Thomas Chalmers
IN the 17th of this month, just a hundred years will have elapsed since the birth of Thomas Chalmers, in the East-of-Fife town of Anstruther. His countrymen, the world over, will not forget the day, nor allow the grand moral of his life to lack emphasis for want of a fitting tribute to the
memory of one of Scotland's foremost sons. The publication of an interesting sketch furnishes an opportunity for presenting to our readers the salient features of his character, and the principal events of his life-story. We deem it necessary at the outset thus to define our aim, in order to prevent the disappointment of any who would like to know more of Chalmers as theologian, philosopher, and ecclesiastical reformer. We must refer such to the exhaustive work of his venerable son-in-law, Dr. Hanna, which can never be surpassed or even equalled, and to which Mr. Dodds honourably confesses his obligation. Our author very wisely disclaims both his intention and ability to portray the Doctor as moralist and theologian. His aim is to set forth the man, the minister, and the moral reformer, and we shall content ourselves with following his example. If, therefore, our sketch be incomplete, the fact must not be attributed to the paucity of material at command, but to the limited aim we have defined.
In taking up the life of a good and great man, we instinctively conclude that he was descended from a pious ancestry. Not that we believe moral qualities are, of necessity, transmitted from sire to son, or that grace is hereditary. Still, the fact remains, account for it as we will, a godly parentage is a subtle factor in the formation of a godly character, and mental and moral qualities in a child find their prototypes in one or other, or both, of his parents. Even the Apostle Paul,
"Thomas Chalmers": a Biographical Study. By James Dodds. Edinburgh: William Oliphant and Co.
while claiming Timothy as his son in the faith, acknowledged that the faith in his beloved protégé dwelt first in his grandmother Lois, and then in his mother Eunice. We are not surprised, therefore, to find that the father of Chalmers is described as "a man of fervent but unostentatious piety—a staunch Calvinist, and a zealous evangelical," and that his mother is characterized as "a true partner to her husband in piety."
As a boy, Thomas Chalmers was all a boy, caring more for play than for books, and though he could have learnt anything put before him easily and well, it needed the coal-hole—the place of punishment at school—to rouse him to the necessary diligence to master his lessons. His uncle tried in vain to initiate him in mathematics, and does not appear to have succeeded beyond the first definition in Euclid. Bearing in mind the colossal attainments of the man, we feel no small pleasure in learning that the boy was not a juvenile prodigy. Had he loved his books more, and his play less, he might have been a marvel of precocity, but found, as others also have done, an early grave for a wrecked constitution. Let our educators note this fact, and study the physical culture of their pupils, as well as their mental discipline, and never attempt to cram them for an examination not strictly justified by their years. A youth with a splendid physique is more likely to succeed in his after studies than a juvenile Crichton, destitute of the muscle and fibre which make up a strong constitution.
At the age of twelve he commenced the serious business of education at the University of St. Andrew's, and in his fifteenth year he passed to the curriculum of theology. When eighteen years of age, he engaged himself as a private tutor, and after a year or so returned for another session to the University, and was licensed as a preacher by the Presbytery of St. Andrew's in 1799. Not obtaining an appointment at once, he proceeded to Edinburgh for a further course of study, and left in 1801, to become assistant minister in the border parish of Cavers, near Hawick. A year later the assistant professorship of mathematics in the University of St. Andrew's was offered to him, and, about the same time, he also became minister of the parish of Kilmany, in Fife. When his professorship was terminated by a misunderstanding with his chief, he commenced a series of independent classes, apparently to vindicate himself against the possible stigma of incompetence.
This rapid narration of facts serves to impress us with a sense of his marvellous activity and intenseness. Every attribute of his robust manhood, roused by his redundant energy, was brought into vigorous exercise to accomplish the end he wished to gain. He had the qualities of a splendid military engineer, and would have succeeded in any sphere into which his predilection might have led him, for concentration was the resistless law which governed his action. He said himself, "I cannot scatter myself over a multitude of points."
In studying the life of Chalmers we see that while philosophy, morals, and theology may fashion a splendid statue, the Spirit of God alone can quicken character and make it a living reality. So long as Chalmers was a mere theorist in morals, the citadel of his soul was easily stormed by doubts. Accordingly, his great, strong nature was
101
thrown into a perfect tumult by the questionings suggested by the scepticism of the age, which defined man to be only matter arrived at a higher state of motion, and destined, when the chemistry of life fails, to fall and wither like an autumn leaf; and pronounced thought and will to be the secretions of brain, and immortality to be nothing more than a posthumous reputation. While wrestling with his doubts he still preached a pure morality, but found he was only "ploughing the rock." He saw no harvest of virtues to reward his anxious toils, and pined for the professor's chair as a way of escape from his dilemma. It would appear that, at this juncture, the Church of Scotland was stranded on the sandbank of moderatism, which was "neither true Christian, nor good pagan; had neither the unction of Knox, nor the yearning desire for truth and goodness of an Epictetus or a Cicero." The few devout Christians of Kilmany, as in other places, deplored the condition of affairs in their parish, and prayed for the dawn of a brighter era. "As for Chalmers," said one, "he's nae minister ava"; and another described his matter and his style as, "neither edifying nor diverting." Nor need we wonder at this, for he held that a minister was free to enjoy five days a week in the uninterrupted pursuit of some favourite study having no bearing on his ministerial duties. For several years this state of things continued, until, at length, he was brought to face the stern realities of death and eternity. As he lay month after month in a sick chamber, and smarting under the stroke of a bitter bereavement, he was brought to the feet of Jesus, and found in simple trust the balm to heal his wounded spirit, and in full assurance the joy which resolved the discord of his doubts into the harmony of a Christian faith. When he emerged from the sanctuary of suffering a new man, and awoke to the solemn responsibility of his position, he declared himself to be, as he resumed his labours, "An ambassador for Christ."
His altered preaching soon attracted the people, and his devotion to pastoral duties effectually bridged over the distance which had long sundered him from his congregation. On some one remarking to a parishioner, "Your minister is like the apostle Paul," he was met with the rejoinder that "Paul was na fit to haud the can'le to him." This verdict may be an exaggerated estimate of the altered minister, but it suggests the reality of the change effected by the grace of God.
When, in 1815, he took his farewell of the Kilmany flock, to remove to Glasgow, the people crowded the church to hear his last discourse on the favourite theme of his later ministry—"Rooted and built up in him, and stablished in the faith, as ye have been taught, abounding therein with thanksgiving." The text alone is sufficient to prove that the philosopher had found a true basis for morals in the person and work of the Lord Jesus Christ, and an all-sufficient bond in his divine fellowship.
"Talk we of morals, oh! thou bleeding Lamb;
Thou Maker of new morals for mankind,
The grand morality is love of thee."
The reputation of Chalmers was an ample guarantee that he would take the first rank amongst the preachers of Glasgow. His advent, therefore, created no small stir amongst the people, and admiring crowds hung spellbound upon the orator as he delivered those sermons which
must ever be regarded as amongst the masterpieces of pulpit eloquence. He no longer claimed "five days a week" for the diversions of scientific study; everything was subordinated to the grand business of his vocation. A touching story is told by his biographer to prove the tact and ardour which he brought to bear upon the work of soul-winning. Visiting an old woman on her death-bed, who appears to have been ignorant of the way of salvation, Chalmers fell back upon a familiar Scotch word to make it clear. "To lippen to a person" is to trust him from full confidence in his truth, his power, and his love. Thus when the poor, bewildered soul interrupted the minister, who was urging her to "believe on the Lord Jesus Christ," with the question, "But what is it to believe?" the prompt reply was, "Lippen to him." As she exclaimed, "Ay, I understand that," light broke in upon her dark mind, and she found the rest and joy she had hitherto vainly sought.
Now that the cross had become the central fact of his ministry, his great abilities and scientific acquirements became powerful auxiliaries in the illustration and enforcement of truth. He thought, and felt, and spoke, not as an essayist, but as a man standing in the midst of his fellow-men who needed to be reconciled to God, and brought into vital union with the Lord Jesus Christ, as the essential pre-requisites to the ennobling of their munhood. His sermons were composed with the sense of an assemblage of people before him, hence the effect of their delivery was as powerful as the extempore utterances of other men. Our author says, "They have all the pith of preparation, and all the quick leap of impromptu." When he tried to preach without his manuscript, he was not successful, not because ideas or language failed him, but because he could not compress into the brief limits of a sermon the vast volume of thought which strove for expression. As his sermons were all composed for delivery, it is, perhaps, unfortunate that so many of them have been published, for the same paragraphs and sentences frequently recur. This fact must not be held to prove that he was not sufficiently prolific of ideas or versatile in expression to be always original, but rather that he was satisfied with the mathematical exactness of the sentences which expressed the fundamental articles of his creed.
"The effect of his preaching," writes Lord Jeffrey, "reminds me more of what one reads of as the effect of the eloquence of Demosthenes than anything I ever heard." When he preached the missionary sermon in Surrey Chapel in the year 1817, it is said, "a constant assent of the head from the whole people accompanied all his paragraphs, and the breathlessness of expectation permitted not the beating of a heart to agitate the stillness." There was one exception, however, for good old Rowland Hill was so moved by the discourse that, unable to restrain his emotion, he thumped upon the book-board and exclaimed, "Well done, Thomas Chalmers."
In 1819 Chalmers quitted the Tron Church to become the minister of St. John's, Glasgow. He saw in the ignorance of the people in the low quarters of the city one cause of their degradation, and in the alienation of classes one of the secrets of their inability to rise. While the precept to "Honour all men" was restricted in its application to a chosen circle of friends or equals, he felt it was impossible to find a fulcrum to apply
103
the lever of the gospel to raise them. The hopelessness of despair seemed to have settled, like a ghastly incubus, upon the toiling masses who were relegated to the slums of the city by the neglect of employers, the alienation of well-to-do neighbours, and the pharisaism of the religious. Shut up to their own slender resources, it is no cause for wonder that the poor and illiterate of the population substituted the excitement of intoxication for the diversion of wholesome recreation, and relapsed into week-day profligacy after the profanation of the Sabbath. The neglect of religion was inevitably followed by the indulgence of vicious appetites which degrade the devotee below the level of humanity. He therefore resolved upon the task of leading the poor to exercise "Self-help" by first of all bringing "Brother-help" to bear upon their condition. To extinguish pauperism and to bring the entire population under the influence of education and religion were the twin factors of the territorial scheme which Chalmers projected, and which should be administered, not by paid officials, but by voluntary workers impelled by Christian philanthropy.
He divided his parish, numbering 10,000 inhabitants, into twenty-five districts, called proportions, each embracing from sixty to one hundred families. Each district was to have a school for its centre, and a godly deacon for a curate. The grand centre, around which everything was to revolve, was the parish church, and the voluntary offerings taken at the doors were to furnish the necessary funds to replenish the exchequer from time to time. The church of his ideal was national, but Christian: endowed, but independent; established, but free; and the revenue from the offertory was not to be squandered in doles to pauperize the worshippers, but to be administered at the homes of the people according to circumstances duly ascertained. The domiciliary visits of the deacon were designed to furnish the opportunity of detecting imposture as well as for the administration of relief. As the assertion of parochial brotherhood was to be the grand outcome of the scheme, only the recognition of class distinctions saved it from degenerating into a pernicious communism. We must hesitate before pronouncing the scheme Utopian; but at the same time it must be confessed that the difficulty of finding suitable agents, resident in the districts, and the uncertain response on the part of the poor to co-operate in any effort to raise them, render its realization doubtful, if not impossible. Well-intentioned and ably-directed efforts are too often resented by the degraded classes as infringements of their personal liberty, or condemned as impertinent intrusions into the privacy of their homes.
Undaunted by difficulty, if, indeed, he was not quickened into heroism by it, Chalmers resolved to attempt the grandest scheme of moral engineering of modern times. Had he been able to command the authority of an autocrat and the general co-operation of the benevolent he would have embraced in his scheme the entire population of Scotland, and incorporated the people in a universal city of God. But, like all great reformers, his ipse dicit was not sufficiently authoritative, and his projected innovations failed to command universal approval. In the parish, however, where his authority was supreme, he ventured to put his scheme to a practical test, and soon succeeded in reducing the cost of pauperism by at least four-fifths. Dr. Hanna says:—"After much thought and
prolonged personal enquiries he became satisfied that the evils naturally and necessarily attendant upon the administration of a legal provision for the poor more than counterbalance the good attained. There was no subject he had more thoroughly investigated than that of the relative advantages and defects of voluntary and compulsory charity, and none upon which his convictions were deeper, remaining unchanged to the last, though the tide of public opinion ran against them. The history of poor-law administration, and the dark issues that threaten us in the future, are raising this question anew. More or less that question must now take this shape—Whether voluntary charity cannot be so organized and administered as to be a safe and beneficial substitute for the poor law. Upon this question what Dr. Chalmers did in Glasgow half-a-century ago, and what has been done of late years in Paris, will help to throw light." To what extent the scheme he formulated admits of general application it is impossible to say, but the present poor-law system, under which the assessments are increasing from year to year, must sooner or later collapse, as it is difficult to meet the clamorous demands of the pauper population, while ratepayers groan under a burden they can ill afford to bear. We shall look forward with considerable interest to the meetings which may be held to celebrate the centenary of the birth of Chalmers, for the discussion of some of the pressing social questions of the day suggested by his labours as much in the cause of religion as that of philanthropy.
When he accepted the professor's chair at St. Andrew's, and afterwards at Edinburgh, it was not to escape from the humiliation which waits on failure, nor to secure the ease so fondly coveted by a disappointed worker, but to enkindle in the souls of the students the fire of his own enthusiasm, and to extend and perpetuate his usefulness in their consecration. "For the first time in a northern university," says Dr. Hamilton, "was taught an evangelized ethics—a system with a motive as well as a rule; a system instinct with the love of God and buoyant with noble purposes. And in the warm atmosphere of his crowded class-room, caught up by enthusiastic and admiring listeners, the contagion spread; and as they passed from before his chair, the élite of Scottish youth—Urquhart, Duff, and Adam—issued forth on the world, awake to the chief end of man, and sworn to life-long labours in the cause of Christ." Under the influence of his sanctified character and inspiring genius the class for ethics was elevated into a missionary college, and instead of sowing the seeds of scepticism, the lectures quickened and confirmed the faith of the students in the verities of the gospel of Jesus Christ. On hearing of his death, Dr. Duff wrote from his Indian bungalow an admiring tribute to his departed tutor, in which he says, "Though not a missionary himself, in the ordinary technical use of that term, yet in all that constitutes the real grandeur of wide, all-comprehending God-like philanthropy, he has been for years the leading missionary spirit of Christendom."*
The part which Dr. Chalmers played in the Disruption of 1843, and which, while it gave a Free Church to Scotland, deprived him of the State machinery upon which he had counted for the realization of his
* See "Life of Dr. Duff." London: Hodder and Stoughton.
105
scheme, demands separate treatment, and need not further concern us in this paper. Suffice it to say, he was eminently fitted for the emergency, and rose to the occasion like a Hebrew seer in a national crisis.
Absorbing and exhaustive as were his labours, he never failed to command the time essential for recreation, and the leisure necessary for social intercourse. Above all, he allowed nothing to deprive him of the seasons devoted to spiritual communion. In this way he maintained a robust constitution, a cheerful spirit, and a vigorous Christian character. His journal reveals much of his inner life—the unceasing conflict with innate corruption, and the struggles after the loftiest ideal of the Christian character. No one could be more entirely free from the pharisaism which affects an unattained sanctity, and mistakes the glib use of an unctuous phraseology for the utterance of sober fact. His honesty saved him from committing the egregious blunder of setting up a claim to perfection, and pronouncing his idiosyncrasies to be the standard to which his fellow Christians should aspire.
Attracted by the love of Jesus, and repelled by the sense of his own unworthiness, his course was a well-defined orbit, and his full-orbed humanity was aglow with the radiance of the light of the Sun of Righteousness. His was "the path of the just," and its growing brightness reached its full meridian in the glory of the perfect day. Busy to the last, his wish and his prayer received their answer and fulfilment—"Come quickly, Lord Jesus! In the attitude of habitual service and of habitual application would I wait for thy coming." Returning from London, whither he had been summoned to give some important evidence in an enquiry into the refusal of some landowners to grant sites for free churches, he felt his work was done. His waking hours, as he paced his garden, were spent in prayer, and the deep peace of his soul was the sweet reflection of heaven's calm. It was a glorious sunset after a troubled day. As he retired to rest at the close of the Sabbath, waving his hand cordially with his usual adieu—"a general good night"—he was nearer heaven than he thought. Within a few brief hours, without a struggle, "the silver cord was loosed," and when they came to rouse him on the morrow, they found the tenement of clay deserted, and the spirit gone.
VERNON J. CHARLESWORTH.
