The Catacombs and the Early Christians
THE catacombs of Rome constitute the most ancient Christian cemetery in the world, as well as the most extensive; for the mysterious caverns, whose origin no historian has been able to explain, have probably served for the sepulture of a multitude as great as that which crowds our British capital in the present day. The historical interest naturally attaching itself to these cheerless retreats of the primitive Christians is heightened by the obscurity enveloping the life and death of the nameless architects whose industry and ingenuity are seen in passages, galleries, and chambers extending for hundreds of miles through the underground solitude. This vast city of the dead has never been completely explored, perhaps it never will be; but what has already been read in these hidden depths makes up as complete a chain of evidence against the semi-Pagan rites of the apostate church of Rome as any evangelical believer in the gospel need wish to possess. There, at any rate, we look in vain for any inscriptions pointing to apostolical succession or to the follies of a sensuous ritual. There was no pope in those days; the myriads who lie in their quiet resting-places were simple believers in the atoning sacrifice of the Son of God; and, could they suddenly arise from their sepulchre to witness one of the ornate services at St. Peter's, they would confound the antics of priests and cardinals with the heathen mummeries of their old Roman persecutors.
The observant visitor to the Catacombs cannot fail to be struck with the fact that a large proportion of the tombs in the walls, ranged one above another, are those of children who were mercifully taken hence before they could experience the bitterness of the persecution which swept their parents into the grave. The inscriptions on others tell a different story, revealing the horror harboured by members of the ancient church relative to having their bones disturbed:—"I conjure you by Christ," says one, "that no violence be offered me by anyone, and that my sepulchre may not be violated;" and again, "I conjure you by the dreadful day of judgment that no one violate this sepulchre." Such are the dungeons which the persecuted people called "God's Cabinet." Here and there the excavations are said to be of Jewish origin, and to have been called by them "the house of the living:" but this is little better than a plausible conjecture. To us the Catacombs are pre-eminently God's acre—the ancient burial-ground of the saints who passed through much tribulation into their eternal home. The truth is that the modern tourist who to-day halts at the Italian capital looks, as it were, on three Romes. Beneath the dome of the Pantheon, amid the remains of the Appian Way, among the imposing ruins of the Colosseum, he looks on the Pagan city. In the services of the so-called Catholic Church, in the crowd of priests, friars, and citizens, who are slowly casting off the degradation engendered by superstition, he sees the Rome of the papal apostasy. But beneath, in the perilous maze, where midnight seems to reign supreme at noon, we feel that we are in the very heart of a Christian camp, a cemetery where the dust of Paul
* The Catacombs of Rome and their Testimony Relative to Primitive Christianity. By W. H. Withrow, M.A. London: Hodder and Stoughton, 27, Paternoster Row.
may possibly mingle with that of more humble veterans who were faithful throughout life and conquerors in death.
Abounding in interest as they do, we should not like to recommend either ailing or nervous persons to undertake the exploration of these subterranean streets. Their hearts would fail them for fear before reaching the bottom step of the stairway entrance. "The awful silence and almost palpable darkness of these deepest dungeons are absolutely appalling. They are fitly described by the epithet applied by Dante to the realms of eternal gloom—a spot mute of all light. Here death reigns supreme. Not even so much as a lizard or a bat has penetrated into these obscure recesses. Nought but skulls and skeletons, dust and ashes, are on every side. The air is impure and deadly, and difficult to breathe. 'The cursed dew of the dungeon damp' distils from the walls, and a sense of oppression, like the patriarch's 'horror of great darkness' broods over the scene."
When a schoolboy at Rome, about fourteen hundred years ago, Jerome tells us that he made a regular Sabbath pastime of visiting the catacombs. "So intense is the darkness," he says, "as to seemingly fulfil the words of the prophet, 'They go down alive to hades.' Here and there is light let in to mitigate the gloom. As we advance the words of the poet are brought to mind: 'Horror on all sides; the very silence fills the soul with dread.' Since the distant day in which Jerome wrote, time has greatly altered the general aspect of the Catacombs. Water, the forces of nature, and the destructive hands of man, have also done their part in aiding the work of devastation. "The rifled graves and broken tablets show where piety or superstition has removed the relics of the dead, or where idle curiosity has wantonly mutilated their monuments."
Determined explorers of these wonderful labyrinths have from time to time incurred considerable risk while following their fascinating occupation. With a light in one hand and an unwinding thread in the other, M. Roberts, an enthusiastic art student, once nearly forfeited his life while absorbed in the study of the sculptured walls. Unobserved the thread dropped from his hand, and while he searched for the precious line on which life depended the light went out, and completed his calamity. Amid the horrid darkness of the tomb, and the silence of death, he shouted with wild vehemence, "but the hollow echoes mocked his voice." At length, with despair chilling his heart, he sunk on to the floor, when to his indescribable relief he felt the missing cord, which guided him to light and life.
An incident also occurred at the close of the last century, and after the French Revolution, which should carry its lesson of warning to hardened sinners of to-day. A number of French military officers, who served under General Berthier, and who professed the atheistic principles of Voltaire and his school, once visited the Catacombs in a party:—
"They caroused in the sepulchral crypts, and sang their bacchanalian songs among the Christian dead. They rifled the graves and committed sacrilege at the tombs of the saints. One of the number, a reckless young cavalry officer, 'who feared not God nor devil, for he believed in neither,' resolved to explore the remoter galleries. He was speedily lost and abandoned by his companions. His excited imagination heightened
73
the natural horrors of the scene. The grim and ghastly skeletons seemed an army of accusing spectres. Down the long corridors the wind mysteriously whispered, rising in inarticulate moanings and woeful sighs, as of souls in pain. The tones of the neighbouring convent bell, echoing through the stony vaults, sounded loud and awful as the knell of doom. Groping blindly in the dark he touched nothing but rocky walls or mouldering bones, that sent a thrill of horror through his frame. Though but a thin roof separated him from the bright sunshine and free air, he seemed condemned to living burial. His philosophical scepticism failed him in this hour of peril. He could no longer scoff at death as un sommeil eternal. The palimpsest of memory recalled with intensest vividness the Christian teachings of his childhood. His soul became filled and penetrated with a solemn awe. His physical powers gave way beneath the intensity of his emotion. He was rescued the next day, but was long ill. He rose from his bed an altered man. His life was henceforth serious and devout. When killed in battle in Calabria, seven years after, a copy of the gospels was found next his heart."
Other adventurers have entered the fatal maze to be totally lost, without any trace of their remains ever having been discovered. About forty years ago a party of more than a dozen students, accompanied by their tutor, purposed spending a pleasant, profitable holiday among the sepulchres of the saints. They entered by a now inaccessible passage, wandered on and on never to be heard of again. They were carefully sought, but not the slightest trace of them could be discovered.
Even Antonio Bosio, the most industrious and persevering explorer of the Catacombs of whom we have any record, was several times nearly lost in that underground world, whose gloom was to him more congenial than open day, and in the mysterious recesses of which he spent half a long life at the end of the sixteenth and the beginning of the seventeenth centuries. His enthusiasm knew of no restraints, while he laughed at difficulty and was never cowed by hardship. He was satisfied with the fare and lodging of a hermit, his heart leaping for joy when he came upon "pictures bright with the colours of yesterday, and characters still sharp and angular from the primeval graving tool." Bosio's life-work was the examination of the Catacombs, and he was cut down by death while engaged in preparing the concluding portion of his bulky posthumous work, "Subterranean Rome."
Though the Catacombs became in time a place of secret burial, and of comparatively safe retreat to the primitive Christians, it was not so at the beginning. For some years, and while the apostle Paul lived in his own hired house at Rome, there was no need of secrecy. It became otherwise after the accession of Nero, who as a craven-hearted coward delighted in cruelty like a wild beast. During the reign of Nero the followers of Christ largely increased; they were found in all ranks and conditions. It was noticed that persons of the best quality embraced the faith, and those who held the reins of power began to grow concerned if not alarmed. Nero himself would not have hesitated to receive a share of divine honours in the Pantheon; but while the plebs might shout their blasphemous flattery the Christians behaved like men.
"These carefully refrained from the idolatrous adulation by which the servile mob were wont to express their loyalty to the imperial monster who aspired to be a god. Hence they were accused of disaffection, of treason. They were the enemies of Caesar and of the Roman people. They were supposed to exercise a malign influence on the course of nature. If it did not rain the Christians were to blame. 'If the Tiber overflows its banks,' says Tertullian, 'or the Nile does not; if there be drought or earthquake, famine or pestilence, the cry is raised, The Christians to the lions.' If the pecking of the sacred chickens, or the entrails of the sacrificial victims gave unfavourable omens, it was attributed to the counter spell of 'the Atheists.' At Rome, as well as at Ephesus and Philippi, the selfish fears of the shrine and image makers, whose craft was in danger, and the hostility of the priests and dependents on the idol-worship, inspired or intensified the opposition to Christianity, as did also the jealousy of the Jews, who regarded with repressed hostility the believers in the lowly Nazarene, whom their fathers with wicked hands had crucified and slain."
When Nero perceived he was becoming unpopular, in consequence of the terrible conflagration which he himself was supposed to have instigated, he found it conveniently easy to fan the flame of fanaticism against the Christians and to lay his own crimes on the shoulders of the followers of Christ. The church was assailed with a fury and cruelty which would have threatened its extinction had not even adversity been overruled for good by an omnipotent Lord. Men and women were murdered with all the fiendish cruelty that a civilized paganism could invent, if indeed a people may be called civilized while living beneath a degrading idolatry. In spite of the assertions of Gibbon to the contrary, the Christians were seized and slain in surprising numbers, the majority of the martyrs having been interred in the Catacombs. The nature of their sufferings is described by Tacitus. They were openly mocked and insulted by infuriated crowds. Enveloped in the skins of animals they were made sport for dogs. Others, like their Lord, were crucified; while some were wrapped in sheets of pitch to be burned as torches in the emperor's gardens. Still the church grew in grace, and being founded on the Rock of Ages she was a house that could not be shaken. It was a terrible sifting time, and there many apostates; but it proved, as it always has done in subsequent years, that days of trial were days of strength.
For more than two centuries after the death of Nero the church experienced seasons of rest or of suffering according to the character and predilections of the man who for the time being might be wearing the imperial purple. Such incidents as the following occurred towards the middle of the third century:—
"Stephen, as the head of the Christian community, was especially obnoxious to heathen rage. According to the Acts of his martyrdom, he sought concealment in these sepulchral crypts, where he was secretly visited by the faithful, and where he administered the sacraments. He was traced by the Roman soldiers to his subterranean chapel, but awed by the mysterious rites, they allowed him to conclude the service in which he was engaged. He was then beheaded, with several of his adherents, and buried in the Catacombs."
75
"Sixtus, the successor of Stephen, within a year received the martyr's crown. Like another Daniel, setting at defiance the emperor's decree, he was leading the devotions of the persecuted flock in the catacomb of Prætextatus, probably because it was less known than the public cemetery at Callixtus, when he was apprehended by the fierce soldiery, who had tracked his footsteps thither. He was hurried away to summary judgment, brought back to the place of his offence, and there beheaded, sprinkling with his blood the walls of the chamber. With him were also executed four of his deacons, the monuments of two of whom, Agapetus and Felicissimus, De Rossi discovered in the very catacomb in which they suffered."
In the same terrible third century no less than seven pastors of the church at Rome perished successively by the hands of the public executioners. It is a remarkable historical fact that a number of the emperors who promoted the extermination of the Christians, themselves died most miserable deaths. Nero and Diocletian committed suicide, the last having been in his last days the victim of tormenting maladies. "During the reign of Aurelius, war, famine, and pestilence wasted the land. Decius perished miserably in a marsh, and his body became the prey of the prowling jackal and unclean buzzard. Valerian, captured by the Persians, after having served as a footstool to his haughty foe, is said to have been flayed alive and his skin stuffed with straw. Aurelian was slain by the hand of a trusted servant, and Carinus by the dagger of a husband whom he had irreparably wronged." All these things were noted by the suffering Christians, and were by them interpreted as the judgments of God.
After Christianity became the recognised religion of the state, the Catacombs were less used as a cemetery, and interments in their depths appear to have ceased at the beginning of the fifteenth century, when "the blast of the Gothic trumpet, startling the ear of midnight in the streets of Rome, proclaimed its capture by the hosts of the stern Alaric." About three centuries later, when the former hostility of Rome to Christian worship was changed for superstitious homage of all relics, the graves were rifled by a troop of ecclesiastical vandals, and their contents carried into the vaults of churches in the city. In the succeeding dark ages the Catacombs became more and more neglected, were forgotten, or unknown, except to a few bands of political conspirators, who would hold their councils in the secret depths. We are told that "the rediscovery of this subterranean city took place in the year 1578. Some labourers digging pazzolana in a vineyard on the Salarian Way, came suddenly on an ancient cemetery with its paintings, inscriptions, sarcophagi, and graves. The event produced a profound sensation in Rome. The city was amazed, says Baronius, who himself examined and described the newly-discovered Catacombs, at finding beneath her suburbs long concealed Christian colonies."
The study of the catacombs thus recommenced was continued after the Reformation, and with the best results, though the Popish apostasy neither then nor since manifested any disposition to heed the striking testimony against her innovating mummeries, which may be read in hundreds of miles of passages. Still individuals may have seen the truth, and a memorable example of its ready acceptance occurred in
the case of Mr. Hemans, who studied and wrote upon the subject of Sacred Art in Italy. He left the Established Church of England to enter the Romish communion; but having learned what the Catacombs could tell him of the simple faith and practices of the primitive Christians, he renounced Popery and returned to the Protestant camp.
The Catacombs testify against the heresies of Rome; they also present us with a fine epitome of Christian thought and practice as contrasted with the contemporary heathen customs. It may be doubted whether the cities of the plain, whose abominations drew down upon them a swift destruction from the Most High, were worse than Rome and Pompeii. The monuments of both cities testify to their worse than bestial degradation, and to the correctness of the Apostle Paul's portraiture of heathenism in the opening of his Epistle to the Romans. "Amid the silence and gloom of the Catacombs we are transported to an entirely different world," says Mr. Withrow; "we breathe a purer moral atmosphere; we are surrounded by the evidences of an infinitely nobler social life; we are struck with the immeasurable superiority in all the elements of true dignity and grandeur of the lowly and persecuted Christians to the highest development of ancient civilization."
The social position of the departed is frequently notified on the tombs in the Catacombs; and although after Constantine made Christianity the state religion the names of important persons occur, the numbers who were previously interred are those of the poor—e.g.—
"It was the sneer of Celsus that 'woolworkers, leather dressers, cobblers, the most illiterate of mankind, were zealous preachers of the gospel;' but Tertullian retorts that every Christian craftsman can teach truths loftier than Plato ever knew. The inscriptions of the Catacombs indicate that not many wise, not many mighty, joined that phalanx of heroic souls; but they teach, too, that the lowliest toil may be dignified and ennobled by being done to the glory of God. We have seen represented on the tombs emblems of the occupation of the carpenter, mason, currier, wool-comber, shoemaker, vine dresser, and fosser. We find also such records of trade as 'a baker of the twelfth district;' . . 'a gardener;' . . 'patron of the corporation of confectioners;' . . 'chief of the cooks;' . . 'a granary keeper;' . . 'a charcoal seller;' . . 'a victualler;' . . 'a flesher from the shambles;' . . 'a keeper of clothes at the Antonine Baths;' . . 'a stone dresser;' . . 'Policla, who sells barley in the new street;' . . 'John, a respectable man, a book-keeper in the tavern of Isidorus;' also less reputable still . . 'Urban, a respectable man, a tavern keeper.' This, however, was in the year A.D. 584, when purity of faith and practice had greatly degenerated. These lowly records are preserved and studied with interest when many of Rome's proudest monuments have crumbled away."
The figures, or Christian symbols, so often met with on the graves, are of a very simple, innocent nature, this being especially true of those which belong to the days of persecution. The anchor, the palm, and the dove with the olive-leaf are frequently met with, and reveal the simple faith of those who died in the Lord. The vine and the Good Shepherd are also favourite symbols; but, on coming to the cross in which Paul gloried, we find that cross to have been "a pledge of the resurrection rather than a memorial of the passion." In other words,
77
the cross of Christ and the symbol so ostentatiously paraded by Popery are not identical. "The early believers carefully avoided, as though prevented by a sacred interdict, any attempt to depict the awful scenes of Christ's passion, the realistic treatment of which in Roman Catholic art so often shocks the sensibilities and harrows the soul," says our author. "This solemn tragedy they felt to be the theme of devout and prayerful meditation rather than of portraiture in art. Hence we find no pictures of the agony and bloody sweat, the mocking and the shame, the death and burial of our Lord. 'The Catacombs of Rome,' says Milman, 'faithful to their general character, offer no instance of a crucifixion, nor does any allusion to such a subject occur in any early writing.'" It is equally satisfactory to find that the Catacombs, during the early centuries, as uniformly bear their unanswerable testimony against the monstrous system of mariolatry which is the very backbone of Popery in modern Rome.
The subject we have thus cursorily glanced at is full of interest and instruction; it is also one which should attract general readers, and successfully compete with the sensational literature of the age. Students of primitive Christian manners and customs who are able to give the subject a more complete examination will be rewarded by many curious revelations belonging to the heroic age of the church. To such Mr. Withrow's work will prove a convenient handbook, as the carefully-prepared text is profusely illustrated with a series of well-executed engravings.
