Menu
‹ Chapter 14 of 220 ›

The Disciples—The Jameses — By Pastor C. A. Davis, Manchester

13 min read · Chapter 14 of 220

FOR the sake of distinctness, we shall bring into one view whatever information can be gleaned of the disciples who bore the name of James. It is easier to discover the differences in faces when seen together, and therefore the presentation of these disciples side by side will give us a more definite notion of their individuality; for they are not always distinguished the one from the other in the New Testament, and the incidents in which an apostle James figures are vaguely distributed in our minds amongst the three. Of the twelve, two bore this name, and a third, the Lord's brother, though not of the original company of the disciples, is so intimately linked with their history that the distinctness we aim at will not be attained unless we epitomise his life also.

James, the son of Zebedee, elder brother of the disciple whom Jesus loved, stands first. Like others of the twelve, he received a triple call from Christ, being twice summoned to the discipleship before he was ordained to the apostleship; for there is no purchase system in Christ's army, all the preparatory discipline must be passed—the apostle must be first a disciple, learning of Christ before he can be sent out by him. Of the first of these calls the lake of Galilee is the scene, a June day in the first year of Christ's ministry the probable date. From the fishing-boat which quietly rocked on the lake near Capernaum, where they were mending their nets, James and his brother were summoned to a higher employment. Not without quick, tremulous forecastings of mind did they leave their nets, the hired servants, the fishing-boat, and their father, to follow Jesus. This abandonment of all things for Christ was as yet only temporary, and after accompanying him in a tour through Galilee they returned to their employment.

In the late summer or early autumn occurred the second call, when by the miraculous draught of fishes Christ portrayed their future career as fishers of men. The vivid touches of the narrative point out the scene before us. We watch the long and strenuous haul of the net, the sinking of Peter's overloaded

* The impression of Mr. Davis that James the son of Alphaeus was not the same as James the Lord's brother is open to considerable question, and we invite remarks upon the very interesting enquiry which our friend has so ably opened.

37

boat, and the eager signalling for help. We hearken to the shout of the men as James's boat is quickly shoved off from the shore and rowed out to their assistance. This prelude prepares us for the after-piece. We do not wonder at their deliberate abandonment of trade to become the adherents of this wonder-working master. "They forsook all and followed him." The miracle foreshadowed, as we have said, their life work, but it may at the same time have answered other side purposes. Probably it was intended to be at once an evidence of the Master's power, and a test of the disciples' self-denial. On the one hand their faith is helped, on the other it is tried. The controversy between flesh and spirit immediately rages within them. Says Faith, Who would not follow a miracle-working Lord? But Worldly wisdom asks, What wise fisherman would leave a miraculous draught of fish? It is not unlike Christ to strengthen faith before he tries it, nor to test it after he has strengthened it. Certainly James and his brother were benefited by this opportunity of denying themselves for Christ. It was better for them to have to leave all this wealth for him, than to be called from an unsuccessful night of toil and from empty nets. The incident suggests also the kind of men Christ wants for his service. Some persons who fail in everything else think they may do well enough in the ministry, but Christ took care not to take unsuccessful fishermen into his apostleship; he made them good fishermen before he gave them the higher appointment. Thus the great haul of fish served many moral purposes, and the provision itself was certainly not wasted any more than the remainder of the miraculous meal afterwards given on the opposite shore of the same lake. Every city has its poor, and glad receivers of this welcome supply of food would not be far to seek.

Now that they are become disciples indeed, men who have irrevocably cast in their lot with Christ, never more to look back to the world, they are promoted in the second year of our Lord's ministry to the apostolic office. This solemn act was preceded by a night spent by Christ in prayer, and followed by the enunciation of the laws and principles of his kingdom (Luke vi.) From this time the glimpses given of James during the wonderful period of miracle and high teaching that followed, impart by their graphic circumstances the interest of an ever-changing expression to his countenance. We catch his look of wonder in the chamber of Jairus' daughter; the more breathless awe which overmasters him as he beholds on the mount of transfiguration God manifest in the flesh; the indignant revenge that flames from his features against the Samaritans who refuse passage to his Master; the half-abashed yet eager desire depicted on every line of his face, as, with his brother John, he endeavours to entrap his Lord into the promise of granting a boon, the nature of which he would fain conceal till the promise is made—"We would that thou shouldst do for us whatsoever we shall desire." We meet him again on Mount Olivet with three other disciples, fixed in rapt attention as Christ dimly shadows out the future. He listens! Jerusalem becomes bathed in blood, and a storm of tribulation falls on Israel, till the nation is swept away by the swift torrent of wrath: the vision melts into the awful outline of the judgment day; he catches the sound of the last trumpet, and sees the light from afar which heralds the coming of the Son of Man: then, as the Master's words narrow to a personal application, "Be ye also ready," the absent look gives way to an expression of serious self-conscious anxiety. To-morrow night is to be the last spent with the Master before the accomplishment of the tragedy, so often, yet so mysteriously hinted at. Sorrowful premonitions steal over him, apprehensions which are to reach their overwhelming realisation when, after the Last Supper, he, with Peter and John, are conducted beyond the gate of the garden, where the other disciples are left, into the dark shades of Gothsemaue, shades less gloomy than those which evidently enwrap the spirit of their Lord. While the Saviour agonizes, the watching disciples, overborne with sorrow, surrender to the influence of sleep, nor can we wonder at this effect of the unnatural strain on mind and body of that week of alternate joy and foreboding. "Sleep on now

and take your rest, behold he is at hand that doth betray me." Slumbering there with his companions while Christ wrestles alone for his and the world's salvation, we leave this apostle, to meet with no further special mention of him till after the tragedy is passed and the Risen One has interpreted the enigma of the cross: then we recognize him among the seven plying their craft on the lake of Galileo while they wait for Christ's appearance, and partaking in the grey morning of the meal provided by him on the shore. At this interview Peter and John have each their special word, but James, though one of the first three, is not yet singled out for this favour. Another glimpse of him, however, before the closing scene of his life, concentrates in itself an interest resembling that which surrounds the post-resurrection interview with Peter: it is the event alluded to by Paul in the words, "After that he was seen of James." Opinion is divided as to which of the three of the name is here indicated. It is argued that since the son of Zebedeo was dead at the time Paul wrote, the allusion cannot be to him, the plain mention of the name without other note, implying the person to be not only known but living: we see little force in this reasoning: prominent men are often spoken of after death by name only. It is urged that either James, the son of Alphæus, being a cousin of the Lord, or James, "the Lord's brother," as destined to preside over the church at Jerusalem, was the favoured one. To our mind the preponderance of evidence leaus to the son of Zebedeo. He was the chief of the Jameses, and in the absence of more particular information, the name may reasonably be supposed to represent him. He was one of the trio privileged to be the closest attendants of Christ, and might therefore be expected to enjoy such an honour, yet, unless he was the subject of this interview, he lacked the distinction bestowed on his friends. An event awaited him which would make this special favour appropriate. To the other two of the "first three" Christ revealed the manner of their death, but not to the third, unless our present conjecture be the truth: yet he was to be the first to die, to die, moreover, a martyr's death. His early removal would afford a fitting reason why Christ should endow him with peculiar strength, and the existence of such a reason for bracing him for the future was cause enough why Christ should do it. As the Lord appeared to Peter because of his recent fall, so to James because of his prospective martyrdom. Christ had already forewarned him that he was to drink of his cup: the disciple understood him not at that time, but after he had seen the bitter draught placed to his Master's lips the prophecy might be repeated with more hope of its being comprehended. We may guess at the subjects of the Saviour's communication. According to his manner, he would unveil to the disciple the meaning of the enigma "You shall drink of my cup." He would say many things to him which, before his death and resurrection, James was unable to bear; and who shall tell what strength for labour and for martyrdom the disciple received in that hour of communication with his risen Lord? It was the ninth appearance of Christ; only one other remained, when he should lead the eleven as far as to Bethany, and in the act of benediction be parted from them and received up into heaven. James was present at the prayer-meeting which linked together two of the grandest events in the history of the church, the ascension of Christ, and the descent of the Holy Spirit; and who more serious and prayerful than the disciple whose mind was pervaded with the expectation of early death? During the stormy period which witnessed the frequent imprisonment of the apostles, the stoning of Stephen, and the persecuting mission of Saul we read nothing of James for eleven years, until A.D. 44. Then his blood stains the page. Herod Agrippa, who soon after miserably died at Cæsarea, and who was the father of him whom Paul almost persuaded to be a Christian, added to his crimes the murder of this apostle. "About that time Herod the king stretched forth his hands to vex certain of the church: and he killed James, the brother of John, with the sword." The blood-stained path to glory had been inaugurated by Stephen; the deacon is worthily followed by the apostle. The second in the noble army of martyrs, he is the first from the apostolic ranks. Earliest of the

39

clown to be seized, he must have occupied no rear position in those ranks; nor was that life an ineffective one, the destruction of which was felt by the hostile party to be a relief; "it pleased the Jews." John survived him more than fifty years, "tarrying till Christ came," while the elder brother was thus violently despatched to the beatific presence by the hand of miscalculating fury. Prematurely? Nay! The premature death of a disciple of Christ is impossible.

Of James the son of Alphæus little is said in Scripture. His name first occurs in the catalogue of the apostles ordained after the night spent in prayer by our Lord in the second year of his ministry. He was already at that time like the rest of the twelve, a disciple as implied by the words of Luke (iv. 13), "He called unto him his disciples; and of them he chose twelve, whom also he named apostles." A supposition that he was Christ's cousin has been based upon John xix. 25. "There stood by the cross of Jesus his mother, and his mother's sister, Mary the wife of Cleophas and Mary Magdalene;" understanding three women and not four to be mentioned, and supposing Cleophas to be the same with Alphæus. Passing by the singularity this would involve of two sisters bearing the same name, we observe that Matthew and Mark, each omitting the mother of our Lord, mention three women at the cross. To these John adds Christ's mother, the name of whose sister, omitted by him must be looked for amongst the three of Matthew and Mark; the missing name, according to Mark, is Salome, and she, according to Matthew, is the mother of Zebedee's children. James and John, therefore, are shown to be the cousins of our Lord; and James the son of Alphæus does not appear to have sustained any family relationship to him. Of his personal appearance Mark gives an interesting note, calling him (ch. xv. 40) "James the little," to distinguish this short apostle from his taller namesake, the son of Zebedee. After the Pentecostal prayer-meeting we read no more of the son of Alphæus, nor does tradition throw any additional light on his after life.

A more prominent part was played by James, the Lord's brother. Though not of the number of the twelve, he appears, nevertheless, to have occupied a position of great consideration in the early church, and to have been regarded with deference equal to that paid to the apostles themselves. In writing of him, however, it becomes our first duty to demonstrate his existence by distinguishing him from the son of Alphæus, with whom he has been confounded, under the mistaken idea that the latter was the Lord's cousin, and that this remoter relationship is the one intended whenever mention is made of the brethren of Christ. There is none but superstitious ground for supposing Mary to have had no children after the birth of Christ, while the plain and repeated references to the brethren and sisters of our Lord leave no room for question in our unprejudiced mind. Matt xiii. 55, 56; Mark vi. 3; Acts i. 14; Gal. i. 19; 1 Cor. ix. 5. They are mentioned in the same sentence with his disciples, and distinguished from them. John ii. 12. At a time subsequent to the ordination of the twelve apostles, among whom James the son of Alphæus is named, it is said that Christ's brethren did not believe in him. John vii. 5. In the prayer-meeting which preceded Pentecost Luke enumerates the apostles by name, among whom, as usual, he mentions the son of Alphæus and adds, "These all continued in prayer and supplication with the women, and Mary the mother of Jesus, and with his brethren." This is sufficient to prove the existence of brethren of Christ not included in the discipleship during his lifetime, though found amongst his adherents after the ascension. Of these the chief was James, whom Paul designates "the Lord's brother." During the Lord's ministry James seems to have shared his brethren's disbelief of Christ's messiahship, and the importance of his claims, which led them to challenge him to the public life which would be involved if those claims were true. "If thou do these things show thyself to the world, for neither did his brethren believe in him." It is not for us to compute the evidence which led them afterwards to accept with reverence both the Messiahship and the Deity of their mysterious Brother, nor to conjecture how much the crucifixion and the

resurrection contributed to their conversion to the faith; but we have to record that immediately after these great events they, as believers, are found with their mother amongst the disciples of Jesus waiting for the descent of the Holy Spirit.

James first comes out into individual distinctness at the interview with Paul, mentioned in Gal. i. 19, on his visit to Jerusalem three years after his conversion. At Jerusalem, six years later, his position in the church ensured to him the first official knowledge of Peter's release from imprisonment. "Go," said Peter to the praying company in the house of Mark's mother, "show these things to James and to the brethren." Acts xii. 17. In the great church meeting at Jerusalem called to consider the relationship of the Gentiles to the Mosaic law, it is James the Lord's brother who presides, as is clear from Acts xv. read in the light of the first and second chapters of Galatians. He, with the elders of the church, received Paul and his company on his last journey to Jerusalem, recorded in Acts xxi. 18, and counselled the conciliatory measures of Paul, which became the pretext for the tumultuous riot in the Temple court, from which Lysias rescued him. There is little doubt that the epistle of James was written by the Lord's brother. It bears the impress of his more Jewish view of the gospel, a view which pre-eminently fitted him to be the pastor of the church in Jerusalem. It is a sententious and weighty exposition of the practical side of Christianity, and in many passages strongly calls to mind the Sermon on the Mount. He is said to have been martyred by being thrown from a pinnacle of the temple, stoned, and then dispatched by a blow on the head with a fuller's pole. His noble title, "The Just," was earned by the strictness of his life, and evidently belongs to the man who could write the Epistle of James.

The three Jameses may, therefore, be thus broadly distinguished: the son of Zebedee is for the most part the James of the gospels; the son of Alphmus is scarcely mentioned except in the catalogues; and the Lord's brother is the hero of most of the references to the name in the Acts of the Apostles, and is also the writer of the epistle which bears the name.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate