Menu
‹ Chapter 45 of 264 ›

Pope's Oft-Quoted Line

1 min read · Chapter 45 of 264

IT is a well-known and oft-used expression—

"For differing creeds let godless bigots fight,

He can't be wrong whose life is in the right."

Not to notice the somewhat unnecessarily hard words, and confining ourselves to the sentiment, what is the conclusion? Of course he cannot! "He can't be wrong," as it is put so antithetically, if his "life is in the right." But is it? That is a subject for previous enquiry. . . . If a man's creed is that of Mahomet, "the Koran or the sword"; or that of the Ultramontanes, that every Pope is, and has been, infallible; or that of the Mormons, that polygamy is a most Christian institution;—if it be any false creed; will his life be right if he acts up to it? Will he be an honest man if he does not? It is a poor compliment to humanity to say that "men are better than their beliefs." But, in fact, you might as well put a disturbing mass of iron by a magnet, and then insist that the ship can still be steered safely, as think to have a man's "life in the right," while he has no fixed principle, or when his creed is "in the wrong." There is scarcely any crime that has not been committed, and justified, at the bidding of a false creed, and under its authority. We would say to Mr. Pope,

"Sweet poet! cease thy most mistaken song!

He can't live right whose creed directs him wrong!"

Canon Ryle says, "The man who wrote the famous line, 'He can't be wrong whose life is in the right,' was a great poet undoubtedly, but he was a wretched divine."—From Proverbial Folk-Lore. By Alan B. Cheales, M.A.

8

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate