The Brave Picture in the House of the Interpreter
A PAPER READ AT THE THIRTEENTH ANNUAL CONFERENCE OF THE PASTORS' COLLEGE, APRIL 12TH, 1877, BY PASTOR GEORGE HILL, SOUTH PARADE, LEEDS.
O crowd into a twenty-five minutes' paper anything like an adequate or satisfactory treatment of my subject seems impossible. I have done my best to meet the difficulty by leaving out of consideration many things which under other circumstances might naturally have claimed a place,
and by dealing in the briefest fashion with the points selected for illustration. If, in spite of these precautions, I should be found unduly trespassing upon your time, what can I say but that, warned as I have been of the penalty which will follow swiftly on the heels of the offence, and more fearful of the ringing of the bell* than was Hamlet's ghost of the cockcrowing, at its first stroke I shall start "like a guilty thing upon a fearful summons," and immediately subside into the obscurity from which for a few minutes I have reluctantly emerged.
I will stop for no panegyric on Bunyan or the "Pilgrim's Progress," but come straightway to our parable and its interpretation. The parable is this: "Then said the Interpreter, Come in; I will show thee, that which will be profitable unto thee. So he commanded his man to light a candle, and bid Christian follow him; so he had him into a private room and bid his man open a door, the which when he had done, Christian saw the picture of a very grave person hang up against
* Writers of papers for the Conference had been told that the bell would be rung at the end of twenty-five minutes.
16
the wall; and this was the fashion of it: it had eyes lifted up to heaven, the best of books in its hand, the law of truth was written upon its lips, the world was behind its back, it stood as if it pleaded with men, and a crown of gold did hang over its head." The interpretation of the parable is not difficult. Bunyan, indeed, adds his own interpretation, which I will not quote, because my purpose in what follows is to bring into prominence one or two points which are there passed over with a mere word. I trust, however, nothing in this paper will be found out of harmony with the spirit and words of our author.
Ministers have been known to make a careful study of the "Pilgrim's Progress" for the sake of acquiring a mastery of its terse and vigorous Saxon. Some have been attracted to the book by its life-like delineation of Christian character. One minister I know who declared that from the "Pilgrim's Progress" and the Bible he had learned all his theology.* May I suggest as likely to be profitable, the study of the book for the sake of the valuable hints which abound as to the office and work of the minister of the gospel? The short extract I have read descriptive of what is called in the margin the "brave picture" in the house of the Interpreter puts before us in distinct outline Bunyan's Ideal of the Christian Preacher.
Passing by the meaning to be assigned to the Interpreter, the Interpreter's house, the lighted candle (over against the mention of which Bunyan significantly writes the single marginal word "illumination") and looking upon the picture itself, the first thing which claims notice is that which Bunyan has put first in his description:—THE CHRISTIAN PREACHER'S HEAVENWARD GAZE.
Bunyan doubtless intended to suggest by this that one mark of the true minister of Jesus Christ is that he seeks strength for his work by communion with God. The uplifted eye indicates the attitude of the soul. The soul looks heavenward, seeking—what when sought is always to be found, what is never found without the seeking—fellowship with God.
Nothing need be said in proof of the reality or possibility of the thing I speak about. That fellowship with God is something real, something within the reach of all of us, we know. We know it from the Scriptures. We know it from the testimony of Christians. Best of all, we know it from our own personal experience. Only by experience can it be at all fully understood. Words cannot make it plain. Yet to prevent misconception, it may be well to say that what we mean is not mere listless reverie, in which the thoughts are allowed to wander away without control. It is very far from being a state in which the soul is nearly or almost passive. In true communion the soul is awake
* The following notes may be interesting to some readers. They are from S. T. Coleridge's "Table Talk," p. 89:—
"I know of no book, the Bible excepted as above all comparison, which I, according to my judgment and experience, could so safely recommend as teaching and enforcing the whole saving truth according to the mind that was in Christ Jesus, as the 'Pilgrim's Progress.' It is, in my conviction, incomparably the best summa theologiae evangelicae ever produced by a writer not miraculously inspired." "I read it once as a theologian, and let me assure you that there is great theological acumen in the book." "I could not have believed beforehand that Calvinism could be painted in such exquisitely delightful colours."
243
and active; seeking, reaching after, finding, waiting upon God: realizing his presence, meditating upon his word, speaking to him, and listening as, in the soul's deepest silence, with voices inaudible to others, he speaks back again. And this communion with God is to the Christian, and to the Christian minister especially, a privilege and need for lack of which nothing else can make up. It is as absolute a necessity as breathing is to life, as rain or dew to the springing up of the tender herb.
We may look at this in two ways. First, I would ask, is not something of this kind possible as the soul's abiding condition? May we not walk with God? May we not live "as ever in our great Taskmaster's eye?" May we not so habituate ourselves to the recognition of his unseen presence that it shall be as real to us as the presence of the companion by whose side we walk, and that we shall as readily turn to speak to him of our joys and sorrows as to any most intimate living friend—nay, that he shall himself be the Friend with whom, while never less than profoundly reverential, we are most familiar too? May not this be so? Was it not thus with him in whom all Christian life finds its perfect pattern? Was not he always conscious of the presence of the Father whose will he came to do? Was not that fellowship—in its nature far liker the fellowship we may know than unlike it—maintained uninterruptedly? And the brief outbursts of audible prayer which occurred—sometimes in the midst of his works of healing, sometimes in the midst of his teaching—were they not indications of communion kept up constantly? Like the golden threads running through some pattern of tapestry, always in the fabric but coming now and then to the surface; like the outflashing of a love which never falters, but needs the special occasion to call forth the token of its presence. You, brethren, shall answer these questionings, and there can be little doubt what the answer will be. If the thing suggested seem to some of us like a bright mountain summit we have not scaled, or in whose brilliance we do not abide, we cannot, down in the mist of the valley, say the brightness does not exist up yonder. We will not deny the reality of the experience because we do not enjoy it. To say "the sun does not shine," because we are in a position where its beams cannot reach us is folly and something worse. Wisdom lives in our stepping out into the sunshine and sharing the light and warmth which gladden others.
But however readily we may admit that something like habitual fellowship with God is a thing possible, we must also admit that to form the habit and then to maintain it when formed, there must be special seasons and (I do not know what better expression to use than) special acts of communion. There will be little reality in that man's "abiding fellowship" who never seeks to contribute to his spiritual welfare by use of what we call "the means of grace." I should be disposed to have little faith in his "walk with God" who thinks he can dispense with private prayer and devout meditation upon the divine word. The preservation of the highest spiritual life has not become so easy and natural a thing even to the best among us that he can venture to be careless about it. To revert for a moment to our great Example, habitual fellowship with the Father can never become to us so
spontaneous and natural as it was to him; yet even he—surely not without need—was wont to retire to the lone desert and quiet mountain top and there continue all night in prayer unto God. The disciple is not greater than the Master.
That special seasons of communion are desirable and valuable we all allow, but who does not know how difficult it is to secure them! Hurried all day long with work which must be done, worried by a thousand cares with which, it may be, we have no business to be perplexed, but from which we cannot escape; wearied at night with the labours of the day and oppressed with anticipations of to-morrow's overwhelming tasks, it seems, at times, a thing next to impossible to set apart periods for prolonged devotion, if our work is to be done at all creditably and we are not to be brought to a dead lock by the accumulation of arrears. Yet this great Christian privilege must not be neglected. We had better fail anywhere, everywhere else than here. Nay, if we fail here we shall fail everywhere in some degree, and we may fail utterly and hopelessly. There are times when our truest strength is to sit still, when we may best consult our people's interests by shutting them out of our thoughts; when we may take the high-road to success in our work by turning right away from the work for a while; when we may most acceptably serve as we "only stand and wait." Certain it is that our piety will soon flag, as the frail flower withers for lack of water, if we seek not the throne of God and of the Lamb to drink of the life-giving stream which flows from thence. Prayerfulness and holiness are something like convertible terms: they are at least mutually inclusive. You cannot have holiness without prayerfulness, and you cannot have prayerfulness without holiness. To say nothing of the operation of divine grace in answer to our prayers, we grow into the likeness of the object with which our thoughts are busy, by the working of a law we can all understand. This is illustrated by the classic legend which tells that that nightingale always had the sweetest song which built its nest nearest the tomb of Orpheus; and by the grosser Roman Catholic legend of S. Francis, which relates how the saint through constantly gazing upon a ghastly crucifix came to have marks of wounds imprinted on his own hands and feet, corresponding with the wounds of Christ. Contemplation leads to transformation. "Beholding we are changed."
Three transfigurations are described in the Bible, and while all are connected with prayer, two are connected with prolonged fellowship with God. It was after forty days spent in the full blaze of a special manifestation of the divine nature, that when Moses went down from the mount the skin of his face shone; and though the prophet wist not of it, the people saw it and were afraid to come nigh, he reminded them so of God. It was when Jesus had withdrawn for devotion that "as he prayed" the fashion of his countenance was altered and his raiment was white and glistening. And holy Stephen, third of the transfigured trio, it was when
Looking upward full of grace
He prayed, that from a happy place
God's glory smote him on the face.
May that upward look, and the spirit of devotion it signifies, be ours.
245
It is the opinion of some eminent Biblical critics* that the authorized version of Exodus xxxiv. which describes the transfiguration of Moses is somewhat misleading, and that what we should read is, not that Moses kept the vail upon his face till he had done speaking so that the people might look upon him while he spoke, but that the people did look upon his unvailed face while he addressed them, and then when he had done he assumed the vail to conceal the fading of the brilliance which had so much affected them. Absent from the manifested presence of God the brightness began to die away, and the vail was used, but when the prophet entered the tabernacle, where, from between the cherubim, the shekinah shone, the vail was removed that God's glory might again smite his face, and that with rekindled lustre he might come forth to speak to the people in the name of the Lord. How suggestive is this interpretation. No words of mine are necessary to give point to it. The Christ-likeness of our character, and our influence over men arising therefrom, will soon fade and die if we remain too much in the world and suffer the mercy-seat to be neglected; but if we go in, in solitude, before the Lord, if we seek constant or even frequent communion with Christ, in whom God has made the fullest revelation of himself, we shall be changed into his image. It is the law of this world as truly as the world to come: we shall be like him when we see him as he is.
I said this heavenward look suggests dependence as well as communion. The Christian preacher seeks the divine presence, not only that he may be blessed in his own spiritual life, but that he may receive such blessing as is necessary for success in his work. Let me try to give emphasis for a moment to that idea. Who among us has not felt, at times, precisely what is here depicted: when from some cause mental preparation has been far from satisfactory, or physical weariness has depressed the spirits, when there has been experienced a sense of absolute dependence which has found expression in the uplifted eye betokening the uplifted heart, while the soul has cried out: "Now Lord! there can be nothing but breakdown and failure if there come no help from thee"? A painful experience, but is it not often, in its results, a very blessed one? We do not at all times feel our dependence as we ought, and yet it is always very real. When we have done our best to equip ourselves in every way for the work we have but whetted a weapon which will lie impotent till it be taken up by the Warrior's hand. We can work no deliverance. The Master must put words into our mouth if we are to speak with power in his name. Alone we are helpless. We are like the Æolian harp which waits for the wind from heaven before sending forth its melody; like "the statue of the Egyptian Memnon, dumb through the dark night and uttering a sound only when the rising sun touched him with his rays." We are
"the trumpet at thy lips, the clarion
Full of thy cry, sonorous with thy breath."
We are but instruments which, whatever they may accomplish when they are made vehicles for the might of his power, are but so much dead
* See Dean Stanley's "Lectures on the Jewish Church," Vol. I., p. 134.
Dean Alford on 2 Cor. iii. 13.
lumber unless he wield them. Our sufficiency is of God. Our hope is in the presence and help of the Divine Spirit who is as the wind that blows where it lists, and for this we must seek the breezy uplands of communion where that Wind always lists to blow. We need to make him our pattern who has taught us how to work as well as how to live, and of whom we read that "praying, the heaven was opened, and the Holy Ghost descended in a bodily shape like a dove upon him." Let us but live as he lived, and the power which rested upon him will in our measure rest also upon us. He lived in fellowship with God. His thoughts and prayers rose to heaven in the midst of all his work. He spent long seasons in lonely devotion, and came down from the hill-top with more than the morning dew clinging to his robes and the mountain freshness lingering about him; he came clad with the Spirit of Power gained by communion with the Father. Let us live thus; let us go to our work straight from fellowship with God, and men will gather round to hearken to our message, and the confession will be renewed concerning our poor utterance—"The word was with power."
II. Passing to the second point: "the brave picture" represented one who had the best of books in his hand, and the law of truth written upon his lips. These two expressions suggest some remarks as to the CHRISTIAN MINISTER'S MESSAGE.
Believing, on evidence which seems to put the matter beyond reasonable doubt, that the Bible is the word of God, the product of divine inspiration, a revelation of God's will, the revelation of God's will, of its kind the only revelation of God's will,—regarding it as a communication which comes to us bearing the signature of heaven, we accept it with reverence; and as preachers we consider it our main work to endeavour by means of all spiritual and intellectual helps to discover what the Bible teaches, and then to make known that teaching to others. Our sole recognised authority in our work, as to what we are to do and the way in which we are to do it, is the Word of God. We may neither do as we like nor teach what we like. We carry with us instructions as to the will of him in whose service we are engaged, and whose representatives in some sort we are; and as to the method of procedure we must adopt in making known that will. We are heralds making an announcement,—servants who have not to express their own thoughts, but to deliver a message from their Master: a message which we understand, with which we are in fullest sympathy, which we may put into our own language, but which, after all, is not so much our message as his. That message we learn from the Word of God; that message is the Word of God, and we must neither add thereto nor subtract therefrom. True, in the still hour of communion God will speak to his servant, will put words into his mouth which he must speak to others. But the message thus specially communicated will be in perfect accord with the written Word. If there be any discrepancy it were better we should believe that we have been deluded than that God has contradicted himself. True, the Spirit of Truth is with us as our Abiding Teacher, and we may well covet earnestly the illumination he vouchsafes; but here again we must utterly distrust any teaching which contradicts the oracle. Better believe ourselves mistaken than that the Scriptures are wrong and unreliable. True, various voices in nature
247
and in human life speak of God to the listening soul, and no voice is without significance and value. Yet here again we must be on our guard: the voice may be true enough but our hearing may be indistinct; the theory all right but our application of it wrong; the revelation trustworthy but we looking with dimmed eyes or through a medium which distorts and misrepresents. In the use of all these methods of learning God's will there is a possibility of our being deceived. Then only can we feel perfectly safe in crying "thus saith the Lord," when we can adduce in proof the words of the inspired Book. Here is our authoritative message; here our standard of appeal. Here is the touchstone by which all teaching must be tested; here is (shall I say) the microcosm in which the whole world of revelation is epitomized, so that "whatsoever is not contained herein nor may be proved hereby" cannot be accepted by us as a subject of Christian teaching.
Our work is to preach the Word. "Read," said Sir Walter Scott, during his last illness. "Read." "What shall we read?" "How can you ask, there is but one Book,"—and for us, as we seek to instruct the living and to comfort the dying, there is but one book. In the ordination service of the Established Church the bishop places a Bible in the hands of the candidate, saying, "Take thou authority to preach the Word of God." When we, brethren, were ordained and authorized for our work the Great Bishop put the "best of books" into our hands, saying, "Go, make known my word"; and he who fails to do this, whatever else he may do, whatever else he may be,—fails to discharge the one great function of the Christian ministry and is unworthy to be called a preacher of the gospel of Christ. We must preach the Word. We are bound to this by the commission of our Master. We are impelled to it by the needs of our hearers, and by our desire to do them some spiritual good. Here are the means God has appointed to regenerate and sanctify. Men want to know just those things which the Bible teaches; and as we would be obedient to Christ and instrumental in the conversion and edification of men we must preach the Word.
To preach the Word implies that we have faith in it as from God, faith in it as an inspired book. This is of the first importance. Much of the scepticism which prevails results from unbelief in the inspiration of the Scriptures. When belief in the inspiration of the Scriptures has been cast away, belief in their full and final authority soon follows; and when these two are gone, then, without rudder, without compass, without anchor, to what "seas of death and sunless gulfs of doubt" the frail vessel will be driven, and where at last the shipwreck will be made God only knows. Here I feel it unnecessary to enlarge. If there is one characteristic which more than any other has marked the men who have gone forth from this College, I am not wrong in saying it is unswerving loyalty to the Word of God,—unfaltering faith in its inspiration and supreme authority. The one thing needful to ensure our acceptance of any doctrine is that it come to us bearing the superscription, "It is written."
There is also involved here the belief that the Word of God speaks clearly and distinctly, that we may positively affirm its authority for the great doctrines we preach. Mr. Froude, in one of his "Short Studies on Great Subjects," says, "It often seems to me as if history was like a
child's box of letters with which we can spell any word we please. We have only to pick out such letters as we want, arrange them as we like, and say nothing about those which do not suit our purpose."* Now, we feel that for one to act thus in relation to history is immoral and dishonest; but what shall we say of those who hold a theory too much like the "box of letters" theory in relation to the Word of God; who think, or profess to think, the Bible may be made to say anything, or that it teaches nothing with absolute certainty and unqualified clearness? It is related of Robert Robinson, of Cambridge, that on one occasion, after explaining a passage of Scripture, he added, "these are my present views, but I am going a walk down the garden, and I may think differently when I come back;" and one has heard of ministers in one's own time who have boasted that they had no settled convictions on doctrinal matters; they were but students of the Scriptures, and were ready to welcome any teaching which commended itself to their judgment. Students of the Scriptures I trust we all are, and ready to welcome all truth from every quarter. But surely he has made poor use of his time in studying the Bible who has not learnt that it teaches definitely at least something. With this kind of thing we have small sympathy. Far more after our heart are the words of the American statesman Webster: "I believe that the Bible is to be understood and received in the plain and obvious meaning of its language, since I cannot persuade myself that a book intended for the instruction and conversion of the whole world should cover its true meaning in such mystery and doubt that none but critics and philosophers can discover it. I believe that the experiments and subtleties of human wisdom are more likely to obscure than to enlighten the revealed will of God, and that he is the most accomplished Christian scholar who has been educated at the feet of Jesus and in the college of fishermen." We, too, believe that the Bible is to be understood in its plain and obvious meaning, and we believe that its teaching with regard to the great essentials of our faith, is plain and obvious. We hold that such questions as whether Jesus Christ is God as well as man; whether salvation is by grace or by works; whether redemption is by sacrifice or by example; whether justification is by faith or by the deeds of the law; whether personal immortality is a fact or an illusion; are settled and placed beyond controversy for all who believe the testimony of the New Testament on such matters to be final. We may heartily agree with the noble Puritan pastor Robinson in thinking that "God hath yet more truth to break forth from his Word," but all truth is harmonious; truth can never be self-contradictory. Any further truth which riper scholarship and more perfectly equipped criticism may bring to light we will receive joyfully, but we are confident it can but supplement and can never contradict the truth we already know. And when we are asked to believe that although during the last eighteen hundred years some of the noblest intellects with which the world was ever blessed have been engaged in the study of the Bible—that Bible, which is to be received in its plain and obvious meaning—we have yet to learn the most
* Has not Mr. Froude supplied a remarkable illustration of his theory in his laborious endeavour to vindicate the character of King Henry VIII.?
219
elementary truths of the Christian religion, our answer is, "Gentlemen, the absurdity is too grotesque." Evangelical Christians are often taunted with credulity, but this is too much even for us. The credulity necessary for such a belief we must leave to the incredulous sceptic.
It follows from all this—from the fact that we have to preach the Word of God which we believe to be inspired, and therefore authoritative in its teaching, which is to be understood in its plain and obvious meaning, and whose meaning is plain and obvious in relation to all essential matters—it follows from all this that we may speak with positiveness and certainty. There is a dogmatism which is out of place, and there is a dogmatism which is eminently right and reasonable. When the preacher is giving utterance to his own speculations, modesty and the consciousness of fallibility demand that he should hesitate to speak with overmuch positiveness. But when the preacher knows he is declaring the truth of God, that for all he says he has the warrant of the Word of God, why should he be other than positive? If a man have no certain belief as to the authority of the Scriptures, or if he have no clear conviction as to the teaching of the Scriptures, then let him hold his peace, for surely no man is called of God to preach doubts and uncertainties. But if a man heartily believe in the truths which the Scriptures reveal then let him speak as one who has a firm unfaltering faith; let him speak boldly as he ought to speak. To this end let us make the Word of God our constant study. Luther said in his day, "We kiss the old shoes of the saints, but we never read their works." We must not lay ourselves open to a charge like that in relation to the Bible. Men must not be able to say of us that we pay a superstitious reverence to the book, but do not know what it contains. Let us seek to be thoroughly acquainted with its teaching; to be sure not only of what we affirm, but of the ground on which we affirm it, and then, confident than our doctrine is in harmony with the mind of the Spirit, we may even go so far as to say in the heroic words of the same Luther, "Here I take my stand, I can do none other. God help me. Amen."
III. The only other point on which I would make remark is the statement that the picture represented one who stood as though he pleaded with men. We have considered what we may term the Christian preacher's preparation and message, here is some indication of what the CHRISTIAN MINISTER'S METHOD should be.
We have to deliver our message plainly and faithfully, adding nothing, keeping back nothing. But Bunyan's idea is, that when all this has been done, we are not to think nothing else remains; that we have simply to state our case and leave it, trusting to the power of the truth and the operation of the Holy Spirit for the rest. The preacher is to plead with men; as though he had a personal interest in the matter, he is to bring all his powers to bear on the work of persuading his hearers to act upon what he teaches, to render the obedience his message demands.
I need hardly say this view has the support of Scripture. Whether we turn to Old Testament prophet or New Testament preacher we find the messenger of God to be one deeply interested in the success of the message he bears, anxious that they to whom he is sent should hear
and heed. We find him warning and beseeching, praying them with much entreaty that they would receive the gift; mourning and lamenting their conduct with sighs and tears when they turn away indifferent or negligent. And if we examine the preaching of men who in later days have been most signally successful in their work—Edwards and Payson, Baxter and Whitefield—we get the impression that when these preachers stood before men they set themselves with deliberate purpose to make their meaning so plain that they could not be misunderstood, and then to compel their hearers—so far as by force of persuasion they could compel them—to act on their instructions. Is not this the way in which we should work? Is not such a method both warranted and demanded by our belief concerning men's need and the gospel's value? Ought we not to teach and to plead too; to warn and to exhort; as though God did beseech men by us to pray them in Christ's stead to be reconciled to God? We need not be afraid of going too far in this direction; of being too emotional, too pathetic; of letting our deep feeling overmaster us. The danger is lest through familiarity with the message our feelings should become blunted and deadened, lest we should feel too little rather than too much, lest we should suffer the grandest and most solemn truths to fall from our lips as if they were the tritest and most trivial of commonplaces. We need to cultivate sensitiveness of feeling, for are not our hearers far more likely to be impressed when they see that the truth we speak impresses us? And when earnestly pleading with men shall we not be in sympathy with him who not only declared himself the Rest of the weary, but invited them to come to him, and wept and lamented bitterly over the impenitent and disobedient?
I have selected from Bunyan's picture what seem to me the three most important particulars. Which of the three is of greatest importance we need not try to decide. All are important, all must be interwoven in our life and work as they are joined together here. Conscious of our dependence on heavenly help, we must seek that help in many an hour of quiet fellowship with God. Then, coming forth from his presence prepared for our work; speaking from a full heart the word he has given us to utter; seeking to declare "the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth;" pleading with men in our Master's name and in our Master's spirit—our labour shall not be in vain in the Lord; we shall be gladdened by tokens of success attending our toil, and cheered as our uplifted eyes catch sight of the crown of gold which hangs over our head. Let us, as faithful pastors, strive to feed the flock of God and to bring back the sheep which have gone astray, "and when the chief Shepherd shall appear we shall receive a crown of glory that fadeth not away."
