory and practice to New Testament temperance, and at the same time rebuked the fanatical, unprofitable, and worldly elements which co-mingled with the wise and devout, were openly and furiously denounced as secret allies of the enemy. They who asserted that man must be born again before he could cease to be a drunkard in heart, and proclaimed that the gospel alone could save the community, were regarded with suspicion and frowned on as sanctimonious obstructionists. Another element of weakness was the co-operation of infidels and spiritualists. They were so thorough and pronounced on the temperance question, that the crusaders hardly dared to notice or criticise their extravagance and blasphemies. One of this class in my hearing scornfully charged the church of Jesus with being tacitly opposed to temperance, and hurled the old calumny, in other's words 'tis true, but with unmistakable emphasis, which was launched at our Divine Lord, viz., that we were wine-bibbers and friends of publicans. Alas! they fired into their own ranks. For if Christian teetotallers and temperance men were taken from the cause, few with character and true power to carry it on would be left. Americans have nobly thrown off the old European and despotic shackles, but the chains of the demagogue are worn and even sought.

Reviewing the whole history of the movement, one is impressed with its romantic and unusual character; distressed that so great an object should be unattained; instructed that man's salvation from sin cannot be effected by human agency alone; and if the crusade has taught nothing else it has rebuked the feverish and impatient spirit, which refuses to endorse the truth, "Our weapons are not carnal."

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate