City Missionaries Six Hundred Years Ago
JUST six hundred and seventy-three years have come and gone since the young Francis Bernadone knelt in a little church of Assisi, seeking in penitent humility the revelation of the Divine will. Suddenly his attention was caught by the word of the gospel: "As ye go, preach, saying, The kingdom of heaven is at hand. Provide neither gold, nor silver, nor brass in your purses, nor scrip for your journey, neither two coats, neither shoes, nor yet staves: for the workman is worthy of his meat." "Here is what I have sought," he cried; hurriedly leaving the church, he threw aside his shoes and staff, his leathern girdle and empty purse, retaining only a rough gown bound with a rope—the ordinary dress of the poorest labourers of that time. Such was the foundation of the Franciscan Order.
It was in the very heart of Italy, in the bustling mountain-town of Assisi, that Francis was born in 1182. The son of a wealthy merchant, he had grown up the brilliant leader of the young men of his borough, fond of magnificence and pleasure, foremost among the gay singers of Provençal ballads. But, at the age of twenty-five, he was seized with an illness, from which he arose with a new sense of the seriousness of life. He would no longer waste his time in idle vanities, but would throw himself into some great and high enterprise. A pretender to the Sicilian throne was about to march to the south. Francis, thinking his vocation was to knightly fame, joined the army; but on the way his sickness returned, and with it came the conviction that such was not his appointed career. He returned to Assisi, and long months of uncertainty and mental tumult followed. But gradually his path became clearer. His mind was more and more possessed by the thought of the life and death of Our Lord, his generous heart was touched by the generosity of Christ, and with literal simplicity he desired to follow the blessed steps of his most holy life. But now instead of the admiring glances of his fellow-citizens, he was met by jeers and bootings, and his own father became his worst enemy. It was at this time, when Francis had determined to devote himself entirely to God's service, but knew not as yet the form that devotion was to take, that what he conceived to be the message of the gospel came to him in the church. As disciples gathered round him, the idea slowly formed of creating a society of men who should carry out to the letter the instructions given to the first teachers of the word, who should preach and employ themselves in deeds of mercy, but should be pledged to absolute poverty, and wholly dependent on the offerings of the people. Like his Great Example, when a small company had joined him, he sent them forth by twos. "'Go,' said our sweet father to his children," we are told by an almost contemporary biographer, "'proclaim peace to men, preach repentance for the remission of sins. Be patient in tribulation, watchful in prayer, strong in labour, moderate in speech, grave in conversation, thankful for benefits.' And to each as he took leave of him, he said, 'Cast thy care upon the Lord, and he will sustain thee.'"
We need not now stop to narrate the history of the Order, how the sanction and patronage of the rulers of the church were obtained, how in the lifetime of its founder it became a vast organization reaching to all parts of the then known world. We must content ourselves with looking at some characteristics of their work, and especially their mission in England. The system of the Brethren, ("Fratres Minores," i.e. Lesser Brethren, corrupted to Friars) was in entire contrast to that of the monastic orders. Men were not to be shut up, to work
• This chapter of history is at once most interesting and suggestive. It concerns an order of Romish friars, but we hope that the most thorough Protestant will not disdain to learn from it. The very name of monk or friar has become an offence among men: it will do us good to see from what a fine ideal they descended to the mire. Let us take heed that we do not decay as they did. We are very grateful to Mr. Ashley for this masterly paper.—C. H. S.
567
out their salvation in selfish seclusion from the world; but with the effort after personal union with God, was to be joined exertion for the good of their neighbours; they were not to be confined to the cloister, but were to go out into the world. Religion had come to be regarded as the trade of a wealthy corporation, which appropriated to itself the name of Church; the words of the Bible were seldom heard, save as the means by which bishops justified their encroachments, and ecclesiastical courts their fees. The work of Francis has been well described as "to strip Christianity of the regal robes in which popes and prelates had invested it, to preach it as the gospel of the poor and oppressed. He caught the poorest in their poverty, the subtle in their subtlety, sending among them preachers as ill-clad and as ill-fed, but as deep thinkers as themselves." When the order had become corrupt, the rule of absolute poverty and mendicancy was the excuse for the existence of a crew of idle beggars, but it seemed wise for the time, and for the immediate purpose Francis saw in it the only means of reaching the neglected classes, who hated and despised the wealthy clergy.
Preaching had fallen almost entirely into disuse, or, at any rate, such preaching as was still to be heard was useless. It is difficult to see how the sermons of the ordinary clergy, bred in the study of the law of the Roman Empire and of the Church, could have been intelligible to the people. The Franciscans saw that their preaching must be simple if it was to reach plain men; so a new style of pulpit oratory arose, founded on spiritual experience, full of earnest appeal, rough wit, and illustrative story. By the clergy these innovations were regarded with horror. These zealots, they cried, were magnifying preaching, and by their dependence upon almsgiving, and their mingling with the lower classes, were destroying the dignity of the clerical office. Complaints not unlike these have been heard in times nearer our own.
With such an audience as the Franciscan had to address, a display of systematic theology would have been without result; but he could touch them to tears and repentance by the burning narration of our Lord's sufferings. The lively imagination of Francis had enabled him to realise in a vivid manner the earthly life of Jesus: throughout he strove to copy that example. His biographers, it is true, tell us occasionally of his devotion to certain saints; but in his own words and actions there is nothing but love of God and of his Christ; no lesser object of worship attracts him. He himself sings—
"Love of Christ has wrought
Such strength I cannot tire;
He dwells in soul and thought,
Love sets my heart on fire."
The same characteristic is seen in his followers, and the more they have caught their founder's spirit the more clearly does it show itself. Personal affection for the Saviour is the key-note of the "Life of Christ," by Bonaventura, that spiritual teacher who in his boyhood had seen Francis himself, and who thirty years afterwards became general of the order. He is ever seeking to bring before the mental eye of his reader the incidents in the life of our Lord, and to show their inner meaning. Continually we come across the expressions: "picture to yourself," "consider," and the like. In his preface he says:—
"In the holy life of Jesus, not merely free from the minutest blemish, but even divinely perfect, you will find such materials as are nowhere else supplied toward arming the heart against the vanities of the world, against tribulations, temptations, and every kind of vice. Frequent and habitual meditations on his life are ever the readiest means of leading the soul, as it were, into such a kind of familiarity with him, and of possessing it with such a confidence and love of him, as will insensibly cause it to hold all else cheap, and will, moreover, fortify it with the knowledge both of what it should do and of what it should avoid. . . . If you are desirous of reaping fruit from this work, you must make yourself as completely present at everything here related to have been said or
done by our Lord Jesus, as if you heard it with your own ears and saw it with your own eyes."
In another place he writes :—
"Let us die to ourselves, let us enter into the mysteries, let us impose silence upon our anxieties, our lusts, and the phantoms of the senses, and let us go with the crucified Christ from this world to the Father."
But it was not only against spiritual ignorance that the Franciscans had to strive. The subtle Manichæan heresy, which taught that all matter was essentially evil, was creeping into Western Europe through the increased connection with the East in the Crusades. How could the existing ecclesiastical system meet this evil; a system which demanded celibacy in its priests, and so inevitably degraded marriage and the domestic life, which ascribed peculiar sanctity to the monastic discipline, and so put the everyday work of men almost outside the pale of grace? The whole church-theory, which drew a hard and fast line between the spiritual and secular, went to strengthen the heretics in their error. The Franciscans were indeed bound to celibacy, but they strove to meet the Manichæan tendencies by insisting on the Humanity of the Son of God, and upon the actual incidents of his sojourn among men. They actively encouraged family joys, so that Chaucer, writing two hundred years later, when the friars had degenerated, tells us of one who
"Hade i-made many a faire marriage
Of yongo women at his owno cost."
But in their endeavour to meet one error, they fell into another. What could seem more natural, in order to display the dignity of woman and the beauty of maternity, than to lay stress on the purity of the Virgin Mary, and her sympathy with her divine Son? Yet from the exaggeration of this apparently harmless method of teaching sprang the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception.
Francis, like all modern reformers, saw that he could not care for the souls of men and entirely neglect their bodies; some attempt must be made to grapple with the physical evils of the times. The great scourge of the world was leprosy—a disease regarded as incurable, against which society had no remedy but to drive the stricken one out of its way, who was forbidden to enter a town, deprived of all civil rights, unable to enter a church, and so practically excommunicated. Mankind did its best to shut its eyes to his existence. But Francis was an enthusiast, and had entire trust in the divine protection. He saw that nothing could be done save by personally caring for and attending on the leprous. He tells us :—
"When I was in the bondage of sin, it was bitter to me and loathsome to see and look upon persons infected with leprosy, but the blessed Lord brought me among them and I did mingle with them, and as I departed from them, what before seemed bitter and loathsome was turned into great sweetness and comfort."
Attendance upon the leprous became the condition for entrance into the order. His biographer says :—
"Francis, as a wise architect, sought from the beginning of his conversion to found himself on the poverty and humility of the Son of God as upon a firm rock. He therefore desired the Brethren to abide in the hospital for lepers, and serve them, to lay there the foundations of humility. For whoever desired admittance into his order, noble or ignoble, was bidden to serve lepers and abide in their houses."
One cannot refrain from quoting from the same source a touching story concerning Francis :—
"There was in a certain place a leper so impatient, froward, and impious, that everyone thought he was possessed by an evil spirit. He abused all that served him with terrible oaths and imprecations, often proceeding to blows. What was still more fearful, he uttered the direst blasphemy against Christ and his mother and the angels. The Brethren endured his ill usage patiently, but
569
they could not endure his blasphemy, lest they should become partakers in his crime; and therefore they resolved to abandon him to his fate, having first taken counsel with Francis. So Brother Francis visited the leper, and upon entering said to him: 'The Lord give thee peace, brother.' 'What peace,' exclaimed the leper, 'can I have, who am wholly diseased?' 'Pains that torment the body,' replied Francis, 'turn to the salvation of the soul if they are borne patiently.' 'But how can I endure patiently,' rejoined the leper, 'since my pains are without intermission night and day? Besides, my sufferings are increased by the vexation I endure from those you have appointed to wait upon me. There is not one of them that serves me as he ought.' Francis perceived that the man was troubled with a malignant spirit, and went away and prayed to God for him. Then returning he said, 'Since others do not satisfy you, let me try.' 'You may if you like, but what can you do more than others?' 'I am ready to do whatever you please,' replied Francis. 'Then wash me,' replied the leper, 'because I cannot endure myself, the stink of my wounds is intolerable.' Then Francis bade water to be warmed with sweet herbs, and stripping the leper began to wash him with his own hands, whilst a Brother standing by poured water upon him."
The danger which attended the Franciscan, in carrying out his Founder's directions, was much greater, it is to be observed, than that to which the watchers on fever patients are in our days exposed; the mediæval philanthropist ran the risk not only of bodily suffering or death, but of the loss of all his rights as a citizen and a Christian: If leprosy is now something we can only faintly imagine, our gratitude must be largely due to the self-devotion of the Brethren.
Yet, with his enthusiasm Francis combined an unusual degree of reasonableness. This mystic devotee was no gloomy ascetic. He bade his followers observe only the ordinary fast of the Church, and to take food and sleep sufficient to maintain the body in health. His disciples were to be of cheerful demeanour. "Why," said he to a Brother one day, "do you wear that sad and gloomy countenance because of your sins? It is enough that your sorrows should be known between you and your God. Pray for his mercy to spare you, and to restore that cheerfulness to your soul which you have lost by your own demerits."
This much of some general characteristics of the Order; it is time that we turn to its work in England. On September 11th, 1224, two years before the death of Francis, the Brethren first landed at Dover. The little band consisted of Agnellus of Pisa, chosen by their founder to be the first superintendent of the English mission, three English clerks, and five laymen, all probably Italians. Near Dover they begged entertainment at a certain baron's castle. He received them, but upon leaving them for the night locked the door of the chamber. Next morning they found themselves fastened in, but waited patiently till later in the day they were brought out to be examined by the barons of the neighbourhood. The brethren calmly stated the object with which they had come, whereupon "one of the magistrates" cried out that they were spies and robbers. But a Brother, offering with a smile the rope from around his waist, replied, "If you take us for robbers, here is a halter to hang us withal"; upon which, we are told, the questioners saw that men who so readily offered themselves to death could have no sinister object, and they were allowed to proceed on their way.
They were indeed sorely needed in England. The state of the church was deplorable. Its rulers, the bishops, were mostly employed as royal ministers, judges, and ambassadors, and their spiritual duties were abandoned to foreign bishops "in partibus." Office in the administration was almost the only stepping-stone to bishoprics, and it was by the study of law alone that great offices could be obtained. Thus the more ambitious of the younger clergy naturally devoted themselves to English and Roman law. In the same way, a large body of the inferior clergy gave themselves to the study of the Canon law, i.e., the Decrees
of Councils and Popes: for the ecclesiastical courts, of which the most active was the archdeacon's, had jurisdiction over many of the most important acts of everyday life, e.g., marriage settlements, dowries, wills, and certain kinds of contracts, and a general supervision of morality, enforced by penance and ex-communication. Around these courts had sprung up a swarm of summoners, apparitors, and the like, who did all the spying and dirty work. Only by ready knowledge of the canon law could these little offices, which were eagerly coveted, be obtained. Hence a great number of the clergy were living wholly secular lives, and at the universities legal studies had supplanted theology. Moreover, many Italian priests, ignorant of the language and often non-resident, had been thrust by papal influence into the best benefices; and the king, leagued in amicable alliance with the Pontiff to rob the church, heaped hundreds of livings on worthless favourites. Of the monastic orders, the Benedictines were now scarcely more than great landowners, the Cistercians than wealthy graziers and wool merchants. It was, in addition, part of the system of the monasteries, to get into their own hands by hook or by crook as many benefices as possible, from which they took the greater part of the tithes, appointing half-starved vicars to the discharge of the pastoral office. To complete the picture we must note that many of the country parsons had fallen into shameless corruption. Grostète of Lincoln, the model bishop of his age, was forced by formal constitutions to forbid gambling, drinking bouts, non-residence, the sale of the sacraments, usury, and the bearing of arms, on the part of the clergy of his diocese. So both in the upper and lower clergy, in the mouks and country parsons, all the tendencies were toward secularity: spirituality was dying out.
While the pastors were thus neglecting their flocks, the need for their energy was becoming more pressing. The population was rapidly increasing, and for that increase there was no room in the rigid system of the manor, while the forest laws prevented the increase of cultivable land. Hence there was a constant flow of surplus population to the towns, and from this arose much of the social distress of the times. In the Middle Ages most towns were built on somewhat rising ground. On this higher ground stood the Guildhall and the houses of the respectable citizens who were bound closely together in trade guilds. But beyond these, in the suburbs, down to and beyond the town ditch, was a seething, half-starved population, partially sheltered by huts of wood and mud, a population continually added to by this influx of rustics to the town to seek their fortunes, and of runaway serfs seeking that freedom which a residence of a year and a day within a town gave them. The guilds were practically close corporations, into which these day-labourers of the suburbs could not hope to enter. In the town proper were parish churches, guild chapels and chaplains, and a system of mutual help. But for those outside the guilds, there was no aid, spiritual or physical; they were left to die of starvation, or by the plague or leprosy, whichever entered the suburbs first, and wrought there the greatest devastation.
It was to these districts that the Franciscans first came. From Dover they proceeded to London, Oxford, York, Warwick, Bristol, Lynn, and were soon spread over the whole country. In all the places just mentioned, they built their houses in the suburbs, near the town walls. As they were bound to absolute poverty, so Francis had directed that they should not build sumptuous dwellings, but should live under the same circumstances as those they came to raise:—
"When the brethren go to any city, and find some one who is ready to give them so much land as is sufficient for a building, a garden, and the like, they must above all things be cautious not to grasp at more than is necessary, always having regard to holy poverty, and that good example which they are bound to exhibit. They shall make a deep ditch all round the land, and a good fence instead of a wall, as an emblem of their poverty. Then they shall build poor cottages of mud and wood, and some few cells for the friars to pray in and labour in, for the eschewing of idleness. They shall have small churches and not large
571
ones, either for preaching or any other pretence. And if ever prelates or clerks, religious or secular men, visit the brethren, their poor houses, cells and churches shall prove to them the best sermons, and they shall be more edified by these things than by words."
The chief house of the order in England was near the shambles of Newgate, in a spot appropriately called "Stynkyng Lane," near the City gate. In Oxford they settled in the swampy ground between the walls and the Thames. Everywhere their houses were humble, squat, and low-roofed. Preaching, and tending the sick and leprous were, as above sketched, their chief work. As Mr. Brewer, the chief English authority on their history, tells us: "The Franciscan is the missionary of the town; he has nothing whatever to do with the country. He belongs to the rising community of the town. If he departs from the primitive institution of his founder, it is so because he is raised with the population among whom his lot is cast. Still, he is the poor missionary preaching to the poor, dependent entirely on their sympathies, never a land-owner."
The success of the Brethren in England was great and rapid. Before thirty years had passed, more than a thousand members were enrolled in the Order, and they had settlements in forty-nine different places. Such of the churchmen as could discern the evils of the time gave them eager welcome. Bishop Grostète writes that such was the devotion and humility with which the people ran to them to hear the word of life, to confess their sin, and to be instructed as to their future conduct, such the improvement the clergy had gained by imitating them, that one could justly say, "They that dwell in the shadow of death, unto them is light sprung up." One story may be quoted out of many, showing how their apostolic lives gradually overcame prejudice. Let us listen to the simple words of the old chronicler, and notice, in passing, that it illustrates what has been above remarked concerning the growth of Mariolatry:—
"Another instance occurred not far from Oxford, in the new settlement of the Brethren there. There was a knight who hated their mode of life, and had used them bitterly, blackening their good name whenever an opportunity offered. It happened on Christmas-day, that he who ruled over the Brethren, assembled them to sow the saving seed of the Lord in the land. As two of them were going into a neighbouring wood, picking their way along the rugged path over the mud and rigid snow, whilst the blood lay in the track of their naked feet without their perceiving it, the junior said to the elder, 'Father, shall I sing and lighten our journey?' And on leave being given, he thundered forth a 'Hail, Queen of mercy.' It so chanced that the knight, by no means in good humour with them, was following the same road without their knowledge. Now, when the hymn was concluded, he who had been the consoler said, with a sort of self-congratulation to his companion, 'Brother, was not that antiphonal well sung?' Whereupon the knight, breaking in upon their talk, 'Yes, by the Lord, it was, and may the Lord bless and prosper you, who, like the apostles, are patient in necessities and rejoice in tribulation.' And at this word, he slipped from his horse, and asked pardon on his knees for the harsh judgments he had passed upon them."
As the preaching of the Franciscans was attended with success, it was necessary that their converts should be bound together in some kind of organization, and that means should be devised for nourishing that spiritual life which had begun within them. This difficulty had been felt early in the ministry of Francis. Public opinion limited his thoughts, as it limits those of the vast majority of men; and the public opinion of the thirteenth century regarded the life of the cloister as the only way of perfection. But all men could not enter the convent or the monastery, the work of the world must be carried on; and Francis was at least clear-sighted enough to see this. "We have wives," said men, touched by his stirring words, "who will not let us go. Tell us how we can keep the path of health." "Remain at home," he replied, "and live
there in the fear of God and the practice of Christian virtues. I will find for you a way of serving God without leaving the condition to which God has called you." Hence arose the Third Order, a religious society into which men and women could enter without quitting the world. They took no vow, but simply promised to keep the commandments of God, and in particular to restore unjust gains, to be reconciled to their enemies, to wear simple and plain dress, to have frugal houses and furniture, to avoid balls and theatres, and not to bear arms except in defence of their country or the church. In the foundation of this society, later critics have discerned many motives of policy; but there can be no doubt among those who have realized the character of Francis, that his single-hearted purpose was to enable simple men and women to live a godly life in the midst of their everyday cares and toils. Besides, as has been well observed, it is the first reappearance in the church of the democratic element, since western Christendom had settled down under the hierarchical system. There is once more a Christian people as distinguished from the simple sheep to be fed, and souls to be ruled. The humblest member of the Third Order was understood to have a definite position in the church; men could no longer think that the "ecclesia" contained only ecclesiastics.
It is unnecessary here to sketch the history of the Order's rapid decline. Some causes of corruption are on the surface. Celibacy and mendicancy, when no longer borne up by constant devotion, were the easy steps to immorality and idleness. But we need not, for two reasons, dwell upon this. In the first place, the Protestant reader has a sufficiently correct notion from the pages of Foxe, and from other sources, of what they became long before the Reformation very wisely swept them away. Secondly, it may be more profitable sometimes to remember the excellencies of their early years, and to meditate upon many points of likeness to modern efforts to evangelize the masses, which their history suggests. The matter is well summed up by the words of the late Sir James Stephen, by no means a very favourable critic of Francis or the Franciscans:—
"So reiterated and so just have been the assaults on the Mendicant Friars, that we forget that till the days of Luther, the church had never seen so great a reform as theirs. During two centuries, Francis and his spiritual descendants, chiefly, if not exclusively, directed the two great engines of the Christian warfare, the mission and the pulpit. Nothing in the histories of Wesley or Whitefield can be compared with the enthusiasm which everywhere welcomed them, or with the immediate and visible results of their labours. In an age of oligarchical tyranny they were the protectors of the weak, in an age of ignorance the instructors of mankind, and in an age of profligacy the stern vindicators of the holiness of the sacerdotal character, and the virtues of domestic life. While other religious societies withdrew from the world, they entered, studied, and traversed it. They were followed by the wretched, the illiterate, the obscure, but not by them only. In every part of Europe, the rich, the powerful, and learned were found among their proselytes. And even when by the natural descent of corruption, the Order had fallen into well-deserved contumely, 'still the mission and the pulpit and the tradition of its founder arrested its decay.'"
W. J. ASHLEY.
