Voysly Versecutions — A Brief Glance At The Inquisition — By Rev. W. P. Cope, Of Maze Pond Chapel
(Continued from page 263.)
GRADUALLY, as its strength consolidated and experience was gained, the Inquisition was prepared for all possible contingencies. At first its action was somewhat arbitrary and often erratic. Precedents were wanting for guidance. It was sometimes fettered by the civil power, not unnaturally jealous of its prerogatives. Like the growth of many tyrannies, its progress was slow, but it was exceedingly sure. Rome can afford to wait. "Men may come and men may go;" but its influences are steadily advancing. Its schemes are pushed forward long after the founders are forgotten. At the end of two centuries we find the Inquisition in full swing. It has "houses"—sometimes called "palaces"—or courts and prisons for the exercise of authority. The office of Inquisitor with a large staff of officers has become a recognized and honoured functionary in the Papal arrangements, and, moreover, it begins to have something like a well-digested code of rules for the guidance of its officials. Eymeric—a kind of Papal Blackstone, for not less than forty years active Inquisitor in the provinces of Castile and Arragon, collected from the civil and canon laws all that related to the punishment of heretics. This "Directory of Inquisitors" was the first and fundamental code. It has been followed ever since without any essential variation wherever the "Holy Office" has been established. Eymeric flourished in the latter half of the fourteenth century; about a hundred years later his "Inquisitor's Directory" was published with a commentary, under the sanction of Pope Gregory XIII. To show the esteem in which it was held, we may add that a second edition was published nine years after the first. In addition to this official document another of equal authority has been unexpectedly brought to light. During a riot in Seville which followed the ratification of the Spanish Constitution by Ferdinand VII. in 1820, the mob broke into the palace of the Inquisitors, surprised them at their task, and drove them out, first taking possession of their documents. Among them was a thin quarto volume, partly written, partly printed. Its title is as follows, "Order of Proceedings in the Holy Office, compiled from Ancient and Modern Instructions, by . . . of the Holy General Inquisition." From a foot-note it appears to have been printed, like other books intended for the use of Inquisitors only, within the walls. Doubtless other documents are in existence. These are enough to give us some idea of the principle and practices of the Inquisition for four centuries. Secrecy, profound secrecy, is one of its most prominent features. If precedent were required it was found in the conduct of the papal legate appointed to the Council of Toulouse. He carried away with him to Rome all the records of inquests made, "lest if any evil-disposed person should chance to find them at any time, and it might be the death of witnesses who had given evidence
309
against them." Witnesses, as well as the accused themselves, are bound by oath to keep secret all they see and hear.
In a case of heresy there were three recognized ways of proceeding—accusation, information, and inquiry. The first method was discouraged; it was found in practice to be dangerous to the accuser and tedious. Information was the method most congenial to the spirit of the Holy Office. Any person suspecting another of heresy was bound under threat of excommunication to lay information against him. The information might be laid in private, with no other witness present than the Secretary of the Inquisitor. The accused would never know who had brought the charge against him.
The process by inquiry might be conducted by the Inquisitor alone. He might make enquiry into the reputation of any person, and if he elicited any suspicion against him it was enough. Nobody needed to say what they had heard, all that was requisite was that people should talk suspectingly about him. It is a well-understood principle of common law that no criminal be required to give evidence against himself: the Inquisition ignored all law, human and divine; a person accused of heresy was required to furnish the particulars of the charge to be entered against himself.
All kinds of witnesses were allowed against the accused. Those discredited in a court of law were heard in the Holy Office, provided, of course, that their testimony was against the heretic. Even a heretic might witness against a heretic. Domestic witnesses—wife, children, servants, might all appear against the accused; they were not to be heard in his favour. The children of heretics rested under a special ban, but if a child informed against the parent the curse was turned into a blessing. Special pains were taken to conceal from the accused the names of all witnesses against him. The time-honoured practice of bringing the accuser and the accused, or the witnesses and the criminal face to face, was especially avoided.
If a witness does not say all the Inquisitor thinks he can say or ought to say, he may be tortured till the evidence wanted is forthcoming. The art of examining a prisoner appears to have reached a perfection that left nothing to be desired. The questions put to him, "were to be vague and general, not in such a manner as would suggest subterfuges or help evasion." The heretics were to be treated as very cunning in disguising their errors. They affect sanctity and false tears which might soften the severest judges: an Inquisitor must therefore be always on the watch against all such tricks.
All methods seem justifiable in proceeding against a heretic. Sometimes the Inquisitor is recommended to assume a paternal tone; for what terror or threats could not do might be accomplished by kind words and an assumed interest in the accused. If he is exhausted by confinement and anxiety, yet obdurate, a change of living is recommended—better food may be furnished, visitors may be allowed him, and the love of life quickened, which may prove stronger than heretical obstinacy. Where everything else failed, an acquaintance of the prisoner might be induced to spend a night with him, who should talk his case over as a sympathizer. Witnesses or a clerk would have to be concealed who should take down notes of all that passed; these notes to be afterwards used
against him. Where all these things failed, the rack or torture might be resorted to. Most diabolical and ingenious were the means of torture employed. Women, stripped of clothing, were bound with cords as relentlessly as the men. Physicians or surgeons stood by indicating how far the torture might be employed without taking away life. With an ingenuity that nothing but long practice could have perfected, thin cords were bound around the arms and legs, and tightened till the skin seemed ready to crack. Should the prisoner die under the treatment, the Inquisitors simply absolved one another from all guilt, and as there was no coroner's inquest, heaven was appeased, and the next case proceeded with.
It might sometimes happen that a person accused through private malice, proved a good Catholic. What was to be done? Should he be declared innocent? That would cast a reflection upon the wisdom of the Holy Office. The Inquisitor was instructed to avoid even the least word that might be taken to imply a formal justification. The accused was dismissed with a written absolution setting forth that the Inquisitor had not found any legal proof of guilt, and therefore he fully released him "from the present charge, inquisition, and judgment."
One point seems to have disturbed the consciences of these Inquisitors a great deal. "May an Inquisitor exact the expenses from those against whom he proceeds? and may he condemn them by sentence to pay the expenses?" Very satisfactorily does Eymeric answer such subtle questions. Inquisitors must live; and as soon as the heretic is pronounced such, his life ceases to be his own, he is able therefore to hold property no longer; the children of a heretic are incapable of any other inheritance than poverty and infamy; the wives of course share the fortunes of their husbands. Who then so fitting to use rightly the property of the heretic as the Inquisitor, whose duty it is to suppress all heresy? Customs in different countries may vary, but this seems to be the safe, as it was the general, rule. A penitent, be it observed, cannot have his property restored. Poverty will be a proper penance; fairness demands that the convertor be rewarded for his zeal; besides, to restore the property to the penitent would lay him open to the suspicion of having been actuated by mercenary motives. What chance there was of escape from such a tribunal may be readily conceived; especially if the accused happened to be a person of means, when most careful questions were put as to his property, and it would be to the interest of the Inquisitor to give sentence against him. If able to procure an advocate to defend his case, the advocate was compelled to abandon the defence if the judge ruled that reasonable proof of guilt had been given.
The method of punishment adopted by the Inquisition did not admit of much variety. The choice generally lay between imprisonment or death. Different degrees of heretical guilt were in some cases met by the varying grades of imprisonment. In the Palace of the Inquisition, or Holy House, there was often extensive accommodation for all classes of delinquents. From rooms well ventilated, light and air being admitted through iron gratings, and sufficiently large for the occupant to move about, with bed, seat, fire-place, and a few conveniences, to a mere cell below the level of the ground, with no light, scarcely space enough
311
to stand upright in, where the poor prisoner was fed with barely sufficient to keep up the functions of nature—just enough to cause a lingering death, and no more. To these were sometimes added, in set proportion of weight and number, manacles, fetters, chains, and other contrivances of torment. Those thus confined were most effectually shut out from all society or companionship. To no call or entreaty, or sigh, or shriek might the keeper answer in any way; he was sworn to speak to none. The Inquisitor might come or send, to question, to tempt, to terrify when he pleased. Amid scenes such as these thousands spent many years; others ended their lives, cut prematurely short, rather than deny Christ, or betray their brethren. In many more cases they were taken out from this living sepulchre to endure the horrors of the stake.
Not all remained stedfast till death. Sometimes the faith faltered; and, conforming to the church, the heretic was set free. Overcome by remorse these "penitents" would afterwards return to their first faith, and the Lord whom they had denied. These were deemed incorrigible, and were at once handed over "to feel the fire." So also were those brought a second time under accusation, heretics who proved obdurate, and "negative heretics" who persisted in denying what the Inquisition thought they should confess, there being full proof against them. Before handing them over to the stake the church made one more effort at reclamation: since they could not escape temporal death they were urged to be reconciled to God. If they will not they must feel the fire, but if any will confess, be absolved, and receive the host, the church will generously receive such to her bosom. Although the penitent must die, for the good of his soul, it shall be so arranged that his death shall be comparatively easy: in other words, he shall be strangled as promptly as possible, so that only the dead body, and not the living person shall go to the flames. The desire of burning the heretic became at last such a passion with the Inquisition, that not only the bodies of penitents, and the bones of dead heretics dug up, but effigies of those who had escaped the clutches of the church, were publicly consumed at appointed times of execution.
Everything possible was done to give these ghastly exhibitions a most impressive and solemn aspect. The services of royalty and religion were laid under contribution for this end. The king, as a token of his good faith towards the church, was frequently present. Sermons were preached in which the damnable effects of heresy were vividly pointed out, and the fidelity of the church extolled, while she deplored the harsh measures she felt it necessary to adopt against the faithless. The ceremony itself was arranged so as to represent as nearly as possible the judgment-day. All sympathy for the suffering martyrs was alienated by suggesting that they were the victims of divine justice, their sins being open, going beforehand to judgment. We do not stay to particularise; the details are too sickening. It would be easy to paint the emaciated sufferers dragged from solitary confinement in loathsome dungeons, many of them maimed and hurt by the tortures of the rack, chained by rough and rude men to the stake. The crowd presses around to mock; the priests with insulting importunity thrust the crucifixes into their faces. The fires are lighted, and amid ascending smoke and flame, the faithful spirits are borne, as in a chariot of fire,
to the presence of that Christ from whose love nothing could separate them.
To Spain belongs the worthless honour of conducting these ghastly pageantries on the most elaborate scale. The Spaniard is naturally hot, vengeful, passionate. More than any other European nation he approaches to the common ideal of the old Oriental despot; with lions' dens, furnaces seven times hotter than the usual heat, the houses of the offender made into a dunghill that his name may be blotted out, or, if preserved, hereafter associated only with that which is infamous. Rome pandered to these tastes. The nation's weak point was one element of her strength. How much of the bloodthirsty spirit which has since characterised Spanish politics may be traced to this phase of its popish training is a question not difficult to answer. No nation is more sanguinary; none has been more priest-ridden.
Not a single province has been subdued by Spanish arms, but its inhabitants, if heretical, have been rapidly decimated by the Inquisition. The most solemn treaties intended to secure religious protection to the vanquished were valueless.
So completely did the policy of the priests bias the State councils, that the course adopted was not only most iniquitous, but eminently self-destructive. The nursery story of the foolish man who killed the goose that laid the golden eggs faintly illustrates the unwisdom of the Spaniards' treatment of the Jews and Moors. Torquemada, the Inquisitor-General of that period, must have determined to outrival Haman. For long ages the Jews had added largely to the wealth of Spain by the trade they so successfully carried on. During the Spanish expedition against Granada, by which the power of the Moors was broken, the Jewish race did more to ensure success to the Spanish arms than the knights and fighting men who formed the army. They were the most efficient armourers in the Spanish camp. They provided the daily rations for the troops. They advanced money to pay the king's troops; and it is more than likely that they raised the gold by which Ferdinand and Isabella, king and queen of Spain, bribed the Moorish king to surrender. Mark their reward. Three months after the occupation of Granada, Torquemada induced Ferdinand to decree the expulsion of the entire race out of all Spain, except such as might choose to surrender the faith of their fathers, and be baptised into the papal church. This was March 30th, 1492. The last day of July was fixed as the last day of their dwelling in the kingdom. The Jew might sell or barter any property he held, but was forbidden to carry away gold or silver out of the country. Any Spaniard who should hide or shelter a Jew or Jewess should forfeit all his property, and be discharged from his office, dignity, or calling. The doomed race could not fail to be reminded of the decree of Ahasuerus, and sighed for another Esther to overrule the counsel of the crafty Torquemada. But so far from Queen Isabella espousing their cause, she steeled her own heart and that of the king against mercy. The spell of the papacy was upon her: she could not resist its influence. Rabbi Abarbanel, who for his wisdom and influence may be compared to Nehemiah at the court of Artaxerxes, pleaded on his knees with tears for his nation, and offered to pay down, as ransom into the king's treasury, six hundred
313
thousand crowns of gold. His plea had nearly prevailed, for the king's treasury was exhausted; but the Inquisitor-General very astutely prevented any compromise. Rushing into the presence of the king and queen with a crucifix in his hand, he shouted, "Judas sold the Son of God once for thirty pieces of silver; your highnesses are going to sell him the second time for thirty thousand. Here he is! Here you have him! Sell him if you will." And flinging the crucifix down upon the table, in ill-suppressed rage, the crafty Inquisitor ran away. The pathetic pleading of the aged Abarbanel failed. By the first week in July the Jews were on their way out of the country which many of them loved almost as their native land. Their possessions were sold for a trifle, and often found no purchasers. A house was exchanged for an ass, a vineyard for a little linen or cloth. Thus suddenly bereft of home and wealth, they set out on a mournful exodus. Heartrending tales are told of their sufferings. Some died on the road; mothers brought up in every luxury were suddenly overcome by the pangs of travail by the roadside. Some perished at sea; many were sold for slaves by mercenary captains, who had agreed to take them in safety across the seas. One vessel landed its living freight, among whom a disease had broken out, at Naples. Another famished company reached Genoa, where a procession of priests met them. The foremost carried a crucifix in one hand and a loaf of bread in the other, to signify that they who would adore the image might have the bread.
It is reckoned that in this bloody papal persecution no less than ten thousand Jews perished at the stake; upwards of six thousand were burnt in effigy, the persons having died in prison or fled the country; beside upwards of ninety thousand punished with infamy, confiscation, perpetual imprisonment, or loss of civil rights. This computation does not include the numbers who perished in the terrible exode we have already referred to.
It is not to be supposed that papal zeal was satisfied with this bloody work. Torquemada now conceived the design of converting or exterminating the Moors, whom the king and queen had engaged by special treaty to shield in the exercise of their religion. To help in the good work one Fray Hernando, prior of a monastery near Valladolid, was induced to come to Granada. Pope Alexander VI. made him archbishop. In a spirit alien to the usual method of papal propagandism, he sought the conversion of the Moors by expostulation and controversy. His gentle spirit and spotless life won the admiration of the conquered race. He studied Arabic, their native language, and went so far as to have the Scriptures translated into that tongue for their use. Such measures were too slow and pacific for the haughty church. Ximenez, afterwards cardinal and Inquisitor-general, took the matter in hand. The prayers and translations of Hernando in the vulgar tongue were promptly forbidden, and harsher measures adopted. The end of it was that the Moors, who refused to be converted, were driven out of the country. If they escaped with less suffering than the Jews, it was owing to a wholesome fear inspired by an expostulation from the Sultan.
Similar sanguinary proceedings were instituted against such as received the light of divine truth, and desired to walk in it, on the
20
dawn of the Reformation. In the years 1557 and 1558 a large number of persons were imprisoned as Lutherans. Against all such Pope Paul IV. gave Valdes, the Inquisitor-general, special powers. The brief greatly exceeded in cruelty the excesses practised by Torquemada and Ferdinand. By it the Inquisition was more especially stirred up against the Lutherans, or any who defended them as good. Not only was the power of the Inquisition augmented, but its income considerably increased, to enable it to carry on the new crusade against the rising reformation. Its autos da fé were quite common at Seville and Cordova, while one was celebrated with unusual magnificence at Madrid as late as 1680, in special honour of King Charles II., newly wedded to a French princess. At this celebration twenty-one victims were handed over to the flames. At the last moment two recanted, and as a marvellous act of clemency were spared. The remaining nineteen were made to feel the fire. So late as 1826 there is record of one or two being burned alive by command of the Inquisition. It is reckoned that nearly 400,000 fell victims to the Holy Office during its supremacy in Spain. At length the proud boast was made that heresy could not rear its head in the domains of the Catholic King.
We have referred chiefly to the practice of the Inquisition as found at work in Spain. The principle has been the same in every country where it has been for any length of time set up. The differences have been more of degree than of kind. In Italy the holy office was worked with more secrecy and refinement than in Spain. It revelled in merciless cruelty, but without inviting observation; it worked, therefore, with less scandal. A revolution and the dethronement of the temporal power were, however, needed to bring to the full light of day all the hidden works of darkness. Ingenious contrivances of torture, supposed only to have had an existence in the pages of fiction, have been paralleled by the actual facts. Father Gavazzi visited the Palace of the Inquisition in Rome, when it was broken into after the ignominious flight of the present Pope, in 1849. At that time, among other relics of the Inquisition, were found two prisoners—a nun and an aged bishop; and a secret trap door, through which the unsuspecting victim fell on his way to receive, as he supposed, a relaxation of his punishment. Nor were evidences wanting that it had been used, for below was found a “compost of common earth, rottenness, ashes, and human hair, foetid to the smell, and horrible to the sight and thought of the beholder.” From other evidence found in the vaults of Pope Pius V., a pope, be it observed, canonised for his zeal against heretics, the only conclusion possible was that the victims had been buried alive up to their necks in quicklime. What with the suffocation of the smoke, and the anguish of a compressed breathing, the horrible and desperate nature of this death can be more easily imagined than described.
It is not our purpose to trace the causes that led to the decline of this infamous institution. It needs not to be said that its decay was not owing to any enlightened principles of toleration or love of religious liberty in the Catholic Church itself. Rome is always the same. That has been her boast. If she do not always persecute the same, it
315
is not from change of principle, but from policy, or lack of power. The ecclesiastical bigotry which the other day excommunicated Mr. Henry Petre for denying the Pope's supremacy in civil matters, while he fully acknowledged his infallibility in things spiritual, would, if it had but the power, carry out the practice of the Inquisition. Other forces are at work counteracting that power. On which side victory may fall we can but hope. When the resources of the Papal hierarchy are borne in mind, together with the silent, persistent method of its procedure, he would be a rash man who should dare to predict.
