Menu
‹ Chapter 56 of 222 ›

Bernardino Ochino — By Vernon J. Charlesworth

15 min read · Chapter 56 of 222

THERE must be something in a volume of which the Rev. William Arthur writes, "This is a book that will make its way into our language and into others, and in each new language it will make its way to the favour of many readers." Written by a German Protestant in Rome—a fact which speaks very loudly of the altered state of things in the year of grace 1876—every page bears trace of the loving labours of a competent scholar, and as a contribution to the history of the Reformation, it will be highly prized by every ecclesiastical student. Mr. Arthur's preface gives expression to his own estimate of the interest and importance of the work. "Henceforth," he says, "it is the lot of Ochino to be known. Italy will, on one side execrate, on another side adopt him, but she cannot bury him any more." We are indebted for the translation to Helen Zimmern, who has succeeded in presenting to the English reader a volume of intense interest.

It is with some difficulty that the author is able to decide the date of Ochino's birth. He fixes it in 1487. Ochino is a pseudonym of very doubtful etymology. His father's name was Domenico Tommasini. Nothing scarcely is known of his early years, but it is certain that he had attained the age of manhood when Aonio Paleario visited Siena, Ochino's native place, in the year 1530. Writing to his friends of the city of his adoption, Paleario says, "Siena is situated on charming hills, the surrounding country is fruitful, and produces all things in plenty. But discord arrays its burghers in arms against each other, and all their strength is exhausted in party strife." The town is situated some twenty-four miles to the south of Florence, on the high road to Rome.

One of the earliest recorded facts in the life of Ochino is the mention of his determination to gain heaven by austerity and self-denial. The preaching of Savonarola had produced a profound impression throughout the Italian peninsula, and the convents greedily received those whose consciences were alarmed, and who sought within their walls the coveted passport to the heavenly world. We cannot better exhibit the legal system of Romanism than by quoting the testimony of Ochino after he had found the more excellent way. He says, "When I was a young man, I was under the delusion, which still prevails among those who are under the imperious sway of Antichrist, that we could earn our salvation by our own works. I thought that it was our duty, and within our power, to expiate our sins by fasting, prayer, continence, vigils, and such like, and thus gain Paradise for ourselves, though not without the assistance of God's grace. Impelled by the desire to save my soul, I went about pondering what path I should choose. The religious orders appeared holy to me, for were they not sanctioned by the Romish church, which I deemed infallible? But among them all, the rule of the friars of St. Francis, named the Observants, seemed to me

* Bernardino Ochino (Pr. Okeeno) of Siena; a contribution towards the History of the Reformation. By Karl Bernath. London: J. Nisbet and Co. 21, Berners Street.

151

the strictest, severest, and most harsh. Hence I concluded that it must best represent the teachings of Christ, and I entered this order. But I did not find what I expected. Still, as no better way offered itself to my blinded understanding, I remained in the order until the Capuchins arose. When I beheld the severity of their life, I put on their garb, yet not without a severe struggle with my carnal wisdom and sensuousness. I now deemed to have found what I sought; and I well remember that I turned to Christ with 'Lord, if I don't now save my soul, I know not what more I can do.' Was I not a very Pharisee? I may say with St. Paul, 'I profited in the Jews' religion above many mine equals in mine own nation.' Although Ochino thinks he was preserved from many sins into which he might have fallen as a layman and attaches some value to his initiation into "contemplative theology," during the period of his conventual residence, we are conscious of a feeling of regret that such an earnest seeker did not, at first, discover God's way of peace, and escape the perils of monasticism.

Failing to find the salvation he sought amongst the Observants, he attributed his failure to the relaxed discipline of the order, and in 1534 sought the consent of the Pope to his admission into the Capuchin order—the most austere of all religious bodies. The Pope assented, and he was received with open arms by the new fraternity, which had not long enjoyed the papal sanction. The Capuchin order being regarded as a formidable rival of the Conventuals and the Observants, grave charges were preferred against it, and the members were summoned to Rome and expelled by the order of Clement VII, from the sacred city. Popular feeling, however, was in their favour, excited as it was by their procession through the streets of the city, for three days headed by a hermit with a long white beard. "Woe for thee," he cried vehemently, "Woe, unto thee, O Rome! Thou lovest to harbour harlots and drunkards, thou nourishest dogs, and thou wouldest banish the Capuchins." The Pope succeeded in getting out of the difficulty in which he found himself by ruling that the order of banishment was only temporary.

Ochino's fame as a preacher dates from this period, and he was made one of the generals of his order. He was universally regarded as a man of great sanctity, and several towns pleaded for the honour of a visit from him to preach the Lenten sermon. It was feared that his austerities would prove fatal. "Wherever he was to preach the citizens might be seen in crowds; no church was large enough to contain the multitude of listeners." Often the guest of nobles, he disdained all luxuries. "If a bed had been prepared for him, he begged permission to rest on a more comfortable pallet, spread his cloak on the ground, and laid down to rest." On the incapacity of the vicar-general of his order through sickness, Ochino was elected to fill the place for three years, and under his rule the order reached unprecedented eminence. In many of the churches where he preached scaffoldings were erected to accommodate the people, and the tiles were removed from the roofs of neighbouring houses that his words might find access. The demands for his services were such that the Pope reserved to himself the right to determine where he should preach. It must have been difficult to refuse such a petition as this—"We beg you earnestly and heartily, for the love of Christ, if ever you

wished to perform something at once for the weal of our city and for the glory of God, put all other matters aside at present, even though it may be difficult to you, to come here to preach before Christmas. For all the citizens are firmly convinced that your preaching will be of great effect; that by your sermons the glory of God will be greatly increased in this city, and that you will thus reap rich gains by the universal welfare and the salvation of souls. We hope, nay, we are firmly convinced, that your reverence, counting the glory of God above everything, and desiring with your whole heart the good of your native city, as you have always shown us that you willingly accede to our wishes, will allow nothing to prevent you from coming to us." This is sufficient to prove how eagerly the people hailed the preaching of Ochino which, if it did not set forth in all its fulness "justification by faith," was certainly in advance of the ordinary teaching of the church of Rome. Preaching, except as a means of instructing the people in the observance of the mass, and the traditions of the church, was but little practised by the clergy. The preacher, indeed, was not regarded as the ambassador for Christ so much as the agent of the church to enforce its authority over the conscience and the life. A man resolutely determined to seek the salvation of his fellow-men, though his ministry was marred by defects in doctrine—possessed of the power of eloquence, rare in any day, rarer still in his, Ochino could not fail to command an audience and to produce an impression for good. Very little of doctrinal teaching characterized his ministry at this period; he dealt almost exclusively in denunciations of sins, and exhortations to a holy life; still, even this was an immense gain upon the histrionic performances of the ordinary priests. The following passage in a sermon on "Confession of Sin and Penitence," must have fallen with strange power upon the ears of an Italian audience from a priest in the pulpit of a Romish church. "Another learns the list of sins by heart, so that when he comes before his father confessor he can show himself a good Christian by repeating his sins in succession, with certain humble expressions, that make him appear a man that truly fears God. Thus a certain nun, who desired to prove herself a true disciple of Christ, began, 'Oh, Father Confessor, I acknowledge that of all others in the convent I am the most haughty, the most careless, and most ungodly,' and so forth, in expressions of exaggerated humility, so that the wise and experienced father saw through her, and answered, 'My daughter, I knew that before; they have told me that thou wast the haughtiest, most careless, ungodly of all in the convent, and therefore surely thou art not worthy to bear the dress of thy order.' Oh! how the nun flew at him! 'Father, you are too credulous; it is not so bad.' And yet she had just told him the same thing in her confession." In the same sermon the following sentence occurs, which clearly proves that Ochino was beginning to cast aside the grave-clothes of a dead formalism, and that the light of the gospel was struggling to overcome the darkness of a corrupt tradition: "The exactest and deepest avowal of sin consists in this, that we regard Christ crucified for us in the mirror of pure faith and ardent love."

As many in the present day, even amongst Protestants, are enamoured of the conventual life, we commend to them the testimony

153

of Ochino, based upon his own experience and observation. "Many enter, and leave their own parents, their brothers or sisters, even their children, in want, or, at any rate, their neighbours, to whom they could be useful. They shut themselves up in convents, feed themselves fat, and are useless and burdensome to the world. If we could see to the bottom of their hearts we should find that they go into the convent out of despair, want, or cowardice, because they have lost courage to rule themselves, or, out of laziness, to live in idleness to the sound of bells, or, at best, to atone for their sins by works and penance, and gain credit in the eyes of God. Oh, we should not find one who entered the convent for the glory of God." If it be replied that his judgment was influenced by his defection, it must be admitted that the verdict is supported by testimony which cannot be refuted.

In 1523, about fifty or sixty Catholics, under Leo X. formed themselves into a society at Rome called the "Oratory of Divine Love," having for their object the amendment of the church. They pledged themselves to visit the churches more diligently, to pray more frequently at sacred spots, to celebrate mass more regularly, in short, to all actions by which Catholicism seeks to awaken and foster the religious sentiment. The basis was too narrow for any substantial reform. Yet this movement was the immediate precursor of the Reformation.

Ochino was now brought under the influence of Juan Valdez, a Spanish nobleman, resident in Naples, who played an important part in the Reformation. It was said of him that he was "a noble knight by the grace of Cæsar, but a more noble knight by the grace of Christ." Valdez became the centre and the bond of a number of distinguished men and women who were "impelled by the one desire to attain a purer conception of Christianity, and a more perfect representation of it in their own lives." The Scriptures were read by this little community, and such works as Bucer's Commentary on the Gospel of Matthew, Luther on the Psalms, and Calvin's Institutes, were discussed. With these they forged the weapons of the Reformation. Ochino's orthodoxy as a Papist was now suspected, and the Theatines, who were the heresy hunters of the time, sent spies to all the churches where he was announced to preach. Amongst other proofs of his declension they adduced the following:—"Augustine had said, 'God, who created thee without thy co-operation, will not save thee without thy co-operation;' but Ochino twists the sense of these words into the contrary meaning, by turning them into a question—'Will not God, who has created thee without thy co-operation, save thee without thy co-operation?'" It was no concern of his accusers that Augustine found a truer exponent in Ochino than in the general teachers of their church.

One remarkable feature in the case of Ochino is this—his enforced obedience to the rules of his order in spite of the growing conviction that such obedience was not necessary to his salvation. He says, "I anxiously obeyed all natural, moral, ecclesiastical, and evangelical observances, and not only those observances contained in the rules of St. Francis, but everything which our fathers had established in the provincial and general chapters." And yet he makes the startling statement, "I had not been long among the Capuchins before the Lord began to open my eyes. He taught me to recognize three things;

firstly, that Christ had done enough for his elect, and had obtained Paradise for them—that he alone is our righteousness; secondly, that the vows of human institution are not only not binding, but even immoral; thirdly, that the Roman church, although outwardly brilliant to the bodily eye, is nevertheless an abomination to the eyes of the Lord." There may be a heroism about his obedience to his vows, but he was certainly guilty of cowardice in resisting the truth and suppressing his convictions. That he suffered so much and imperilled so much more by pursuing this course may suffice to redeem him from the suspicion of a selfish ambition. In vain he had observed masses, recited paternosters, and chastised his body by fasts and flagellations, for he observes—"under the semblance of doing good, I had, really, persecuted Christ and his gospel, and had departed the further from God the more I had tried to attain him by storming him by works." He endeavours to justify his inconsistency in holding this belief and yet shrinking from its full avowal by the following plea of expediency—"I saw that the eyes of Italy were so weak that I should have hurt them grievously if I had let them look full on the great light, Christ, as it had been revealed to me. The scribes and pharisees who govern Italy would have killed me. I, therefore, thought it better not to reveal the great light of the gospel so suddenly, but, gradually showing it, accommodating myself to their weak powers of sight." Such a confession as this, pitiable as it is, must not be visited with a censure too severe in his case, but it must not be justified by any apology. To stifle convictions by expediency, and to compromise truth by complicity with error, is a policy which defeats the most excellent intentions and degrades a man's moral nature. In every department of life the resolution which Norman McLeod embodies in the following stanza is the truest wisdom :—

"Perish policy and cunning,

Perish all that fears the light,

Whether losing, whether winning,

Trust in God and do the right."

Notwithstanding his studied ambiguity in preaching he could not escape the suspicion of heresy, and he was forbidden to fulfil an engagement to preach in Venice. His friend Terenziano was committed to a dungeon, where he remained several years for preaching boldly the same doctrines which Ochino believed.

The shadow of the Inquisition now began to fall darkly on the heart of Ochino, and he received a citation to appear in Rome. To respond was to rush into the lion's mouth; to refuse obedience was to challenge pursuit. At length he resolved to leave Italy and seek the freedom for which his soul had yearned, but which he had denied himself by his own deliberate policy. He reached Geneva, and Calvin speaks of him as "a fugitive Italian, an old man of venerable appearance." His austere mode of living had told upon his constitution and he had aged beyond his years. He remained in Geneva three years on good terms with the Reformers, and employed the greater part of his time in writing gospel pamphlets for circulation in Italy. The following passage expresses the sum of his teaching at this time :—"We do not attain

155

paradise through the observance of divine ordinances, but Christ has won it for us on the cross. It is no wages for servants, but an inheritance for children. God does not sell it to us as a trader, but he gives it us as a father. It is sufficient for us to have a living faith, a faith we cannot attain through our own understanding and strength because it is a gift of God. And even if it were our own work, we should not be saved because our faith deserved salvation, but through Christ alone."

In 1545, Ochino, who had visited Basle and Strasburg with letters of commendation from Calvin, settled in Augsburg as preacher to the Italian congregation, but receiving a call to England, he set out in company with Peter Martyr, and the two companions were entertained by Craumer at Lambeth Palace. Martyr was named professor of theology at Oxford, and Ochino was appointed prebendary of Canterbury, without being obliged to go into residence. He was allowed a salary of a hundred marks out of the king's privy purse, and preached to a congregation of Italian refugees in London. He only remained in England six years, for on the death of Edward VI. the reaction set in under Queen Mary and all Protestants had to seek safety either in recantation or flight. Returning to the Continent, he took up his residence at Basle, but receiving a call to the pastorate of the Italian congregation in Zurich, he entered upon his duties with an unabated zeal. Here he was joined again by Peter Martyr, and the two Reformers laboured together in spreading sound Protestant doctrine. The controversy with Rome was a simple matter compared with the controversy occasioned by the failure of the various sections of Protestants to agree among themselves. The discussions were most unprofitable; they rendered unity impossible and weakened the forces which should have been arrayed against the Romish system in resistless concentration. While at Zurich Ochino became involved in arguing a question of morals, and fell a victim to his expediency. This was the one great blemish of his character. In theology his expediency and even compromise of truth had been condoned, but in the realm of morals it was not to be tolerated. His doctrine was condemned, and the council dismissed him from his congregation and banished him from their city and domains,—a sentence harsh in the extreme. He was driven from Zurich, and afterwards from Basle, a widower with four young children, during a severe winter. He was forced to fly to the distant kingdom of Poland, and thence to Moravia. He had been tossed about the world, bither and thither, like a ball. He had already reached his 76th year and was suffering from the troubles and infirmities of age. Although he was equipped with such exceptional endowments, and had brought the Reformed church so much honour, he was exiled with no more regret than is expressed in the report to the council by his examiners:—"We are sincerely grieved that this aged man, who came here when seventy years old, and who had before then won a great name, should be involved in this trouble." Bullinger appears to have been the most intolerant opponent of Ochino in this matter. There is a touch of sarcasm in the following remark of Ochino,—"I never thought that Bullinger was Pope in Zurich, and that not his decrees only but his private wishes must needs be obeyed."

Misfortune followed Ochino into Poland, for, under the influence of the Papal legate, a royal edict appeared, forbidding all foreigners, not being Catholics, to reside in the land. The nobles pleaded that an exception should be made in the "favour of this old, infirm, pious, quiet man," but failing in their suit, the exile was again driven forth, disowned by Catholics and Protestants alike. On his way to Moravia he was stricken down by the plague, which carried off three of his children. What became of the fourth is not known. Such a picture of misery rarely finds a parallel in the course of history. The only record of his last days is the mention of the fact that the old man died in solitude at Schlackan, in Moravia. There is something tragic in the close of such a chequered life, and the conviction is forced upon the reader of his life-story that a career shaped by expediency will be attended with weakness and end in sorrow.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate