Notices of Books
The Spurgeon Birthday Book and Autographic Register. Passmore and Alabaster.
THIS Birthday book is a great favourite. The first large edition has been already cleared out. In the cheapest binding, at half-a-crown, it is a handsome object, but it is kept in various bindings up to ten shillings and sixpence.
The Story of the Years. A Text Book and Diary. With Verses by MARIANNE FARNINGHAM. James Clarke and Co.
ANOTHER text-book tastefully got up, but a little dear at 4s. 6d. The gentle music of Miss Farningham's verses has charms for many readers, and we do not wonder.
Song Services. Edited by V. J. CHARLESWORTH. Passmore and Alabaster.
THESE are a capital series of services suitable for Sunday-school anniversaries, or any other special services. The
music of each service costs threepence, and the words alone one penny. There are or will be ten sorts. These will furnish holy song in private houses, and will give healthy entertainment to gatherings which may in certain districts be got together by music when other means are unavailing.
The Stockwell Reciter. A collection of old and new favourites for the Home, the School, and the Band of Hope. Edited by VERNON J. CHARLESWORTH. Nos. I. and II. One Penny each. Passmore and Alabaster.
JUST the thing which was wanted. Our friend, the head master of the Orphanage, has a genius for making telling selections for recitation. What with his "Song Services" and the "Reciter," he gives teachers all that they need for utilizing the talents of children for public or private entertainment, and he takes care that something good and instructive shall always be the leading article.
The Culture of Pleasure; or, the Enjoyment of Life in its Social and Religious Aspects. By the Author of "The Mirage of Life." Nisbet and Co.
RARELY does such a rich book as this come in our way. It has afforded us useful pleasurable entertainment during the whole of our sojourn abroad, for it has been read to us chapter by chapter as we have been able to bear it. It cheered our sickness, and it charmed our health. By its countless quotations we are reminded of old Burton's book on "Melancholy," though it is odd that its subjects should lie in the opposite direction. Our author has made a mosaic of extracts from all sorts of biographies by which he illustrates judiciously and graciously his chosen theme. Certainly he has promoted pleasure by writing upon the culture of it. We do not wonder that the volume is in the eighth edition, it deserves to be in the eight-hundredth. Most of our readers will know the Tract Society's attractive and impressive little book, "The Mirage of Life," and they will guess the style of "The Culture of Pleasure," when they know that it is by the same author. A high Christian spirit pervades these pages, and those who read and practise their precepts will grow the Pleasure Plant in their heart-gardens.
The Glories of Christ, as set forth in the Epistle to the Hebrews. A Series of Bible Readings. By E. A. II. (Mrs. GORDON.) J. E. Hawkins, 36, Baker-street.
NOT written in the usual book form for consecutive reading. We have here a suggestive series of notes, or rather hints, which will many of them be of great value to preachers who need to be started on a train of thought. We often get more out of a thoughtful line than from pages of verbiage. These notes on the Epistle to the Hebrews appeared in The Christian, and we certainly think that it would have been a great pity that they should have passed away with the ephemeral matter of which weekly journals are necessarily composed. We are not overwhelmed with admiration of the usual "Bible-readings" way of
treating the Scriptures, for the sacred book is frequently pulled to pieces word by word, and treated cabalistically, after the manner of the Jewish Talmud. The whole business of key words is a rather delicate one, and may soon degenerate into a superstitious worship of the letter by which the spirit will be missed. We do not attribute any measure of this fault to the little work now before us, which we greatly value because its studies preserve the good points of modern "Bible-readings" literature, and miss its faults. Our authoress often sheds a valuable side-light upon a passage, and at other times by setting one portion of Scripture over against another, she produces a blended light which is even more useful. Mr. Stevenson Blackwood has done good service by writing a brief introductory preface, which will no doubt commend the little book to the attention of the many by whom Mr. Blackwood is highly esteemed, among whom we reckon ourselves. To us, however, the writer needs no letter of commendation, for she is a sister well beloved in the Lord. Let every minister who reads this review get the book at once, and bless us for our advice. It costs, we believe, only one shilling.
Matthew Mellowdew. A Story with more Heroes than one. By J. JACKSON WRAY. Cassell, Petter, and Galpin.
BEING under very great obligation to Mr. Jackson Wray, and having a very high esteem for him, we undertook to read his story through. We began the task as a sort of penance, but were gradually beguiled into enjoying the exercise. Our virtuous opposition to works of fiction began to falter under the seductive influence of Mr. Wray's pen, the more especially as Matthew Mellowdew, the butcher, turns out to be a cousin of our old friend, John Ploughman, and a great expert in the use of Proverbial Philosophy. The tale is about as improbable as it can very well be, but it is splendidly written, and full of energetic life, and vigorous imagination. The tone of it is healthy, inspiring, and encouraging, and the moral of it is Christian in the highest sense. To Mr. Wray the writing of a religious story is
187
as easy as to talk; for his imagination is always at work, weaving webs of fancy, and creating incidents of interest: this faculty is thoroughly consecrated, and kept in due subjection to higher powers, and therefore, although he will never convert us into admirers of religious novels, we shall always accord him a high place among those who produce fiction of the purest order. Many minds must have literature of the imaginative kind to feed upon, and while this is the case we are glad that they can have it, not only winnowed from all impurity, but mixed with valuable truth. The abundant proverbs of Matthew Melodew render this work valuable to those who delight in terse sayings. Matthew uses many pithy sentences which are quite new to us, though we are tolerably versed in proverbial lore. Messrs. Cassell, Petter, and Galpin may as well get another edition ready, for such a book cannot fail to be popular. To Mr. Jackson Wray himself we wish a long and prosperous ministry as the successor of Whitefield at the Tottenham-court-road Tabernacle, and long may he favour us with his much appreciated help at the other Tabernacle where Whitefield's gospel is regarded as a joyful sound.
Transcendentalism, with Preludes on Current Events. By JOSEPH COOK, R. D. Dickinson.
We have read with care the most of these lectures, and have derived edification from them. It is a great joy to us that a man has been raised up who knows the follies of the Germans, and the scepticisms of the "modern thought" school, and is set to give them battle. Mr. Cook does his work con amore, as a Gordon Cumming might hunt lions; he evidently relishes the exercise, and may be well styled in controversy "a mighty hunter before the Lord." There is no trace of bitterness, however, in him, no mark of that savage Red Indian ferocity which is so usual in a theological debater. He follows Walton's advice, and handles his frog gently, as if he loved him; indeed, we believe he has a genuine love for the errorist, and would set him right if he could. Mr. Cook is both in belief and in spirit on the
right side, and we rejoice in him, glorifying God in him. At the same time these sets of lectures are better suited to the region of Boston than to London. We cannot but think very highly of a city which continues to find a large audience for such recondite metaphysical addresses; for popular as they are, they would be regarded as deep and abstruse by most London audiences. We think also that more of Scripture and less of Shakespeare and the poets would be more attractive and powerful with earnest minds. Mr. Cook, however, is the best judge about this matter, and of course has an eye rather to the conversion of sceptics than to the edification of old-fashioned believers. We like the talks before the lectures; they are so fresh, so practical, that we are always sorry when they are over.
Marriage. By JOSEPH COOK. Richard D. Dickinson, Farringdon-street.
THE lectures of Mr. Cook upon a great variety of subjects are too well known to need any further commendation. It is sufficient recommendation of the lectures upon marriage to say they are as terse, thoughtful, and comprehensive as other lectures of the same author. They exhibit the same lofty and sound principles; and even upon the subject of marriage, which by most others is brought down to a low level, the same high level is preserved. They may be read by all without any injury, and with much profit.
The Fatherhood of God. By ROBERT MITCHELL. London: Hamilton, Adams, and Co.
ONE of the most poetic, beautiful, pseudo-philosophic but altogether erroneous books on the Fatherhood of God which we ever read. As insidious and attractive as it can be, but altogether subversive of the very fundamental truths of the gospel concerning man's ruin, regeneration, and redemption. Our advice concerning it would be the same as given with respect to the proper way of preparing cucumber. "Carefully peel and slice it, flavour with pepper, salt, and vinegar, and then—eat it?—oh no! throw it on the dung-hill!"
The Limitations of Life, and other Sermons. By W. M. TAYLOR, D.D. Hodder and Stoughton, 27, Paternoster Row.
THE author of these sermons is well known, and his name is a guarantee for their soundness in both faith and practice. They are an abiding testimony that there is no need to go away from the plainest truths of the gospel for the exercise of original thought, for deep reasoning, for variety of sentiment, or for indulgence of literary taste. It is gratifying to meet with authors in favour of old truths as eminent for talent and acquirements as those who profess to have discovered new ones. The difference between the old divines and the new lies not in the head so much as in the heart. There is an experimental tranquillity, an unction from the Holy One, in the one that is not found in the other. Evangelical experience and evangelical doctrine are inseparably united. Some of the most remarkable instances of this may be found in Scotch Presbyterians, as in the case before us, and it is pleasing to find that the ministry of such an one is duly appreciated in New York.
These sermons are of varied excellence. The one upon the Atonement is clear as crystal.
The most striking feature in the whole is the originality and suitability of the illustrations. Two of these may be here given, one to illustrate what God is in Christ, and the other what Christ is in himself:—"You know the beautiful story which Homer tells us in connection with the parting of Hector and Andromache. The hero was going to his last battle, and his wife accompanied him as far as the gates of the city, followed by a nurse, carrying in her arms their infant child. When he was about to depart, Hector held out his hands to receive the little one, but terrified by the burnished helmet and the waving plume, the child turned away and clung crying to his nurse's neck. In a moment, divining the cause of the infant's alarm, the warrior took off his helmet, and laid it on the ground, and then, smiling through his tears, the little fellow leaped into his father's arms. Now, similarly, Jehovah of hosts, Jehovah with the helmet on, would
frighten us weak, guilty ones away, but in the person of the Lord Jesus he has laid that helmet off, and now the guiltiest and the neediest are encouraged to go to his fatherly embrace, and avail themselves of his support." The other illustration immediately follows:—"While thus his humanity emboldens us to apply to him, his divinity furnishes us with the help we need. That which I cling to for strength must be something other than myself, and something stronger than myself, otherwise it will be to me as worthless as a broken reed. When in the howling hurricane wave after wave is breaking over the ship, and sweeping the deck from stem to stern, it will not do for the sailor to depend upon himself, neither will it avail for him to grasp his fellow, for they may together be washed into the deep; but he lays hold of the iron bulwark, making the strength of the iron for the moment to be as his own, and is upheld. So in the surges of agony that sooner or later sweep over every man, it will not do for him to depend upon himself, or even to hold by a fellow-mortal. He needs one who, while he is a brother, is mightier than any human brother; and here in Jesus Christ the God-man the great necessity of the heart is met, for here is the omnipotence of divinity added to the acceptability of humanity."
Saving Faith. What is it? Religious Tract Society.
THIS is one of many little volumes, issued by the Tract Society, that contain a clear and full statement of the way of salvation, with an earnest appeal to all, and especially the young, to consider whether they are in the right way. Those who are specially concerned that others may be led into the way of all truth cannot do better than put this little book into their hands.
The Christian Commonwealth a Theocracy. By the Rev. ROBERT SEWELL. R. D. Dickinson.
AN eloquent plea for the Congregational form of church government, about which we do not feel so enthusiastic as the excellent author. It is a fine theory; but whether it can ever be so worked as to evangelize England is another question; and if it will not do that it is not the system of the future.
189
The Return from the Captivity. Isandula, and other Poems. By Rev. T. TILSTON, B.A. London: Houlston and Sons.
THIS little book of poems has upon the whole most agreeably surprised us. It is far beyond the meaningless jingle that is so commonly called poetry. In the main poem especially, "The Return from the Captivity," there are noble thoughts, and elevated emotions, expressed in language of equal force and beauty. The smaller pieces are of unequal merit, and since the author seems less at home upon the battle-field than in the scenes of peace, we are not surprised that the poems on Isandula, Ekowe, and Rorke's Drift, fall beneath the general power of his other productions.
Handbook for Visitors of the Sick. By WALTER BAKER. New York: N. Tibbals and Sons.
ADMIRABLE as is the intention of the author, we do not think it is likely to be very profitable. True sick-visitors are like poets, born, not made, and could no more be guided by rules and regulations than a poet can sing by Act of Parliament. Persons possessing the qualifications of a true Barnabas, "a son of consolation," will not need this little manual: while those who do not will never be qualified by it.
The Gospel for the Nineteenth Century. Cassell, Petter, Galpin and Co.
THIS is a clear and outspoken statement of what may be fairly considered to be the man-invented gospel of the nineteenth century. We earnestly hope and pray that it may be the gospel of no other. As it is certainly not the gospel of the first century of the Christian era, and will not be of the last, so we hope it will be known to the nineteenth century only. It is a gospel in which the example of Christ is the remedy for all human woes, and the sum and substance of all human desires. The life-giving doctrine of an atoning sacrifice is left out, and a mere example put in its place. The moral aspect of the gospel is common to all ages, and as to its value and importance all good men are agreed; the peculiarity of the present case is its presentation as the
gospel itself; as though, after all, Jesus was nothing more than a teacher of ethics and a model of virtue. This, which seems to be implied in Ecce Homo, and in Dr. Farrar's Life of Christ, is here unhesitatingly expressed. The divinity of Christ is admitted, and an attempt is made to show how he becomes on that account a better example to men; but, as common sense may suffice to prove, it is an attempt only. For the matter of that, a man is the best model for a man, if he be perfect in all respects. Of justification the author thus speaks: "God takes the will for the deed. He accounts the resolute choice of the will in favour of right to be righteousness. He may plead for forgiveness through the merits of Christ, because the graces of Christ's blessed life are now his in will." The italics are the author's own. Such teaching desires the essential truth of revelation. Again, he says, "So long as we understand by the term 'Faith in Christ' the meaning which we have assigned to it, viz., the acceptance of Christ's yoke, so long does justification by faith remain an intelligible thing, in accordance with Scripture and reason. For it simply means justification by oneness of spirit with Christ. But justification by faith ceases to be either Scriptural or rational when we understand by the words 'Faith in Christ' anything short of this. Whether it be merely objective faith that is intended, or whether it be simply trust in Christ's work, which is perhaps the meaning most generally given to the words, neither of these are the faith which justifies the sinner. The faith which can and does justify the sinner is the act of submission to Christ. This alone gives to sinful men a real part in him." Of the atonement we thus read: "If this view of faith were fully understood and universally received, we should never hear of the doctrine of substitution again, for the two are wholly irreconcilable. It is clear there is no idea here of wrath or of punishment; there is no necessity, no room, for the legal fiction implied in the popular doctrine of substitution." Alas, for the nineteenth century, if this is to be its gospel.
The reason for the divinity of Christ is thus stated: "Had God given to man
a perfect example other than his only-begotten Son, it would have been to transfer their worship and allegiance to another than himself. This will be evident from what has been already said of the effect of faith. The perfect example to be effective must be adored." Might we not add here that in proportion as we become like Christ we also are to be adored? This would be a logical conclusion. It is marvellous to us that any one can so thoroughly admire and endeavour to imitate the moral beauties in the life of Christ and suppose this to be all that is meant by "The glorious gospel of the blessed God." Was not man in innocence a sufficient example of a model man? What need that Christ should be God in order to be an example of a perfect man? Surely something more than an example was intended by the mission of our Lord as God and man in one person. May our author know his own condition before God, and his conscience will crave for something more than an example to appease its cravings.
Jesus Christ: his Times, Life, and Work. By E. DE PRESSENSE, D.D. Seventh Edition. Hodder and Stoughton.
On a further and more careful reading of this "Life of Christ," we are obliged to qualify our approval of it. We consider it, like all other lives of Christ, to be altogether cut out, and rendered superfluous by Geikie's wonderful volumes; but apart from this, it contains strange and crude notions upon many subjects. The work was most useful in its own time and day, and for the French public it answered and may still answer a very important purpose; but the attention which has been drawn to the great "Life of lives" has produced us much deeper and fuller works than this. Messrs. Hodder and Stoughton have republished the book in a form uniform with "Early Years of Christianity," and we would advise all ministers to complete their set of Pressense by purchasing this volume for 7s. 6d.; for even though it is not the best treatise upon the subject, it is needful to complete a series, of which the last four volumes are certainly invaluable. The copy before us is a specimen of the
seventh edition; it is unabridged, and yet can be procured for the small sum we have named.
The Christian at Home. By Rev. J. NISBET WALLACE. Edinburgh: Macniven and Wallace.
HOMELY, timely, valuable counsels as to the conduct of the Christian home with its varied relationships. No better little gift could be presented to those about to marry, or those already settled in homes of their own.
The Divine Forecast of the Corruption of Christianity. By the Rev. EDWARD HUNTINGFORD, D.C.L. Bickers and Son, 1, Leicester-square.
THE same consolation is here given to the church of Christ which an apostle gives to individual Christians, when he says "That no man should be moved by these afflictions: for yourselves know that we are appointed thereunto." It might have been said with an appearance of just reasoning, that the Christian church would not have been so persecuted and corrupted as it has been in past ages, if it had been continually under divine guidance and protection. When it can be shown that all these changes were foreseen and foretold, they become evidences of the special oversight which they might otherwise seem to disprove. If the predictions in relation to the dark days of Christianity in the world have been strictly fulfilled, with equal certainty we may look upon the predictions of brighter days yet to be fulfilled. Our author justly says, "The manifest fulfilment of Christian prophecy in the history of the Christian church, which has been going on for nearly eighteen hundred years is still going on, and will, as we believe, continue to go on until Jesus Christ comes again." The Romish church is justly shown to have taken a prominent part in the past corruption of Christianity; but too much dependence, we think, is placed upon the English church for the purity and prosperity of Christianity in the future. This is nothing more than might be expected from the author's position; but as it is accompanied with charity to others, and has little or no influence upon the substantial merits of the volume, we do not make a point of it.
