Robert Browne and Martin Mar-Prulate
ALTHOUGH in these days of sensational reading Nonconformist history is usually set down as a dry study, it is not found to be so when the craftsman is equal to his task; when, by the judicious sifting of old tomes and forgotten parchments, he can bring again from the grave of oblivion the lives and works of the heroes of the bygone times. The historians of other days, such as Crosby, Ivimey, and Calamy, were not writers whose books the general public cared to read, although to do them justice their literary achievements were quite as brilliant as those of Walker in his "Sufferings of the Clergy." During the last generation, however, a new school has arisen; and guided by Marsden, Stoughton, or Waddington, the acquirement of knowledge becomes a pleasure where before it was an irksome task. Last in the field, Mr. Dexter will, nevertheless, take a distinguished place as a laborious investigator of original documents. With the genius and the learning necessary for his task, he is both by birth and inclination a Nonconformist, and throughout life his taste has led him to devote a large share of attention to those who lived in the heroic age of the modern church. His work has been issued on both sides of the Atlantic—a royal octavo volume of about a thousand pages—consisting of twelve lectures and an ample bibliographical index, the former having been delivered before the students of Andover Theological Seminary between the years 1876—9. The labour involved in the production of such a work, necessitating as it did research in American, English, and European libraries, was of course enormous; and the man whose industry and enterprise led him to bear the ordeal deserves some grateful recognition. He is not simply a gleaner where others have gone before, he has searched as diligently as though he had had no predecessors, and he has accordingly come across not a few things which others had overlooked or misunderstood. The book should at least be found in all good libraries, and the pastor who receives it through his reading club should prize the privilege of reading what has been so thoroughly well prepared.
In England, as in other nations, the darkness culminated in Egyptian night just before the dawn of the Reformation; for what is bad usually grows worse and worse until it is superseded by something better. It is painful even to think of those long years of ignorance known to us as the Dark Ages, days wherein religion was frequently made a cloak for concealing wickedness both in high and low places. Reared too often by the gains of iniquity, the cathedrals were little better than the idol shrines of Mary worshippers; while the parish churches, between which and the village ale-houses the priests chiefly divided their time, might as well have been pagan temples, so far as any gospel teaching was concerned; indeed, things had come to such a pass that the people as a body were virtually the serfs of an ecclesiastical system, and their property was regarded as fair spoil by clerical adventurers. In time the bondage, of which the pope and his agents were the task-masters,
* The Congregationalism of the Last Three Hundred Years, as seen in its Literature. By H. M. Dexter. Hodder and Stoughton.
must have become heavier than the yoke of the law in Jewish days; for, to quote Mr. Dexter's words, the church "set aside nearly one half of the year, on various pretexts, as festival time. And when it is remembered that on all these 'holy days' the people were compelled to attend church, under severe penalties, it will be seen how great was the tax thus put upon the industry of the land." Instead of faith in Christ, men were taught to earn salvation by obedience to the Church; and costly as this obedience sometimes was, it included a belief in many absurdities and lying impostures almost too gross to be mentioned. In the worst times there were a few who deplored the ignorance and profligacy of the shepherds of the flock; but no remedy was found until the Lord put forth his arm and brought on the Reformation.
Though the sixteenth century did not dawn with any exceptional promise, its second quarter did not begin without the sunrise of a gospel day being gloriously apparent. Tyndall's New Testament in English was, in one sense, the greatest boon the nation had received; and the dissemination of this book, and the many successive editions of the Bible which appeared during the next fifteen years, had the effect of sealing the doom of Romanism in England. Henry VIII. was a greater friend to religion than he intended to be, and thus unwittingly laid the basis of that Protestant structure which his successor strengthened, and which the fiery persecution of Mary's reign could not destroy. Even in this darkest period of suffering there was a Protestant congregation which worshipped in and about London, and two of its pastors, together with some of the leading members, were committed to the flames. With the accession of Elizabeth the sky brightened, but persecution did not cease. The day-dream of this queen and her advisers was uniformity; and thus her reign, though auspicious in some respects, became the birthday of Nonconformity. The Presbyterians are said to have established themselves at Wandsworth in 1572, and about eight years later the Brownists, or followers of Robert Browne, were lifting up their protest against State establishments.
Robert Browne, who may be regarded as the founder of the Congregational system of nonconformity, has been so long one of the riddles of history, that we are not sure that his character is properly understood even now. Through placing implicit reliance in the biassed representations of Fuller and others of like sympathies, even Dissenting historians were, until a comparatively recent date, manifestly misled while forming their estimate of Browne's character. He was represented as a man of learning, but loose in his principles and daily life, and who, after all the stir he had made in the country, eventually conformed to an establishment which he did not believe was founded on a scriptural basis.
Mr. Dexter has made a very exhaustive examination of the authorities which are able to throw light on Browne's work and character; and he has arrived at conclusions different from the opinions of explorers in the same field who have taken their supposed facts at second-hand.
Born in the middle of the sixteenth century, Robert Browne was a native of Talethorpe in Rutlandshire. His ancestors were substantial merchants, the Reformer's great-grandfather's great-grandfather having come over from France about two centuries before. There are still at
509
Stamford almshouses which their charity founded, while other things attest that both at court and on the exchange they were considerable people. One of the line was allowed by royal patent to wear his hat in the presence of royalty and of all titled personages, a distinction too eccentric to be fully comprehended at the present time.
Educated at the University of Cambridge, Robert Browne became, in or about his twenty-first year, chaplain to the Duke of Norfolk, and even thus early he began to disseminate those doctrines concerning the Church and State which rendered him obnoxious to his contemporaries. He is afterwards supposed to have taught in a school in Southwark, and to have preached on Sundays to a congregation at Islington, the latter practice bringing him into dangerous contact with the persecuting ecclesiastics of the times. To escape the plague, which broke out in London and other places in 1578, Browne retired to his father's house; but soon afterwards he was found in the family of Mr. Greenham, the parish clergyman of Dry Drayton, near Cambridge, and there he distinguished himself as a theological student, but more as a preacher of righteousness to assemblies in the village and in the university town. While thus labouring he thought for himself on church matters, and his cogitations were so startlingly in unison with the New Testament that certain learned men considered that trouble would come of them if a check were not forthcoming. Browne, as a young man, was so far in advance of his time through being a simple reader of the Word that he longed to relieve the church from the thraldom of worldly-minded prelates. What made him so troublesome an innovator to easy-living Anglicans was the surprising fact that his boldness never lagged behind his convictions. A man who in the ecclesiastical world of the days of Queen Elizabeth had the courage to call a spade a spade was a veritable firebrand in the eyes of trimmers and time-servers. Fancy the man's openly speaking "of that woeful state of Cambridge whereunto those wicked prelates and doctors of divinity have brought it."
At Cambridge Browne had become acquainted with Robert Harrison, a kindred spirit, whose opinions in the main coincided with his own; and just three hundred years ago the two friends lived together in the same house, and walked together in the quiet suburbs, conversing on "the lamentable abuses, disorders, and sinnes," which were too characteristic of the times. Of course Bishop Freake, who then thrived in the Norwich diocese, very soon scented the "corrupt and contentions doctrine," for it was sufficiently tasteful with the "vulgar sort of people" to attract a hundred of them at a time to some out-of-the-way conventicle at a private house. The bishop acted with the decision of a man who supposed he was saving the church. Unable to resist the opposition of their enemies, Browne and his followers crossed the sea to Zealand, where two years of active exile were passed. Speaking of the products of Browne and Harrison's pens, Mr. Dexter says: "These books, aside from any little local currency which they may have had, were sent over in sheets into England, where they were bound and circulated by warm sympathizers there, where they arrived at the dignity of drawing a special proclamation from the Queen; and where, before Browne trod again his natal soil, two men had been hanged for dispersing, and another nearly hanged for binding the same."
33
On his return from exile Browne landed in Scotland, to disseminate his views of a Scriptural reformation among a people who had already accepted from John Knox the Presbyterian way of Government; but after a good deal of travelling about the country, he sadly confessed: "I have seen all manner of wickedness to abound much more in their best places in Scotland, than in our worser places here in England." Besides passing this judgment he greatly incensed the Scotch by saying that Presbyterianism gave a thousand popes instead of one, and instead of "Bishops in name, a thousand lordly tyrants indeed." In this sentence we do not agree, but we admire the courage which dare say as much if it seemed to be so. Browne would seem to have been more than sufficiently severe in his judgments, and in this we cannot hold him up as an example. Indeed, he was rather a destroyer of evil than a builder up of good.
After this, Browne re-entered the Established Church, and spent the last forty years of his life in that communion. Hence, while he has become a riddle to impartial historians, he has also for centuries been a butt at which the one-sided and the malicious have aimed their arrows. First one and then another have added varnish of their own to Fuller's ugly picture, until Browne has been held up to odium as a cruel, licentious, and unprincipled man. One party has hated him because he is supposed never to have really given up his nonconformity; while the Dissenters have seen in him a renegade unworthy of their cause. Mr. Dexter has fairly succeeded in clearing the man's memory from these cobwebs of prejudice, and in presenting him before modern students as he really lived and acted. He infers something from the fact of Browne's having been the pupil and the protégé of Richard Greenham, one of the most godly Puritans of his time; while the testimony of the man's own writings shows that he was a Christian of deep experience. Brownism was not, as is sometimes represented, merely a difference with the Church of England on questions of discipline. Browne's "one original, urgent, controlling thought, which grew to be a burden upon his soul which he could no longer carry, was that of the laxness, the corruption, the practical ungodliness of those parish assemblies of all sorts of persons which were the only churches that the Church of England knew." This matter of the purity of the church touches the essence of Brownism and the basis of Nonconformity. The mystery which hangs over Browne's later years is, in the opinion of our historian, the mystery of an unhinged mind which sometimes lapsed into actual insanity. If this were so—if, with the help of a curate, he could just manage to look after a small parish, while he was totally disabled from taking part in the sterner conflict, we can understand why Lord Burleigh should have found for him a safe retreat where he could pass his days in peace. Unhappily, also, one can understand why malice pursued him to the last, hit him when he was down, and vilified his memory in after years.
The anonymous, and still unrecognized, writer called Martin Marprelate is one of those singular phenomena of the Elizabethan times which few have understood, and nearly all have presented in a false light. Like Junius, nearly two hundred years later, he darted suddenly
511
upon the world, and like him he attacked private persons with a caustic satire which was as piquant to the astonished outer world as it was inconvenient to the ecclesiastical culprits arraigned. This remarkable tract-writer was so far a founder of nonconformity that he was one of the first to teach that bishops were not necessarily either the chosen of God nor the infallible guides of fallible men. There was more than one reason why such an author should at once rise into sufficient popularity to become an object of general interest both at court and in the homes of the people. He wrote like a man who realized that he had a duty to perform; while working in secret he fearlessly braved all penalties, and, eschewing Latin, he called things by their right names in that mother tongue which all could understand.
It was about the year 1586 that the "little pilot balloon" of the Mar-prelate series appeared, as "The State of the Church of England Laid Open," in a tract of nearly seventy pages, the disputants being a bishop, a papist, a usurer, an innkeeper, and Paul the preacher. If not actually penned by Martin himself, the author was recognized as a brother on the right side; and the public had a promise of something else to follow when Paul, in answer to being threatened with imprisonment for boldness of speech, told the bishop that, "The Clincke, Gatehouse, White Lion, and the Fleet, have been your only arguments whereby you have proved your cause these many years, but you shall prevail no longer."
Before Martin actually appeared upon the scene, two books against the Puritans had been circulated in England, one in answer to Knox's "First Blast of the Trumpet Against the Monstrous Regiment of Women;" the other being a bulky quarto, by Dean Bridges, of Sarum, "A Defence of the Government established in the Church of England," etc. Martin had his eye on both of these productions when he made his debit, his pioneer production, "printed over sea, in Europe, within two furlongs of a bouncing priest," having special reference to Dr. John Bridges, the champion of episcopacy. He begun by writing a small book in answer to a very large one; but the effect was not measured by the number of words. The bishops had never before encountered an antagonist of Martin's calibre and trenchant outspokenness; the public were naturally interested when church dignitaries were for the first time arraigned and judged according to their merit or demerit.
It has been customary to set Martin Mar-prelate down as a coarse, scurrilous libeller, with more violence than principle; but if free of speech, he was undoubtedly conscientious, and that the licence he took was no greater than fashion tolerated may be proved by the none too choice phraseology of the opposite side. His object was to bring before the bar of public opinion very glaring abuses; and earnest reformers of three centuries ago had no notion of going about their business in the delicate manner characteristic of ourselves. After all, the ecclesiastics were not so enraged because they were assailed with deadly thrusts as because their cause was weakest at the points where it should have been strongest. Had Martin's case been founded upon nothing better than rough epithets, he might safely have been ignored as a beater of the air. The noise he made and the dread he inspired both arose out of the existence of the ills he desired to cure.
It is quite credible that this old controversialist's caustic wit and free way of calling things by their right names may have given some hints to Junius in after days. In dealing with the bishops he regards them not as priests, but as men with all the weakness of humanity; as men, moreover, who had not turned their advantages and opportunities to very good account. Whatsoever Martin believed to be truth he said; and in some measure this constitutes his offence with critics who have not made allowances for the age, nor for the old author's honesty. Doubtless, a man was not hampered by any conventionalism, who, with all England looking on, could say, "You ass," to an Elizabethan bishop, and start the theory that Martin Bridges was "hatched in a goose nest"; but he may, nevertheless, have been terribly earnest for the truth. Though his plain words may often appear to degenerate into a licence which we cannot commend, we may remember that Martin Mar-prelate's "proud, popish, presumptuous, profane, paltry, pestilent, and pernicious" bishops were persons in no wise resembling men like Dr. Ryle of Liverpool or Dr. Tait of Canterbury. The public formed a pretty correct estimate of the character of those who were set over them; and hence we need hardly wonder that people were carried away with what Mr. Dexter calls "the easy impudence" of Martin's "free personal assaults." While blaming the coarseness of one side, the detractors of Puritanism should take into account the shortcomings of the opposite camp. Thus, "Dumb John of London," more "like a lewd swag," played upon the Sabbath, transformed his gatekeeper into a rector, and did other things as characteristic of the times as they were unworthy of an upper shepherd. The bishop does not even appear to have been decently honest in the common transactions of life.
To quote Mr. Dexter's words, this mode of arraigning the bishops, and of compelling them to answer for themselves before the bar of public opinion, "must have been tremendously effective at the time, when it is considered with whom it dealt; and one can easily imagine broad-mouthed, coarse-fibred yeomen shutting and barring the door, and making sure of no eavesdroppers under the windows, and then roaring and shaking their sides together, partly at what seemed to them the smartness of the book itself, but still more at the high fun that anybody should have spirit enough to take this old bull thus by the horns." We need not wonder that in those days of a gagged press "there was a general ferment and guffaw:" that Martin could reckon among his readers the Queen herself, the three estates of the realm, large numbers of students at the universities, and common people everywhere, nor that the accused bishops determined on revenge. The most remarkable part of the story is, that Martin was a man of peace, whom conscientious zeal impelled into war; but the conditions of peace which he demanded were far ahead of the times. He demanded, among other things, that the word should be everywhere preached by none save godly ministers; and that none should be troubled for refusing popish garments, nor for omitting objectionable passages in the Common Prayer. How wide-spread was his influence, and how justly he was feared by opponents, is shown by their not being content to merely search for his press and person. Martin's brochure of fifty-four pages
513
was carefully answered in a quarto volume of nearly five times that length. Even "Dumb John of London" had to apologize for his common swearing, as well as for his common habit of playing games on the Sabbath; and, meanwhile, the stage, by turning the reformer into ridicule, took the church side of the dispute.
It will not be necessary to follow this controversy which once so excited the nation; for while seven pamphlets in seven months were issued from the mysterious press, which was here to-day and somewhere else to-morrow, all are characterized by the same family likeness. We might almost say the same of the replies drawn forth; but these greatly differed from one another in power.
Mr. Dexter endeavours to remove some misapprehensions in regard to this controversy, that, for example, the work of Martin was the work of either Puritans or Jesuits; and his estimate of the quality of the reformer's writings is a high one. In this respect he differs from nearly all who have preceded him in the same field, with the exception of the venerable Charles Stovel, who, at least, showed the virtue of acquainting himself with the merits of the case by reading the original works. "Martin was not defending himself, or storming at his oppressors," says Mr. Dexter. "He was attacking what he firmly believed to be a grievous error and monstrous wrong. . . . A high, unselfish, noble purpose animated, and I must think justified, all; and a clean and wholesome savour, as of bitter herbs, flavours even his rudest and coarsest speech."
It has been usual to identify John Penry, the Welsh martyr, with Martin Mar-prelate; but this has been done without sufficient proof. Turning to the Fleet prisoner, and future martyr, Henry Barrowe, our historian says, "I find considerable similarity of style between Barrowe's acknowledged books and the Mar-prelate tracts, in general and in particular."
He says again: "If Barrowe were Martin, and Penry the only man then outside the Fleet who was master of the secret, we may well think that, in the midst of the sharpness of all their troubles, the two men must sometimes have broken out into a noisy and almost uproarious glee at the inherent queerness of the thought of the bishops and their bailiffs scurrying up and down the land, and of Bancroft's listening miscellaneously at English keyholes, in the frantic endeavour to identify and arrest a man whom they had already had for more than two long years behind the bars of one of their safest dungeons. . . If Barrowe were Martin, and Penry his only ally, as the two men took the close secret to heaven with them within sixty days of each other in 1593, it is small wonder that it has been so well kept since."
If, as one historian remarks, these works represent the main controversy of Elizabeth's reign, Martin had no small share in directing the tendencies of the next century, which was the golden age of Puritanism. Happy are we that controversy need not now be carried on in such a bitter style. Unhappy shall we be if in courting courtesy we forget fidelity. It is still needful to contend earnestly for the faith.
