Notices of Books
The Postman. A Paper for the People. Passmore and Alabaster.
A FIRST-RATE little paper for giving away. Each number is an improvement on its predecessor. It is only one half-penny, and ought to be scattered thick as autumn leaves.
The Biblical Museum By JAMES COMPER GRAY. Old Testament. Vols. VI. and VII. Psalms to Solomon's Song. Elliot Stock.
WE are right glad to see this admirable work nearing completion. It must be a great boon to those students of the Bible whose libraries are small. A great deal of useful exposition is given in small compass, and for a small price. Mr. Gray has laboured well and wisely, and he will have his reward in the gratitude of thousands.
The Stars of the Reformation: being short sketches of eminent Reformers. By J. MILTON SMITH. S. W. Partridge and Co.
THIS book is calculated to keep alive the Protestant feeling of the country wherever it has survived the choking smoke of Ritualism. It is the sort of volume to place in a Sunday-school library, or to give to young men and women. The engravings assist in attracting attention to the history, which is very well written. That a second edition should be so soon called for is a cheering fact; but we shall not be at all surprised if the book should even reach a seventh edition, for 3s. 6d. is a reasonable price, and the volume is prettily got up and well illustrated. The more of such records the better.
The Union Jack: Tales for British Boys. Edited by W. H. G. KINGSTON. Griffith and Farran.
THIS strikes us as being the very thing that was wanted to cope with the shamefully bad literature which is prepared for boys. Mr. Kingston is a master in the art of writing boys' stories; he would have written "Robinson Crusoe" if Defoe had not happened to have done it before him. The style of this paper, the order of the wood-cuts, and the
whole spirit of the thing exactly suit its object. Other papers have been too good for the lower class of boys, but this condescends to their weakness, satisfies their love of sensation, and withal gives them wholesome reading instead of garbage. We do not recommend the paper for our own homes, but as a substitute for the bad papers which have such influence over the lower order of youths. It would not be so good for them if it were better. It suits the class it aims at, and for that very reason is hardly the thing for good and gracious youth.
A Commentary on the Holy Scriptures: critical, doctrinal, and homiletical. By J. P. LANGE, D.D. Vol. III. Numbers and Deuteronomy. Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark.
WITH this volume the English issue of Lange's great Commentary is completed, and all ministers and students are deeply indebted to Dr. Schall and the Messrs. Clark for so great a boon. The several volumes differ in value according to the ability of the various authors and translators, but we could not spare one of them. It is well that the publishers will now sell separate volumes at 15s., for thus a poor minister may purchase a volume or two when he picks up a windfall; but our younger men who are not yet compelled to devour the library in the nursery ought to possess themselves of the complete set as soon as possible. Homiletically, these commentaries are of high value. Often by a single sentence they will start the mind and give it a push along a line of thought, and this is the chief thing that most of us need.
The Rule and Exercises of Holy Living and Dying. By JEREMY TAYLOR, D.D. Edited by Rev. F. A. Malleson, M.A. Ward, Lock and Co.
AN exceedingly cheap edition of this famous work. No one expects us to review the book at this time of day, or else we might say that it is not altogether sound in its teaching, and needs to be read with discretion. Its poetry is unrivalled, but its gospel light is somewhat dim.
235
Memories of Patmos. By J. R. Macduff, D.D. London: J. Nisbet and Co.
A NEW and cheaper edition of a well-known specimen of Dr. Macduff's powers. Suggestive, sweet, spiritual discourses on the principal words and visions of the Apocalypse. We do not accept all Dr. Macduff's interpretations on a confessedly difficult book, but we thankfully receive every fresh ray of light which he throws upon these marvellous word-pictures. May this reissue have a speedy and extensive sale.
The Bible Reader's Commentary: the New Testament. In two volumes. Prepared by J. GLENWORTH BUTLER, D.D. New York: Appleton.
THIS commentary appears to us to be well compiled, and to contain a very large amount of information about the text, as well as of comment upon it. The range of authors consulted is wide and catholic, and all the citations are fairly acknowledged. We do not know whether the work is to be published in England, but its style of production is highly creditable to Messrs. Appleton, and the Commentary deserves a large sale in both the great English-speaking nations.
The Sovereigns of Judah. A series of Sermons. By ROBERT A. HALLAM, D.D. New York: E. P. Dutton.
THERE is so little upon this portion of Scripture history that we welcomed Dr. Hallam's book with a sort of love at first sight. On further acquaintance we are satisfied that our favourable prejudice was fully justified, and we place the work among our standard expositions. There is not much of spiritual unction about the book, but it is helpful as indicating the moral and religious teachings of the lives of the kings; indeed, in that direction it is richly suggestive.
In New Granada; or, Heroes and Patriots. A Tale for Boys. By W. H. G. KINGSTON. Thomas Nelson and Sons.
THE story gives a fair idea of the products and scenery of New Granada, and also brings out in relief the miseries
caused by war. There is nothing very special in the plot of the narrative, but boys will find it much to their liking, as it is full of incident and adventure, and it is abundantly adorned with pleasing wood-cuts.
The Migration from Shinar. By Captain GEORGE PALMER, R.N., F.R.G.S. Hodder and Stoughton
No very extensive knowledge of geography, of ancient history, and of ethnology is required to reject the modern theories of the origin of the human race, its antiquity, and of the causes of its diversity, and to substantiate the literal accuracy of the Scripture narrative upon the subject. As there are those by whom the Scripture testimony is opposed with much learning and labour, it is well that there are those who are able with equal, if not with greater, ingenuity and research to refute the objectors. The volume before us, if we may judge from the authorities referred to, and from the author's own experience, is as reliable as any recent production can be upon the subject. To those who are interested in both the ancient and the present populations of the two American continents, this volume will be of special worth.
Light, Life, and Love. The Principles of Holiness. By ALFRED J. FRENCH, B.A. 66, Paternoster-row.
THIS is an elaborate defence of the Wesleyan doctrine of personal holiness and its perfection in this life. Its interest, therefore, may be expected to be almost entirely confined to its own community. With the strongest parts of Wesleyan theology we are in full sympathy, and we can charitably bear with our brethren's weak points, as they will with what they deem to be ours. Do they believe that "without holiness no man shall see the Lord"? So do we. Do they believe that "without faith it is impossible to please God"? So do we. That faith is before holiness is not so clear with Wesleyans, we should judge from this pamphlet, as with us. Ours is a holiness of faith rather than a faith of holiness. Though we differ in some degree from each other, we are one in Christ.
Ecce Christianus: or, Christ's idea of the Christian life. An attempt to ascertain the stature and power, mental, moral, and spiritual, of a man formed as Christ intended. Hodder and Stoughton.
No one could have written a book so large as this is, on such a subject, without making a fair claim to credit for laborious earnestness. But it is difficult to see how any good end that the writer has set before him can be reached by the strange method and speculations of the book itself. The author's aim is, in his own words, to show that "a man in Christ, built up according to the stature which Christ designed, will become of the order of the first apostles of Christ, and will be able, in consequence, to hold a large measure of divine graces, and in that might perform tasks equal to any that the most remarkable men have performed." Or again—"a Christian man, according to Christ's idea, is of apostolic mould, i.e., greater than Plato or Shakespeare." And in another place it is said, in a chapter on "The Indwelling of the Holy Ghost," that "a man who perpetually receives this enrichment of the Holy Ghost, may grow out of all weakness and infirmity; may come into the possession of those high qualities out of which the most daring intrepidity naturally springs; may have a will and a power of endurance that can far outmatch those of every being who is not enriched to the same extent by the same power; a will that might be made more powerful than the collective wills of all the inhabitants of the globe, &c." And in a chapter on "Following the Lord fully," it is said that "as the mind acquires that lofty tone, it can send that burning passion into burning words, can coin it into mental strength; and when such a nature projects itself in any work, it must take the shape of high creative genius." And then follows a strange compliment to Jesus, and promise to the ideal man of the writer's imagination—"this is one of the rewards conferred by Heaven on any one who follows the Lord fully—acquiring the character of Christ, he necessarily gets much of the mind of Christ, and with it much of the splendour of intellect and imagination which that mind displayed." So again in the chapter on "The mental
result of following Christ"—the true man in Christ "will have a splendid originality, the power and attribute of high creative genius. He will have a compass and grasp of mind far surpassing those of the greatest theologians, and probably will say in hours what they take days to express." And a little later, as if anticipating a martyrdom for what he thinks not far from a revelation, the writer says—"Can we become men as great and commanding as the apostles?" The author claims to be absolutely the first who has dared to enter on this enquiry. Of course he has suffered much from theological prejudice, and expects to suffer more. This is his first appeal to the world of enlightened reason, to see whether anything approaching fair play will be granted him. Oh, this "enlightened reason" of modern would-be-martyrs! It tempts us to parody Cromwell's words—"Oh, Sir Harry Vane! The Lord deliver me from Sir Harry Vane!"
In the "Conclusion" we are told that "it has been proved that a man may acquire the intellect of a Shakespeare, yielding to the inspiring spirit of Christ within him"; and this is after a review and criticism of Shakespeare, for which real lovers of the poet will not thank the author of this book; and also after an analysis of Plato's "Republic," that will not tempt anyone to follow the author's example, and try to dissect the rest of the "Dialogues." Many other and lengthier quotations might be given from the book, all of which are in the same odd and inflated style. But the above are more than enough to justify the criticism—that it seems almost impossible to give the author credit for having worthily tried to understand what it was for which the Father sent the Son into the world. All through the book the writer seems to be under the power of a notion that what is chiefly to be sought in and by means of Christ our Lord, is to be a big something, or a great everything; only whatever it is that the Christian seeks to become, it must be big. And there is a forecast hazarded that in the times of great things, of which this book is to be the herald, philosophy, theology, art, science, and religion, which "have been greatly narrowed and restricted in their range
237
because of the false and feeble ideas that have prevailed, will be found to have a greatness and a richness never yet manifested." This self-assumed character of champion and vindicator of the day of big things will prove a vain effort; at least, it is to be hoped so. Compliments to Christ and the Bible, based on a comparison with Plato and his Republic, or with Shakespeare and his "Tempest" and "Hamlet," must go for nothing. What Christian wants to be "greater than Shakespeare"? The meaning has not yet gone out of the Lord's word to Baruch—"Seekest thou great things for thyself? Seek them not!" Nor does our age require the "great thinkers, &c., &c.," who, according to this writer, alone can do everything that is not now done. The ability shown in this work, for there is evidence of power, has been ill-directed upon a half-theological and half-intellectual "fad." The author has written vigorously, not on the practical and blessed life of a Christian, but on a fanciful and even foolish idea of the province of faith. An hour spent in teaching a class of children in the Sunday school, or in visiting sick saints, or seeking sinners, would do more towards bringing back "the days of the Son of Man," than all the time and energy wasted on producing this unwise book.
The Union Tune Book, with Supplement: a Selection of Tunes and Chants suitable for use in Congregations and Sunday-schools. London: Sunday-school Union.
As reviewing music is not our especial forte we have called in the help of one of the "chief musicians," who is as free from crotchets in the matter of partiality for particular tune-books as any of the sons of harmony we know, and is able to bring out of his musical treasury tunes new and old, and to compare musical things with musical. His opinion is in unison with our own, of whatever value that may be; and, therefore, we give the tenor of his opinion, but in compressed score. In this new edition of the "Union" the first part of the work, containing 483 tunes, remains as in former editions; the editor has "left well alone," and that is well. The
Supplement contains about 200 tunes; a large addition, truly, but a small improvement, as very few of these are likely to come into general use—certainly not by ordinary congregations. On the other hand, we were pleased to find about a score tunes which have become generally known and approved among the additions; such are Houghton, Evan, Belmont, Winchester (old and new), St. Peter's, Ernan, Pascal, Boylston, St. Cuthbert, Stella, Pembroke, and a few others. Of the rest, many are good, and may be suitable for choirs, but the melodies of not a few are not very pleasing to our ear, though, of course, the harmonies are good. Unlike the old book, the compressed score, has been adopted, which will make it more acceptable to the organist, while it minimizes space; so that, although the book contains the large number of 724 tunes and chants it is not at all inconveniently bulky.
Palms of Elim. By Dr. MACDUFF. James Nisbet and Co., 21, Berners Street.
THE suitability of the title and the popularity of the author of this book will suffice to recommend it to all who delight in the savour of evangelical truths. Elim, which denotes valleys, is considered to be emblematical of the valleys of tribulation through which the people of God have to pass on the way to their heavenly rest; and the three-score-and-ten palm trees bear each and all a rich fruitage of instruction and comfort to those who have come thus far in their pilgrimage. This use of Scripture is well adapted to those who are well grounded in its fundamental doctrines, and can safely take pleasure in their ornamentation. Having obtained the excellency of the knowledge of Christ Jesus the Lord from some parts of the Scriptures, they can afterwards "behold the Saviour's face almost in every page." It is, we are told, a well-known tradition in the Eastern Church that when the long, tapering palm leaves quiver in the breeze, they whisper the name of Jesus. Happy are they who can sit under the shadow of these trees with great delight, and find their fruit sweet to their taste.
The Child's Life of our Lord. By SARAH GERALDINE STOCK. Marcus Ward and Co., 67 and 68, Chandos Street, Strand.
ONE main excellence of the Bible is that it brings the sublimest truths within the comprehension of a child; or, according to a well-known saying, it is a stream in which lambs may wade and elephants may swim. It is not every one who can enjoy the deep things of God, and teach them to others, that is able or willing to adapt them to youthful minds. It is not every one who is familiar with the life of Christ, and can appreciate its principal antecedents and consequents, that is able to bring all its particulars, as recorded in the New Testament, within the comprehension of a child. This has been admirably done, both as to sentiment and style of address, in the work before us. It is a more faithful and effective life of Christ, scripturally and evangelically considered, within its own limits, than others which have been much applauded in a higher sphere.
Christian Home-life. A book of example and principles. By the author of "Christian Manliness." Religious Tract Society.
BEAUTIFULLY written: abounding with incident and illustration. Family virtue lies at the root of society, and must therefore be carefully guarded. This most readable book touches the home-life in many vital points in a fine Christian spirit. We should like to see it in every house in Great Britain.
Oakhurst Manor. By ANNETTE LYSTER. Sunday School Union.
THE authoress displays considerable powers of description and knowledge of character, and employs her gifts in the interests of total abstinence; should we not rather say, in the cause of truth and soberness? She—we would say Mistress or Miss Lyster if we knew how to style this excellent lady—has done her very best to interweave evangelical principles and motives with her story; but in this she has not succeeded as we could desire. We do not blame her for this; it is her misfortune rather than her fault that she has been educated in a superstition which causes her to believe
and write such sentences as the following:—"Your mistake was made when you mistook your oath (the total abstinence pledge) for a shield. . . You thought yourself safe, because you had sworn to avoid one particular sin—a sin which, however fearful, is not more truly a sin than others, about which you seem hardly to have thought at all. Well, this oath you broke. To break an oath is no light thing; it is a sin to be repented of. But you, Dick, have broken a more solemn oath than this. You swore to be Christ's soldier and servant all your life long; now, if what you said to me means anything, you have made up your mind not to be his servant any more, but with your eyes open to serve the devil. The cross marked upon your brow in infancy may aptly represent the medal or card; that cross you have determined to efface, and to enlist under another banner."
Was it any wonder that one who began to swear so young—a baby a few weeks old—and in a church, and in a clergyman's arms, too, and who was cared for and brought up by persons who swore for him because he wasn't big enough to swear properly, was it any wonder that such a child should break his pledge? Profane swearing and drinking generally go together.
The Kingdom and the People; or the Parables of our Lord Jesus Christ explained and illustrated. By MARY SEELEY. London: The Religious Tract Society.
THE parables of our Lord are inexhaustible in suggestion and beauty, and we are glad to welcome this latest attempt to expound and illustrate them. This is a book for the quiet hour after the day's work, or on the Sunday afternoon, if no Christian labour has a prior claim. The illustrations of the principles in the parables are apt and powerful.
Jemima. A story of English family life. By ADELAIDE. W. B. Whittingham and Co.
A NOVEL, which probably was sent to us by a mistake of the packer in the place of some book which had a useful purpose to serve, which Jemima lacks, as far as our search has extended.
