Menu
‹ Chapter 57 of 220 ›

On Objections to joining the Church — A Fireside Homily, By Vernon J. Charlesworth

15 min read · Chapter 57 of 220

THERE are many pious persons who are not identified with any

assembly of the Lord's people. That they are resting for salva-

tion upon the finished work of the Lord Jesus Christ, that they cherish

a refreshing sense of God's pardoning love, that they are heirs of an

inheritance in the skies, and that their outward lives are, for the most

part, regulated according to the Divine will, admit of no doubt what-

ever, and yet they hold aloof from those who share with them such

glorious blessings. Although they are guilty of a strange inconsistency,

they are perhaps sincere in the course they have taken; but while they

are to be commended for their sincerity, their inconsistency is not to be

excused. If my reader is living a Christian life without professing

fellowship with the people of the Lord, let me beg his earnest attention

to the following answers to the objections we have heard against be-

coming what is popularly called a member of a church.

1. Many true Christians fail to identify themselves with the Lord's

people because they say it is such a solemn thing to join the Church!

This objection is based upon a misunderstanding of the true nature of

the Church of God. In the language of the New Testament, the

Church is the aggregate of saved persons. We are not only saved when

we believe in the Lord Jesus Christ, but we are "baptized by one

Spirit into one body." True believers constitute this body, and no

believer is contemplated by God as a solitary unit, for the Church, in

the mind of God, is a living unity. There is a wondrous inter-relation

of being, between the Lord Jesus Christ as Head, and all true be-

lievers who constitute his mystical body. There is no such thing as

being saved, apart from a vital connection with this grand unity.

* Hoping that this homily may prove useful and seasonable, we have issued it as

a little book. Price one halfpenny, or 3s. per hundred. Passmore and Alabaster,

4, Paternoster-buildings, E.C.

Now, every company of Christians, meeting together in any place whatsoever for worship, is the local expression of this unity. We call it a Church, but in reality it is only the local expression of "the Holy Church throughout all the world." The true Church is the unity of the entire company of believers, and each assembly is the local expression of this fact. No assembly, then, and no aggregate of assemblies short of the whole, can claim to be exclusively "the Church." The Church is broader than the sects, and embraces all who are united to the Lord Jesus Christ in life, liberty, and love. This truth has been overlooked in the zeal of party strifes. Many have shut themselves up to the circle of their own narrow views, and have looked upon all as excluded from the Church who are living beyond their self-defined boundary. It is pitiable to think that men should thus pretend to limit God. It is wicked to make and perpetuate schism upon the ground of difference of opinion. We must contemplate the Church from the Divine standpoint, and view it in all the comprehensiveness of the Divine idea!

If, then, the Lord regards the Church as a corporate body, and the Holy Spirit, dwelling in every believer, really unites us to this body, then you will see it is not optional with us, whether or not we avow the fact. Failure to identify ourselves with the assembly of saints is a contravention of Divine order, and is a guilty resistance of the Spirit of God. It is not enough that we are saved individually, we must "not forsake the assembling of ourselves together," for the Church of God can only be seen to exist in the world by the association of those who name the name of Jesus.

Now, it will be seen that the popular term "joining the Church" is not strictly correct. A man cannot be a Christian without having been joined to the Church of God by the baptism of the Spirit. If, then, a true believer in Jesus is already a member of the Church, the profession of the fact is not the awful thing many imagine.

2. Others admit the duty of publicly professing their identity with the Church of God, but do not feel the necessity of immediate action. Their excuse is that they "will wait a little longer." Now, while we object most strongly to any one outwardly uniting with the people of God as a worshipper, unless first united to the Lord as a saint, we equally object to a saint refusing to come forward as a worshipper. There should be much heart-searching before the Lord, and this may occasion a little delay, but delay should not be allowed to issue in procrastination. What is more natural than for Christians in the ardour of their first love to come forward and declare their decision for Christ before the Church and the world? It is a lamentable fact that thousands of Christians allow year after year to glide away, leaving them still outside the visible fold. They cannot altogether reconcile their delay with their sense of duty, and yet they still urge the idle plea that they "will wait a little longer."

If my reader is a member of this class, let me counsel a speedy decision. Let conviction of duty pass into resolution, and let your resolution lead to immediate action. Remember, "Procrastination is the thief of time."

Many of the people of God have bitterly regretted in old age, or on a

155

dying bed, that their best years were allowed to pass away without their becoming identified with the assembly of saints by the enrolment of their names, and by associating in loving fellowship with their fellow believers for the work and worship of God.

3. Again, it is asked, "What are the advantages of church fellowship?" You say you can unite now in the worship of God—you can meet with his people in social converse and public service, and what more can you secure? That you have no pew rents to pay for the support of the minister, and are not pledged to contribute to any enterprise to which the church is committed.

Now, while admitting that the mere record of your name in the Church register will not really unite you more closely to the Lord than you are at present through a living faith in the Lord Jesus Christ, we affirm that there is an immense satisfaction to one's own mind in the bond of fraternity to which we publicly subscribe. A child is no less a child because he keeps his relationship to his father's family a profound secret, but he acts an unfilial part; and the refusal of a child of God to avow before the world the fact of his relationship to the Divine family, does not unchristianize him, but it is an unworthy part to play.

Again, the fact of your identity with an assembly of God's people would furnish a most important check to the spirit of worldliness into which all are so prone to fall. A Christian in church fellowship feels, or ought to feel, that the slightest deviation from the path of rectitude not only injures his own reputation, but compromises others and injures the whole body corporate; and, as we are human, such a check as this is of the most salutary nature. Then, fellowship with the people of God secures the most blessed sympathy. The fellowship of saints is not maintained merely that we may listen to the instruction of a duly gifted pastor, and present the sacrifice of praise and prayer to our heavenly Father, but that mutual sympathy may be encouraged and manifested. We are commanded to "bear one another's burdens and so fulfil the law of Christ." It must be admitted that we fall very far below the standard fixed in the New Testament, and which was attained by the local assembly at Jerusalem shortly after Pentecost, when we are told "the multitude of them that believed were of one heart and one soul, neither said any of them that aught of the things which he possessed was his own, but they had all things common." No doubt to those who have but little of the "mind of Christ" this seems Utopian, and in these days when the most popular creed is expressed in the syllable "GET," it is regarded as the dream of enthusiasts, but, depend upon it, the Church signally fails in duty unless the members are bound together by the bond of sympathy, and "live not unto themselves, but unto Him who died for them and rose again." As individuals we are able to labour for the Lord, but in fellowship with others we increase our usefulness.

Another advantage is that our growth in grace is assisted. It is incumbent upon Church members to "edify one another in love." Faith is strengthened, love increased, and our zeal for Christ stimulated by fellowship with each other. The uniform testimony of Christians is that they are assisted in their heavenward walk by union in Church-fellowship with their fellow believers.

But, supposing you feel that you have no necessity to unite with the assembly of saints to secure these advantages, remember there are tens of thousands who crave for them, and, perhaps, the influence of your example is deterring some from coming forward to enjoy them. If you are a parent, you may thus inflict a permanent injury upon your children who are rising into manhood and womanhood. Their piety would be fostered and their spiritual life developed and matured if they enjoyed these advantages, but your example sanctions their delay. Or if you are a master, those in your employ are influenced by your example, and they feel justified in pleading your conduct as an excuse. Now, if you can rise superior to these advantages, they cannot, and for their sakes your decision should be prompt.

4. Another objection which is urged and which may have influenced my reader is, "I see so much inconsistency in those who are Church members." Alas! all must plead guilty, we suppose, to some inconsistencies, greater or smaller. "There is none that doeth good and sinneth not." It is said of the late Dr. James Hamilton that "he has left no heaven-lier soul behind him," but he would have confessed with the disciple whom Jesus loved, "If we say that we have no sin we deceive ourselves." We do not urge this to justify inconsistencies in the lives of professors, but to show that the Church is not composed of sinless persons; and that if we stand aloof from the public assembly of saints until we see absolute perfection in all its members, we shall have to wait until we join the Church of the First-born above. It is deeply to be deplored that all who name the name of Christ do not depart from iniquity, and are not sufficiently careful to maintain good works, but we must never plead the delinquencies of others in justification of our own neglect of duty.

Besides, if we are convinced that the Church fails in testimony to the world because of the inconsistencies of its members, is it not all the more incumbent upon us to endeavour to show them a more excellent way, and, by the influence of our saintly lives, to rebuke, if not correct their faults? But I would ask, do those who demand the strictest consistency between the profession and lives of others detect no inconsistencies in themselves? Are they without sin? Do they not judge others by a standard they dare not apply to themselves, demand more than they themselves are able to render, and withhold that charity from an erring brother which they feel they need? If my reader has been influenced by this spirit, let me counsel charity and forbearance. Do not neglect a duty by pleading the failures of others, but declare yourself openly to be on the Lord's side.

5. Then, again, it is urged that salvation does not depend upon our communion with the Church, and that many eminent Christians are not members of any particular assembly. This is true. He who seeks, by being publicly identified with the Church, a passport to heaven, is doomed to be disappointed, and he who refuses to be so identified, because it is not necessary to salvation, urges an idle plea. We must identify ourselves with the Church by a public profession, not to secure salvation, but because we are saved, and because church membership, though not necessary to salvation, is very helpful to the development of our piety.

157

The conduct of many eminent Christians, in refusing a public profession, does not justify your disobedience. If you can point to ten thousand eminent Christians who are not united to the church, this does not release you from your duty: their neglect of duty rather constitutes an argument for the immediate performance of yours. If the influence of so many is lost we should be anxious not to extend the number, but to exert ourselves the more earnestly to supply their lack. It is something worse than idle to plead the disobedience of others in justification of our own; were this plea allowed, the whole system of morals would be destroyed. In the determination of our duty we must not be influenced by an appeal to the conduct of others. To our own master we stand or fall.

6. Many are deterred from publicly uniting with the people of God for fear they shall fall away! The dread thought haunts them continually that they shall become castaways—it flings a dark shadow across their hearts, and disturbs their joy and peace. Now, those who withhold a profession and neglect a duty under the fear of falling and proving castaways, take the likeliest means of securing what they deprecate. The conscious performance of duty would dissipate such a fear as this.

But what is meant by becoming a castaway? The word castaway occurs in the ninth chapter of St. Paul's first epistle to the Corinthians. The metaphors of the passage are drawn from the Olympic Race. The apostle urges the Corinthians to run for an incorruptible crown—mark! not for salvation—not for eternal life, not for heaven, but for a CROWN. They had life, but there was a crown to be won for unwavering fidelity and persistent service. He says, "so run that ye may obtain." And to encourage them, he adds, "I therefore so run—I keep under my body and bring it into subjection, lest that by any means when I have preached to others I myself should be a castaway." The apostle was influenced by the salutary fear lest "after having been a herald to others, he himself should be disapproved of." This is a correct reading of the passage, and strips it of all its terror.

You will remember that it was the fear of losing his lord's money which led the servant of the parable to hide his talents in the napkin. Instead of commending him for his caution, his lord censured and condemned him for the neglect of duty. Fear of failure is right when it induces a spirit of watchfulness; it is wrong when it paralyzes effort and leads to the neglect of duty. If the reader belongs to this class, we would commend to him that noble resolution of the Psalmist, "what time I am afraid I will trust in thee," and urge the still nobler resolution of the prophet—"I will trust, and not be afraid!"

7. Many remain outside the pale of the visible church because of their objection to the ordinance of believers' baptism. Some contend that the baptism of the Spirit is sufficient, others urge that the mode of water baptism is unimportant. Many of the most estimable people of our acquaintance have lingered at the threshold of the visible church for years, and justify their conduct by an appeal to the above pleas.

We would ask these simple questions with an emphasis which the importance of the subject demands—Is water baptism a Christian ordinance? Is it implied, by the terms of the apostolic commission, that

it was intended for all disciples? Does the uniform practice of the apostles indicate that they so understood it? Let anyone take the New Testament, and, discarding all ecclesiastical traditions, endeavour to answer these questions, and we venture to affirm that he will come to the conclusion that baptism by immersion was appointed by the Lord Jesus Christ, that believers uniformly submitted to it, that the apostles administered it as one of the sacred functions of their office, and that it was regarded as an avowal and a recognition of Christian discipleship.

But it is urged by many, we were baptized as infants, is that to be ignored as of no account? This is, perhaps, best answered by the following questions:—Were you a voluntary, or even a conscious, party to the ordinance? Was it not impossible for you, as a condition of your, so-called, baptism not only to make a profession of faith, but even to exercise faith in the Lord Jesus Christ? What validity, then, can there be in an ordinance to which you were an unconscious party, and the divinely appointed conditions of which it was impossible for you to fulfil?

To those who contend that water baptism was only an initial ordinance of the Christian dispensation, and was not designed to be permanent in its obligation, we have simply to say—refer us to the text in which its limits are determined.

It is not within the scope of the present paper to discuss the fourfold ground on which, it is contended, infant baptism rests; we may recur to this anon. Our present purpose is to show that the baptism of believers by immersion is an ordinance of divine appointment, and is commanded as a preliminary to the public recognition of believers as disciples of Christ.

8. And now, in the last place, let me say a word to those who are deterred from church fellowship from a fear to eat and drink the bread and wine of the Lord's Supper unworthily. If it be a sin to eat and drink unworthily, it is, also, a sin to refuse to commune in the Lord's Supper from fear. If the fear were allowable in your case, it would be allowable in the case of others, and then there would be no table at all; and the whole Church would be guilty of disobeying the plain command of the Lord Jesus Christ—"This do in remembrance of me." The eating and drinking unworthily doubtless referred to the conduct of the Corinthians, who regarded the Lord's Supper as an ordinary meal, and partook of it in a most irreverent manner. "They did not discern the Lord's Body," but partook of the symbols of the "Body and Blood of Christ" as though they were bread and wine for ordinary use. They were thus guilty of slighting the sacrifice of Jesus which these elements symbolized. The words "guilty of the Body and Blood of Christ" do not imply that these Corinthian Christians were as guilty of the death of Christ as were his actual murderers, but their offence, whatever it was, was committed against the Body and Blood of Christ.

The word "damnation" here means judgment; and the judgment visited upon these people was very severe indeed. "For this cause," says the Apostle, i.e., for eating and drinking unworthily, "many are weak and sickly among you," i.e., are bodily afflicted, "and many sleep," i.e., are dead. Not that those who had died had perished, for the Apostle adds, "If we would judge ourselves, we should not be judged; but when we are judged, we are chastened of the Lord, that

159

we should not be condemned with the world." Read 1 Corinthians xi. 18-34.

But why should we eat and drink unworthily? Can we not come with our hearts rightly affected towards the Lord Jesus Christ, and discern in the bread and wine fit symbols of His broken body and shed blood? Can we not come mourning that so much evil lurks within us, and seek for grace to crucify the flesh with its affections and lusts? Can we not come in the spirit of reverent humility to worship the Father, and to hold communion with each other? Believe me, if we come thus, we shall not eat and drink unworthily, and to us the Saviour says, "Eat, O friends! Drink, yea, drink abundantly, O beloved!"

But, still, you urge that you feel your own unworthiness. Be it so. This excuse may be innocent; but it savours more of self-righteousness than humility. The moment you feel worthy because of any goodness you may discover in yourself, that moment God must pronounce you unworthy. Did you go to Christ for salvation because you felt yourself worthy of it, or was your plea your deep necessity, your own unworthiness, and Christ's abounding mercy? Self-worthiness is no more the ground of church communion than of access to Christ for salvation. If all Christians held aloof from each other until each felt worthy of the honour, there would be no visible Church on earth. They are unworthy who still cling to their lusts, and are living in known sin, or who pride themselves in their own goodness: but they are worthy (in the Scriptural sense) who, in full reliance upon the atoning merits of the death of Jesus, are striving to "live soberly, righteously, and godly in this present world." In dealing with the above objections, we have endeavoured to reach the conclusion—That it is the imperative duty of all who are saved by virtue of their union with the Lord Jesus Christ, who "is the head of the body, the church," to avow the fact by an honest profession, and by obedience to his command to enter into sincere and hearty fellowship, that the unity of the Church may be apparent, and the worship and work of the Lord maintained in the world.

But if you are holding back from Church fellowship because you are holding back from Christ, we would urge the immediate acceptance of pardon. Jesus says to you, "Come unto me, and I will give you rest." Your first duty is to give yourself to the Lord, and then to his Church, by the will of God.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate